for those who have reality tv as their guilty pleasure
Reality Ravings | Australia's leading Reality TV blog!

Masterchef – surprise chef!

Ominous drums signal the welcome back to the Masterchef kitchen.  Gary thinks there are not many of them left, but there are still a lot I don’t know.  And a lot I don’t care for, Carrie.  I hope the fact that she’s getting the initial interview here signals that she’ll be on the block.  In any other reality show, I’d suspect that this was a red herring, but the way the editing has been so far I’m sure that it’s something I can take to the bank.

The Challenge

Making a three course family dinner WITH A TWIST! Which is that they will stalk a supermarket shopper and cook them a bew-ti-ful three course meal in their kitchen.  I’m horrified that nobody gives Ari the Surprise Chef a shoutout, or did I imagine him?  Somebody please confirm that he wasn’t just a figment of my imagination.

Matt will be dining with a super secret mystery guest judge, and we all know that it’s Curtis so I’ve completely lost interest in Matt’s camping this up.  The winners will have a meal at Sailor’s Thai and two of the losers will be facing elimination.

The three celeb challengers from last night have to decide which one of them will be the captain and Joanne really wants this.  Aaron strategically decides to vote for her and she’s a bit surprised, since Aaron is tight with Matt, who is also surprised.  Finally, though, he figures out why Aaron’s playing this way.  Bright spark, our Matt.

Joanne chooses blue, and she picks Sharnee as the opposing captain.

Joanne’s team: Jimmy, Claire, Adam, Aaron, Skye, Alvin, Jonathan, Carrie

Sharnee’s team: Marion, Peter, Callum, Matthew, Phil, Fiona, Jake

Coles

Joanne is Kath. Or Kim.  “Just stick with moi, ploise?”

Both teams get some knockbacks before the reds hit on a handsome looking guy with a cute kid.  Who gets the fireball treatment.  And then the reds discovered that their dad is a chef so they ask him what he’d cook and then they start picking up nasty parmesan cheese from the sponsors.  Ick.

Nobody wants Kimmy to cook for them, until Kirrily magically appears.  She and her family have just returned from Singapore, so Aaron is pleased by this.  They break into two groups to complete the shopping.  I wonder if the green bags were factored into the $100 budget.

Cooking

Tua has a nice kitchen – reds are lucky!  And they have Gary, who… is not George.

Kirrily’s house meets with Joanne’s approval, but she notes that the kitchen is tiny.  They’ve drawn George as their coach.

Callum alienates the sponsor by interviewing that the filo is past its use by date so instead of making spanakopita, they will now make frittata, which is what Tua wanted, anyway.

Kirrily’s small kitchen means that Jimmy and Aaron are making chilli prawns outside.  Claire, Adam and Alvin are making poached chicken with coconut milk and Carrie and Jonathan are dealing with dessert.  What is Joanne doing?  “Guys, what can I do for you? Nothing? Good?”  So she goes outside for a cry.  While she’s out there being soothed by George, the dessert is a disaster in the making: pastry not working, split cream… so she goes to make the table beautiful.  In the red corner, Marion is giving Sharnee props for her spot-on leadership.  Joanne interviews that her role is to oversee everythink (sic), which seems to mean asking people what they want and then not responding to their requests.

The Situation is having problems getting the frittatas out of the muffin tins and if he keeps talking, he’ll have problems getting that date he seems to think his MC celebrity will bring, abs or no abs.

Blah blah lack-of-dramatic-tension… here’s Curtis.  And Jake watches OPRAH!

Dining

Red Team

The red family like the frittata, but Curtis thinks it’s a bit cheese heavy.  The kids think the lamb is yum, and it reminds Curtis of something you’d get in a good pub.  Tua is happy with it, so Curtis asks “are you blown away?” and he admits that he’s not.  Was being “blown away” part of the “family meal” brief?  I’m not blown away by Curtis’ fettucine bolognese, either.  Not, you know, that I’ve tried it.  It just looks so lumpy and unappetising. Matt says that their dessert will need to be special and the kids give it a “great” and a “good” and because they’re happy, Tua’s happy.  And so are the red team, spying through the kitchen window.  Curtis thinks the reds have done a great job, “but this is Masterchef”, he adds ominously, as though that means that standard should be higher.  They should really make him watch the show so that he can develop some realistic expectations.

Blue Team

Hawker style prawns.  Dad says that they eat well at home anyway, a bit snarkily, but 15 year old Harry – who hasn’t ever eaten prawns – has a crack, which amazes everybody.  The chicken poached in coconut broth with chicken rice gets the thumbs up from the family, and Curtis thinks they’ve hit the nail on the head.  Dessert comes out and it’s the poached peach tart. Fireball.  God, now even Matt’s saying bewt-i-ful.  The pastry is heavy – CARRIE! – and Kirrily thinks it’s a bit uh-UH.

