Category — Masterchef
Reality Tidbits – more Masterchef
How can we miss Masterchef if it really won’t go away? Another week goes by and our season two contestants keep themselves in, at least, our peripheral vision.
Matt Preston alerted the Twitterverse to this story, about Callum’s dream of having his own show, asking whether people would watch it. Would you? I’d watch it once, and – to be honest – would be hoping for it to be more Julie Goodwin than Poh, as it would make for a more entertaining blog post!
I fear that Callum has no real understanding of the television world, even after his months of immersion. “It [hanging out with Poh] made me jealous because her job is so fun – it’s MasterChef without the pressure of being eliminated.” They might not call it “elimination”, but networks do have other ways of making unsuccessful shows disappear.
Adam Liaw has been busy blogging, and posted a fabulous piece about the chefs he met on the show. I hope Claire is taking note of the comment about Shaun Presland: “Your food is defined by your passion, not your ethnicity.” It’s a really fun post, with some interesting insights and genuine laugh-out-loud moments.
Aaron Harvie has taken to social media like a duck to water, and has been dropping hints of an upcoming project with Matthew Caldicott. He was also spending time yesterday with “some of the MC boys”.
For those of you with pay TV, the real Masterchef is starting on Monday. Some of you hardcore fans might have already found ways to see this series (I’m guessing it’s the one from earlier this year), but if you haven’t it is definitely worth checking out. It’s on Lifestyle Food at 7.30.
Finally, if you are still jonesing for a reality TV cooking fix, check out The Restaurant on BBC Knowledge, Thursdays at 7.30. You might be able to catch the opening episode again on repeat during the week – I watched it and was instantly hooked (shameless plug for my recap here).
August 14, 2010 10 Comments
Masterchef – surprise chef!
Ominous drums signal the welcome back to the Masterchef kitchen. Gary thinks there are not many of them left, but there are still a lot I don’t know. And a lot I don’t care for, Carrie. I hope the fact that she’s getting the initial interview here signals that she’ll be on the block. In any other reality show, I’d suspect that this was a red herring, but the way the editing has been so far I’m sure that it’s something I can take to the bank.
The Challenge
Making a three course family dinner WITH A TWIST! Which is that they will stalk a supermarket shopper and cook them a bew-ti-ful three course meal in their kitchen. I’m horrified that nobody gives Ari the Surprise Chef a shoutout, or did I imagine him? Somebody please confirm that he wasn’t just a figment of my imagination.
Matt will be dining with a super secret mystery guest judge, and we all know that it’s Curtis so I’ve completely lost interest in Matt’s camping this up. The winners will have a meal at Sailor’s Thai and two of the losers will be facing elimination.
The three celeb challengers from last night have to decide which one of them will be the captain and Joanne really wants this. Aaron strategically decides to vote for her and she’s a bit surprised, since Aaron is tight with Matt, who is also surprised. Finally, though, he figures out why Aaron’s playing this way. Bright spark, our Matt.
Joanne chooses blue, and she picks Sharnee as the opposing captain.
Joanne’s team: Jimmy, Claire, Adam, Aaron, Skye, Alvin, Jonathan, Carrie
Sharnee’s team: Marion, Peter, Callum, Matthew, Phil, Fiona, Jake
Coles
Joanne is Kath. Or Kim. “Just stick with moi, ploise?”
Both teams get some knockbacks before the reds hit on a handsome looking guy with a cute kid. Who gets the fireball treatment. And then the reds discovered that their dad is a chef so they ask him what he’d cook and then they start picking up nasty parmesan cheese from the sponsors. Ick.
Nobody wants Kimmy to cook for them, until Kirrily magically appears. She and her family have just returned from Singapore, so Aaron is pleased by this. They break into two groups to complete the shopping. I wonder if the green bags were factored into the $100 budget.
Cooking
Tua has a nice kitchen – reds are lucky! And they have Gary, who… is not George.
Kirrily’s house meets with Joanne’s approval, but she notes that the kitchen is tiny. They’ve drawn George as their coach.
