for those who have reality tv as their guilty pleasure
Reality Ravings | Australia's leading Reality TV blog!

Posts from — May 2010

Masterchef – sudden death (open post)

As sudden death is exactly what happened to my laptop earlier, and I don’t want it to happen to my relatively peaceful domestic partnership, I can’t blog tonight’s episode.  I look forward to wresting the working tech from my partner’s hands at some point during the evening so I can read your comments and chime in with some of my own, but his sanity at the moment is resting on being able to websurf and play Fallout while I’m glued to the TV so I’ll have to wait until he’s occupied with The Daily Show or Colbert.

I wish I could confidently predict Carrie’s demise, but I have no faith in the sudden death process as a means to allowing the “right people” to advance in this competition.

May 20, 2010   51 Comments

Masterchef Australia – Were The Families Not As Random As They Pretended To Be

Masterchef Australia this year is starting to look faker than Paris Hilton’s …..personality. In last night’s challenge as wonderfully recapped by Injera here, the two teams had to find a random family in Coles Chatswood.

There was some comments speculating about whether anyone’s kitchen would be camera ready to have a crew come and film it, let alone the opportunity to replace all those manky wooden spoons in the second drawer. However,  most viewers would expect they would give them a day or so to clean up.

However a person on Facebook has revealed that she photographed one of the families and says they were from an agency. Were these families cast for this challenge? I have made enquiries and will update when I get a response.

I particularly agree with the person who said it is was interesting both teams were able to find a family of five.

Read the excerpt below.

Masterchef Australia is being known this year more for its reality TV trickery rather then the cooking.

Thank you to Fiona for alerting me to this.

UPDATE: Fremantle Media has responded and said the selection of the families were random.

May 20, 2010   16 Comments

Masterchef – surprise chef!

Ominous drums signal the welcome back to the Masterchef kitchen.  Gary thinks there are not many of them left, but there are still a lot I don’t know.  And a lot I don’t care for, Carrie.  I hope the fact that she’s getting the initial interview here signals that she’ll be on the block.  In any other reality show, I’d suspect that this was a red herring, but the way the editing has been so far I’m sure that it’s something I can take to the bank.

The Challenge

Making a three course family dinner WITH A TWIST! Which is that they will stalk a supermarket shopper and cook them a bew-ti-ful three course meal in their kitchen.  I’m horrified that nobody gives Ari the Surprise Chef a shoutout, or did I imagine him?  Somebody please confirm that he wasn’t just a figment of my imagination.

Matt will be dining with a super secret mystery guest judge, and we all know that it’s Curtis so I’ve completely lost interest in Matt’s camping this up.  The winners will have a meal at Sailor’s Thai and two of the losers will be facing elimination.

The three celeb challengers from last night have to decide which one of them will be the captain and Joanne really wants this.  Aaron strategically decides to vote for her and she’s a bit surprised, since Aaron is tight with Matt, who is also surprised.  Finally, though, he figures out why Aaron’s playing this way.  Bright spark, our Matt.

Joanne chooses blue, and she picks Sharnee as the opposing captain.

Joanne’s team: Jimmy, Claire, Adam, Aaron, Skye, Alvin, Jonathan, Carrie

Sharnee’s team: Marion, Peter, Callum, Matthew, Phil, Fiona, Jake

Coles

Joanne is Kath. Or Kim.  “Just stick with moi, ploise?”

Both teams get some knockbacks before the reds hit on a handsome looking guy with a cute kid.  Who gets the fireball treatment.  And then the reds discovered that their dad is a chef so they ask him what he’d cook and then they start picking up nasty parmesan cheese from the sponsors.  Ick.

Nobody wants Kimmy to cook for them, until Kirrily magically appears.  She and her family have just returned from Singapore, so Aaron is pleased by this.  They break into two groups to complete the shopping.  I wonder if the green bags were factored into the $100 budget.

Cooking

Tua has a nice kitchen – reds are lucky!  And they have Gary, who… is not George.

Kirrily’s house meets with Joanne’s approval, but she notes that the kitchen is tiny.  They’ve drawn George as their coach.

Callum alienates the sponsor by interviewing that the filo is past its use by date so instead of making spanakopita, they will now make frittata, which is what Tua wanted, anyway.

Kirrily’s small kitchen means that Jimmy and Aaron are making chilli prawns outside.  Claire, Adam and Alvin are making poached chicken with coconut milk and Carrie and Jonathan are dealing with dessert.  What is Joanne doing?  “Guys, what can I do for you? Nothing? Good?”  So she goes outside for a cry.  While she’s out there being soothed by George, the dessert is a disaster in the making: pastry not working, split cream… so she goes to make the table beautiful.  In the red corner, Marion is giving Sharnee props for her spot-on leadership.  Joanne interviews that her role is to oversee everythink (sic), which seems to mean asking people what they want and then not responding to their requests.

