Masterchef Australia – Dani Got Gifted An Immunity Pin
“It is really quite strange to be cooking against an Olympian” said Dani. Or fortuitous considering it is a cooking competition not Wipeout. In fact the Masterchef Australia scandal today is not that the production company pays the contestant’s $500 a week (blog post following on that issue), but the fact that with only two weeks to go before the final that Dani got to go up against another amateur cook was outrageous.
Ok I like Eamon Sullivan and he is now 25 years old so is old enough to perve at, but he won Celebrity Masterchef not a Michelin Star.
Quite a few commenters have already raised this as an issue, and I agree. It is not fair on the other contestant’s remaining that Dani has been gifted another immunity pin. I am not saying she didn’t deserve to win it she did her Chocolate Delice looked much better than Eamon’s.
Davenports who sponsor Eamon will be happy he actually wears the product as when he bent down there was a great shot of his knickers – so no sponsored by pepsi but drinking coke scandal here.
Eamon and Dani had to cook the dish he won to get his Celebrity Masterchef title – Chocolate Delice. She got the recipe he did not.
The dish does look amazing with a salted caramel base, with a biscuit (I don’t think they made that element), creme brulee, mousse, and a ganache.
Dani who has been intensely cooking for the last seven months always had the advantage, even after she stuffed up her mousse and had to re do it.
Eamon over cooked his creme brulee. I noticed there was no coaching or shouting from the gallery on tonight’s episode for either competitor. Except for when Alana told him he had left the blast chiller door open.
Eamon’s cake ended up looking lop sided and collapsed whereas Dani’s looked great, and her definition between layers was a highlight.
What I don’t get was how they could have judged Eamon’s so high considering his presentation. However he go all eights from the judges including Phillipa Sibley who was guest judge for a total of 24. Whereas Dani got one extra point with Matt Preston giving her a nine for her to get the pin.
By the way if you do want to eat Eamon Sullivan’s food he is opening a cafe in Perth called Louis Baxter. He opened it with Laki Baker a Senior Producer of Masterchef. I thought he trained in Sydney so I am not sure how much cooking he will be doing there.
UPDATE: An article from the Daily Telegraph stating the producers are baffled that Dani is being so criticised and that she is a model contestant. They also try to beat up a death threat story, but it has no legs.
Also here is a link to the live chat the Daily Telegraph had with the lastest evictee Billy Law, he admits his spoiler tweet was a mistake.
UPDATE: Laki Baker who is Eamon’s partner in his cafe Louis Baxter, has not worked on Season 3 of Masterchef Australia.

169 comments
appalling joke danni & ellie worse cooks in show but looks getting them the votes please!!!!!! its just lost all credibility last year callum was the worse cook ever been but he won second!!!!! they need to relook at things and base on cooking ability not who they think get the ratings!!!
Complete farce. All this crap about ‘the only person to win two pins’. Made me want to puke.
I had such high hopes for this season! How much I enjoyed Masterchef last year and surely, they had found a winning formula! How great the finals week would be this year! .. Oh for pity’s sake, who am I kidding? This season lost all credibility and fell over long ago. Dilly Hamster Ellie is still there and now Dani has another pin. God help us. Maybe she’ll lose it in the next challenge like the last pin she had for.. what was it? 24 hours?
Can’t watch any more. I hope the producers of British Masterchef are taking note and furiously backpedalling away from any ideas to further “Australianise” their far superior product.
Couldn’t even bring myself to fast-forward through this tonight, since it was obvious the fix was in. Thanks for the recap.
Plot thickens….who would remember a “celebrity” who won a challenge. Better he be known as “that swimmer” who lost in Masterchef AND who is opening up a cafe AND (now as revealed) happens to be opening that cafe with a senior producer of Masterchef. As they say…there is no such thing as bad publicity.
Wait, what!?!
GAH.
URG.
gurgle.
The final immunity challenge should be a cook off against an orangutan from the Perth zoo. Even Jimmy from last season thinks the handing out of immunity pins like lollies this season is a load of wank.
anonymice – interesting you should say that, as the issue has been rumbling in my head since I saw that on the website. Was this why Eamon was given a spot later on in the series for his guest appearance as it was closer to the opening of their cafe.
I really am unsure of the ethics of all this. Should a producer be able to promote their business on the show? I know Gary, and George promote their restaurant’s on the show by wearing the name emblazoned on their chef whites. But we know they are chefs and they own restaurants.
I am going to sleep on it tonight and think about it. What do other people think?
This was a Ma$terchef nightmare. These producers make News Of The World look like choirboys. Three Michelin hats off to the in$ide job tonight.
I can’t see Michael being a threat with that beige haircut. Wasted trip to New York. There should be a disposable nappy company sponsor him for the rest of the series. You can literally smell the fear coming out of him.
Knock it off Jowlsy with the “‘nine” for Dani’s dish or was that just a sugar hit clouding his judgement?
No wonder Dani gets so much face time – the producers mistakenly think we like her. It must mean they’re giving her good edits as well, so it’s bizarre that she’s still coming off as so unlikeable.
I thought the $500 thing already came to light in the behind-the-scenes SMH article? Why is it only becoming a big deal now? I don’t think it’s so bad. The contestants are getting valuable exposure which is very important to those who want a media career, and let’s face it – there are probably people out there who would be willing to do it for free. A bit like any other job out there; don’t sign the contract if you don’t agree to the terms.
If Ellie had kept her pin, no way would Dani have won one tonight. And Dani was pretty lucky to win over Michael in Sunday’s challenge anyway – I wouldn’t have minded so much if Michael won tonight, but the inconsistencies of the immunity pin challenge would still be the same. Kate must really be spewing -she had that really tricky banana dessert – a chef’s signature dish no less – and she came so close.
Now if Dani uses her pin this week to knock out someone else (I won’t be upset if it’s Ellie) then I guarantee next week the pin will be won again.
I missed the ending even though I had recorded 11 minutes over time. All I saw before it cut off was Matt P handing out that winning 9. Did the others fake their delight well? How did Eamon handle it?
I’m just confused as to why the immunity challenges are becoming easier as the show goes on?
I’m sure none of us are naive enough to think that reality tv is actually real but this is really treating viewers like idiots.
