for those who have reality tv as their guilty pleasure
Reality Ravings | Australia's leading Reality TV blog!

Masterchef Australia – The How Much Does My Fellow Competitor Like Me Mystery Box

Interesting how Michael and Alana who I think are the stronger people in the competition have not won a challenge to go up for an immunity pin. This is why viewers are frustrated by the show this year, better cooks have been sidelined.

Tonight there were no losers only a winner who would go into an immunity pin challenge against a chef or amateur cook.

The mystery box challenge should have been the “show us how much you like the other contestants” challenge, as each contestant had to choose the ingredients for one of the other contestants to cook with.

They were instructed to go for their competitors weak points. This episode came complete with cut to the contestants making cats meow faces when someone elses dish was being praised. I am looking at you Alana.  Also Michael had a grimace on his face when Alana was getting some praise. But both could have just been cheeky editing.

Ellie made an italian type basket for Dani and threw in a rabbit as well. Kate was given seafood and asian ingredients by Dani. Michael gave Alana flounder with beetroot and kohl rabi, now that was an interesting mix. Alana gave Ellie rabbit, but also gave her some nice brussell sprouts and lentils, and Kate gave Michael a dessert basket, as that is his weak spot.

I was surprised no one was given offal to cook. That would have been an act of bastardry.

Ellie stuffed around for most of the challenge but finally plated up something which was simple but nice. She is not stupid she knows how to get on the judges good side. Ellie said ” I am putting the kidney on top as George loves kidneys.” Ok maybe I need to delete that appropriate behaviour post about the judges not touching the contestants I did a few weeks ago.

However Dani’s dish was diabolical. Olive and boccocini tortellini with rabbit and tomato broth. Oh and it came with a side dish of tears. Ok I know they only had 60 minutes to cook something – would it have been possible to do a ragu in that time?

Matt Preston said “Elements of good technique there …. not quite a car crash”.

Michael made Pannacottta with roasted rhubarb with honey and orange syrup. He put a piece of honeycomb in the bottom of he brulee, and Gary did not know whether to spit or swallow as he didn’t like the texture it left in his mouth.  Many female viewers thought get over it.

Alana made almond crusted flounder with a beetroot puree with some pickled kohlrabi and radish. Gary liked the pickled vegetables but called it a “weird dish”.

Matt Preston again showed why he was the sartorial one of the group, when he invoked Coco Chanel in his critique. Coco said when you dress and before you go out always take one item off. She needed to do the same with her ingredients.

Kate made panfried seafood with curry sauce. Gary said “I love chilli and for me it is a nice hot sauce, but misses balance of sour and sweet”. George sweated and panted out  “It’s lovely it has lots of different flavour there,”

Michael won which was obvious after Alana tanked, and will play off for the immunity pin. If he wins this means there is the potential for two pins to be in play for the elimination the second last week of the competition. The pin should not be able to be played in the last two weeks of the competition. It should be all about the cooking.

Tomorrow night looks like it is the conjugal rights challenge, with family and friends visiting to watch them cook.

85 comments

1 Sonia { 07.24.11 at 10:52 pm }

So over it any way you look at it this years Masterchef will only ever be an amatuer cook and who will buy their cookbook. These immunity challenges have been ridiculous and cheapened the whole competition

2 aneets { 07.24.11 at 10:59 pm }

The fact that Dani served up such an average dish at this stage of the comp says a lot. I cannot believe she has an immunity pin! The show has seriously jumped the shark.
Loved The Renovators though & looking forward to your recap!

3 Moo { 07.24.11 at 11:05 pm }

Yeah, I actually laughed when Dani presented her awful dish to the judges. Matt’s initial expression was priceless! The only other time I’ve laughed at someone’s dish was Julie’s puddle pie.

And I really wish Michael would have saved us from that ridiculous “Ellie and Kate did so well I’m soooo scared I’m gonna lose hehehe!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!” act. Honestly, you had to be ignorant or retarded to think Michael was going to lose considering the way he was edited tonight.

4 Jo { 07.24.11 at 11:10 pm }

I’m not too surprised that Michael and Alana have never gone up for immunity. They’re strong and solid cooks, but they don’t seem the type to come out with the flashy OMG BEST dish. They’re fairly safe. This also means that they don’t come out with the worst dishes, either.