The Situation is having problems getting the frittatas out of the muffin tins and if he keeps talking, he’ll have problems getting that date he seems to think his MC celebrity will bring, abs or no abs.

Blah blah lack-of-dramatic-tension… here’s Curtis.  And Jake watches OPRAH!

Dining

Red Team

The red family like the frittata, but Curtis thinks it’s a bit cheese heavy.  The kids think the lamb is yum, and it reminds Curtis of something you’d get in a good pub.  Tua is happy with it, so Curtis asks “are you blown away?” and he admits that he’s not.  Was being “blown away” part of the “family meal” brief?  I’m not blown away by Curtis’ fettucine bolognese, either.  Not, you know, that I’ve tried it.  It just looks so lumpy and unappetising. Matt says that their dessert will need to be special and the kids give it a “great” and a “good” and because they’re happy, Tua’s happy.  And so are the red team, spying through the kitchen window.  Curtis thinks the reds have done a great job, “but this is Masterchef”, he adds ominously, as though that means that standard should be higher.  They should really make him watch the show so that he can develop some realistic expectations.

Blue Team

Hawker style prawns.  Dad says that they eat well at home anyway, a bit snarkily, but 15 year old Harry – who hasn’t ever eaten prawns – has a crack, which amazes everybody.  The chicken poached in coconut broth with chicken rice gets the thumbs up from the family, and Curtis thinks they’ve hit the nail on the head.  Dessert comes out and it’s the poached peach tart. Fireball.  God, now even Matt’s saying bewt-i-ful.  The pastry is heavy – CARRIE! – and Kirrily thinks it’s a bit uh-UH.

Pointless Judge comments

Sharnee wants to go on a reward lunch and Joanne is trying to be confident but not cocky.

Sharnee says that her team performed well overall.  The positives: they nailed talking to the family, understanding it and delivering it.  The dessert was a “hero moment… FAN-tastic”.  Negatives: frittata was disappointing.  Callum says that it’s what Tua mentioned, but Gary thinks they could have done it better.  No mention of the supermarket stocking out-of-date products.

Joanne thinks the blue team worked well but didn’t support her and Claire and Jonathan give her death stares.  Jonathan says there was no leadership, to nods from Aaron.  Joanne interviews that she disagrees with his opinion.  Positives: innovative menu, magnificent entree.  They are still going with the idea that someone who has never eaten something is a good judge of whether it is good or not.  Negatives: dessert disaster.  It failed on two fronts: didn’t match the brief and was executed poorly.  The meringue and the pastry are the main culprits.

Results

Red: 7

Blue: 7

Curtis and Matt had the casting vote.  Curtis liked the reds, but Matt liked the blues.  So we’re getting all the cliches now, as Gary dusts off “long and hard”.  I’m predicting that, after the inevitable fireball, we’re going to see them send the two captains to elimination.

Unfortunately I’m wrong.  Carrie and Jonathan will face it for the blues, and Joanne – who did nothing – gets away with it.  Phillip and Callum will be up against it for the reds.  If Carrie doesn’t go home, it will be a travesty.

Random thoughts

  • Is Curtis’ surprise chef show the elephant in the room?  Matt says he was the perfect judge, but doesn’t say “because he does this shit all the time in the US”.
  • Why were the positive comments from Harry on the prawns given so much weight. He’d never eaten the bloody things before, so how could he judge a good prawn from a bad one?
  • Ugh, how awful was that staged everybody-grabbed-a-tea-towel shot?
  • Matt’s trousers tonight? Tangerine nightmare.
  • Somebody (Pollywaffle?) pointed out that Gary has adopted George’s foot bouncing.  He and Matt are also aping the “bew-ti-ful” pronunciation.
  • There’s a Curry Pot aisle in Coles?
  • And, once again, because it rocked… Jake watches OPRAH!

May 19, 2010   51 Comments

Masterchef – three’s company?

Aaron opens the show by telling us that he’s awake. This does not bode well. If you’re putting your jacket on, we can tell you’re awake. Matthew tells us that he’s listening to music, which we can also see, and Joanne is pretty pleased with herself (ditto – she seems smugger by the minute). Our trio enter the kitchen in their white jackets for a history making challenge. Donna is rocking some heels and a short dress and she doesn’t seem to be too intimidated by Matt’s extraordinary yellow pants and matching pocket handkerchief.