You cant even call this a joke, Dani winning another pin let alone still being in the comp along with her cry baby mate Ellie. A joke is funny this is not funny its just so wrong in every way. If the producers cannot understand why all the bad comments about these two girls, then they are obviously walking aroung with blinders on. As for George he makes me sick the way he oggles over these two. Just put on the water works and Georgie will come running and wipe your nose for you. My god its sickening the whole damn show. All the really truely good cooks are gone. It should be renamed Amaturechef with the worst cook winning. Then we’d have nothing to complain about.
I’ve also just read the Daily Telegraph link with the producers ‘baffled’ by the backlash against Dani. The thing which they need to take on board is that there has been inconsistency across the board this season. Inconsistency in the rules applied to Immunity Pin Challenges (some challenges with time bonuses some without, some with recipes, some without), inconsistency in the difficulty of dishes in Immunity Pin Challenges (Roast Pork, Pasta with Meat Sauce, then a complex dessert by Darren Purchese) inconsistency in the varying levels of help given by judges during elimination rounds. As a result, some contestants have benefited and it is very easy for the viewers to draw the conclusion of bias or favouritism, even if this is not the intention. Certainly, it appears there are some contestants considered more ‘marketable’ who have benefited from this and it would be safe to say, questions over the cooking ability and credibility behind who has a pin and who doesn’t. Looking back to the high quality of contestants in Season 2 where there were only two? (Adam and Marion?) pins won throughout the season should highlight the disparity between last year and the current season where Immunity Pins are being passed around like candy. Challenges, particularly Immunity Challenges across the board were of a higher standard last year and Masterchef has inadvertently opened itself to questions of bias with the change in approach.
Quote from Telegraph article “Dani is a delight on and off set”… the off set part sounds so fishy. Great…
The producers think that ‘cute’ Dani will wins the audience heart !!!! This is not a kid show. It’s a cooking show and her cooking is hot and cold. Obviously the producers think the audience are dumb. They can’t do much now as they must be filming the finale now. If the final is between Dani and Ellie, god please help my hubby. May need a new tele.
Hmmm, I’m pretty sure this challenge last year (ie 2nd last immunity pin) was Claire doing that weird peas and eggs molecular gastronomy thing. And then the last challenge was the sushi one where she lost the plot completely and had to be given extra time. Both were pretty complex challenges, as they ought to be. Why can’t the producers see what’s gone wrong this year?
Now I know why masterchef keeps banging on about the “coarse language warning” at the beginning of every episode – it’s because of all the viewers swearing at the teev!
Dani will do well with a Hello Kitty range of cupcakes but not much more.
Alana looked mighty pissed at the pin, caught one of her micro expressions that clearly read Envy + Disgust
Is Michael skipping wardrobe or what? I’m still having nightmares from his foie gras shaded jumper from last night
@davsimp… spot on! New TV sales must be booming at the moment. …so many shoes being thrown at them….
Billy and Sun did their interviews on the circle from the Masterchef kitchen. So it’s true, they are filming the last bit of MC.
I wonder how many people bullying (or cyberbulling should i say) are actually parents with children. I thought Australia is all against bullying. Hypocrisy at its finest.
bk, Callum was a three Michelin hat chef by comparison to Dani and Allie. Honestly, what a farce this is. Without wishing to spark an anti-cookbook windfall tirade from Paul, I predict a flop outcome this year, which while it won’t make a dent in the cash they’re pocketing, will certainly be bad for the image of the show and its future. And rightfully so. It’s been manipulated to the nth degree every step of the way.
@RR Don’t see the problem with the promo. The sheep will always follow.
Are we really meant to beleive that a person with no culinary training created this dish from their own experience? Then can not reproduce it.
ROFLMAO.Pull the other one 10
Mat had to go to be fair to the other contestants apparently and then dani is handed immunity pins like lollies.
Pathetic.
Baffled by the backlash against Dani??? Try SHE CAN”t COOK and we are actually intelligent enough to be watching Masterchef to witness “normal people” showcase their cooking skills. If the producers haven’t cottoned onto this and think that we watch to listen to the “”smiling assassin”” or to repetitive, droning recaps from some surfer dude…they should, quite simply, be sacked.
Being the only person to win 2 pins is, in this case, a comment on the calibre of the competitiOn and not the chef.
And Mac – Australians have always heartily endorsed the sledging of opposing sports teams or of any other competitors… Such as the competitors in a televised competition like this one
I wonder if this year Dani is the only one that really can ‘speak’ to to the camera, which could mean that when the show is edited, Dani is probably the only one that makes ‘good television’… from season 2 most of the people on the show seems to speak well to the camera (more people to chose for editing)… this season there is hardly anybody you can chose from that sounds ‘entertaining’… probably why the produces like her… rather than what the negative feeling (most?) audience have towards her ways.
I agree with the post about the difficulty of the immunity challenges, its not consistent and more like a lucky dip… I like how they have made a ‘tie’ equating to a win for a contestant, but then the challenges needs to be just a hard like season 1 and 2…
The other 5 on the balcony looks pretty ‘pissed’ at Dani’s win… Micheal didn’t appear to even have forced a smile at all.
Ref the daily telegraph article:
“model contestant” — of course she is, she cries on cue, storms out when she doesn’t get her way, stuffs up as team leader, rude to teammate and Macro Pierre White, etc.
I don’t even mind her excessive laughter, and I sometimes think it’s refreshing.
What annoys me is that she milks the producers, and gives them the drama they want to overcompensate the fact that she’s only a so-so cook.
She gets the credit even when she stuffs up (milk shake what?!)….good god.
Er, Mac, if anyone is being “bullied” here it’s the three stooges and their fellow producers, not the hapless contestants.
@RR – I’ve taken your comment from your the project runway post “Tip if you are on a show like this make sure you show personality or are controversial it can keep in you a bit longer even if you are not talented.” I think this also applies to this season’s MC.
remember i said i could smell a dead carcass, that carcass is the third series of ma$terchef after tonight’s show . we sat there quietly after dani the mouth won realising how bad and corrupt this series has become . this year has become like a bad car crash you don’t want to look but you still do . we have followed masterchef over the years and love the concept it was fresh and no bullying , just cooking and being invited to the world of master cooking but alas it’s turned into who’s pretty and interesting not who’s brilliant at creating . r.i.p masterchef
The producers have done their jobs beautifully when you consider what the job really entails. Alot of people are watching long after they have stated they were done with MC and the amount of talk being generated is pretty damn impressive. How many other shows would love to get the amount of interest MC’s managed to achieve. Publicity of anykind, good or bad is cream in TV land and the MC producers are grinning like fat cats at the moment.
