Masterchef – the dish that changed your life
As RR noted in her post earlier today, the top 24 – having not had time to even set properly – underwent a change prior to getting into the Masterchef kitchen. Paul the RAAF pilot was “reassigned”, so the wildcard went to Alex. Matt Moran delivered the news to him in person, telling him that he was chosen because of his “enthusiasm and passion”, but to me it seems like swapping one WA contestant for another.
Preamble
The slightly-reconfigured 24 arrive at the Masterchef kitchen and we’re introduced to them, since we really didn’t see many of them at all last week. It feels like the first episode of the season all over again. The Vespa in front of the kitchen is now a big red motorbike, so Alex jumps onto it and pretends to RRRRRREV to remind me how much of a tosser I think he is. Welcome back, Lobes.
As the 24 wander around the Masterchef kitchen, Jay decides he wants to start cooking. He heads into the pantry, followed by a few others, and they choose some ingredients to start cooking. Nobody has noticed that the clock is ticking down, and why should they? It’s not as though this is really going to be “cook whatever you want” challenge, right?
Suddenly, the judges walk out onto the balcony (from the toilet, Callum suggested in a tweet during the show). Matt reminds the top 24 that they are, well, the top 24 and that they are the best amateur cooks in the country. And I thought they were going to stop such ridiculous hyperbole! Three days ago, Alex wasn’t even one of the top 24 cooks on Cockatoo Island.
The Challenge
George finally gets around to telling the 24 that they are to cook the dish that changed their life, and Hayden knows what he is going to cook straight away, and (more importantly) he even knows the story behind it. Gary tells them that there is no elimination today and my interest wanes immediately. Those who were already demonstrating their “passion” by cooking when the judges emerged will get 90 minutes. The rest will get 80 minutes.
George is “nervous” to hear that Alex is making another risotto, but since there’s nothing at stake, I’m not sure why. We hear the life-changing backstories from the competitors and family and travel dominate. At least, amongst those we see. Time is finally up and Matt tells the contestants that they have done fantastically well! Might as well turn off now, then. I like at least one disaster per episode.
Tasting (some of the) dishes
- Kate’s coffee cake “story is great”, says Gary [to summarise, she made it as a kid and pretended to be a TV chef while she did]. Prospective contestants, put away your knife sharpeners and start pinning down your narrative. Cooking competition? Next door, on your right.
- Alex’s risotto is too salty. Why is he there again? He got through to the top 50 on a risotto and hasn’t demonstrated to my satisfaction that he can cook anything else. Seems he can only occasionally cook a successful risotto, too.
- George loves Jay’s lamb and veg, which is just as well for Jay, who always seems on the verge of a complete loss of confidence.
- Chelsea’s salad is assessed as “delicious, good, great” and “one of the best dishes of the day so far”.
- I agree with Hayden that moules frites goes well with beer, but possibly not a Pure Blonde. The sponsor will obviously disagree. Matt says he’s “brought finesse to peasant food” and Gary is also a fan.
- Billy fails one of StratMatt’s rules when he admitted to Matt that he hasn’t cooked to the brief, rather has chosen the ingredient that changed his life. This is worthy of a fireball, but after the ad-break he recovers to explain that the pork belly that was named “dish of the day” in the desert island challenge was the dish that changed his life. This is a pretty good save as it reminds the judges of something they loved and takes the focus away from him fudging the brief.
- Michael’s black pudding ravioli was praised for it’s “aligance” (thanks, Zoe!) but George didn’t like the “borled” flavour.
- Dani’s bun cha is a hit, taking Matt back to the streets of Hanoi. She is justifiably happy.
The rest? Eh, who cares, we’re only down to the top 24. What, you want to see what the cello guy cooked or something?
The three top dishes belonged to Billy, Hayden and Kate. Hayden will cook off for immunity tomorrow and Alex will get to cheer from the balcony. Hopefully for the last time!
May 9, 2011 38 Comments
Masterchef Australia – Guest Post – Strategic Thoughts From Matt
Matt has again put his strategic thinking hat on and gives his take on how the game is being played.
Over to you Matt:
Second-time lucky Jay appears to have taken a few of my thoughts on Masterchef strategy to heart. However, like more than a few others on Masterchef, he discovered that you have to back up strategic nous with tactical action.
It’s why my first rule of Masterchef strategy is “Be Able To Cook”. It’s a cooking show, after all, and while strategy can put you in an optimum position (usually through actions which don’t involve cooking – picking teams/choosing an action such as the fishing challenge), it puts you in an optimum position TO COOK.
Last night was a good example. Jay followed Rule Three “Nice Judge, niiiice judge” – which states that you should seek to emulate your judges’ cooking skills whenever possible – not, I hasten to add, by fawning over them, like my favourite cougar, Rachel. Rearrrr!
Jay has been boning up (hey, it’s a cooking show) on Matt Moran, reading his awesome eponymous cookbook. Smart move – it won’t be the last Matt Moran dish in a challenge, and you can just bet that if you throw a few Matt Moran elements into an invention test or Mystery box, the big fella will notice, and it might tip a vote your way.
Also – if you’re going to invest six months of your life in the Masterchef house, you’d better treat it like a uni course and study. The opportunity cost alone demands this.