Matt tells the contestants that they will face “not one! Not two! But three! Talented! Chefs!” and I expect that Jim Henson’s Creature Shop will be contacting Ten soon to licence a Matt Muppet. The Situation – sorry, I mean Phillip – applauds enthusiastically from the balcony. George tells them that the trio of chefs they will face have hats and that one has worked for Heston Blumenthal, eliciting gasps from the two contestants who have heard of him. But enough preamble! Let’s meet Team Arras:

  • Adam Humphrey
  • Lovaine Allen
  • Aaron Somebody else (please let me know if you caught that name)

Our trio gets a 20 minute head start in making rack on black: lamb saddle wrapped in black pudding with a leek and potato boulangere. They even have to make the black pudding! I hope there is some Nick Nairn style gagging over the buckets of blood. They taste.

Apparently Matthew is the boss of our trio, and hands out the tasks to the others. Aaron ends up with the pig’s blood – lucky Aaron – and Joanne starts the potato boulangere. Matthew is… well, I think the technical term is “boning the lamb”.

Team Arras disappears behind the partition and I hope nobody mistakes their frantic activity for the scrabblings of a rat (and that’s the only immature Hamlet reference I’ll be making, so you can relax now).

Matthew purees his dates, and no, that is not a euphemism.  He ends up with “date soup” which is no good, so he starts again. Aaron’s got the black pudding under control and notices that Joanne is struggling with her potatoes. Lorraine, on the Arras team, is having trouble with her blood pudding and Matthew seems to be spending too much time spying on their technique and feeling smug, which surely encroaches on Joanne’s territory. Adam thinks they’ll lose if their black pudding is not up to scratch, but they have enough time to make another one.

The last two minutes are the longest ever and I hope there are some eagle eyes out there looking for possible replatings. Adam thinks they’re in with a good chance, but the peanut gallery wasn’t exactly on song with predictions last night now, were they?

Tasting

Plate 1 – Team Arras

  • Donna likes they way it’s balanced on the plate and thinks the camera would like it, which is odd, since it’s BROWN. They taste and she screws up her nose.
  • George: Leeks undercooked, crunchy, not good at all. Potatoes lack salt, but are buttery.
  • Matt thinks the crunchy leek adds a textural contrast.
  • Donna: the date pulls it together.

Plate 2 – Team Masterchef

  • Donna is not asked for her view on how this plate does, so she seems completely redundant in this round.
  • George – “that potato is absolutely gorgeous for me” but the lamb is undercooked.
  • Matt thinks the potato lacks the shivers of leek. (I think that’s what he says… anybody?)
  • Donna finds the puree fruitier than on plate one.

Lineball, says George. Fireball, says the ad break.

Verdict

Team MC: 6 from Donna and Joanne makes it known that she is responsible for the potatoes. There is still no Jo in t-e-a-m. 6 from Matt and 7 from George.
Team Arras: 7 from George, 7 from Donna, 8 from Matt.

Arras wins, but Team MC earn praise for cooking right through to the end, which seems like a prize for showing up.

Other thoughts:

  • Did anybody else think that Aaron and Matthew’s high five was very rehearsed?
  • Gary keeps telling us how important a munity is, but what exactly IS a munity? (Seriously, did I miss it when immunity was explained?)
  • Did the judges even mention the black pudding?
  • Is that it?

May 18, 2010   17 Comments

Masterchef Australia – Daniel Aulsebrook Claims Favouritism Occurs On Show

Ok Daniel tell us something we don’t know of course the producers and judges have favourites. In fact as Injera’s latest blog post it suggests that this is very much the case with Gary Mehigan’s comment “We need to make sure we keep the right people in this competition”!

Daniel Aulsebrook has said to Adelaide Now the makers of the show, as well as judges Matt Preston, George Calombaris and Gary Mehigan, have favourites.

He said:

“Alvin is like the dream child and I am sure Fiona is very popular (with the judges) too,” Aulsebrook says.

“I felt mine (schnitzel) looked the best and I was fairly confident, as were the (other) contestants watching, that I had it in the bag.

“I wasn’t there for the (judges) tasting so I don’t know what the story is.”

Aulsebrook says Quah and Inglis, along with South Australian student Marion Grasby, are the apples of the judges’ eyes.

“The impression a few of us get is that they (the show’s producers and the judges) do have their favourites,” Aulsebrook says.

“Some of those favourites are a step up on the others (better cooks) and it is justified, but then there are a few other favourites that aren’t necessarily the best cooks in the competition but they go down well with the producers and the judges.”

Channel Ten obviously said it was all bollocks:

“The decision to eliminate Daniel was based purely on his cooking which in last night’s show was simply not up to scratch,” a Ten spokesperson says.

“He had no idea what meat he was using, his schnitzel was over cooked but his decision to use mayonnaise from the jar for his coleslaw sealed his fate.”

I am sure Daniel’s theory that they have favourites has been confirmed by the fact he got very limited screen time on the show.

May 18, 2010   25 Comments