5 sue { 07.24.11 at 11:11 pm }

I actually watched it tonite (heavily ff’d thru all the chaff) but it is still VERY ordinary this year. bad effort that has wrecked what was once an enjoyable show….
won’t bother again, will stick to here for recaps. have done so for the last week or so, and it has been a much better use of my time!

6 CJ { 07.24.11 at 11:27 pm }

Haven’t watched it for two weeks. Can’t believe Dani is still crying as she gets feedback. Most interesting developments were Michael’s weight gain and Alana’s ringworm on upper arm which had a bandaid for the pieces to camera but not for cooking. dani’s haircut, once her only asset, has grown out so I’m unsure why we are still looking at her.

7 Fides { 07.24.11 at 11:39 pm }

This week seems like it’s all filler. It should be finals week already. It is embarrassing that Dani, who is guaranteed a finals spot, cooked such a woeful dish – totally agree RR there should be no pins for the last 2 weeks. Glad Michael got the win, but no way will he get the pin this week.

In the previews for tomorrow, isn’t Kate’s little daughter a cutie – and I reckon she does a better adorable scrunchy face than Ellie.

8 Jess { 07.24.11 at 11:40 pm }

Maybe it’s just the way this episode was edited, but this seemed more like a “Give Michael an Immunity Pin” challenge than anything else. I didn’t enjoy it.

9 Dmc { 07.24.11 at 11:51 pm }

‘will go up against a chef or an amateur cook’. Love it.

10 JaniceG { 07.24.11 at 11:58 pm }

Dishes were underwhelming and once again, I was surprised to see how much help the judges gave them. One of the reasons that flounder was chosen was because it’s hard to filet but there Gary was, showing Alana and Kate exactly how to do it.

I was surprised when Alana put forth the idea of kohlrabi chips to George and Gary and was told that it’s more like apple that she didn’t just switch the veggies and do beetroot chips and kohlrabi puree. Also, I found it very odd that she didn’t cook the crumb onto the fish but just patted it on.

Dani’s dish was appalling, and even worse given that it was cooked by one of the final five in this competition. If anyone needed proof that the level this year is woeful, they wouldn’t need to look any further than tonight. For Matt to call Ellie’s dish professional-quality plating was just insane.

Anyone else wonder whether the last 5 competitors from last year are watching this year’s show at this stage and cursing the fates that made them compete last year instead of this year?

11 Doops { 07.25.11 at 12:11 am }

Ahahaha, and the worst dish of the day was plated by the current record-holder of two immunity pins in their respective season! Whoopee!

This episode was fairly boring to watch, and Ellie’s constant giggling and face-pulling was fairly annoying. Though the given challenge was pretty mundane too, the Mystery Box and Invention Test combination last year was far more enjoyable than this…

12 AnonyMousse { 07.25.11 at 12:18 am }

“Go for the other person’s weakpoints.”

“So pick anything from the pantry in other words.”

Hard to believe this is the same show I went out of my way to be home in time for last season. Why are they dragging the top 5 out to two weeks?

13 Lily { 07.25.11 at 12:34 am }

@ JaniceG

I’m pretty sure Jimmy from season 2 has been tweeting about the difference between the competition from this year and last years.

This episode was boring. I actually thought Ellie’s dish looked pretty good but her erratic behaviour and overall giggling, amateurish something personality makes her impossible to respect as a potential winner.
At this stage, I’m really hoping that Ellie and Dani leave next but given Danis immunity pin, that might hinder any dreams I have for this season of Masterchef to gain some credibility.

14 brain dead dave { 07.25.11 at 3:48 am }

So this is the “pointy” , “business ” end of the “competition”?

It’s all chaff and no wheat.

15 Darryl { 07.25.11 at 7:08 am }

Put Ellie or Lego Head into a real kitchen and they would be sacked before the end of Day 1

16 librarygirl { 07.25.11 at 8:42 am }

Perhaps the editors hate her but Ellies’ weird face scrunching and arms over the head thing / or stretching yoga action do make her look like a four year old who is about to throw a tantrum.

17 Sooty { 07.25.11 at 8:42 am }

It’s sad. I can barely be bothered watching knowing they’re only going to give one of these remaining muppets the flick this week. Do they think we like these people!? Oh, can’t wait to spend a whole hour watching them reunited with their loved ones tonight. I don’t wish any of the remainders ill, but god, go home.