Callum alienates the sponsor by interviewing that the filo is past its use by date so instead of making spanakopita, they will now make frittata, which is what Tua wanted, anyway.
Kirrily’s small kitchen means that Jimmy and Aaron are making chilli prawns outside. Claire, Adam and Alvin are making poached chicken with coconut milk and Carrie and Jonathan are dealing with dessert. What is Joanne doing? “Guys, what can I do for you? Nothing? Good?” So she goes outside for a cry. While she’s out there being soothed by George, the dessert is a disaster in the making: pastry not working, split cream… so she goes to make the table beautiful. In the red corner, Marion is giving Sharnee props for her spot-on leadership. Joanne interviews that her role is to oversee everythink (sic), which seems to mean asking people what they want and then not responding to their requests.
The Situation is having problems getting the frittatas out of the muffin tins and if he keeps talking, he’ll have problems getting that date he seems to think his MC celebrity will bring, abs or no abs.
Blah blah lack-of-dramatic-tension… here’s Curtis. And Jake watches OPRAH!
Dining
Red Team
The red family like the frittata, but Curtis thinks it’s a bit cheese heavy. The kids think the lamb is yum, and it reminds Curtis of something you’d get in a good pub. Tua is happy with it, so Curtis asks “are you blown away?” and he admits that he’s not. Was being “blown away” part of the “family meal” brief? I’m not blown away by Curtis’ fettucine bolognese, either. Not, you know, that I’ve tried it. It just looks so lumpy and unappetising. Matt says that their dessert will need to be special and the kids give it a “great” and a “good” and because they’re happy, Tua’s happy. And so are the red team, spying through the kitchen window. Curtis thinks the reds have done a great job, “but this is Masterchef”, he adds ominously, as though that means that standard should be higher. They should really make him watch the show so that he can develop some realistic expectations.
Blue Team
Hawker style prawns. Dad says that they eat well at home anyway, a bit snarkily, but 15 year old Harry – who hasn’t ever eaten prawns – has a crack, which amazes everybody. The chicken poached in coconut broth with chicken rice gets the thumbs up from the family, and Curtis thinks they’ve hit the nail on the head. Dessert comes out and it’s the poached peach tart. Fireball. God, now even Matt’s saying bewt-i-ful. The pastry is heavy – CARRIE! – and Kirrily thinks it’s a bit uh-UH.
Pointless Judge comments
Sharnee wants to go on a reward lunch and Joanne is trying to be confident but not cocky.
Sharnee says that her team performed well overall. The positives: they nailed talking to the family, understanding it and delivering it. The dessert was a “hero moment… FAN-tastic”. Negatives: frittata was disappointing. Callum says that it’s what Tua mentioned, but Gary thinks they could have done it better. No mention of the supermarket stocking out-of-date products.
Joanne thinks the blue team worked well but didn’t support her and Claire and Jonathan give her death stares. Jonathan says there was no leadership, to nods from Aaron. Joanne interviews that she disagrees with his opinion. Positives: innovative menu, magnificent entree. They are still going with the idea that someone who has never eaten something is a good judge of whether it is good or not. Negatives: dessert disaster. It failed on two fronts: didn’t match the brief and was executed poorly. The meringue and the pastry are the main culprits.
Results
Red: 7
Blue: 7
Curtis and Matt had the casting vote. Curtis liked the reds, but Matt liked the blues. So we’re getting all the cliches now, as Gary dusts off “long and hard”. I’m predicting that, after the inevitable fireball, we’re going to see them send the two captains to elimination.
Unfortunately I’m wrong. Carrie and Jonathan will face it for the blues, and Joanne – who did nothing – gets away with it. Phillip and Callum will be up against it for the reds. If Carrie doesn’t go home, it will be a travesty.
Random thoughts
- Is Curtis’ surprise chef show the elephant in the room? Matt says he was the perfect judge, but doesn’t say “because he does this shit all the time in the US”.
- Why were the positive comments from Harry on the prawns given so much weight. He’d never eaten the bloody things before, so how could he judge a good prawn from a bad one?
