Category — The Apprentice
The Apprentice Contestants Request Removal Of Readers Comments From Reality Ravings
Gavin McInnes and Amy Cato, both contestants on Channel Nine’s reality TV show, The Apprentice, recently contacted me, requesting comments made by readers be removed from the site.
Both Gavin and Amy contacted me concerned about comments that were made on the site by readers. Obviously I have no idea whether the reader’s remarks were defamatory, however my blog’s policy is that any reasonable request of removal of comments will be considered.
Both contestants own businesses and are probably concerned about comments which may cause a question mark about their integrity.
Viewers of reality TV shows can sometimes be forthright in their opinions about performances, or how the “character” is edited. Fan forums, both official and unofficial, and blogs are an important part of reality TV. Chances are contestants not going to be loved by all. Criticism will range from minor, like the clothes people are wearing, to major where people dissect personality traits.
Gavin McInnes, who requested only one comment be removed, is a corporate lawyer, who has started his own company Stone Leaf Capital, a corporate advisory and capital raising company.
In an interview with www.Sofix.com.au he also states he is in the process of setting up Stone Leaf Finance, which will broker all types of commercial finance solutions to businesses and companies in a range of industries. The interview would also indicate if he wins the show he may not take up the prize of working with Mark Bouris for a year.
Amy who is a partner in recruitment company Cato and Hall also requested comments also be removed from Reality Ravings.
Reality TV has become a vehicle for people to promote their businesses or themselves to obtain some long term benefit for themselves or their companies.
This can have some success, for example, MasterChef Australia contestant, Chris Badenoch successfully promoted his beer business Beer Masons whilst on the show.
However conversely there is a risk if you are portrayed badly on the show your brand may become damaged.
October 19, 2009 26 Comments
Reality TV Shows Duking It Out For End Of Year Ratings
I have just posted this article on The Punch.
The TV stations are in the final throes of the ratings year and over the past few weeks they have launched the shows to lead them into the Christmas break.
The big three stations have included some new reality TV shows in their arsenal to win over the viewers and therefore gain advertising dollars.
The Apprentice:
One of Channel Nine’s highly promoted new programs, made by reality TV gurus Fremantle Media. The show started off to very poor ratings of under 700,000, but this week it improved and look like it is gaining traction. The problem with attracting viewers may not be the show but people lacking faith in Nine not sticking with the program.
Channel Nine this year have had a history of not treating their reality TV shows very well, and not giving them time to gain traction with their audience. They have pulled programs after one episode, like Dance Your Ass Off, changed the time they have been shown, Home Made, or even just shorten the programs to 30 minutes like Australia’s Perfect Couple. Or in fact just haven’t shown programs at all, like Superstars of Dance, and Survivor Gabon.
Personally I think viewers were sceptical on whether to put the effort into watching the show when they think it will be pulled at a moments notice.
The Apprentice is an entertaining well produced reality show. Mark Bouris who is now settling into his role, is entertaining and charismatic. There is a good mix of personalities in the contestants, with perhaps my only criticism is the likeability of a lot of them is questionable. The challenges are diverse and fun, and the boardroom scenes have the requisite amount of backstabbing in them.
Beauty And The Geek:
Channel Seven premiered Beauty and The Geek last week, this is a take off of a US program of the same name. The premise is the Geeks (the guys) teach the girls “academic” subjects, while the Beauty’s teach the geeks about girls. One team is eliminated each week. For what is a fluffy premise it really is entertaining, particularly the geeks who are witty, both intentionally and unintentionally, and who will find themselves chased by girls once they are out of the house.
The girls most whom will be vying for Ralph photoshoots at the end of the series are not quite as engaging, and I seriously hope they are not at stupid as they are playing up to the camera. Oh and if anyone knows which airline, stewardess Jenna works for please tell, as I don’t want to be on her plane when an emergency occurs, as my confidence in her remembering the emergency procedures are low. I would guess she is playing dumb to get on the show.