18 Toby Tom { 07.25.11 at 8:50 am }

One week of nothing? Man get it over with already.

19 Toby Tom { 07.25.11 at 9:13 am }

And sorry Michael only one immunity pin in play at a time. Don’t think you’ll be getting one!

20 kingfisher { 07.25.11 at 9:14 am }

top 5 and 2 amatas can’t fillet a flounder , 2 can’t even cook a flamin rabbit . ellie looking at her basket saying what’s this and that !!! dani plates that crap meal and then on cue “blubbers, feel sorry for me judges ” matt p thinking how do i get outta this with my reputation still intacted ,i guess his reputation was shot to pieces when he said ellie’s dish was restaurant quality , it looked like rabbit on rabbit pooh . how much help do this top 5 need, they should be able to cook anything with out any help .well it’s nearly finished anyway loved the renovators where real renovating occured not like the block .

21 Culinary Boner { 07.25.11 at 9:24 am }

I just felt sorry for the rabbits.
They could’ve made somethin’ of their post-life as a delicious stew on my table but were instead butchered to resemble a plate of (dried-out) scallops and a budgie’s ribcage. My cat would’ve looked at me with her fuck-you-you-expect-me-to-eat-that-shit expression if I stumped up similar for her.
And since when is scampi a hard dish to cook? Sure most people have probably not bought it and have neither cooked scampi nor green balmain bugs but aren’t we to expect that the final five would have some greater cooking skills and knowledge FFS than the average punter? That said, at least Kate experimented and came up with what looked like a good effort in the end.
Top Chef Allstars is on Foxtel tonight, thank the Flying Spaghetti Monster’s noodly appendage.

22 Paul { 07.25.11 at 9:37 am }

Why do some people continually think that these contestants should be perfectly across every type of cuisine?

Does anyone understand how difficult it is to cook strange ingredients without a recipe ?

Some perspective, please.

23 Culinary Boner { 07.25.11 at 9:39 am }

Yeah kingfisher. Forgot about the flounder. In many ways an easier fish to fillet than standard fish if you’ve bothered to try. Or even done what most of us have done and checked out the techniques explained – with pretty pictures in sequence – in plenty of mainstream cookbooks. Rick Stein’s being my favorite. But I even have Woman’s Day Seafood cookbook from what must be 25-30 years ago that shows step-by-step how to do flounder, crab, cuttlefish, etc… This lot are just so unworthy. Flounder beurre blanc is a classic french combo. What do they cook at home? Nigella’s cupcakes? Crumbed lamb chops? McCain’s pizzas? Bring back Billy and Jay and piss off Allie and Dani.

24 Sunflower { 07.25.11 at 9:39 am }

End of Day One? By lunchtime

25 Culinary Boner { 07.25.11 at 9:46 am }

Paul, I’ll grant that Kohlrabi might be considered ‘unusual’ but flounder and rabbit? What are they watching on the tele in their compound? Maybe the producers could rent them out Ratatouille for a night.

26 Paul { 07.25.11 at 9:54 am }

CB,
They are not professionals. They don’t get to spend 8 hours a day at their craft. Nor are all the ingredients easily at their disposal.

They would get home from work and perhaps spend 1, maybe 2 hours in the kitchen at best. When you are only cooking for that amount of time, its only natural that you cook things that you like doing.

I’m embarassed here as I consider myself an above average cook but I had never heard of Kohlrabi before. If someone gave me that, I’d be stuffed !!!!!

27 Rosie { 07.25.11 at 10:00 am }

God. I haven’t bothered with this show for a couple of weeks now, but gave it another try last night. Husband kept asking me why I was bothering with this dross, and I have to say he is right. I will watch the final night – IFF the finalists don’t include Ellie or Dani – but otherwise I’ll just wait for the second kiddies’ version.

28 NT Kate { 07.25.11 at 10:07 am }

But here’s the thing Paul, kohlrabi was featured in an earlier season epi of MC. So I, like anyone who is interested in cooking actually went and bought some to see what it was like, and now have some growing in my garden so I can experiment more cheaply in future…

Personally, I think anyone entering this show would sensibly have looked around the vege shop for more unusual ingredients and tried most of them out, or at least studied one or both of Stephanie Alexander’s books on characteristics of and how to use veges and other key ingredients. Its what you do if you are really interested in cooking.