Pointless Judge comments

Sharnee wants to go on a reward lunch and Joanne is trying to be confident but not cocky.

Sharnee says that her team performed well overall.  The positives: they nailed talking to the family, understanding it and delivering it.  The dessert was a “hero moment… FAN-tastic”.  Negatives: frittata was disappointing.  Callum says that it’s what Tua mentioned, but Gary thinks they could have done it better.  No mention of the supermarket stocking out-of-date products.

Joanne thinks the blue team worked well but didn’t support her and Claire and Jonathan give her death stares.  Jonathan says there was no leadership, to nods from Aaron.  Joanne interviews that she disagrees with his opinion.  Positives: innovative menu, magnificent entree.  They are still going with the idea that someone who has never eaten something is a good judge of whether it is good or not.  Negatives: dessert disaster.  It failed on two fronts: didn’t match the brief and was executed poorly.  The meringue and the pastry are the main culprits.

Results

Red: 7

Blue: 7

Curtis and Matt had the casting vote.  Curtis liked the reds, but Matt liked the blues.  So we’re getting all the cliches now, as Gary dusts off “long and hard”.  I’m predicting that, after the inevitable fireball, we’re going to see them send the two captains to elimination.

Unfortunately I’m wrong.  Carrie and Jonathan will face it for the blues, and Joanne – who did nothing – gets away with it.  Phillip and Callum will be up against it for the reds.  If Carrie doesn’t go home, it will be a travesty.

Random thoughts

  • Is Curtis’ surprise chef show the elephant in the room?  Matt says he was the perfect judge, but doesn’t say “because he does this shit all the time in the US”.
  • Why were the positive comments from Harry on the prawns given so much weight. He’d never eaten the bloody things before, so how could he judge a good prawn from a bad one?
  • Ugh, how awful was that staged everybody-grabbed-a-tea-towel shot?
  • Matt’s trousers tonight? Tangerine nightmare.
  • Somebody (Pollywaffle?) pointed out that Gary has adopted George’s foot bouncing.  He and Matt are also aping the “bew-ti-ful” pronunciation.
  • There’s a Curry Pot aisle in Coles?
  • And, once again, because it rocked… Jake watches OPRAH!

51 comments

1 Pollywaffle { 05.19.10 at 10:33 pm }

Family ties! Great recap, didn’t see the subtle cheese selection – puke
It got a bit testy tonight – the knives were out , enjoyed that, they might be shedding all that passion for food ( PFF) and becoming self centred humans after all.

LOVED the lawyer coming out in Claire when she was chosen on J’s team – she wanted be on the winning team!

How come we can have a draw when we never see what the actual voting system is? It reminds me of my BFs approach to finishing a monopoly game at whatever stage, thats it I’ ve won, goodnight.
I was waiting for the countback, surely there were more 6s or 5s in some families ratings, and we never heard that much from the older kids

Or maybe there is no ‘system’, its all made up and Matt has a spittoon bucket beside him that we never see, no that cant be true, that the rating system is a scam, not possible, next you will be telling me those dinners happened on different days!!!!!

It felt real setup Aristos style ( Injera, he existed for a brief meatball of reality TV).

The ‘randomly chosen’ supermarket families, amazingly good luck they happened to have beautiful families, that were intact nuclear families, lived in beautiful houses, owned great kitchens , not to mention educated palates and kids that, gulp, eat their dinner…..what stonking luck.

How does MC achieve such feats, in one supermarket on one random afternoon. Now those families are an absolute crossection of ‘sourdough bread, I mean, ‘whitebread’ Australia.

The other questions/comments beaming down from the universe are:

Duh, Jonathan. white chocolate ain’t chocolate ( for kids) – how hard would a brownie with fudge sauce have been ?

What does Curtis know about family food anyway?

George is becoming a little Buddha- buttons are tight, expect to see his kaftan phase coming up soon

2 The magic of television { 05.19.10 at 10:38 pm }

Wasn’t it fortunate they found families with kitchens painted the same colours as the respective teams?

3 Wurstsemmel { 05.19.10 at 10:39 pm }

Joanne, go home please.

Well, that’s my planned first line go to buggery.
This woman or should I say female? is driving me crazy. Not supported? How much support do you need when all you do is ask people if they need anything and then ignore them? Must have been so traumatic to have been asked to help with plates. No wonder she had to cry on George’s shoulder.

Still I’ll settle for Carrie going.

I don’t know how far the red team could have pushed the envelope when they were catering for such young children. They did a great job and Sharnee managed it well.

Why is Alvin nearly always last picked though?

4 Backhand compliments { 05.19.10 at 10:44 pm }

So what does Jake really think of Curtis with his Oprah reference?