- Ugh, how awful was that staged everybody-grabbed-a-tea-towel shot?
- Matt’s trousers tonight? Tangerine nightmare.
- Somebody (Pollywaffle?) pointed out that Gary has adopted George’s foot bouncing. He and Matt are also aping the “bew-ti-ful” pronunciation.
- There’s a Curry Pot aisle in Coles?
- And, once again, because it rocked… Jake watches OPRAH!
May 19, 2010 51 Comments
Masterchef – it is what it is (and it’s not what I was expecting)
It’s probably clear to all who’ve been reading my guest posts on Masterchef that it’s filling my spot of “show I love to hate”. That position has been empty since Kitchen Nightmares demoted itself down the order to “show I now merely hate, and therefore no longer watch” thanks to an ill-advised American adaptation that was half abuse, half recap. I wasn’t expecting Masterchef to fill that vacancy; from the moment I first heard that we were getting a local version, I was looking forward to it.
Like many Australians, I took advantage of the working holiday visa and spent a while living in London, working strange temp jobs, and spending most of my meagre earnings at the pub. Of course, since the Labour government came to power, many things – including licensing hours – have changed, but back then, with Major in charge, pubs closed at eleven and were open for a bizarre period of time on a Sunday. Sunday opening gave us enough time for a hearty roast with Yorkshire pud, a couple of pints of bitter, and then we’d head home for a lazy afternoon in front of Masterchef. That’s right – it was on once a week, on a Sunday afternoon.
The show was hosted by Loyd Grossman, a Bostonian whose bizarre native accent had been rendered even stranger by his time in Britain. Each week, he judged the competitors – who competed in heats of three hopefuls a time – with the help of a couple of guest judges: a chef, and a celebrity. The competitors were true amateurs; they were the types of people you’d also see on Mastermind. I recall – although this is through a haze of 18 years and the beer fog I’d be in at the time – cardigans with elbow pads. The show had a cosy feel to it. Each week, I looked forward to the results, which were delivered with Loyd’s trademark: “We’ve deliberated, cogitated and digested”. I don’t remember there being a prize, beyond being crowned Masterchef.
When we finally took the plunge into “pay TV” this year, I was excited to see that Masterchef was on. Not just the vanilla Masterchef, but also Masterchef: The Professionals. The format had changed since those days in Clapham South, and Loyd no longer presided over the competition, but I was still hooked. Hooked by the catchphrases (“cooking doesn’t get tougher than this!”), by the extreme volume of the two hosts/judges, by the rapid pace (six contestents cook from mystery ingredients – three go on; three cook in a professional kitchen; three cook a two course menu – one goes on… all in 30 minutes) and by the focus on food, rather than the personality quirks or flaws of the contestants. In fact, the prize seems to be nothing more than the Perspex trophy and the prestige that comes with the title. With that, though, doors do seem to open up.
That’s what I was hoping for with the home-grown version, but ours has trended more towards an American model and away from the original. Remember when Survivor first started? Well, do you also remember Shipwrecked? This was a British version, but instead of alliances and challenges, the aim was to adapt to a more hostile environment than what the participants were used to. There was no prize, but there were occasional lively spats over who’d taken more than their fair share of Hob Nobs from the bikkie tin. The British Masterchef is, of course, no Shipwrecked but they share some bloodlines. It’s not about the cash. It’s about both the journey (but not “the journey”) and the destination. It’s about nurturing and developing talent, not being sidetracked by squabbles. It’s also, despite how that sounds, quality entertainment.
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
Thanks for your responses to my guest posts! It’s been great fun being here. No doubt I’ll see you around in the comments on Raver’s posts…
May 23, 2009 4 Comments
Masterchef (UK) – “Whoever wins, it’ll change their life!”
And so it has, for the winner of the most recent season of the REAL Masterchef, Mat Follas. Given that Mat spent a lot of his life in New Zealand, I’m amazed that nobody here has tried to claim him as a local. That’s gotta be a first. Anyway, Mat has just found a venue for his own restaurant and is working to get it open in just over a month. He keeps a blog, which includes recipes, news on the food he loves, and some inside goss on his time on the show. Here’s hoping it goes well.