The show is rating well with an opening audience of 1.05 million last week, and they are holding and gaining viewers with 1.067 last night, with a win in most demographics. Also following on from this show is the highly entertaining The Amazing Race which deservedly wins the best reality TV show at the Emmy’s each year.
Celebrity MasterChef:
Celebrity MasterChef was never going to live up to MasterChef Australia hype, but this Fremantle Media production is delivering solid, but not stratospheric ratings like the original did earlier this year. I think one of the reasons why Celebrity versions of shows are not as popular is because one of the great things about reality TV is seeing ordinary people breaking out of the everyday mediocrity or their lives, or discovering new personalities, and talent.
However it is a watchable once a week show, with a nice mix of celebrities to hit their key demographics. The entertainment is in watching the contestants tackle a difficult dish which is a signature of a well known celebrity chef this week was Kylie Kwong’s delicious duck recipe. Expect to see an Adriano Zumbo creation with a high degree of difficulty later in the finals to really ensure the celebrities are really under pressure. Who can forget the chocolate cake from the last week of MasterChef Australia? It will be interesting to see if Channel Ten do another Celebrity version next year.
Australian Idol:
Channel Ten traditionally finish their year with Australian Idol and it is not new and and is struggling with it not making the magic one million viewer mark. See a previous The Punch post on here on what has gone wrong on Australian Idol here and whether this is going to be the final season is currently the $64 million question.
Finally a new show that started a few weeks ago on Arena deserves a special shout out – Tabatha’s Takeover Salon. The reason it is hosted by Australian now living in USA, hairdresser Tabatha Coffey. It is like the Gordon Ramsay of hairdressing shows where she “takes over” struggling hair salons to make them a viable business again. Tabatha’s direct manner without the famous Ramsay aggression, and an Australian sense of humour actually makes her likeable and entertaining. It is not just a reality TV show for girls.
At this stage none of these Australian shows have been renewed and the stations will be watching viewer demographics keenly to see if they deserve another series.
October 16, 2009 10 Comments
The Apprentice – Episode Three – The Pie Challenge
This week’s challenge was to create, make, market and to sell a completely new flavour of pie.
The winning team is the one who makes the most profit. They were given $2600 for the challenge.
But first project managers had to be chosen Amy Cato, a business woman from South Australia was one, and Gavin McInnes the buffed lawyer was the other.
I loved how the narrator had to point out to the viewer the pro’s and cons about being the project manager, you don’t have to be a member of mensa to work that out.
Then their was a surprise twist where Amy and Gavin had to swap teams, and lead them.
Gavin said this week “it is time to bring out the personality.” which if by the following comment is anything to go is a tad chauvinistic. When talking about the women he said “They need to be controlled as the fly off the handle easily….”
The girls settled on a vegetable curry pie. Which I don’t think was actually a new flavour of pie, but maybe just not one sold at Hannah’s. They had the advantage of having Mary-Ann on the team who had been in catering and knew the tricks of ordering already peeled and washed potatoes. Also both her and Carmen were accomplished cooks.
Back at team Pinnacle Amy was doing market research on where they are going to market the pies so this delayed the discussion on what pie to make. Sam showed his frustration and Amy bawled him out about it.
I kind of got the feeling that Amy has done business 101 and was not going to diverge from the basic management strategy, white board included. To be honest I thought in this challenge Amy Cato’s likeability was pretty low. They finally decided on a lamb, potato and mint pie, that came out of one of Sam’s brain storming saying anything that comes out of his mouth ideas. He was talking about a roast, and John (I think) expanded upon it. So maybe spewing crap is not such a negative trait after all.
I was very happy they ditched the veal parmigana concept, and some of their more disgusting ideas.
They bought unwashed potatoes which took much longer to prepare. Oh and their prepping technique how much dirt was in their pie?
Then it was onto marketing. Blake’s view was “If you use your personality you don’t need a T-Shirt.” I am not sure if he was talking about his personality, as I have not seen any sign of it yet, or if it was a generic comment. But Amy insisted on T-shirts and flyers.