5 Leadership material { 05.19.10 at 10:47 pm }

How can you head the kitchen if no-one respects you?

6 More fireballs please { 05.19.10 at 10:49 pm }

Please bring Gordon Ramsay in as a guest judge.

7 Zibb { 05.19.10 at 10:50 pm }

Loved the bitchyness tonight. Joanne should be going, she was bad enough that all these usually nice for the camera people were complaining about her. I actually don’t hate Carrie that much, especially after her comment about being lumped in on joanne’s team. But I think she is the best to go home from the four

8 sourkraut { 05.19.10 at 10:53 pm }

Cant be bothered much any more!
assorted kraut whinges
1 Program was a rip-off from a previous ENTERTAINING cooking show of about 10 years ago where a Greek chef who said kaleodexi (or similar) cooked meals in peoples homes with wot was in their pantries
2 the number of things that POTENTIALLY COULD be rigged. the lucky families…demographics, ages ., tastes, cooking stoves,
The size of their kitchens. (all just happened to be in North Shore mansions and were spotless! Sharnee if you thought that kitchen was small you should cook in my mates kitchen in Paddington ….prat
I shop at Coles Chatswood so they were mighty lucky it was on a day I was not there!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
How much were the families paid by 10 to allow a gallumphing crowd of amachas into their kitchens. It was cringeful watching the teams try to convince people to let them do so!
reds trifle ( presumably with wine, great for young kids, morphed into mousse by the end of the cooking.
Reds fritatas looked shitata and may result in one of them saying ta ta ha ha (they looked worse than Alvins raw hamburger schnitzel! Rest of meal looked average, TYPICAL for MASTERchef 2
Blues .prawns looked delish but with MINT sauce and why did it need two to prepare that dish?? and yeah a 15 y.o. boy had never tasted prawns b4, pull the other1.
Johnos f*@ked up the dessert hooray! Then tries to blame joanne ( who had a true clutterf%$k effort tonite) OH Shit who cares. Its a TIE 1st ever blah blah! Matt wont change his mind Why am I not surprised. Put the yellow panties on again and at least give a sour kraut another larf.
Termorrer
Johny babes guesses oi.l Geo says be specific. J says youre kidding Geo says i never bin more serious. Why??? You were not specific about the type of mint used you pack of geese!
Did they do the dishes/

9 Pollywaffle { 05.19.10 at 10:59 pm }

Kraut – take a lesson, Kali orexi :)

MFB I’d love the Irish judge from Great British Menu to drop in, he’d take no prisoners

10 dmc { 05.19.10 at 11:03 pm }

I predict a mighty fall for Jake sometime soon. He’s been flying well under the radar.

And Joanne should count herself MIGHTY lucky she wasn’t dragged into the elimination for all round bitchery.

11 sourkraut { 05.19.10 at 11:03 pm }

Injera
Yes there is a curry pot isle in Coles, and what’s more the curries are reasonably good for the price. Certainly no worse than the Masterwankers could produce!

12 Pollywaffle { 05.19.10 at 11:11 pm }

Theres always a positive out of idiocy – demand for Matt P fancy dress costume outfitting is propping up the nation’s opp shops, all out of yellow, tangerine supplies depleting fast

13 Ursa { 05.19.10 at 11:34 pm }

It was pretty hilarious to watch those ads for coles after the masterchefs purchased expired goods from the store.

I liked the family dinner concept but the judges really ruined it. Red family, eating happily: ‘I like the frittatas’, Judges:’these frittatas suck’. Way to ruin the mood judges.

I’m with you all on Joanne, what bad form.

Also, not sure why the dad was so shocked to see the kid eat prawns – he’s on national tv, I’m a fussy eater but I would have eaten everything on the plate and said I liked it if I was in his position.

14 sourkraut { 05.19.10 at 11:46 pm }

Polyw
In the word of some of the MC2 contestants, Near enough is good enough. By the way What does it mean, I never did Greek at school and the program (which i loved) never told me

15 sourkraut { 05.19.10 at 11:49 pm }

Pollyw
He could wear size 20 shoes with pompoms sewn on the top.
In the word of a highly cultured OZ GENTLEMAN, to wit Rodney Rude, “someone with pompoms on his shoes is a f&%King clown”

16 Muru { 05.19.10 at 11:56 pm }

It’s funny how Jake is always picked last or second last in team challenges. I wonder if that’s related to his cooking ability, his likableness among other contestants, or both. We haven’t seen much of him at all so it’s hard to judge what he’s like. Two other contestants who are always flying under the radar are Claire and Peter.

I hope Carrie goes. I’ll actually be very disappointed if any of the other three go home, but especially Callum. Crossing my fingers.