“Dani got gifted an immunity pin” The title to this piece says it all. Got nothing more to add
Totally agree Kingfisher. Dani winning an immunity pin killed the little credibility Masterchef had left.
I hope it is dani and Ellie in the final so that it becomes the final nail in the Masterchef coffin.
Casper you may be right about the free publicity, but don’t forget it was the bad publicity that killed big brother in the end.
This kind of stupid and very evident manipulation will hurt the brand and could even rub off on the chef/judges real life.
I actually couldn’t care less who wins now. The fast forwarding of the episodes is going to be even faster now-straight to the results.
Crabtech – you may well be correct with your comparison to BB but BB’s demise was primarily due to the turkey slap incident IMO. If you look at the statistics such as amount of articles written (especially compared to all other reality shows recently) number of posted comments and the ratings I don’t see this as the beginning of the end for MC, rather the contrary. If people were saying they were done and stopped watching I’d agree with you but they’re not. The hype being generated by viewers is only growing. That’s more of an indicator of a successful program to the networks. If ten dropped MC, nine and seven would go into a record bidding war for an Australian produced program. The bottom line’s about ad dollars. The viewing numbers and interest shown, whether good or bad equals bank.
Sigh Legohead got another pin. Well that looked like a better dessert than the one Billy and Kate did.
I think the producers not showing what the contestants cooked each time has hurt the series and its credibility. That said, I will keep watching until the end.
Casper they have lost me as a viewer. I know it’s not real and knew it when Poh found a 100 day old eggs in the pantry in season one and Justine found duck at Coles. People were complaining I season one and season two but at least the immunity challenges were relatively even. This year the eneveness in the immunity challenges is costing them. Getting chefs to cook things they are unfamiliar with or even gettim
Ng Ellie to cook pasta in an immunity challenge is voing too far Maybe they can’t get chefs to agree to go up against the amateurs????
Eamon is not a chef and dani beating him is no Great featb.
I watch Masterchef Australia here in Germany. For me it’s hard to understand, why so many poeple in Australia hate Dani. Twitter and this board is full of them. Maybe she’s a little bit too bubbling. But it’s not her fault, that she got two immunity pins; and it’s not her fault, that she is being promoted so much; and it’s not her fault either that the other contestans are so epicly boring.
Well, I must confess, that last season had a much higher standard of cooking skills but nevertheless I could only blame the producers. Blame them for ridiculous team challenges, inconsistency, unfairness, and biased airtime given to contestans.
Crabtech – Your point “Maybe they can’t get chefs to agree to go up against the amateurs????” is quite valid. What would a chef achieve by beating one of the contestants? Nothing but if they where to lose to one it could be disasterous to their career and/or business.
They very well may have lost you as a viewer but take a look at how many people have stated they were done with the program only to continue commenting and obviously watching. When MC starts again next season how many people that are saying they won’t watch anymore will give it another go or just check it out to see if it has changed? They’ll all get addicted again, constantly whinge and complain and the ratings will once again soar. It’s basic human behavour.
Couldn’t bring myself to watch tonight (or at all this week actually) but my reaction to the title of this article was pretty much:
http://www.nooooooooooooooo.com/
Gurgle? Yes, I gurgle in rage.
Fear me.
I’m a Dani fan but I don’t like the inconsistencies that have plagued season 3. Immunity challenge against a swimmer and he doesn’t get a recipe. Dani has been cooking every day for 6 months. Come on..
Has Masterchef “jumped the shark”? Ie. Is this the episode that will be remembered as the trigger for the show going into decline?
Rigged? How come Phillipa held up Plate 2 for a score of ’8′ for Danni? same card she used for the guest who also scored 8 from her but was actually plate 2
Bit mean taking his MC Celebrity title away; talk about walking away feeling flat…………….. didnt like it
In fact dont like this year’s MC – no balance in age groups at all
Those Fairfax articles can be held responsible for a lot of the Dani hate. By calling her ‘lego-head’ and continually degrading her they have legitimized the gutless sniping that has come off the interwebs.
I don’t know what she has done wrong. She has been a model contestant. Bubbly, shows personality and always seems cheerful. FFS, what do people want in a contestant ?????
I really would like to know their expectations.
As for the demise of Masterchef. People don’t know what they are talking about. Still consistently rating 1.6-1.8 and more importantly killing them in the key demographics. It is down on last year but hell, what Season 3 of any show actually improves on Seasons 1 & 2 ratings wise. None that I can think of.
Honestly I wish all the people who actually state they they are done with the show and are going to stop watching, would actually follow through and stop watching. Kudos to Injera as I know she is one of those who has actually done this – for the most part anyway. LOL.
Masterchef jumped the Shark when Marion was voted out last year and Matt Preston and his Logie
I think the tide turned against Dani after the Nigella challenge when she went on and on about Arena’s fail red velvet cupcakes and madevit like she was the one who saved the team. Then she cornered Arena into volunteering herself for elimination round with Shannon.
Since then Dani got a lot more airtime than the rest of the contestants. It’s always about Dani’s opinions. The viewers are overdosed with it. Do the producers expect us to like her and see her as the model contestant after how she is being edited on the show?
Her poor performances in NYC, her not so ‘original’ ideas of rice burger (Mos burger) and baklava ice cream (I have seen it on many food magazines) just couldn’t sit well with most of the audience.
@ Paul: This season is like s train wreck. You want to turn away but can’t help but watching. A lot of us got suck into watching it because of last season. We keep watching and hoping it will get better closer to the finale and to have closure. Note the good rating but the producers should not take it for granted. It will be a different story next season. Many will not tune in to it from the start.
What’s the point of having good ratings but with majority of the viewers have nothing good to say about it?
And here’s another thing thats annoying.
People using the phrase ‘jumping the shark’ when they have no idea what it actually means.
Just to clarify – the term ‘jumping the shark’ refers to a scene in a long standing show that has basically no relevance as to what the show has been traditionally about. The scene is inputted to jump-start flagging ratings and to generate interest.
Masterchef is a long, long, long way from needing a ‘jumping the shark’ type scene.
@EH – heard it all before. People weren’t going to watch S2 after S1 was supposedly rigged. Guess what, highest ratings ever.
Then people weren’t going to watch S3 after being disappointed with S2 – yet its still consistently been the top rating show night after night with the odd few exceptions.