And that’s the thing that really appalled me about Ellie’s effort. Having stuffed up rabbit 101 at the beginning of the season and then been given a masterclass on it, anyone serious in a competition like this would try and find an opportunity to give it another go (and another go) until they get it right. It is how you learn and improve. That is what Callum did last year, and by all accounts the pantry at the house is stuffed with ingredients which she has deliberately avoided. Instead she pretty much massacred it again…

If your attitude is tro run away from opportunities to learn, you shouldn’t be on this show.

And I agree on flounder – not that hard, not that expensive to buy (or hard to catch yourself!), and a fairly basic skillset to have for a show of this kind.

29 Culinary Boner { 07.25.11 at 10:18 am }

Paul, they have weekends like the rest of us. People who claim to be as into cooking as this lot claim often see cooking as a creative outlet and will experiment and try new things to learn and improve their skills and knowledge and get new flavour experiences. Of course, if they have kids then this becomes much, much more difficult. I speak from experience on this front. That said, I note that Kate does better than many of the others on new stuff. Kohlrabi is outside my experience. I’ve never cooked it, nor tasted it. So sure, all of us non-professionals will have stuff we have never worked with. Plus experiments we stuffed up and ingredients/techniques we’d never try again. But some things would be considered fundamental for all cooking hobbyists. This would include making mayonaisse from scratch, blending your own curry pastes, making basic cake types etc… Not something you’d waste time doing routinely, but a skill you’d test yourself with at least once. Rabbit and flounder prep and cooking sit there with these basics. So are MCA’s inmates cooking-hobbyists or are they simply reality TV fame-sluts? If they are just the latter I’d might as well watch Jersey Shore.

30 Paul { 07.25.11 at 10:27 am }

CB, agree that mayonaisse, curries and cakes are all basics and contestants should be able to do a more than average version without a recipe.

Youc an’t seriously compare rabbit and flounder to the above. Most people would be lucky to eat either once or twice a year.

I think you are way too harsh. Its a lot easier with a recipe or cookbook next to you. Trying to do something unfamiliar without a reference point would be extremely difficult.

Hell, we saw how some of the professional chefs struggled in immunity challengers without a recipe and these are dishes FROM THEIR OWN KITCHEN.

31 davsimp { 07.25.11 at 10:28 am }

What a shame the bottom three are not facing off in an elimination round tonight. Perfect opportunity to get rid of another incompetent. Instead we have to suffer through the hugs, tears etc, of the family reunions. They didnt do this last year did they? I dont remember seeing anyone’s family until the final episode with Callum and Adam.

And speaking of correcting a ballsed up dish – when Jay went home on the back of the green Panda cake, the first thing he did was whip up three or more until he had perfected it. Wouldn’t you be constantly trying to improve on your weakest dishes by practicing them again? I know I would.

32 Sooty { 07.25.11 at 10:42 am }

All the people who wanted to better themselves as cooks or had chef aspirations have gone – sorry, been sent – home. Jay, and… I forget. But Michael I think does want to cook/chef . The others – fame-sluts! Even goody-goody Kate. Poor Alana, the ghost of Masterchef 3, wants to be (wait for it, it’s so unusual!) a food writer/blogger. Nice one to add to her list of shlashie titles.

33 Paul { 07.25.11 at 10:46 am }

Sooty,
Kate wants to open a B & B.

I didn’t know there was a rule that states if you appeared on Masterchef that you actually wanted to be a chef. Most simply want a career in food which could encompass many different forms. They’ve always been clear on that.

In fact, only a very small percentage have gone on to the show with aspirations of being an actual chef in an actual restaurant.

34 lulu { 07.25.11 at 11:05 am }

Davsimp and Sooty: absolutely agree – the thought of having to put up with a ‘loved ones’ episode is excruciating. More tears and sentimental slush and only serves to further distance this show from its ostensible purpose…cooking. Oh, silly me…because they’ll be ‘cooking from the heart,’ ‘cooking with love’ and cooking with every other platitude.
Throw in a cute kid….now for a chorus of Kumbaya.