However Jay discovered that mere study isn’t enough. You have to remember as well. Strategically, I am a little divided on the wisdom of revealing he’d read the book. On the one hand, it made him look stupid for not remembering it. On the other, it demonstrates his seriousness about this competition to the judges. From an end-game perspective – and the smart competitors should already be planning their final-three speech to the judges – I like Jay’s move.
The actual cooking part was an interesting challenge, and I love the way there are a few new elements in this season, like the Amazing Race-style fishing detour challenge. Changing the game up means that Survivors, sorry, contestants, can’t completely rely on past seasons as a guide. I suspect next taste test, everyone will be trying hard to name basic ingredients first, just so they’ve got enough to cook with.
I actually thought the competitors were better off for NOT having a great amount of ingredients. That way you could keep it simple. Didn’t work for John though, although I suspect in the end it was his cooking skills that let him down. Props to the judges for eliminating him – the temptation would have been to keep John on board for the emotional factor. John, however, wanted to be treated like everyone else. Unfortunately for him, everyone else included Alex.
This was one of the rare times when Rule Two, “Winning Isn’t Everything” wasn’t important. Rule Two states that the important thing isn’t winning a challenge, it’s not losing, because losers are eliminated and winners start equal with second-last place the next night.
However with 24 contestants and 12 slots, merely “not losing” was never going to cut it. You simply had to cook really, really well.
From now on though, Rule Two should be paramount. Simply “not losing” for the next month or two will see you into the top 12 – where you can start thinking of the end game.
May 9, 2011 4 Comments
Masterchef Australia – Alex In The Top 24 As Paul Lombardi Pulls Out
Just when we thought Alex had been eliminated from the competition it looks like he is having a lazarus like return.
It appears Western Australian fighter pilot Paul Lombardi has withdrawn from the Masterchef Australia top 24 and has been replaced by Alex he of the earlobes and raw meatballs fame.
How do I know about this? A sharp eyed reader notice he was on the official masterchef website top 24 photos, and a quick look revealed Paul Lombardi was no longer there. Click on the link here to check it out – http://community.ten.com.au/community/masterchef/f/156/t/25762.aspx
I will contact Channel Ten to see if I can find out the reason, and ask why hottie Dan was not brought back in…
UPDATE: Channel Ten said watch it and find out, however I suspect as he was in the defence force this maybe the issue.
May 9, 2011 30 Comments
Fergie Now Doing A Reality TV Show

You knew it was inevitable, but Sarah Ferguson former wife of Prince Andrew, and mother of the worse dressed daughters at THAT wedding is now filming a reality TV show.
The show called Finding Sarah will air in the USA next month. No news whether it will be shown here or what the premise of the show is. However there was filming done at a health retreat in Thailand earlier this year according to the Sunday Telegraph. To be honest I am not interested in seeing her have a colonic, or doing downward dog (yoga pose).
Quite frankly I think her doing a reality show downgrades the reputation of the genre.
I can think of a few story plot lines for her. How about how to spot an undercover reporter dressed up as an undercover middle eastern business man?
What do you think? Would you watch it?
For further information go to this site.
Source
May 9, 2011 6 Comments
Dancing With The Stars – Vote For Brynne
Due to a dreadfully badly sleeping child last night I am still trying to watch Dancing With The Stars.
However I was lucky enough to get up to Brynne Edelsten’s fantastic routine. Please vote for her as I have not laughed so much in ages, and seriously not at her.
Also loved the way she gave Arsen a tickle up when he said to her in rehearsals to think of someone to get her feeling the sexy vibe and suggested Brad Pitt etc.
And she turned to him and said “I think of my husband”. He then said well imagine he is looking into your eyes… and she responded “Oh he won’t be looking there.”
TV gold.
According to TV Tonight, twitter erupted when Sonia Kruger made a rude remark to her in the Green Room after the routine.
TV Tonight wrote:
But it began trending after comments Kruger made to her when hosting in the Green Room segment of the show.
Never shy of a cheeky remark, Kruger said, “I think it’s nice you get on so well with your dad.” With her husband Geoffrey Edelsten sitting in the audience, it triggered a wave of Twitter comments.
Mikkijr: Sonia Kruger shame on you. Speaking to Brynne that way. You should apologise and should be sacked #dwts
ralphbuttigieg: I did think that some of the comments about Brynne on DWTS were unnecessary sexist and rude.
purcelltweet: Twitter gave Ch7 the msg that #DWTS viewers were horrified. who does @SoniaKruger think she is?
Kruger later admitted it was a “brain freeze” and Tweeted: I do love Brynne! She is much fun and we all wish her fun on this show xx
She apologised on air to Brynne Edelsten, presenting her with a flower.
Also the Daily Telegraph allege her husband Geoffrey had something to say to the judges after they savaged her routine.
The only other routine I saw was Damien Leith’s.
I am still not convinced about Damien Leith being a great Dancing With The Stars contestant, I am still trying to repressed that disco song he did on Australian Idol where he bounced around the set like a jack rabbit.
I was a bit disturbed by his hip swivels and not in a good way. However, he and his cha cha received good reviews. Helen thought he had good foot work and she clearly likes him. But she is smack bang in the middle in his voting demographic, particularly now he has released a Roy Orbison tribute album.
I did not even get to see Manu Feildel or Lara Bingle, I understand both were quite good. Will Manu’s female fans cope with the thought of his hips swivelling from side to side rather then back and..ahem ok I don’t need to spell it for you.
Your thoughts on the show?
May 9, 2011 23 Comments