Im sure Dani is lovely, im sure she is a great girl, shes pretty and bubbly. so it’s completly masterchefs fault that there is such a backlash against her. People are sick of watching such unfair bias towards her! They shove her down our throat at every opportunity and then consistenly let her slip through with absolutely horrible dishes and then dont even challenge her when giving her an immunity pin!! Eamon Sullivan – he’s no more than a total amateur cook himself.
Thats why people dont like Dani, they dont like the unfair bias towards her and then have her laughing in our faces when she wins and no one thinks she deserves it.
Oh well, Alana will rise to the top and take out the title! She’s consistently performed across all dishes, she’s never had anything handed to her and she’s enver had an easy challenge! Go Alana!
To follow up, i think the real damage that masterchef is doing is to their credibility. I wonder how many people will tune in next year? People are totally sick of the inconsistency through the show. This didn’t happen previous seasons but this season has surely ruined the show for a lot of people!
People have always complained about inconsistency on Masterchef.
Its been a weekly complaint throughout its short history.
Could not watch the rest of last night’s episode when it was obvious that Dani was going to win.
Through over-exposure, the producers have ruined Brand Dani. Anyone could edit an episode of S3 MC. Open with Dani, announce challenge, Cut back to Dani’s reaction, start challenge, cut to clock, corny quip by judges, focus another contestant’s disaster, cut to Dani opining how that particular contestant feels at the time, cut back to action, maybe cut to another constestant -Ellie/Hayden, clock, judges, Dani, Ellie/Hayden, and finish with Dani.
Don’t know if Michael, Kate or Alana can speak. Throw in the uneveness of the challenges and then the producers wonder why people are annoyed.
I like Dani (and all of the other remaining contestants) and given this challenge its only fair she won it (though I was expecting a tie, which is the same result for her anyway). However, I agree that the difficulty seems to be shifting around a bit.
Could it be that there are just scheduling issues? I’m sure the guest chefs and judges have other things to do than MC. Though if they’re concerned about re-using guest chefs they should switch them with the guest judges who are all supposedly good chefs too right?
To avoid inconsistency in the future they should do the following all the time:
- Gary (or the non-tasting host) always gets to choose the dish
- No help from peanut gallery for either side
- No help from visiting / competing chef
- Contestant gets recipie, chef doesn’t
- No time advantage
Anyway, that dessert looked yummy… *drools*.
This year has been poor and there is no way to sugar coat it. The judges are not idiots and they know the cooking standard is appreciably lower than in past seasons. I would hope their credibility would drive them to demand ‘better’ contestants next season. It is crystal clear that after last year with the lawyers and professionals, they wanted more ‘salt of the earth’ types to resonate with the mass public (and there is nothing wrong with that in theory). Unfortunately, the result of that has been less than inspired cooking, so the ‘it’s all about the food’ motto has gone by the wayside. I personally can’t see anybody this year who will sell cookbooks and who will represent Masterchef and its ability to produce ‘Australia’s best amateur cook’ with pride.
My prediction is that we will see a better standard of cook in season 4, and the lessons from this season will have been learned. To argue that ratings are the ONLY thing that drives a show like this is cynical – I know some people in the industry and there are people higher up who are very concerned with the quality of the product they produce.
dmc,
How is Adam going at representing the Masterchef brand?
Doing ads for Noodle Box, isn’t he?
Honestly, people vastly over-estimate how important the winner is. Nobody cares once the season is over. Its irrelevant and not important. The cookbooks angle is again moot. The money they make is so small compared to the big picture which is advertising and the sale of rights.
And I’m sorry – the only thing that is really important in the scheme of things is the ratings. Not being cynical. Its reality.
Ma$terchef is consistently contrived and one would be have to taking it like a chook for the show not to see it.
Second time Dani has been gifted an immunity pin. A joke.
Ah damnit, my edit came too late. Anyway here it is again:
I think they should also incorporate a weekly score system to keep track of everyone’s progress through the week which will determine who goes into the elimination rounds.
Masterclass: Everyone resets to 0 points.
+3 pts for best dish
+2 pts for almost best dish
+1 for middle of pack or on winning team
-5 for yelling advice from peanut gallery when not supposed to.
(Cheering is permitted only during scripted cheering times :P)
That way, if you cooked the best dish but are on the losing team you don’t necessarily drop into elimination and none of this “who goes to elimination?” stuff.
Yeah my system needs work but at least it would pull back more focus on the cooking?
(Somewhat related)
http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-wIhH_CLpC_M/TgCNz3M__sI/AAAAAAAAABU/G0q07BuS0FU/s1600/0008a.jpg
dmc, sorry to be cynical, but the massive amount of cash going into certain pockets from the ads and product placement are what’s driving this show.
Problem is people will watch again next year, and people will take Matt Preston seriously…..I gave it another chance watching the soul food ep . I wonder about the reactions if you served up piece of blackened fried chicken and a dehydrated yam to Moran and Preston off camera. That’s where they lost me with the whole Dani thing, raving about a moist bit of meat they’d found in the middle of all that charcoal. As for Dani, yes she’s probably the ideal contestant. But too much of a good thing? Immunity against an amateur whose cafe got mentioned 4 or 5 times in the episode? In business with a producer? MC is now reminding me of a friend of mine back when U2 released “Rattle and Hum” ‘They could have farted on it and it would have sold a million copies in Ireland alone.’
Interesting about ratings… With many people having foxtel and by default foxtel iQ, I wonder how many people have MC set for series link in the PVR but dont actually watch it? I know of 3 girls out of my very small workplace who dont watch it but still record it anyway “just in case” And one who somehow still hasnt caught up and is unaware of the Mat scandal! Yes she lives under a rock. We are all still sworn to not breathe a word around her!
I think for some odd reason (other than ratings) that there has been a lot of favouritism in MC this year, towards some contestants, notibly the younger more good-looking ones. I think that it was wrong that every immunity challenge so far this year has been against a trained chef and yet Dan’s latest immunity challenge was not. I love Eamon Sullivan not just for his good looks but also his humility and personality but he is not a professional and desserts need to be accurate in terms of their ingredients. It would have been more fair to have given him the recipe as well. No way would I have given Dani’s dessert a 9, as Matt Preston did.
In terms of the favouritism, this was so evident in terms of the air time that different contestants got. Kumar, who I thought was an interesting character, received hardly any air time, unlike Dani and Michael and also perhaps Hayden. I like all of these contestants but the producers do need to be fair in the air time (such as which contestants are chosen to present their dishes to the judges when not all contestants were asked to present their dishes to the judges).