35 Fides { 07.25.11 at 11:10 am }

davsimp – great point about the stark differences in attitude towards a stuff-up. The best example of that for me was in S1 and Poh with her deep fried meringues. After she got the boot, she researched and perfected them not knowing she’d be called back. And of course, wowing them when she did it so successfully second time round. Allie I can just see giggling about how she’s just never going to cook with rabbit again.

One thing to to grateful for though I suppose, is that we were spared most of Dani’s tears last night. I don’t think we actually heard her blubber away. Maybe they’ve had to hurriedly re-edit some of the episodes after realising how unpopular she is. And there was less Dani recapping overall, though when it’s replaced by Allie recaps (enough with those faces, shrieks, giggles, flailing limbs – it might be adorable if she was on JMC but even those kids didn’t do that ) it is every bit as annoying.

36 kingfisher { 07.25.11 at 11:10 am }

szzzzzzzzzzzzz a certain persons view puts me to sleep. were only having some fun we don’t really mean it

37 Sooty { 07.25.11 at 11:12 am }

Oh, suck my fat one Paul. This prissy side of you is too much lately. Yes, she says she wants to open a BandB – were you convinced? The judges, especially Matt Preston sure didn’t look it. I don’t mind if people come on MS and say I really really want to win the title and the 100,000. But all this phoney ‘food dreams’ they’ve come up with this year to replace ‘my passion for cooking’ is bollocks.

38 Culinary Boner { 07.25.11 at 11:16 am }

Paul, most of the professional chefs who’ve struggled this year are cooking a dish of the highest level of fiddliness and restaurant presentation for which they been outsourcing the preparation and cooking to their sous chefs. In this case I’m entirely unsurprised they have problems. It’s a bit like expecting a CEO whose come from an accountancy background to be able to do the latest tax compliance. They generally can’t. That said, last night’s MCA was not one of these high-level challenges. The final 5 just needed to plate up some tasty food that didn’t look like a dogs-breakfast in 60mins. As expected they were made to do so with some form of handicap, of which co-contestant chosen ingredients is probably one of the least insurmountable challenges you could give them. I know I couldn’t compete to the highest level on MCA and therefore would not inflict myself on the viewing public. But this season pisses me off when I think back to season one and the fact that I could watch for both reality comp entertainment and to at times be inspired to try something new from the contestants. Two of the final five are just floundering. It annoys me to think that I could outcook them. That’s not why I’ve watched this show in the past. If I want incompetence I’ll have it with pantomime thrown in thanks, as in Hell’s Kitchen.

39 Paul { 07.25.11 at 11:19 am }

Sooty,
The fact is hardly any of the contestants want to be a chef in their own restaurant. I don’t know why you think this – maybe its the title of the show and you’re taking it literally.

They’ve reiterated a hundred times that they want a career in food. This covers hundreds of different occupations.

40 Paul { 07.25.11 at 11:21 am }

CB,
Fair points and agree that S1 was fantastic.

I try not to compare as it ends in inevitable disappointment.

41 lulu { 07.25.11 at 11:28 am }

Yes Paul, you need to ‘suck on Sooty’s fat one.’ You say all this stuff to make yourself appear to be the ‘good guy,’ to elicit responses and put people on the defensive – you enjoy the attention (which I’m guilty of giving you now). I think you, Daniii and Eliiii should go off together and open up a B & B somewhere far away and happily burn toast together.

42 Paul { 07.25.11 at 11:32 am }

Hi lulu,
Yes I’m a terrible human being.

Fancy challenging people to have a think about the constant criticism that they are happy to anonymously dish out to the contestants.

43 lulu { 07.25.11 at 11:37 am }

In that case, Paul, you should be happy that at the moment, I’m not dishing it out to contestants, but to you.

44 Sooty { 07.25.11 at 11:47 am }

Baiting. Ridiculing the poster’s grasp of ‘the facts’ (as Paul sees it) and the ‘reality’ (in Paul’s World) and suggesting one has a subnormal intelligence ‘maybe its the title of the show and you’re taking it literally’.

I was just getting a bit sick of all of that “come on, people!’ and ‘have some perspective, people’ shit of late. I’ve stuck up for you in a major way twice, against mob bullying, but now I am wondering if you do have an agenda. Or a personality disorder.

Suck on it, buddy.