17 Pollywaffle { 05.19.10 at 11:59 pm }

Skt – All Greek to you? means ‘good appetite’, ….suprised Georgie isnt dropping it in between bewt-ti-fuls for added impact, but then he might cop too much flak from the rellies, who no doubt sneer at his smudges of tzatiki, while they pour out their vatfuls.

18 Jenny Draut { 05.20.10 at 12:03 am }

you guys crack me up so much as ive given watching the show already.

all i need is this blog….so much fun just to read

19 Jenny Draut { 05.20.10 at 12:11 am }

O, I forgot something…

are these judges aware that they might be in danger of getting Diabetes…i mean just looking at those bloody ever expanding waistline……

remember the ad sometime ago every1?????

alright, i’ll be brave…if im being a bit too harsh on the judges…

20 Fides { 05.20.10 at 12:18 am }

Ursa, totally agree. The judges ruined it for me. Just wanted Curtis to shut up with all the “are you blown away?” comments. Let the families decide for themselves instead of telling them it’s a great prawn dish and the frittata is below par. Ridiculous judging method anyway – who liked their dinner more?

Is Joanne the contestant who’s complained about being bullied? I remember a TV week cover just before MC started with something about bullying in the MC house. I didn’t bother looking at the magazine, so was wondering whether anyone knows the story behind that. It wouldn’t surprise me, given the way she acts like such a victim.

I’ve definitely lost the love for this show. Final straw was finding today on the MC forum that the thread I’d been posting in re Courtney’s elimination and judges lacking credibility in actual food knowledge has disappeared. Gone! It was a few pages long, but clearly TPTB weren’t impressed with the consensus that a) it was spearmint, b) the judges and producers are fools and c) Courtney was robbed.

Pollyw – I’m trying not be picture George is a kaftan but from now on, that’s all I’m going to be seeing every time I see that bouncy little guy. Thanks a lot!

21 Kaylen { 05.20.10 at 12:29 am }

Judging in this episode was a joke. Brief was a family dinner, yet the way the judges went on it was like they expected Michelin star quality food from them. Uhm, three kids under the age of 10? Or were the judges blind, or stupid, to not realise that? Kids that age are extremely picky about their food – parents know best as to what they eat, and the Red team followed that.

As Sharnee mentioned, it was a “Safe” meal – but it was either that, or go all out and wow the judges, but completely alienate the family – yeah, great idea. Let’s do that, Curtis. 😉

But then, what does Curtis know about family meals? Obviously not much. 😛

Highly amused that they allowed the fact that Coles sold out-of-date food through. Highlight of the episode, really.

Right people were chosen for the elimination – dessert failed in all aspects except the peaches. Skye keeps skating through though, so she better keep an eye out.

Frittatas looked awful, and that they couldn’t come up with better presentation or wtfever Curtis was talking about did let the Red team down.

Am surprised at Sharnee – she handled herself well, and was impressed.

Jake is in that “safe” place, and I don’t expect him to last into the top 10. Which is a shame, as I kinda like him. Unfortunately, we really haven’t seen much of his cooking – or rather, haven’t seen anyone actually taste and comment on it. 😛

Joanne was a joke. You could tell no one liked her, especially when at the end they were all told that they were safe and could go to lunch – everyone was hugging each other, saying good-bye (sorry you sucked?) to those left behind, and there’s Joanne in the middle looking around, all by herself.

Hope Phillipe doesn’t go – he’s really (really) good on the eyes, so he can stay as long as he wants. 😉 Can’t cook for donkey nuts, though. Shame!

I also liked how a number of shoppers seemed ready to run away from the teams – don’t blame them. Mental asylum escapees, anyone?

15yr old kid and prawns – yeah right. I’m with sourkraut on this – “pull the other1(sic)”. As always, sourkraut, love your comments. 😛

Besides, as Ursa said – national TV, well-known show. Of course he’s going to eat it. Too bad if he didn’t – the judges probably would have held him down and force fed it to him. Sad thing is, though? I can so totally see Matt and Curtis doing that. 😛

The dad from that family creeped the hell out of me, though.

It’s a shame that sourkraut didn’t get chosen! I’d love to see that episode; I doubt anyone would survive long. 😉

All-in-all: “eh”. Staged, out of touch, and so melodramatic I wondered for a moment if ch10 weren’t accidentally showing a repeat of Days of our Lives. (ew)

Interesting to see that in the elimination they FINALLY have to be specific about the ingredient they say, and no general answers anymore. But lols for Jonathan – “oil”, “yes, but what type of oil” “OIL USED TO WAX YOUR HEAD, LITTLE MAN!”