Paul we all understand it is all about ratings our point of view is they are treating our intelligence as s..t we want to be entertained by the the best amata cooks in australia vying for the pin against the top chefs of the world but the producers create rubbish scenarios and we will not accept that !!!
kingfisher,
If you don’t want to accept it, then don’t watch it.
Changes will only be made if the ratings start declining to the point where it just isn’t profitable any more.
Its just like any business. If you are making a good profit, then its unlikely you are going to change things up too much.
I would love to see the British MC be more like ours in terms of the format. They rarely give any insight in to the peronalities of the contestants plus they only have two or three contestants competing against each other at the one time. Plus they do not seem to have all of the elements of the competition that our MC has. I gave up watching the British MC as it was way too boring although I did like the judges.
Why is everyone arguing with paul about his comments? He’s 100% correct and his opinion is based on facts not emotion.
Paul enough, we get your point, discuss something else
Some new material to brow beat and bully us would be nice.
Sorry kingfisher,
Silly me. From now on I will stick with pointless whinging and slagging off of contestants.
Again my apologies BDD,
I will try and concentrate my activities in future to commenting on contestants body shapes and their parenting skills. That obviously meets the definition of non bullying commentary.
Thanks Paul ,that what us whingers like to hear
kingfisher – Paul should have the right to reply to your comments, especially when they were directed at him by name. Just my opinion.
Unfortunatley Casper, some people like to think they have the god given right to denigrate people over the interwebs as they see fit without fear of being challenged about it.
I will say that kingfisher is generally not one of these people.
Paul, yes of course ratings are important and Masterchef has always had lots of free publicity through the various controversies through all the seasons – Poh was not liked, they brought back eliminated contestants in season 1 etc. Marion’s elimination, the silly taste test eliminations, and the poor girl people disliked who never came back even in the final in season 2 also got people talking, and watching. In season 2 the food was really over the top but at least the immunity challenges were of an equal standard. This year all pins have been won when the contestants cooked either easy food ellie, or not against chefs Hayden and the apprentice and now dani and an amateur cook. The exception was dani’s first pin.
The immunity pin was devised because ten realized that by taking the contestant out of the show, viewers didn’t get to see them, and the contestants were not prepared enough in cooking under time pressures – Julia the classic example.
There is no objection to ten tweaking elements that were not working or were seen to be unfair. However, the perception that it is being dumbed down and not fair will I believe result in the ratings dropping especially if the final is between Dani and Ellie.
There isn’t that vibe, people talking about the show as there was in previous years. How many people went out and bought gadgets shown on the show? What dish generated discussion the way the dessert in season one did (sorry can’t spell it). I guess only time will tell.
Paul – My biggest problem with that type of behavour is that the vast majority who act like that would never dream of doing it without the anonimity. I call it the ethug epidemic.
That includes people like you ,Paul. Your word against yours.
Paul you use your views against others as a bully would use his presence in a school yard and I stand up to school yard bullies to protect others who cannot . Choose your words carefully
And once again we have a lynch mob. But who are ‘we’ (count me out) going to lynch? Paul, or Dani? Or the MC producers?!
I, for one, like Dani. (And that is not a vote to lynch Paul instead)
Warning to readers of any sensitivity. This place is going to get really ugly when the winner is announced.
Well said Sooty but I think it’s already gotten ugly.
Dani has been overused by the producers. At first her comments and sense of enjoyment were good. However when she continued to escape elimination and then went on to win two immunity pins after the total disasters in NY the viewer is left with the impression that Dani and Ellie are being favored. That’s where the problem is.
As someone said, perhaps the other contestants just can’t speak to camera and they have to overuse Dani. Maybe next year the producers should also test contestants on their speaking skills as well. After all it is not a cooking show but a reality competition.
I did warm to Dani for a while after she teared up talking to her Dad on the phone.
She gets a lot of camera time but it isn’t her fault that the others are like cadavers.
Then she blew it big time when she crowed about ‘earning” her first ammunity pin after she blubbed and the judges helped her.
That immunity challenge last night was a crock of sh*t. How is it fair that the elimination challenge the night before featured a dish from a world class pastry chef and the immunity challenge was with a swimmer? Also, how is it that Dani can get 2 elements of the dish wrong and still score a 9? Have you noticed how much air time Dani is getting? This stinks of preferential treatment. The producers of this show are killing any credibility it ever had.
I don’t really understand all the scrapping. I guess people are just very invested in this show and need somewhere to vent where people actually give a damn. No good venting to your friends or family if they’ll look at you like you’ve got two heads for getting so worked up about a TV show! And having said that, if the final does end up being Dani vs Allie, I for one will NOT be watching, and not because I personally dislike either of them but simply because it would be excruciating to witness either of them crowned Australia’s “Masterchef”.
Some interesting comments here – perhaps Crabtech is right and Dani is the only one to consistently give “good TV” so they’ve had to use her.
I have stopped watching (thanks, Paul, for the acknowledgement!), but still come here to find out what’s going on. Not sure whether that counts as a win for the Masterchef brand, a confirmation of my need to procrastinate, or what
Let’s all take a deep breath and remember that we enjoy coming here and airing our views. Let’s not make Raver come back here and give us a talking to…
We are a bit like a family. Usually functional, sometimes not… and in the absence of challenging topics for discussion (i.e. being able to focus on events in the show) we revert to our default conversations.
Well it was a recipe that he cooked before.
MC Australia isn’t the worst reality cooking show I’ve seen, but not the best either. After so much time I still can’t get much grasp of the personalities, which I had a much better idea for those in Top Chef, which was just one ep a week. MC US is the most brutal, but there’s something addictive about watching those that get abused rise up and fight.
I’ll keep watching and hope it’s either Hayden or Alana that win it, though I’d be fine with Michael. Alana is an outstanding leader; not sure if she’s the best cook overall but quite impressed with her.
I don’t think it is Dani that people are angry at. To me it is the challenges that they set up for them. Some of the elimination challenges were more difficult than the immunity challenges. Immunity challenges should be more difficult as the weeks go by but we are not seeing that.
I read that when they select the contestants they were selected for their appeal on TV. They can’t be introverts and must be comfortable in front of the camera.
I do blame the production team for destroying the integrity of the show.
Au$tralia’s projecting it’s hate for the carbon tax onto Dani.