45 Bruiser Brody { 07.25.11 at 11:49 am }

are they deliberately trying to make this series more like Survivor??
6 months in lock-down, isolated on a dessert island (pun intended) …
and now we get the Very Special Episode of a chance to cook to spend time with your family!
wtf send these Stockholm Kids to the finish line plz!

46 Toby Tom { 07.25.11 at 11:53 am }

Paul> Arguing with anyone on the net is like trying to convince a shark to be a vegetarian.

47 brain dead dave { 07.25.11 at 12:00 pm }

Not happy unless you’re unhappy…..

48 Gillian { 07.25.11 at 12:11 pm }

What is with the rude comments on this forum lately? I enjoyed this forum because people were able to converse like adults. Perhaps some moderation is in order.

@ ‘Oh, suck my fat one Paul’ – I just laughed at this. Very childish and hardly constructive.

I agreed with Paul. I was sitting on the sofa watching TV and thought to myself there is no way I’d be able to make a meal with those ingredients. I think they are put in very stressful and difficult situations that I certainly would not be able to handle.

49 Chunks { 07.25.11 at 12:20 pm }

Fraid I think Pete and Manu and the MKR producers must be rubbing their hands together with glee over the complete derailing of Masterchef. The second series of MKR was very watchable and rather like Masterchef used to be. True, Pete is as stiff as a sheet of five-ply but Manu more than makes up for that. Really, Masterchef series 4? Will the contestants have to make fairy floss from pork belly while hanging upside from the light fittings?

50 kingfisher { 07.25.11 at 12:24 pm }

hallelua sooty you have finally seen the light !! we are just frustrated by what mc have served us this year .we have been treated to 2 excellent series and now we get this drivel and we have had enough ,all we want is to be treated with respect as a viewer and by voicing our views on this blog will hopefully get the message across . we don’t really care about the amatas cooks or their personality or ratings ,we just want top notch cooking ,that’s what i like about the concept in the first and second series.
this is the only blog (thanks to my wife )i communicate on but this year my views has just been about frustration due to the content .

51 Chunks { 07.25.11 at 12:26 pm }

Gillian, no point being bothered by what people say on Internet forums. The promise of anonymity causes all restraint to fly out the window. All things considered, the bickering could be a LOT worse.

52 JaniceG { 07.25.11 at 12:28 pm }

@Paul: As has been mentioned previously, you seem to be comparing the contestants to your average home cook. If you volunteer to be a MasterChef contestant, I don’t think it’s unreasonable to expect that you have more breadth of knowledge and experience with food than your average home cook. Plus, keep in mind that this is near the end of the competition, when they have had the benefit of previous challenges, master classes, one-on-one experience with chefs, a well-equipped kitchen with other people interested in food to learn from and cookbooks all around plus no distractions of everyday life, and so on. Finally, just compare this season’s final five contestants to last year’s. They too were amateur cooks but by this point in the competition, they were producing mostly restaurant-quality dishes on taste and presentation.

@Lily: Cool – Jimmy is indeed tweeting about this year’s competition. (“It’s raining immunity pins and it’s official the contestants this year on #masterchef are heaps better than our year… Or are they?”)

53 Toby Tom { 07.25.11 at 12:29 pm }

Uh if you want to be respected as a viewer.. stop watching? If it’s causing so much pain change the channel.

54 kingfisher { 07.25.11 at 12:35 pm }

toby tom . i ve thought about it many times just put something else ,but you know tonight could be the night something good is gonna happen and when it’s over i think why didn’t i watch something else . doh!!!

55 Gillian { 07.25.11 at 12:48 pm }

@ Chunks – yes, that’s what I’m afraid of!

56 Sooty { 07.25.11 at 1:14 pm }

PS Thanks Lulu.

You can suck my fat one, too, Gillian. It’s a joke. I am ‘a female’. Just quoting.

57 Gillian { 07.25.11 at 1:18 pm }

@ Sooty You can agree to disagree on a forum. Paul’s opinion has no bearing on yours. When you have to resort to such childish insults, you’ve already lost the argument in my opinion anyway. It just ‘sucks’ up all the fun out of the forum.

58 Sooty { 07.25.11 at 1:22 pm }

Wow – more life tips. I would say the reverse. My opinion has no bearing on Paul’s. Every second or third commenter here is gifted with a correction, usually an attitude adjustment exhortation from Paul. I just got sick of it this morning. But good to know you are always on hand to step in for a follow-up on web protocol, Gillian, if he is otherwise indisposed.