If he can manage to taste what oil was used, then I’ll be impressed. 😉

injera – you make Masterchef easier to watch. Thank-you. 😉

22 Anon { 05.20.10 at 1:07 am }

This blog is the only reason I am bothering to watch MC2. (That and Stephen Colbert seems to be repeats this week)

Hope Joanne goes soon…otherwise dub her voice/mute it and subtitle her. Just don’t let her talk!

Nah…I agree that those families were rigged. Too perfect…their houses too immaculate.

I have also wondered whether those green bags are included in the budget. I mean seriously according to Curtis the number of bags each team had you could feed a familyof four.

Least Jake has got the handle on cross promotion mentioning Oprah.

My theory on why Jake is picked last …think there is bit of a class divide in the house. Professionals vs Tradies.

23 KC { 05.20.10 at 1:19 am }

^Or Marion verse everyone else

GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO MARION!!!!!!!!!!!!!

AND GOOOOOOOOOOOOOO AARON!!!!!!!!!!!

24 Lucy { 05.20.10 at 1:29 am }

This is so much better than the show.
I wonder how many ‘kitchens’ they rejected before they found these two – or do you think perhaps an email went round at the Channel 10 studios? Wanted kitchen, must colour coordinate with red and blue and kaftans.
So everyone hates Joanne now – seems fair, it takes the heat of the other J for now 😉
Imagine if Ramsey showed up as a guest judge – maybe that’s where they all went on their UK trip? As an aside, do you think he’d remember John from when he worked for him?
As for those up for elimination this week, given that article that appeared in the national press the other day it seems a pointless episode to watch now. However, am sure it will provide great fodder for the terminator critics LOL
Thank goodness for this Blog!

25 librarygirl { 05.20.10 at 7:33 am }

I would have absolutely loved to be bailed up in the supermarket! But would my house have been suitable for filming ?- I’m sure it wouldn’t. I,too,wonder if any people said yes and then were knocked back after the tv people deemed kitchen not suitable after initial visit? No way in the world this was all done on the same day – no-one I know would have a house/kitchen cupboards drop-dead ready for a dozen people to swing by and start cooking.

Was it explained why one families’ request for choc dessert was ingnored? Completely and utterly.

26 Angel86 { 05.20.10 at 8:24 am }

Joanne is really starting to p!ss me off! First that stupid comment about not being the one to make the creme brulee last week, now all the drama last night about the team not supporting her. She obviously hasn’t done anything to earn their respect, deal with it. She should’ve been up for elimination. She was the leader, she made the ultimate decision to ignore the family and not go with a chocolate dessert like the mother asked for. Even their original dessert, before the cream stuffed up, wasn’t really enough chocolate to satisfy 3 teenagers. The red team listened to their family and gave them what they asked for, that was the brief. Red team should’ve won, based on that.

And what was with Joanne’s stupid little plait in her hair, she’s not 5 years old, she’s like 40-something, isn’t she? It just looked stupid.

27 rusty { 05.20.10 at 9:15 am }

Miaow! Poor Joanne, even her hair is getting up people’s nostrils now –

“And what was with Joanne’s stupid little plait in her hair, she’s not 5 years old, she’s like 40-something, isn’t she?”

What about Aaron’s beanie, or Callum’s pimples? Carrie’s dress sense or Jake’s chronic basset hound mug?

I don’t find Jo’s hair half as bad as Skye’s. At least it is neat and off her face. Finding a frond of Skye’s wrapped around a piece of poached peach (poached peach again?) in my mouth would be a bigger turn-off than a raw pork for me.

She’s a bit of a victim-type – and her winsome smirks at the judges are getting a bit frequent, but the total unreality of that immaculate family/immaculate kitchen/immaculate kids set-up reallay di it for me. More than the more relalisticl reactions of Jo. Lot of staged acting from some of the others, though, incl. everyone’s fave Marion. Such happy campers, the red team – so feelgood, so bland. Like their food.

One hour in a foreign kitchen to cook a meal? In reality reality they would have spent at least 1/2 that time trying to find the implements. Funny how we saw no frantic searches for whisks, or despair over non-functioning blenders!

Jo should’ve been the one to go but the other Jo is obviously better tv.

28 Paul { 05.20.10 at 9:34 am }

1. If you’ve got a crap house and kitchen, then its pretty unlikely that you would be agreeing to let the whole of Australia look at it. Stands to reason that the only ones who would agree are the ones that are quite proud to ‘show off’. Or they were inveterate attention seekers.

2. I don’t think it stated anywhere that it was all filmed the same day. Think you’ll find the filming was all done a few days later after they found the family in order to give them time to clean the house and ‘TV” it up a bit.

3. Marion continues to impress me.

29 TDK { 05.20.10 at 9:49 am }

Did anyone noticed that the red team’s kitchen also conveniently has red paint on it?

Blue team’s family’s son – he hadn’t had prawn until now? That’s just wrong, and stupid, and wrong, and sissy, great way to get teased at school now!!

