Posts from — March 2013
Survivor France Contestant Dies – Production Is Packed Up
I always find it difficult to believe there are not more deaths on reality TV shows considering how they drive on The Amazing Race, however in sad news a 25 year old has died on location of Survivor France in Cambodia.
News.com.au are reporting on the first day of filming 25 year old Gerald Babin died after cardiac arresting. He was seen by a medic after the a tug of war challenge where he was complaining of pain in both sides of his arms, he died whilst being transport to hospital.
The production company flew everyone back to France and cancelled the program.
March 26, 2013 7 Comments
The Biggest Loser – At What Point Does Product Placement Become An Advertorial?
When did The Biggest Loser turn into The Truman Show? Where the product placement moved from being placed on benches to becoming part of the storyline.
Watch this clip from The Truman Show and then think back to last night’s The Biggest Loser episode.
Half way through last night’s episode Shannan Ponton was talking to Cher and her mum about how he was going to assist them this week as their exclusive trainer, an advantage they had just won on the show.
The segment has him instructing them to eat 1000 calories a day and then asks them how their bodies are holding up to training?
The code outlines:
Disclosure of Commercial Arrangements
1.19 For the purposes of Clauses 1.20–1.23 the following definitions apply:
1.19.1 “Commercial arrangement” means an agreement or arrangement under which
a licensee, an independent producer or a presenter agrees with a third party to
endorse or feature the third party’s products or services in a factual program in
exchange for consideration. For the avoidance of doubt, the free provision of a
product or service for review is not a commercial arrangement.1.19.2 “Factual program” means a current affairs, documentary or infotainment
program broadcast by the licensee.
1.20 If a licensee enters into a commercial arrangement in relation to a factual program, and
the third party’s products or services are endorsed or featured in the program, the
licensee must disclose the existence of that commercial arrangement. ommercial Television Industry Code of Practice January 20101.23 A disclosure required by this clause must be made either during the program or in the
credits of the program and should adequately bring the existence of any such commercial
arrangement to the attention of viewers in a way that is readily understandable to a
reasonable person.Also under the section titled Presentation Of Broadcast Material it states:
1.18 Where a licensee receives payment for material that is presented in a program or segment
of a program, that material must be distinguishable from other program material, either
because it is clearly promoting a product or service, or because of labelling or some other
form of differentiation.
One of the issues is whether The Biggest Loser would be classified as a factual program under the code. Also whether the disclosure made was readily understandable to a reasonable person. In other words did the viewer realise that this Krill Oil segment which went for about a minute was an advertisement?
I raised this issue with Network, and a TEN spokesperson said the segment did comply with the Code.
The Network TEN spokesperson said:
“Product placement is a fact of life in television programs today (thanks to rising production costs, the search by advertisers for new ways to engage with consumers), and most consumers understand why product placement exists. They may not like it, but they understand it.”
“The level of product placement in The Biggest Loser: The Next Generation is not excessive. In fact, we would argue the level of product placement is higher in other programs, including The Block and Celebrity Apprentice.”
“Of course, Network Ten adheres strictly to the Commercial Television Industry Code of Practice. The Code is co-regulated by industry and the government regulator and contains provisions regarding branded entertainment. The primary focus is on ensuring paid content in a program / segment is clearly distinguishable due to branding / labelling or because it is clearly promoting a product or service. Nothing in last night’s episode of The Biggest Loser: The Next Generation breached the Code.”
“The commercial arrangement with Nature’s Way was disclosed in the program end credits and in sponsorship billboards accompanying the program. The end credits say The Biggest Loser is made with the support of and various company logos, including Nature’s Way.”
I have no problem with product placement and think it is part and parcel of reality TV and ensures there production values can be maintained. I also agree with the TEN spokesperson The Biggest Loser has nowhere as near the amount of product placement as we see on The Block and to be fair that show has people visiting Freedom and Mitre TEN, the shows sponsors as part of their plot lines.
However the Natures Way Krill Oil segment was different it was not just the product sitting on a kitchen bench or a logo or a person eating yoghurt. It was presented by Shannan, who viewers would see as an authority on fitness and health, spruiking and also endorsing a product in an educational way as part of a storyline where he was giving out other diet information.
This is a grey area and is it will be something we will continue to see more of on reality TV shows, and the question whether a mention in the credits is enough for a reasonable person to understand that some of the dialogue they just heard in the show was in fact advertising.
What are your thoughts on product placement and the segment last night?
The Biggest Loser Australia on TEN Sunday to Tuesday at 7.30pm
March 26, 2013 22 Comments
Networks Were Back In Court Fighting Over Mel B – Still No Resolution
There is still no resolution to the Mel B contract fight between NINE and SEVEN. Network Seven where she worked on The X Factor has received an injunction from the Supreme Court saying she cannot work for another station before January 2014. They were back in court again.
Previously SEVEN had argued the reason they released Mel B from her contract this year was because she told them Eddie Murphy, the father of her second child, wanted to spend more times with the kid and it was too hard with them living in Australia. This is kind of ironic as he in the past he had denied he was even the father of the baby. So it appears SEVEN were a tad surprised when it was announced she was going to be a judge on NINE’s Australia’s Got Talent.
The SMH is reporting today in court was more about lawyers arguing on all sides about keeping her salary a secret, on the basis that it is a “trade secret” and if revealed it may be detrimental for her negotiating contracts in the future.
The court case was adjourned until April 3 until her husband and manager Stephen Belafonte fronts the court.
If SEVEN get their way, it will mean Australia’s Got Talent loses its fourth judge, leaving a panel consisting of Kyle Sandilands, Timomatic and Dawn French with not that much time to find a replacement.
March 25, 2013 5 Comments
Masterchef Australia Has Started Filming And They Would Be Feeling The Pressure
Masterchef Australia has started filming in Melbourne and there will be a different mood on set from previous years. This year for one of the first years since it started they will not be filming as the top reality cooking show on our screens.
In fact there is a lot of pressure not helped that Masterchef Professionals did not rate as well as they hoped. To be fair the Professionals series was good television most of the time, but was up against My Kitchen Rules that was pumping out the drama.
George Calombaris talks about the pressure in today’s Daily Telegraph.
It will be interesting to see if the producers of Masterchef will try and amp up the drama, the back stories and the inter-contestant dynamics or if they will focus on the cooking.
One of things I hope they get rid of this year were the immunity pin challenges where the person could win a pin off the back of other peoples good cooking. That never made sense to me. I would also like to see George, Gary and Matt Preston intespersed with more guest judges like Dan Hong, Chris Mansfield, Donovan Cooke and other established stars of the culinary scene.
What would you like to see on this series of Masterchef?
March 25, 2013 35 Comments
Kyle Sandilands Rehabilitation Looks Like It Is Complete
Kyle Sandiland’s is like Lazarus one minute you think he his career is dead and he like Lazarus rises out of the ashes bigger than ever.
It has been a good week for him, he has been announced as the fourth judge on Australia’s Got Talent, and also he has been photgraphed with the Prime Minister, albeit as a rabbit but still it was the Prime Minister. This photo opportunity will have gone down well with NINE as it will absolve any doubts they might of had in signing the shock jock.
This of course is good for Kyle but not sure it is as good for the PM, as he is a tad controversial with some of the remarks he has said about and to females in the past, and let’s face it probably in the future as well.
However maybe she can learn how to become popular when you are unpopular, because let’s face it Kyle has this mastered he is the most popular, unpopular person on radio and his ratings back him up on this.
March 25, 2013 14 Comments