59 brain dead dave { 07.25.11 at 1:27 pm }

The crux of the problem is that Ma$terchef “sucks”….

60 dmc { 07.25.11 at 1:33 pm }

I think it says a lot about where the standards of the show are when we say ‘gosh I couldn’t do something with those ingredients’ and we use that as the benchmark of judging the contestants’ skills.

But hang on. These are people who auditioned out of thousands and were actually chosen by professionals as people with ‘talent’. And they have now been in weeks and weeks of tests and masterclasses. And they have reached the top 5 out of 24. Shouldn’t we expect them to be able to make something out of ingredients that we can’t?

I think last night we saw what everyone knows: it’s a two tiered race. Kate, Michael and Alana did jobs that I thought were fine and the other two didn’t. That disappoints me. And the fact that one of them has won two immunity pins (and the other one won one pin) disappoints me more. It’s not their fault at all. RR said it all: maybe you’ll cook against a real chef, or maybe against a swimmer….

61 Gillian { 07.25.11 at 1:35 pm }

@Sooty – Always happy to be of assistance.

@BBD – Totally agree. It has definitely lost it’s ‘flavour’ this year.

62 Paul { 07.25.11 at 1:36 pm }

Sooty,
Don’t get things so wrong and you won’t get corrected.
Its pretty simple.

You were under the impression that every contestant wanted to be a professional chef in a professional kitchen. I corrected you on that.

End of story.

63 Rickard Lomez { 07.25.11 at 1:38 pm }

Last Night was a waste of time, just another excuse to milk the viewers for another night, it was a nothing show

64 Rachel Batta { 07.25.11 at 1:40 pm }

Just like the first series of the Block when DR Andrew Rochford went on to get recognised and get on TV, which he has, that is what Masterchef is all about, none of them will ever open a restaurant, by the way where is Julie Goodwin, who show on 9 has gone???

65 Sooty { 07.25.11 at 1:42 pm }

Paul, are you for real?

That was not my misconception.

Get help.

66 brain dead dave { 07.25.11 at 1:49 pm }

Just the idea that any of the contestants could cope as a chef in a busy restaurant kitchen is crazy. This is Wankerchef(tm)

Dani might be able manage a burger bar in Rabbit Flat.

67 SaintsDeano { 07.25.11 at 1:51 pm }

Alana’s crumbed flounder was a train crash. Dani’s was a disaster too. Not a good challenge to promote the best 5 “amatars”. Book sales will also be a train crash.

68 brain dead dave { 07.25.11 at 1:54 pm }

The cookbooks will need to come with First Aid Kits.

69 Fides { 07.25.11 at 2:01 pm }

If Dani had a burger joint, you’d be getting burnt buns. Oh but that’s right, there’s no bread in a Dani burger, just mushrooms or rice.

70 brain dead dave { 07.25.11 at 2:06 pm }

The Legoburger(tm)–you have to dislocate your jaw to have a bite.

71 Fides { 07.25.11 at 2:08 pm }

BDD – Love it!

72 Casper { 07.25.11 at 2:16 pm }

I agree with most of the comment based on some of the contestants seemingly lack of general cooking knowledge and poor skill set. Disappointing when I consider I shouldn’t be able to trump any of the contestants at this stage of the competition in those areas when I would be lucky to be classed as an average cook.

73 kingfisher { 07.25.11 at 2:32 pm }

hohummmm

74 kleenex mum { 07.25.11 at 2:32 pm }

oh please bring out the kleenex for ken (aka- dani ) and barbie ( aka Ellie ) i was sitting on the edge off my seat watching the two chefs ( yeh right ) destroy the Wabbit….. omg, this late in the comp and this is what theses two dimwits come up with, but right on cue, the tears appear….. what a joke, first time ive ever watched a reality tv show and have to say channel 10, what a joke…………

75 kingfisher { 07.25.11 at 2:40 pm }

kleenex mum “welcome to the party pal “

76 Chunks { 07.25.11 at 2:46 pm }

please, PLEASE don’t start the cook book thing up again. Some people just can’t resist a good cookbook barney…

77 Culinary Boner { 07.25.11 at 3:15 pm }

“Ellie said ‘I am putting the kidney on top as George loves kidneys’” ….