Joanne is useless and annoying as usual. I just want to smack her face everytime I see it. At lesat Sharnee is possitive and calm and happy looking, Joanne’s face is one of constant agitation and smugness.

It will be a sudden death taste test, so travesty is a god 75%.

30 TDK { 05.20.10 at 9:49 am }

Leadership material – exactly as Aaron has planned 😛

31 Pollywaffle { 05.20.10 at 9:49 am }

Rusty- thankfully Carrie is in elimination gear tonight, no more fugly outfits from her !!!!

Hope Callum never has to suffer the indignity of making spotted dick

Bet Skye has hairy armpits too

Georgie will be wringing his hands today over filo pastry deal he almost had his stubby mits on

32 akris { 05.20.10 at 9:59 am }

Can Carrie just please go tonight? Has she done ANYTHING right all season?? I don’t even remember how she got into the top 24 at all.. The challenge tonight is a bit iffy though.. what if Callum leaves?? He’s the only one i really like from the bottom 4.. but ideally Carrie to go.

Joanne Joanne Joanne.. i want to like you but you make it so darn hard!! Can we swap you to have Adele back?? I have to admit I do like having a mother in the competition.

Oprah comment by Jake.. too cute.. he’s got layers that Jakey.. I agree he’s under the radar but I kinda like having him around.. when all the not so great cooks (Carrie, Sharnee, Fiona) leave then he can go after them. but for now.. I hope he stays!

33 akris { 05.20.10 at 10:04 am }

Muru: I would think thatJake getting picked early isn’t helped by his penchant for knife accidents and his having to walk on crutches..

34 Fiona { 05.20.10 at 10:35 am }

I’m not sure why, after being asked for chocolate dessert, they came up with poached peaches with white chocolate (they are not the same thing at all). I think Skye has thing for poaching peaches – it is the third time she’s done them now, perhaps she pushed it and the white choc followed – unfortunately it didn’t even work out and we were left with … well, not sure really. Kids don’t like poached peaches, it’s such a granny dessert. I feel bad for Johnathon but I think he would survive if it was a cooking pressure test, but a tasting – given the edits, who knows! Joanna has a permanently pinched look on the her face now, striding around the house shouting “is everyone allright?” does not constitute leadership to me, but maybe we didn’t see her best moments. Also noted that they went to a Coles in a nice suburb to make sure they had a chance of visiting a house that was big enough.

35 Jenny { 05.20.10 at 11:05 am }

Great post! Summed up everything beautifully. Yes Joanne is annoying. I get the feeling that she isn’t coping very well with all the group challenges. Maybe it is all very overwhelming for her coping with all the different personalities. Yes got to agree that Carrie has to go. Has she cooked anything well yet? Also she always looks a bundle of nerves which makes me, the tv watcher at home, nervy. I am starting to warm to Jonathan – he is coping very well with constantly being in the elimination challenges and has cooked some nice meals. If he survives this elimination round he surely should be nicknamed the “terminator”!

36 anon { 05.20.10 at 12:08 pm }

TDK

“at lesat Sharnee is possitive and calm and happy looking”

or vacuous. And has she cooked anything at all yet?

Paul
” Marion continues to impress me.”

by doing just what? over-acting?

37 Reality Raver { 05.20.10 at 12:59 pm }

Oh man I wish I had seen this episode it sounded like it was great.

They would have to give time to clean up otherwise they would get no one. I would have to put that week’s worth of washing that is always on my couch. And if anyone was cooking me dinner I would love it.

Hilarious about the out of date filo – but wouldn’t the judges expect them to make their own or does that only relate to mayo?

38 injera { 05.20.10 at 1:32 pm }

Pollywaffle: Oh, “Family Ties”- I wish I’d thought of that for my heading! “You know we belong together…”! And you’re right, it was great to see some honesty coming out in this ep. Thanks for confirming the existence of Aristos – was he in Perth? As for the Little Buddha – great image.

Magic of TV: I’m so unobservant – didn’t even notice the colour schemes!

Wurstsemmel: Good point on the pushing-the-envelope limitations with a young family. And it’s interesting that Alvin is picked towards the bottom. Wonder why?

Zibb: I’m disappointed that Joanne isn’t up for elimination due to the fact that she was such a poor leader, too. If ABC (anyone but Carrie) goes tonight I’ll be sad.

Sourkraut: Every time you say you can’t be bothered anymore I have a mild anxiety attack. I’d really miss your comments! For the love of all that is whatever, keep watching! It would have been teh orsm if you’d been in Coles that day… but would you have agreed to go on? Mint must’ve been on sale, since the reds also used it with their (sh)frittata. Didn’t see the promos for tomorrow so missed the oil thing. Look forward to seeing it.