Gavin’s marketing plan was much more strategic as he got some free t-shirts by offering advertising of the printers logo on them. It would have been nice if Channel 9 had at least flashed the company name once.
Back to Amy and Blake they were handing out flyers at Darling Harbour the day before they were going to sell them there. How dumb was that it is tourist central where it was highly unlikely those people would be back the following day. Oh and the kicker they did not even start selling at Darling Harbour, but at Hyde Park.
At this stage of the show I was starting to wonder where Heather was, but it was later revealed she had the flu so she was staying home.
Team Eventus got to the pie machine first and were very slow, and Sabrina and Gavin disappeared after their marketing prep was done.
This resulted in the teams have a bit of a tiff over when Eventus would get off it. Carmen was tough saying we’re getting our pies done. Amy was whining “It is in the spirit of the competition to be fair,”.
That meat mixture looks disgusting, like pureed dog food. Even though they had a late start Pinnacle ended up producing more pies.
The teams was selling in two locations – Bondi Organic Markets, either Hyde Park or Darling Harbour. Obviously the last two location had to be pre- arranged. But I loved the way the narrator implied the teams had just rocked up there.
In the end the pies were being discounted with Morello selling them for below cost. I am not sure Morello is real smart.
Sabrina and Gavin were giving away t-shirts with their pies but they still had 200 pies left over.
And then it was off to the board room.
Eventus got their heads kicked in for marketing the pies as home made. And Sabrina I thought unfairly got swiped at by Mark Bouris when she pointed out that the t-shirt’s slogan said “for that home made taste”. Bouris thought it was a gray area and he said “we don’t go there”.
Personally I thought it was not a huge sin considering when I think of something as home made I think of it as hand crafted not necessarily made in a house. And the girls did do those pies by hand.
Anyway Eventus made $567.60 but if Mark Bouris thought the Home made sign was so false and misleading he should have stuck a ACCC fine on the for being false and misleading under the Trade Practices Act. Anyway he didn’t and they got to go for a meal at Quay.
Pinnacle’s net profit was $194.70 so a big loss for team Pinnacle, because $20 of that was from Eventus when they bought them out of the prime spot in the markets.
Amy started scapegoat as soon as the team’s loss was announced. But Bouris laid into them for having no pricing strategy and no margin policy. The team had not put a price upas they wanted to allow for pie price flexibility but Mark Bouris scathingly said “I don’t know any business who gives the sales team that sort of flexibility.”
Amy not surprisingly chose to bring back Sam and Morello into the boardroom.Her reasoning for Sam was because he did not express the business maturity the others had, and Morello for selling too low.
Bouris concerned that Morello is one dimensional, but kept him around for another week and it was Amy who got fired. I am not unhappy with that, as I don’t think I saw anything dynamic or spectcular about her in her three weeks on the show.
October 13, 2009 20 Comments
The Apprentice – Ratings Still Not Great
The ratings for The Apprentice are now in and it is not great. Last night episode recorded 657,000 viewers in its timeslot. (Source Mumbrella). On the up side none of the shows at that time did any good.
Hopefully Channel Nine won’t fire the show.
One of Australia’s leading media blog’s Mumbrella were backing in their boy Lynton Pipkorn, but apparently this may not be the last we see of him as soe of the eliminated contestants return to the show.
The article says:
Pipkorn told Mumbrella: “It was a bit tough to take. To be called Machiavellian was a little bit harsh, and a bit puzzling.”
He said that he was also disappointed that the broadcast had concentrated on him forgetting the names rather than the presentation. He said: “They focused on the fact that we did not dance around with silly hats like the girls did.”
However, despite his firing, Pipkorn will feature again towards the end of the series when some of the ousted contestants return.
He said: “˜I’ve got no regrets about doing it although I had thought the series would be more like the UK version where they were interested in one’s abilities. I’ve got a career and I did not want to cause conflict and shout people down which is not my style. Bouris seems to like the battlers and kept them in.”