I think Dani has been getting a good edit after a bit of a negative one at the beginning of the season. Personally I think her and Hayden are the only two who have any chance of getting careers out of the show this season. I hope Michael and Alana are in the final. But we barely know Alana.
As Injera said lets all try to be nice to each other. I now need to go over to the Dalai Lama thread to see what is going on over there.
Ive been watching this season swinging between wild laughter and blind fury listening to these people and their dreams. Dani would not last one service in a real kitchen, neither would Ellie. The first sign of tears would be the end. If this show was about really good home cooks it would be better than the dreams of ‘hatted’ (is that even a word?) kitchens and opening cafes.
This is the first season of adult MC I have watched, and it will be the last. Bring on the kiddies!
Kate’s “dream” is to open a Bed and Breakfast. Ha. That’s good because plenty of people will be confined to bed after one of her awesome “breakfasts”. As seen on Ma$terchef. If you’re lucky she might even call you “Sir” or”Madam”
I’ve love to frequent a B&B that Kate opens. Don’t need to be called Sir or Madam.
Her signature dish could be toasted frumpets.
You’d get burnt porridge at Kate’s B&B.
Plus a strict “No Kids” policy.
Stop it, you’re killing me.
Thank the Flying Spaghetti Monster’s salty brown balls I had a pre-record of this week’s Top Chef Allstars to cleanse myself in after watching this train wreck of a Ma$terFarce episode.
For those interested in real cooking in an enjoyable reality format with the right mix of personality, bitchiness, professional respect and eye-candy (for all persuasions), regular judge Tom Colocchio had to don his whites to cook a restaurant quality meal in under 15minutes. He clocked in at 8min 30s for a sea bass dish, setting a time and standard the vast majority of the allstars could not get near. Why not see if the Podge Bros, George and Gary could do the same? Would certainly beat watching unispiring sporting ‘legends’ go all flaccid in the kitchen.
CB – 8 mins 30 secs for a restuarant quality sea bass dish, now that’s impressive. you’ve sold me. I’ll definately be checking it out. Thanks for the tip.
Gary would waste five minutes licking the spoon.
George will be distracted by anything wearing a skirt. i’m surprised he didn’t try to look up Arnold Schwarzenegger’s housekeeper while he was in the States.
Yes it’s about ratings BUT I have it on good authority that the judges have been concerned about the quality of the cooking. Remember that they have restaurants and reputations outside the show and they do not want to be seen as endorsing mediocre cooking.
I do think the venison has bolted on that score, dmc.
The jutbutted judges aren’t endorsing mediocre cooking,they’re celebrating it.
I don’t remeber the judges helping and interfering this much in the previous seasons. I wnder if they really have a say in who wins or if the producers nudge them towards the desired result.
I agree that the judges should be thinking of their reputations and their businesses post-masterchef.
bdd, lol at the reference to Big Arnie’s housekeeper
Anonymous, they always leap in to help if the contestant is petite, female and pretty. Gary could barely breathe in the same room as Fiona last year.
maybe they are afraid they will either not finish on time or they will have mud on their faces especially in the team challenges
Chunks this season they have been helping the males as well. i can almost smell the fear on them that the contestants will messup.
why is tonights episode 90 minutes? I remeber when it was 30 minutes and bit was more enjoyable.
Chunks, which one was Fiona?
I only had eyes for Skye
People work hard on this show and they care a lot about how the quality of their product is perceived. To say it’s only about ratings is rubbish. They read the forums intently realize the general reaction out there.
I think Fiona was too young for the likes of CB and myself. It was all about Skye.
CB, Fiona, was petite and pretty with long, wavy brown hair and her most memorable contribution to the show was a chocolate tart with lavender (gross) cream that she got to demonstrate in a masterclass with Gary beside her making eyes the whole while. She was last heard of teaching kids about food with Stephanie Alexander.
dmc,
MC is watched by between 1.6 to 1.8 million daily. The contributors to forums, newspaper articles, social media in general might number maybe 1000. And to be frank, some of the opinions expressed are so far off the mark that its hard to take the general take on them seriously at times.
Every cook in the country would be clamouring to get on the show. You can’t buy publicity like what they get. To suggest, that they are deeply concerned about the standards is a bit melodramatic.
George has just opened I think his 5th restaurant now. Yep, Masterchef has been terrible for him…..
It’s all about the contestant marketing potential and advertising $, not the cooking ability.
I don’t think it is correct to say every cook would be clamouring to get on the show. There were 7000 applicants – are you saying we only have 7000 cooks in Australia? I didn’t apply, I guess I am not a cook just someone who throw in some ingredients to make a meal.
Hi littlepetal,
By cook, I meant professional chefs.
Fiona was the teacher who went on to work in a school with the Stephanie Alexander garden scheme. Fiona wanted to combine teaching and cooking and she really got a good outcome from appearing on the show.
DMC I’m sure the people on the show read the forums but the ratings are important because if the ratings fall they will be out of jobs.
I think the problem is that people don’t want to apply. After all it is 6 months away from jobs and family, a drop in income and then having to cope with the viewers getting nasty about them.
Let’s not forget Joanne from last season and how nasty the forums became and after she was eliminated she didn’t come back for the finals.
Even here it has become personal about the contestants and even the judges. It’s okay to criticize their cooking but it’s unfair to make fun of them. So if one was an aspiring cook would they go on the show? For the long run? Maybe to get a bit of a profile, meet some chefs and then they’d be out of there. Unless of course they get Stockholm syndrome and believe that winning the competition is the be all of their existence.
Point taken, Paul.
There are many,many self respecting cooks who would never go on a cheeseball money go round like Ma$terchef.
The clamouring is from the desperate and deluded camera fodder that go on Ma$terchef.
brain dead dave = Reality Raver’s Dani.
Thanks for the description Chunks.
Cooking? And making eyes?
Maybe she thought she was Nigella?
bdd, you’re spot on that as i don’t remember her, she must’ve been too young.
I prefer the MILFs – but only the no moustache variety
Ouch, Snappy TomThat would make you Christopher Pyne and Paul Hitler if you want to get down to it.
God how I wish Bully Beatdown was still going. There’d be a few nominees here I’d love to see on it. Maybe Mayhem can be convinced to do an Australian special.
Pretty clear which team will get the judges help tonight in the Qantas first class challenge.