Pollywaffle: Yes to Oliver Peyton from GBM!

DMC: Jake is a mystery – so many injuries, but so little airtime.

Sourkraut: What sort of curries are in the curry pot aisle? I thought it would be pot noodles, but perhaps I’m wrong.

Ursa: No press releases from Coles so far about filo-gate! And that’s a good point about the presence of TV pressure on the kid to eat the prawns.

Muru: Peter has been getting a lot of to-cameras recently, which sort of tells me he’ll be around. I agree that it would be great to see more of their cooking so we can have an idea of what they’re producing, but we’re all broken records on that issue!

Jenny: RR posted an link where Padma from Top Chef talked about keeping the wardrobe stocked with a couple of sizes to accommodate the growing waistline during shooting. Of course, she didn’t grow as much as these guys appear to be…

Fides: Would be interesting to find out more about that story. Aaron was definitely targeting her, so I wonder if there is an openness in the house about who’s not seen to be cutting it (it not being “fingers”or “feet”). I haven’t been visiting the forums, so thanks for letting us know about the deleted thread.

39 injera { 05.20.10 at 1:35 pm }

Kaylem: The frittatas DID look awful. Maybe okay for a brunch that the kids made for dad on Fathers’day, but pretty ordinary for this. Clearly needed to be wrapped in filo and called spanner ko peters. Didn’t see the shunning of Joanne at the end, but it’s not really surprising. She didn’t have to call out the team for not being supportive, particularly when her only responsibility, it seemed was… to be supportive. So, they were meant to be supportive of her supportiveness? Is tonight’s dish bouilliabaisse (sp?)? If it’s a Mediterranean dish, you’d have to be safe with olive oil. And I’m STILL laughing at the “Oil to wax your head, little man” comment!

Anon: Ah, didn’t think of it being a class thing. Interesting… I guess we should be grateful that there was no “Oprah: Weekdays at…” at the bottom of the screen when Jake was talking!

Lucy: I missed the article last week, so am ignorant as to who is leaving. Will google it afterwards so I don’t spoil myself (if that’s the right phrasing…).

Librarygirl: I’d need a week’s notice to get my place in order! As for the chocolate wishes, the blues went with white chocolate (noooooo!) and then messed it up so had to leave it out. So they missed the mark completely, rather than just by a lot.

Angel86: Agree, agree! She should have been up for elim.

Rusty: Finding your way around anybody else’s kitchen would be a challenge worth more than the time given, you’re right. Although I think everybody knows not to look in the third drawer down, right?

Paul: Absolutely agree – I wouldn’t be agreeing to let anyone in my kitchen, so it stands to reason that people who did would be pretty confident that theirs would be okay. It certainly is implied that it’s the same day, if not directly stated. I know we’re all reality TV veterans and know instinctively that it mightn’t be, but I’m pretty sure the judges say “and tomorrow, two of you will be up for elim” or something along those lines. Marion is impressive and it’s a good sign that she seems universally admired.

TDK: The sudden death nature of the challenge does worry me.

Akris: LOL – Jake does seem to be a liability!

Fiona: I hadn’t linked Skye with serial peach poaching – well-spotted!

Jenny: The group challenges are my least favourite part of this, given that everyone is in competition with everyone else, so while working well as a team is necessary for victory, there is innate tension in a team full of individual competitors.

Anon: Marion has had some good results, and I think the fact that she’s picked early in the teams shows us what the editors don’t always – she’s seen as reliable and consistent by her competitors. I… can’t remember anything Sharnee has cooked, no.

RR: I did see filo making once on a food show – maybe a Rick Stein? Or Food Safari? – and it looked amazing. And amazingly difficult! Would love to see these guys have a crack at it!

40 TDK { 05.20.10 at 1:47 pm }

anon – or that; and a no to that as well, but at least she’s the least I’d want to punch in the face, lol.

41 Rusty { 05.20.10 at 1:50 pm }

injera,

Both teams chose white chocolate, you know, not just the Blues. To me, white choc is a real stylist’s choice, not a cook’s, but admit it would look better with red/purple berries (REd team) than with brown.

Obviously Alvin is not a popular team member (as opposed to individual). Maybe he’s more like Jonno than he likes to admit – ambitious and self-serving maybe. . Remember, in the 1st team challenge Alvin didn’t want J on his team because he perceived him as not a team member type.

Perhaps old Alvie, isn’t, either! I’d like to see a showdown at the end of the comp. between these two!