Wiki entry from 2015…
“Carry on ‘assolet”, produced 2013
Set in 1799, just after coup that makes Napoleon the First Consul of France. No. 33 in the Carry On series. First since 1992. Rick Mayall, Adrian Edmondson rejected parts when offered in 2012. With no one in UK interested, production moves downunder in desperation. While initially sought for the project Anh Do, Steady Eddy and Jimeon also decline. Manu Fiedel whilst strongly linked, issued a firm denial saying he was “otherwise engaged and had better things to do” citing the following link as evidence- http://www.perthnow.com.au/entertainment/perth-confidential/tongue-in-cheeky-manu-upsets-foodies/story-e6frg30l-1226097054717.
Production finally resumed with MCA ‘stars’ playing the parts…
…Example segment:
Scene: Inside a post-revolutionary restaurant. Our hero George Napoleon is keen to boost tourism and have wealthy Americans open their wallets for steak frites in Paris’ new restaurants, not knowing that they are eating grilled beef and thin chips. N’s inspecting one such establishment. Walks in flanked by Gary Talleyrand and his new inspector d’cuisine M Creosote.
George N, looking around: “This place seems to have all the alaments. Wot ya think fellas? Anyone care for some spotted dick and a bowl of slap and tickle?”
*young blonde serving wench walks in*
“Ooh, you’re a cheeky one, big boy”.
*she curtseys and they all oogle her cleavage*
“We heard you was COMING,’ she winks. “Would ‘is lordship fancy a kidney? I ‘er his lordship loves kidneys. I’d prefer a large sausage, meself.”
“A saucy one, at that,” she winks again and flounces out waggling her bussle…
…What the critics said:
“Why, oh why did they bother?” – Margaret Pomeranz.
“I thought it was absolute shit. But I’m still giving it 4 stars because it was good to see lots of tits in a film that didn’t feature Vin Diesel.” – David Straton
“Best in the franchise since Carry on Dick,” – Nigel, aged 13
“Not enough spotted dick.” – Mod Brit Cuisine Magazine

78 littlepetal { 07.25.11 at 3:49 pm }

I haven’t watch the episode yet but I am going to watch it to see how bad Dani and Ellie cooked. These 2 girls really need to go.

79 dmc { 07.25.11 at 4:01 pm }

Personally I like Dani and Ellie and I don’t think they are awful cooks. They are certainly better than me. But should they really be in the final stages of a show designed to find ‘Australia’s best amateur cook’? No answer required.

80 Skod { 07.25.11 at 4:34 pm }

Well George loves boobies more than kidneys..

81 lulu { 07.25.11 at 5:17 pm }

It does seem that they did a quick re-edit last night as there was much less of Daniii – I guess they just let her ‘food’ do the talking.

….and here comes Gillian (Paul’s fellow apostle?) riding in on her white horse like a valkyrie, the latest purveyor of online etiquette. It’s all a bit of fun, and without a variety of critiques, there would be no forums.
So lighten up, joy-suckers.

82 Allie { 07.25.11 at 6:19 pm }

Will Hayden come back as Michael’s loved one tonight?

83 ange { 07.25.11 at 6:37 pm }

I was amazed at how well Ellie did last night – she made a mess of the rabbit before and did a great job last night. I thought it was very difficult to make something when the ingredients were mismatched in some instances. Thought Lego’s dish was a shocker. Thought Micheal’s looked great and was impressed with what Kate did with the limited ingredients.

84 JaniceG { 07.25.11 at 8:16 pm }

@Allie: My husband was making all sorts of Hayden jokes about the show’s use of bridesmaid and bride for Michael’s immunity pin drought :->

85 Moonstruck { 07.25.11 at 9:54 pm }

Hi all. New to this blog and on the whole enjoyable.
The reason MKR got better was because they they started to have challenges and they went to Darwin. I personally found the home cooking a bore. Just two people cooking who I didn’t know for a whole sixty minutes.
As for who wants to open a restaurant, Andre did as did Chris B. But let’s be truthful – who would go to their restaurants even if they open them. Would be interesting to find out how many of those that started catering are still at it.
Keep up the discussions. It’s almost worth watching mc just to be able to read this blog (as long as u r all nice to each other.)