Other finalists
One of my only criticisms of the current version of Masterchef in the UK is the section in the quarter finals where a contestant is eliminated without getting a chance to cook. This decision is made on the basis of their performance in the “ingredients test” (identifying, say, particular birds, cuts of meat, spices…) and in the “passion test”, where the prospective semi-finalists have to demonstrate how much they want this (and, for those who have only seen the local version of the show, “this” seems to be nothing more than bragging rights – there is no $100,000 cash prize, no book deal… just a trophy designed to go straight to the pool room). I dislike this, particularly, as it seems to favour the articulate, as well as those who are willing to pimp out their emotions for the camera. It’s the only time of the UK Masterchef week that I really talk back to the TV.
This is all preamble to the news that finalist Andy Oliver was, indeed, a finalist who really wanted “it”. Despite losing to Mat, he has chucked in his job to follow his dream of a career in food. He’s recording his “journey” over at The Cook’s Broth. I don’t know how many of the local contestants would be willing to do this:
i went about making a list of london places which do the food and have the kind of style & vibe i love, so these are the places i’m planning to work in: Bocca di Lupo, The Modern Pantry, Moro, Nobu, Brindisa
There may be other places too, but as i’m mainly offering to work for free it cant last forever, so plan is to take full time cooking job at one of them or somewhere similar in perhaps a month or 6 weeks. In the meantime i’ve got to be Frugal McDoogal because the bills still gotta be paid!
Now that’s what I call having a calling!
According to the Evening Star, the other finalist, Chris Gates, has made a few TV appearances and has had some offers from restaurants, but is still working in his old job. He’s blogging over at the creatively named Christopher Gates.
It’s hard to compare the skills of these guys and our local contestants, given that cooking plays such a ridiculously small part in the local version, but I haven’t seen anything from the locals so far that matches what these guys turned out on a regular basis. Subtext: don’t give up your day jobs, MCAers!
May 18, 2009 Comments Off on Masterchef (UK) – “Whoever wins, it’ll change their life!”
Reality Tidbits
Australia’s Next Top Model Severs Ties With Vogue Australia
A new host is not the only change of this season’s Australia’s Next Top Model, as Harper’s Bazaar and Cosmopolitan will take over from Vogue Australia as the magazine represented in the show. The Sunday Tele gossip column (scroll down the article) states the split could have occurred because they did not put Demelza Reveley last year’s winner on the cover as they did with Alice Burdeau. However I think this is bollocks as Alice was the first winner ever to be put on the cover and there was never any expectation that other winners would get this honour.
Head Judge For Interior Design Show Home Made Announced.
Belle magazine editor-in-chief Neale Whitaker has joined the team on Nine’s lifestyle reality series Home Made. It is thought his role will be as head judge. Similar to that of Johnathan Adler of Arena’s Top Design. Sorry I should not have mentioned those shows in the same post as apparently they are going to be completely different. Each show is about interior designers competing to design different spaces and a designer is eliminated each week.
The producers Julian Cress and David Barbour of The Block fame, look like they are on a winner with this show. Also they always have high production values. David Heimann, proprietor of Orson & Blake will be the host.
Masterchef Australia – Another Melbourne Chef/Judge Announced.
As a Sydneysider I am about to crawl into a dark corner and curl into the feotal position with shame. Matt Preston a chef from Melbourne has been announced as the third judge to join the other two chefs from Melbourne Gary Mehigan and George Calombaris. Just a minor snipe why no female judge? Are there no good female televisual chefs in Australia?
The show is currently in pre-production and carrying out auditions throughout Australia.
Project Runway Australia Season 2 – Applications Are Now Open.
Project Runway Australia Season 2 applications are now open for aspiring or otherwise fashion designers. It will start filming in April and will launch midyear. Kristy Hinzes will continue to be the host.
Aspiring designers need to upload a CV, design samples and a video audition at arenatv.com.au
January 27, 2009 Comments Off on Reality Tidbits