42 Suzanne { 05.20.10 at 2:01 pm }

Absolutely loving this blog! Thank you for the diligent recaps Injera (and the original RR), as well as regular comment contributors. I have been following this blog since the first MC, and have been addicted ever since. What I love most is seeing comments that I have been screaming at the TV, in print. I don’t get to watch all the episodes, but as others have said, I don’t feel that I’m missing out on anything when I can read this blog – though I have to stop reading at work – too much laughing out loud. :-)

43 Injera { 05.20.10 at 2:11 pm }

Rusty: You’re right, both teams did choose the white chocolate (eat the wagon wheel!) but the blues were the ones who’d been advised to do a chocolate dessert, where the reds focus was on fruit (and, as you say, the white worked better visually with the fruit – and also, I’d say, as far as appeal to the little kids would go). In some ways I’m hoping that Alvin and Jonathan both make it a bit further as I’d like to see more of their personalities emerging, particularly in light of your observations about their similarities.

Suzanne: Glad you’re enjoying the recaps and comments or “therapy” as I like to call it!

44 sourkraut { 05.20.10 at 2:51 pm }

Injera Kaylen
Everyone has their price. For an elegant sufficiency i would have agreed provide they cleaned up the house first, a herculean task given the co inhabitation of 3 2o-somethings. Trouble is when i tell them my fave meal is a Shit sandwich (Old joke :GROAN The more “Bread” you have in life the less shit you have to eat. GROAN again) would they be able to cook it properly or would it come back raw YUCK I have my limits! ALSO as John Cleese portrayed in a real estate agents ad about 15 years ago, I wouldn’t want the crew to come stomping through my bed of petunias.
Injera
The curry pot curries I have tried from Coles are all the stock standards. Roghan Josh, Butter chicken Lamb Korma, Lamb Madras, Dhal Mixede vegetables, (there are others) and separate containers of rice. At about $9 (I think) per container (same size as standard restaurant take away,) its quite good value. Not quite as tasty as restaurant but definitely acceptable. NO I DONT WORK FOR COLES!

45 Airwalk { 05.20.10 at 4:14 pm }

Thanks again for the blog and the comments-entertains us all…even though my comments are not witty. Yes Aristos is Perth based-has a restaurant over on Rottnest now. The MC episode last night was crap-wth was Curtis Stone there for? He grimaced his way through the whole episode(probably wondering why he was there to? Thinking about The Apprentice and Miss USA Pageant got him through it). If they were going to have him there, why didn’t they do a $10 per course challenge instead of annoying family challenge(Agree the Dad of the nonprawn eater was creepy and the young family were a waste of time, they would have eaten anything. And why didn’t they make a chocolate tart or a million other things than a wretched poached peach)Just cause the Dad was a chef doesn’t mean he is a decent one either). Anyway just watched the latest Top Chef Masters episode so that makes up for the MC rubbish. Maybe we should open betting on how many ingredients they guess right tonight…will it be more than 2 this time? Thursday episode is the worst for me.

46 Injera { 05.20.10 at 4:37 pm }

Airwalk: Oh, I’ve been missing Top Chef Masters! Good call on the number of ingredients they’ll get right before the axe falls. It is, after all, a half hour episode so… let’s see… 5 mins fluffing around in the house, 5 mins of judges bellowing, 10 mins ads, 5 mins of the winners eating… leaves 5 mins of taste test. Sound about right?

47 kate (NTK!) { 05.20.10 at 5:08 pm }

I think the comments about the Dad being creepy are a bit unfair – remember editing, editing, editing. Adn you’d be making snide comments too if you had George or Gary lurking around your house telling you over and over about you have half of Ostaya’s best amata chefs about to make you the best meal you’ve ever eaten, having a camera crew filming your every mouthful after a long day at work, let alone having to dine with Matt and what’s his name.

Particularly if you’ve actually seen some of the efforts of these amateurs on tv…Personally I’d be waiting to have words with my spouse about what on earth she was thinking of when she agreed.

48 Injera { 05.20.10 at 5:10 pm }

kate (NTK!): Spot on! I’d be horrified if a group of reality TV participants and entourage landed in my place. I’d be the snippiest spouse in the history of snippy spouses…

49 Airwalk { 05.20.10 at 5:37 pm }

I do think the best thing about the offsite challenges is the string quartet doesn’t go with them-you know the one that plays the music that gives away what the Gs and Matt are going to say after they have finishing stabbing the plate with a fork(George) or slobbering food in their gob(Matt).

50 sourkraut { 05.20.10 at 8:26 pm }

Injera
You might even be a bit” sour” about it?
Possibly an opportunity wasted if they came to the krauthaus I’d, wear a groucho marx pair of glasses, yellow pantaloons with the bottom cut out of them and a Rupert shirt. What price 5 minutes of fame?

51 Masterchef Australia – Were The Families Not As Random As They Pretended To Be | reality ravings { 05.20.10 at 10:31 pm }

[…] Hilton’s …..personality. In last night’s challenge as wonderfully recapped by Injera here, the two teams had to find a random family in Coles […]