for those who have reality tv as their guilty pleasure
Reality Ravings | Australia's leading Reality TV blog!

Guest Post Survivor: Can Natalie Win?

Rosie’s gives us her take on the latest Survivor episode:

As usual, we start our weekly dose of Survivor with a wee rehash of last week’s (for us, but just a little while ago for the contestants) events at TC. The survivors are trying to decide who voted for Alec instead of for Keith, so Natalie ‘fesses up but in an intelligent way. Which is just as well, because I was worried she was going to be in trubble. But girlie is a smart playa. She says she got confused about which one she was supposed to vote for, and so voted for Alec. Baylor tells her later that she’s a really good actress. Jon tells Natalie it’s fine that she stuffed up, even though it screwed up his plans. Natalie explains to Keith the next morning that she saved him by voting for Alec and that she plans to blindside Jon when she can. He is just happy to have squeaked by.

Reward Challenge. The reward is have some kind of a Survivor spa day with a meal of steak and brownies. Cue lots of oohs and aahs. They are once again divided into two teams: this time it will be Missy, Keith and Jon versus Natalie, Baylor and Jaclyn.The teams are tied together and must go through an obstacle course, consisting of a hay tunnel, a seesaw thing, sorry “teeter totter”, plus another obstacle kind of thing, and they must fill buckets of water as well to put into other buckets of water, and then somehow retrieve puzzle pieces. Missy managed to bash her ankle quite a bit during this challenge. Missy, Keith and Jon win, but Jon gives up his place for Baylor. AGAIN with the friggin’ swapsies! Natalie volunteers for Exile, and Jon tells Jaclyn he’ll be able to give her her own personal spa back at camp. Rooting? If so I guarantee we won’t wee a hint of it. Hee. Besides, the cameramen would too busy hurling to bother filming.
Jeff notices Missy’s ankle is swollen and asks if she needs medical attention but she insists it’s fine. Baylor gives her mother a piggyback ride away to Reward.

On the reward, Keith enjoys his first shower in 30 days and he tells us he’ll come out looking like George Clooney. Heh, maybe he will at that. Baylor thinks he’s funny. I roll my eyes just a little. He gives Missy’s swollen ankle his professional firey opinion. He basically thinks that it doesn’t look good.

Back at camp, Jaclyn tells Jon that Natalie felt really bad about voting for Alec. I snigger. Possibly everyone watching also has a good old chuckle. She also suggests Natalie might have an alliance with Keith and did it on purpose, but Jon thinks that wouldn’t make sense. I keep sniggering.

Over on Exile, Natalie can’t stop thinking of her twin. They’ve never really been apart for 28 years, and this has now been 30 days, and Natalie can’t help but be a bit tearful.

Immunity Challenge. Natalie comes in, crying. She says she is utterly exhausted. Baylor gives her a bowl of rice, which is actually rather sweet of her. And here comes Missy, also crying, and hobbling on a stick, looking barely alive. Her foot looks dreadful – really swollen and horrible. Of course when Mummy bawls, Baylor bawls too. .

Jeff is worried about Missy’s foot and gets Medical to check it. Dr Ben says Missy’s ankle is definitely sprained, but could be broken and of course the only way to tell is with an X-ray, and of course that means pulling Madam Missy from the game. The doctor says the injury is not life threatening, and agrees she’ll be okay if they just immobilize it. So they do. On to the challenge, which Missy sits out. They have to balance a vase, or “vayss” if you are American, while standing on a seesaw thing, and holding onto two handles. There’s quite a wind blowing, which really makes the whole operation rather precarious. The wind breaks Jaclyn’s vase fairly quickly. Baylor goes next, then Keith, leaving Jon and Natalie. Lots of exciting music, please! Aaand the wind sends Jon’s vase a’crashing down! Thank you, wind. Natalie is so excited she gives Jeff a hug, Jon a hug and generally looks as happy as can be. And who can blame her? Jon says Natalie’s winning makes up for her messing up the last vote. I’m not even sure that makes sense.