Dani, Ellie & Alana vs Michael, Hayden & Kate
Was the selection criteria “Beauties” vs “Beasts”
More opportunity for cringeworthy TV. I predict Dani and/or Ellie will cry and George will rush in to help.
More outcry then on this blog.
Casper , you’re happy to call a regular blogger here a failed human being. Not that I give a s… but you’d get a starring role on the show you’re blabbering about. You wrote off a whole generation of people on the other blog,so you might want to clean up your own back yard.
BDD – lmao. After your conduct you should talk. If your not just all piss and wind why don’t we organise for you to give me the beatdown then buddy. Keep up the ethuggin’ champ.
Surely they must be concerned about the quality of the cooking though Paul. It’s been appalling and other blogs and columns have wasted no time laughing at last night’s embarrassing debacle.
Just had a look back over last year’s Top 24 to refresh my memory and nearly all of them could cook this year’s top six under the kitchen counter with one hand tied behind their backs. And then there were Phil’s abs…
I don’t get why last night was embarassing to be honest Chunks.
That dessert looked extremely technical and for Eamonn to have to do it without a recipe would have been nigh on impossible unless you were cooking it every day multiple times over a long period.
From memory, everyone was appalled at the standard of the cooks last year. The nature of the online jungle is to be overwhelmingly negative.
The only real opinion that matters is garnered through a Nielsen set top box !!!!!
What time do you knock off from peeling potatoes,Casper?
BDD – just as I thought, more shit talk but no guts. Either step up or fuck up ethug.
Neil Perry must be smiling to himself and is happy that he is not involved with this show. I still remember the judges mentioning that this series contestants were so much better than previous series and that there were some who were not successful in previous series and they have got better to be selected this year.
We all now know that is not true. The cooking this year is really poor.
Well Casper, you’re out of the closet, just another foul-mouthed troll wanting a fight. Why would you bother with a failed human being like me?
Exactly Paul, so why didn’t Eamon have a recipe? He’s not a professional chef and Dani has become the only person in the (entire, aeons long) history of Masterchef to win two ammunity pins as a result. It’s rubbish. And it’s not just a handful of people here who think so. I dunno, let’s see how well a grand final between Dani and Allie competing to see who can make the best boiled egg without scalding themself fares in the ratings…
Little petal, Neil perry was involved in this season’s masterchef. They did the qantas challenge with him. BTW Rockpool Melbourne has great food. I bet he wouldn’t offer it for a challenge. Must admit I went there because of the show and I’m loving his recipes on the age good weekender. I feel they are doable and after trying a few very tasty.
Yes, Neil Perry was on Masterchef but he is representing Qantas !!! I don’t think MC will want him after his comments last year but they have to kowtow to their big sponsors.
BDD – You’ve got it all wrong champ, no troll here. Infact you’re the one typical of trolling (ie: start a fight and then hide behind your keyboard). As I said before champ either step up or fuck up. Simple.
Wasting your your time,chump.
BDD – whatever champ. Now go and shut up little boy.
MC is as much about food as the 7pm Project is about current affairs. It’s about the people. They edit to produce a human storyline.
In the end they don’t care whether you like it as long as their sponsors think you watch it.
Oh, get a room you two…
What other bullying material can you possibly exhaust from your appallingly impoverished vocabulary? I won’t be shutting up for you, nor should anyone. Chimp.
Whatever Dave.
Agree chunks
It’s really not Dani’s fault that she actually can string a sentence together in a way that is informative and entertaining when compared to the others, and is favored by post production. Dani can not choose how much she is included in each episode! She has also proved that she is a creative and talented cook, unlike say Sun, who lucked out by being in every winning team challenge except one therefore skipping eliminations. Dani has cooked in 6 so far. I would suggest that she is way better then 95% of amateur cooks out there. I think a lot of people out there are jealous of her package (looks, personality, talent) and are threatened by her success and wonderful future I’m sure she will have. Give Dani a break, if it’s Masterchef your upset with because of inconsistencies, leave Dani out of it as none of this is her fault. And I happen to love her hair and style, at least she has some!
Its getting a bit hot in the kitchen today but just popped in to say Callum is now running Asian Master Classes in Melbourne for Intrepid, the travel co, – funny, I dont recall that skill set……maybe Poh wasnt available or Julie’s Chow mein wouldnt work without Chicken Noodle soup mix
Guess he’s probably doing sweet and sour fondants
@Pollywaffle Perhaps the connection is that you’d have to be an intrepid adventurer to eat the food… They might be going for an “if you survive this, you can survive anything!” slogan.
Intrepid bolt for the toilet after sampling the burnt custard.
I do find it strange having Callum cooking Asian meals. Shouldn’t they get Alvin (maybe he is working full time now) or Adam? The only thing he cooked well was a curry that he learned from Jimmy.
Dani has ‘looks, personality and talent?’ Too funny. Someone needs to visit Mr. Optometrist.
Callum’s from the Barossa Valley , heavy German/European influence. Maggie Beer territory. It surprises me too that Callum is doing this.
The proceeds from the Asian masterclasses go to the cancer council which Callum has been involved with since his Dad passed from cancer six years ago.
Ah, that makes sense then, davsimp. I’ve just checked and they are on this Saturday in Melbourne – only $10 for a 45 minute “mini-masterclass” with all proceeds going to the Cancer Council.
http://www.intrepidtravel.com/events
Paul, it’s not so much George who has expressed concern….
People know that when the quality of the product dips, there is a good chance that ratings in future seasons may suffer. Combine that with some of the senior staff being disappointed and yes, there is concern. Is it deep? Well, it’s deep enough for them to take more care with next season, I know that.
@Cynthia, in Sun’s defence, just lucking out on team challenges is not enough to completely avoid eliminations. There are the individual challenges too and Dani has gone into eliminations on the back of her own poor performances. Those times must have been hard for her since she couldn’t slag off team mates. In fact…she’s been pretty lucky with team challenges herself on occasions – she really messed up at the mines as vice-captain.
As for “looks, personality, talent”…looks is subjective and personally she doesn’t do much for me, personality I’ll give her but it’s an annoying one, and talent? I’m not sure she’s shown all that much aside from “inventing” a couple of things. And what is this theory that if you don’t like someone, it must mean you’re jealous? Can’t I just dislike them because they’re unlikeable? Or can’t I just be a misanthrope?
Paul, changes are not just made when ratings dip – by then it’s usually too late. They are also made before ratings dip, to maintain position. See when they changed things this year to not allow contestants to return.
