Survivor World’s Apart – Interview With Max and Lindsey
It was a tag team interview with Max Dawson and Lindsay Cascadan who were eliminated in a double eviction on Survivor. Max, who is a Survivor scholar so to speak was the first to be eliminated after the tribal swap whereas Lindsay was the first to be eliminated from the blue collar tribe.
RR: Max you’re a scholar of the game and on your white collar tribe there was a lot of players who were fans/students of the game and had watched a lot of it but then you got the tribe swap and it was all a bit different and you were in with a lot of no-collars who were a bit more laid back about the game. Was that your downfall?
Max Dawson: The change in vibe certainly did not help my game, but my downfall actually began at white collar – it began on day 3. Before the first tribal council things were pretty precarious and we were desperately trying to work out the coalition to make sure Carolyn and Shirin were safe. They were really gunning for Carolyn and Shirin also had a huge target on her back due to that puzzle. So we worked out a move where we told Joaquin and So to vote for Carolyn and then we blindsided them. We told Carolyn we were doing this but after tribal council Carolyn was irate and was furious with Joaquin and said why did you write my name down? Joaquin, quite rightly said, “because Max told me to”. After that Carolyn was under the impression that I was a manipulative, mind controlling cult leader who had the entire tribe dancing like puppets at the end of my string. It was a misunderstanding that I was actually saving her from going home, but Carolyn is an emotional person and very competitive and she took it as a personal affront and from then on wanted to remove me from the game.
RR: Did you anticipate the tribal swap?
MD: I knew exactly when it was going to happen. I had told my other tribe mates that it will happen on this day. We had intended on, or I had thought that we had intended on trying to stay strong so if we made it to the merge we could reunite. Tyler and I were working on Shirin and Joaquin who we thought would be most likely to flip in a tribe swap. Little did I know it was Carolyn. I was not worrying enough about Carolyn and that was one of the biggest lessons I learnt in the game it is not enough to worry about the people that are not in your alliance but you have to worry about your alliance just as much if not more then the people you are going up against.
RR: You’re an academic and you lecture about Survivor?
MD: I used to be an academic and one of the classes I taught was on the history of reality television and we used Survivor as our case study. It was not teaching about how to make a fire but I did teach a class about how Survivor and other reality TV shows have transformed the landscape of American pop culture.
RR: Would you change your lecture notes after playing the game?
MD: I would not change the notes, but I would change the elements of the class. I would pay more attention to the behind the scenes production as one of the most exciting and illuminating thing about this experience was watching the men and women who make this show go about their job. It was the most impressive operation I have ever been witness to. It was like an army and all the people who work on the show are extremely talented, cool and eccentric.
RR: Who would be you favourite Survivor contestant over the years?
MD: Hands down Jonathan Penner who not only plays the game the hardest and who I identify the most with. A similar background and intellectual interests and sense of humour and fortunate enough to call him a friend.
RR: Lindsay you are the first person of the blue collar tribe to be eliminated, what was the blue collar team like? Rodney seemed particularly offensive with his sexist behaviour. Was the sexist behaviour going on all the time?
LC: The blue collar tribe was really really hard working and we were definitely more of a high strung tribe. I don’t think all the guys were sexist, I think that was mainly from Rodney. It is normal to think that the the blue collar men in America are more classic, southern or old school type of thinking, they might think they have a little bit more power over women. You are looking at three immature, uneducated guys who are starving and threatened by women and are exhausted and they need to fall back on “well we are better then women” to get themselves further in the game and make themselves feel better.
RR: What was happening with the alliances in the blue collar as the vote went two, two, two. What were you doing to try and get a majority alliance?
LC: The strategy there was Sierra, Kelly and Mike and I were the strongest alliance and it looked like we were the strongest alliance, though Dan was a swinging vote and had said he would vote for anyone but himself. I think what happened was not that Rodney was such a great strategic player but what I think was that everyone saw Rodney for what he is, just this guy who is the perfect player to sit next to in the top three as much as you want to poke his eyes out in that situation, I would love to sit next to Rodney in three. Who is going to vote for that guy? Nobody.
RR: Do people that early in the game think about who you are going to take to a possible jury vote?
LC: What you are going to see is people starting to shoot themselves in the back for making those choices so early in the game. Everyone thinks they are going to win Survivor when they get onto the island. You wouldn’t go on the show not thinking that. I think the only one who went on without thinking that is Dan who played the game of “I will play with anyone but me”. I think you are going to see a lot of people kick themselves for making the choices they made.
RR: If life a reality TV show so far for you, which show or character would best represent you?
LC: I don’t watch enough TV to answer this question, but I think Amelie [from the movie of the same name] is the character that would represent me best. She plays jokes on people and is a smart bee, funny artsy, weird girls that no one really gets. Or a classic literature character who uses the f-word a lot.
Thanks to JStar for the suggestions for the questions.



2 comments
Please. Someone explain to me the reasoning behind Carolyn and Tyler’s backing the BC tribe when they are clearly on the bottom there.
And I’m dumbfounded that Will thought he’d be in a better position to align himself with them too instead of sticking with his NC alliance.
Peski, I am still baffled by those decisions..unless there are unseen alliances we not aware of
Great interview from both, thanks…really love reading these.