And it’s scramble time. Natalie tells Keith to make sure to look depressed at TC, as though he knows he’s going home. She explains to him that they are going to vote out Jon but will start with a three way vote. Now that’s a hell of a big ask, because, well, it’s Keith! Meanwhile, Natalie is planning the 3 way vote. At first it will be 2 for Keith, and 2 each for J and J, in case Jon plays his idol. Then if it’s a tie, and he hasn’t voted his idol, they vote for Jon. If he has, it will be bye bye Jaclyn. My girl knows how to strategize. Meanwhile, Jaclyn tells Jon he should play his idol in case they blindside him, but Mr Confidence isn’t worried. Heh. The only possible fly in Natalie’s ointment is Missy’s reluctance to vote for Jon. She gave him her word! Baylor eventually gets her to look at things a little differently. Maybe.

Tribal Council. Keith starts straight in with a speech about being the odd man out against the alliance of 5. An amused Jeff says he hasn’t asked him anything yet. Alec’s mouth is hanging wide open. Yes, he still looks really stupid. Jaclyn actually says that she doesn’t think she and Jon are going anywhere. I cross all of my fingers and all of my fingers and toes. Okay, I don’t really cross all my toes, but would if I possibly could. It’s time to vote. They vote, Keith helping Missy to hobble over. No idols are played. The votes: Keith, Jaclyn, Keith, Jaclyn, Jon, Jon. The jury is greatly amused, as am I. Yep, it’s a tie, just as our girl planned. In the revote, only Natalie, Baylor and Missy can vote, and of course the next vote comes out:Jon, Jon, and we don’t need to see the third vote. So we’ll never know whether or not Missy voted Jon out. Natalie, I love you! Or to put it another way, HA HA HA HA HA !!!! Love it, just love it! At least Jon took it well, saying, “No hard feelings, guys” as he left. Although he seemed a little discombobulated, forgetting his torch after kissing Jaclyn goodbye. He says he wishes he’d played his idol. Well duh.

And next week is the grand finale. It may have been one of the most most boring seasons ever of a wonderful show, but at least next week promises to be fascinating. Stay tuned!

22 comments

1 Alan { 12.13.14 at 10:43 am }

On Survivor Live Jon claimed that Jaclyn told him to play his idol before Natalie did.

I know the edit has been weird at times but I just can’t believe they would show Natalie as the prime mover if she were not. On the other hand, I can think of multiple occasions where Jon persuaded himself of things that don’t happen.

If you’ll remember he was making claims at one point that he was going to play the idol before Natalie or allegedly Jaclyn intervened. Jon also believes he’s played without lying to anyone, which would probably be interesting news to both Josh and Jeremy.

I guess it’s now one of Natalie and Ol Spitty for the win. I assume Jaclyn goes next, although players with half a brain would vote out Natalie.

If 30 is a special season, are we going to see Natalie in back on back seasons like Malcolm and Russell?

2 Sioux Denim { 12.13.14 at 11:43 am }

Well played Natalie, seems that was her move for the finale and I hope she plays it to the end, man I have changed my tune from TAR!
Spitty deserves to be there at the end but not sure how well he is going to come across to the final Jury….
Bring it on next week!

3 Carole { 12.13.14 at 11:05 pm }

How dumb was Jaclyn asking if Alec voted for himself. From the promo for next week, she is really pissed off at them voting her man off.

That challenge where Missy got hurt was thought up by a 13 year old boy. It was for make a wish, it was his dream to create a challenge for Survivor so he gave them his idea and they liked it.

So will Jon be bitter & not vote for Natalie if she makes the final or will he respect her game play. She has them all fooled. I wonder what their reactions are watching it back. Jeremy thinks she voted him off because she said sorry to him when he left. How ironic will it be if she loses his vote when everything she did was revenge for him being voted off.