Pipkorn labelled contestant Carmen – saved from eviction in the first week – as “rubbish”.
Pikorn is currently working with website My Property Partner and consulting with Urban Media.
October 6, 2009 4 Comments
The Apprentice – Episode 2 – The Cereal Challenge
Ok we have already established that Carmen Parnos is the bad guy in the show, with some commenter’s on a previous post here talking about her dubious business practices. However she was not given much air time this episode, probably to her relief.
Also there are rumours of a romance in the household – obviously not caught on camera this episode, and considering they were woken up at 4.45am apparently by Mark Bouris’s office, however we all know it was the production assistant assistant.
The challenge was to create a breakfast cereal brand for children. The teams had to design the box, a mascot, a campaign, and a jingle. They then have to present it to Oglivy executives who would decide who the winner was.
Team Eventus (the girls team) started stumbling at the start, by not going for the obvious project manager in Heather Williams who has relevant experience, but Sabrina who was thinking about her feedback she got back from Mark Bouris last episode and said she wanted to lead the team.
Lynton Pipkorn led The Pinnacle (the boys) team as he has marketing experience and wanted to showcase it.
Then it was off to do research with some school kids (obviously set up). John was sent along for the boys team as he was a father and so should know how to talk to kids, however he barely said a word when he got there.
I thought the girls were going to be stronger in this challenge. Sabrina was a bit condescending to her team mates, obviously in her management 101 class she had been told to praise her colleagues and that is what she did. In fact Heather had a more leadership role. In fact after this challenge it would appear there is not a lot of love between Heather and Sabrina.
Sabrina played a leadership by consensus role, but she did not really put her stamp on the challenge either. I thought Carmen was correct when she said in the boardroom it would not have mattered if Sabrina had been leading or not the same outcome would have been achieved.
The boys stuffed up by having a maze on the back that was impossible to do, but really the box was a prototype so was no big deal. Lynton stuffed up by not calling the Oglivy executives by their proper names, and also by being the only one that spoke. I did think their jingle was catchy. By the way did Blake even speak or contribute to the challenge apart from dressing up as the pink elephant?
So Eventus send in the two good looking chicks to pitch to the middle aged men, and then the girls proceed to jump all around the room. This was thought to present a better energy to the room. Seriously if someone started boogieing to a song whilst they were trying to pitch me something it would be a big turnoff.
Also I was not sure about what the worthiness of the zebra apparently it will help with kids self esteem, telling the kids that eat the cereal that they can be whoever they want to be. The Oglivy executives did call them on that.
Sabrina seemed to arch up when the team got some negative feedback on their pitch well and argued back. She has a very strong sense of self, about herself and her abilities. This was brought up in the boardroom and she realised that she was getting nowhere arguing she apologised. I have to confess I find the way she speaks rather irritating, it is very mono tonal.
The girls won, apparently the boys lost because they did not bring the same energy to their pitch. The girls prize was cocktails at The Ivy talking with Brett Rutledge, a world class public speaker.
In the elimination scene, Lynton was criticised for stuffing up the advertising executives names, and John was criticised for not speaking to the children. Morello was trying his real estate bullshit patter when he tried to hoodwink Mark Bouris into thinking the maze on the back of the packet. And boy did Mark put him in his place.
Lynton picked John and Sam to go on the firing line with him. I thought it particularly unfair that Sam was pulled in considering he sung the jingle and picked the cereal name.
I thought John was right when he said that Lynton had been a bit self indulgent with wanting to show off his “marketing skills” to the people. I actually thought Mark Bouris got it right. Even though I see no future in John being on the show. I thought Lynton had made all the calls which made them lose the pitch and hence the challenge.
He had decided no one else would speak, and he also did bring in Sam and particularly John in as a sacrificial lambs. Mark Bouris called him on it and fired him. Goodbye Lynton.
October 5, 2009 27 Comments