The ratings this year were never in question. Believe what you will, but the producers are interested in Masterchef as a longer term juggernaut and they are already planning future seasons. They knew the ratings would be big this year (how could they not be?). Their goal was to increase them and ensure future success.
The producers are people with ambition. They want to create a product that exceeds every year in terms of ‘quality’. ‘More impressive challenges’, ‘all about the food’ etc. Like everyone, they crave praise for their hard work, and by and large they haven’t received it for this season. Does anyone care about the winner? Not really, but they care about the standard of the cooking, that’s for sure. To suggest that all they care about is the ratings today is simply untrue.
Hmm… if blue team doesn’t win tonight, we may have the shortest ever elimination episode tomorrow with 2 of the 3 in the red team having immunity pins
Edit: Wait, no, forgot that Ellie used her pin already (didn’t she only win it a couple of days ago?).
Anonymouse: They’ve only kept one immunity pin in play throughout the season, and when one is used, it’s practically assured that a new one is gonna be dissed out at the next immunity challenge. Thus more accusations of rigging/tampering.
dmc, tell us again how caring, wonderful and hard-working the producers are (about 4 times so far) – oh, and the kicker….that they’re more concerned about quality than ratings. Hilarious. So what’s your actual job description at mc?
DMC – I think it would help if you guys show the more human side of the contestants, such as letting them do some cooking for a non-profit cause of their choice. It works well for TC Masters and you get a feel of the personality of the chef by the charity they support. At the least, I guess people want to feel good about watching the show at least. Even after 60+ episodes, I don’t feel I know much about these contestants or even their cooking skills. It would be good to think about how to inject more of the story of the cooks into the show, rather than squeezing it in when they leave. My 2 cents.
I checked the definition for jumped the shark.
http://www.urbandictionary.com/iphone/#define?term=jump%20the%20shark
Rating is one think. Without a good show, rating will drop. Just because it has been good before doesn’t mean people will keep watching even when it is crap.
NOOO!!!!! red team won tonight…… OMG………..
Does anyone think that this season’s MC it is more and more formatted like an infomercial, but shown at prime time?
How many people watch Ma$terchef just to avoid being the untouchable jackass around the water cooler who didn’t see what happened to who the previous night?
Golden boy is so versatile. He serves raw and burnt fish on one plate.
tonight was an infommercial for Quantas First Clar$e
BDD – I was thinking about Masterchef, as someone was asking me what my favourite TV shows were. I said currently The Amazing Race Australia, and then I thought about it, with all its faults Masterchef is still one of the best particularly in relation to production values. Obviously I am getting recap fatigue so will be glad when it finishes, however the New York eps were great. The problem with this year as has been commented by a lot of people of this blog. There is no stand out or people you really feel emotional about. Hayden and Dani are probably the highest profile, but I can remember very few dishes any of the contestants have cooked both good and bad. Whereas in other seasons I have and can still do so. Maybe my brain is just going.
I must confess I did have first class envy last night.
Casper – I know you and BDD a big enough to look after yourselves but if you don’t like each other try and ignore each other, there are plenty of other people to engage with please.
RR – totally agree with your point and have no problem with doing that. How ever you should have really addressed that to both parties.
Casper – it should have read Casper and BDD
But the crux of it was ignore each other. And the other thing to any third parties that involve themselves on tiffs that occur now and then on the blog – stay out of it. As it is usually the third party that incurs my wrath.
Totally ridiculous show now – get back to the honesty of the previous two shows please, or is it too late! For me it is.
Omg take a chill pill guys its a fucking tv show! Wah Wah so Dani got her immunity pin easy… Gary defended the decision 2bring in Eamon cos his chocolate delice was the best dessert he’d had in the entire time of Masterchef. And also these are just amateur cooks & Masterchef as a whole thought it would be better this season to make it “fairer”. Obviously their fairness came a bit too late in the competition… But seriously none of us know who is pulling the strings with this puppet so why get so worked up??
nnat must work for MC, so glad to see so many think as I do, before reading this I thought I was alone, definitely it is a case of Danni speaks the most and shows more emotion so lets keep her on, and I cant even delve into the whole Eamon situation without wanting to lose my mind, **** this show and all their nonsene, who cares who wins now, it is all a sham
get the fuck over yourself no i don’t work for Masterchef i just dont know why some of u are taking it so far & losing ur bloody heads about it. Like i said, we don’t kno who’s runnin this shit so why carry on that Dani’s a whinger & Gary & George are playin favourites & blah blah blah this show’s so crap but im still watching it? EDITING might hav sumthin 2do with it??
Hey I was just thinking, after hearing Eamon’s name in the news today, is it possible he assumed he would be getting a recipe as well? Looking at the recipe, which calls for 1.3 L of thickened cream, I doubt he’d have made or eaten it that often in recent times if he was in training for the world champs.
I liked the previous Australian Masterchef series (even the junior..) but this one is terrible. Yes we know its all stage managed etc. but really this is too much. Its a cooking competition where this time, you don’t have to be able to cook, most of the good cooks have been sent home. Danni’s braying laugh and very irritating voice, along with Ellie the ‘idiot’ (thank god shes not a ‘student nurse’ while shes doing this, patients are safe for the time being). This is more of a fix than ever, the ‘idiot ‘ cries when she doesnt get her own way, the ‘horse’ prattles on and on. ‘Idiot’ uses her ‘fixed’ immunity pin, and Billy gets sent home for producing a fair copy of the dessert in the elimination challenge, when the other ‘woman’ gives them a plate of slop and gets to stay. The same woman got Peter sent home, he did 3 good dishes in the elimination and she scraped 1). The Danni ‘horse’ is so pathetic, she let down the team on the team challenge, used her ‘fixed’ immunity pin to get out of an earlier elimination challenge, and then got handed yet another. I started watching the series, then recorded it so I could fast forward, now I have stopped even recording it. Garys still great, George – well mmmm, I suspect he’s been told to exaggerate the hand gestures and bouncing etc. (he looks demented), the big guy who dresses worse than the rest of them (forget his name), what’s with the smiley face for the ‘horse’ and ‘idiot’, he finds something good to say everytime. The hugging – let ‘idiot’ and ‘horse’ cry, stop encourging them, its pathetic. Sorry about the rant, but I dont watch a lot of TV, so feel cheated by this sham. (I was watching this from the UK where its still ongoing)