4 megan { 12.14.14 at 9:16 am }

Oh, that was sweet! I had my everything crossed, too, Rosie.
The season has finally heated up. Can’t wait for the final shows next week. Fingers crossed for Nat or Keith.

5 emp { 12.14.14 at 11:10 am }

I havent watched since episode 4 or 5 but i hopr natalie wins everyone else is as boring as batshit

6 Anonymous { 12.15.14 at 6:04 am }

I just realized this week , that Natalaie was in the Amazing Race.

7 Bolders { 12.15.14 at 9:59 am }

Two things that struck me from this episode:

1. How bloody petty and selfish Jaclyn was when she told Jon he was being “annoying” because he was happy he’d won the reward challenge, this was before he gave it away to Baylor. You can tell alot about a person by how gracious they are when they lose. Jaclyn is a pill.
2. Jon is a NICE guy. It was right for him to be voted off from Natalie’s perspective but that “no hard feelings ” comment after being voted off was very gracious. He should dump the ol’ pill and chains that is Jaclyn asap.

I didnt watch from teh begining this season, but from what I have seen of Natalie she has had a dream edit. Was there anything negative of her shown in the first few episodes?

8 q10 { 12.15.14 at 2:18 pm }

i agree @bolders jon was very good/gracious in defeat, despite being quite cocky before (eg last week’s reward of the bed)

@carole I think Jeremy wouldve talked to enough of the jury members in ponderosa to figure out natalie did not blindside him, besides they can hash it out in the final tribal council (if nat makes it)

nat ftw (or keith if nat is booted)

9 Fiona - Perth { 12.15.14 at 7:44 pm }

Natalia has had a good edit, however, I think that is probably because she has not put a foot wrong. She has managed to tread that line between being funny, hardworking, helpful in challenges but not so much to be a threat until the individual ones where she is proving her strength and determination. It has probably helped her by being alone, as on the Amazing Race the two of them together rubbed a lot of people up the wrong way simply because of their enthusiasm and loudness, on her own she has played a smart game. I wonder if Nadia had been the one to stay whether she would have played a similar game? I hope she wins and that she gets the credit for getting rid of Jon with the jury.

10 Alan { 12.15.14 at 7:46 pm }

@Bolders

I think Jon and Jaclyn both have a problem with entitlement, although that seems to be endemic in this cast. You need only think, for example, of Missy’s expression when Natalie, Jon and Jaclyn had the strange threesome reward. Or Reed’s very strange claims about his family’s vast stable of horses.

I’m not unsympathetic to Jaclyn. it strikes me we’ve seen lots of occasions where Jaclyn would say something and Jon would shut her down. Generally Jaclyn was right and Jon was wrong. The most famous, of course, was Jaclyn suggesting Natalie was plotting against them and Jon refusing even to consider it.

Jon made lots of decisions on his ‘gut’. As I said in an earlier thread, leave the gut to look after itself until you work out how the game is played.

Naturally I still want Natalie or Keith to win. I’m not that sympathetic.

11 Bolders { 12.16.14 at 5:09 pm }

@Alan and Fiona – thanks both. One final question, when I started watching this season, there was a challenge with the winning team being the one Natalie was in. After the win Natalie started mouthing off at one of the dudes on the other team who she says had been baiting her/others, I didnt understand it – do you know what the backstory to that was?

12 Alan { 12.16.14 at 6:58 pm }

John Rocker made some racist and homophobic statements in the 1990s when he was big in baseball. The geniuses in casting wanted a lovely story where he would be confronted with his record, he’d repent and everyone would live happily ever after.

What they got was his early and unrepentant exit and Julie’s quit.

Someone better than I am at stats should tell the casting geniuses that 1. incognito athletes are recognised within seconds of the game starting and 2. they usually sink like a stone. I think Jeff Kent went deepest and he made it to Day 22 on Survivor:Philippines.

Lisa Whelchel was an incognito actor who made it to the final in the same season. Apparently former soap stars are better at manipulating people than former sport stars. I mean really, whoda thunk it?

13 Bolders { 12.17.14 at 9:21 am }

Thanks Alan @12 – makes sense, I like this season I dont like it when they bring so called allstars back because they usually are targeted for an early exit and it becomes all about them. Except of course for Boston Rob – that guy was a great competitor .

14 Alan { 12.17.14 at 10:02 am }

I don’t mind the occasional allstars season. About once every 10 seasons is right. There is also a small group of players who were thoroughly screwed by random ‘twists’ dreamed up by production.

I hated the way 2 players were voted off without ever getting to play in (I think) Fiji. I seriously hated the fake merge in Thailand where Shi Ann and Ken were voted off by production as much as by the players because the players thought they had merged when they had not.

And the less said about Gabon, where tribe swaps happened faster and more often than Jeff saying ‘Got nothing for you’ the better.

Maybe a second chance season would be good.

15 Fijane { 12.18.14 at 7:14 am }

Bolders, the episode where Natalie mouthed off at John Rocker was the first one I saw. I thought (at the time) that she was a shrew and that I would never support her. How things have changed.
While I’m not sure if I would have her a personal friend, I now have tremendous admiration for her playing of this game, and believe she deserves to win by a country mile.
The only thing that bothers me is the declaration of undying love for MIssy and Baylor. If Natalie is not playing them for fools, then I will be extremely disappointed. Surely someone as smart as her could not be genuinely friendly with such a pair of ditzes?

16 JStar { 12.18.14 at 7:30 pm }

Can’t wait for finale tonight although it has been a season that sputtered and limped to the end. Guess you can’t catch lightning in a bottle twice after the success of blood vs water the first time around.

Trying to work out final three based solely on the little clues dropped by all season. Basically, I am positive Baylor will not be in the final three but can’t decide on the odd person out of the remaining four. I’ll explain my recollection of the clues as to why the following will be at the end and not Baylor.

Out of the five, Jaclyn was the only one who was given fewer confessionals and a lot of her airtime was tied in with her boyfriend. However her “sob story” and how she was unsure if the jury would vote for her and Jon over Jeremy due to who has a more compelling backstory (just after the merge) makes me think she could be a Final 3 participant. Reed (when voting for Missy in the tribal council when he was voted out) said this would be the only time he would write her name down. Since Missy was not medically evacuated, the only other time Reed can make a speech/scene against Missy would be at the final tribal council. When both Nadiya and Wes were eliminated, their final words shown was hoping their loved ones would win the million dollars. Every loved one said that but only those two were shown in the final edit saying that. And sure enough, Keith and Natalie are in the final five.

Baylor, on the other hand, had a story arc edit that was heavily mother-daughter dependant. Both looking out for each other. Given the above, Baylor (in my view) will not make the final three and will probably vote for her mother (if she is in the final three), thus concluding that story arc.

Both of Natalie and Keith have had a lot of screen time and are favourites with the audience. However, if Keith is in the Final 3 he will win as he has more friends on the jury.

17 Techhater { 12.18.14 at 10:01 pm }

Hey gice i’m watching but won’t read comments or post again until after winner is announced. We’re an hour behind and don’t want to see any spoilers.

Go Spitty Keith and Natalie :smile:

And see you all at the end.

18 Fijane { 12.19.14 at 11:03 am }

Where’s the new thread to dicuss the finale?

19 Rosie { 12.19.14 at 12:05 pm }

It’s been written and sent to RR, and I’m sure she will post it as soon as she is able.

20 Fijane { 12.19.14 at 12:28 pm }

Thanks for the info, Rosie. Apologies that my post was a little blunt. I wasn’t trying to hassle anyone, just worried that I had missed it somehow.

21 Chrissie { 12.19.14 at 1:37 pm }
22 Fijane { 12.20.14 at 7:54 am }

I’d already read that article, Chrissie, and I didn’t agree with most of it. Like most of the comments, I thought the speech was fantastic, and not at all related to Missy’s gender or the fact that she is a ‘mom’.
I felt that the article was written purely to create controversy.