Masterchef Australia – Adriano Zumbo Is A Sadist
If there is such a thing as a nice sadist then Adriano Zumbo is one of them. Or is he just a good looking version of Dr Evil? Once he realises he is on Masterchef Australia for a pressure test, in the final’s week, does he just dream up the hardest combinations that are going to send the contestant’s completely over the edge. I thought at one stage we were going to see Claire curled up in the foetal position when she was in difficulty with tempering her chocolate.
I know we whinge about the show being rigged or not rigged, or whether it is a game show or a cooking show, or whether the best cook should win. But with Alvin being eliminated it means there is only one personality left in the house and that is Adam. The rest are all pretty charisma free.
Tonight the remaining six contestants had to recreate Zumbo’s V8 cake, which was an eight layer vanilla cake. Apparently he made it for Margaret Fulton’s 85th birthday celebrations.
By the way I liked Zumbo on the panel and on the kitchen floor I thought he was relaxed and straight forward, however I wish he had not been quite so helpful, as Jimmy would have chucked out half his brulee layer. It was a killer challenge with four hours of prep and cooking and some of them still did not complete all the elements.
Highlights from the kitchen:
- Jimmy accidentally pinching Adam’s macaroon layer, but it would have been more hilarious if it had been Callum considering he used the wrong lobster last night.
- Alvin’s assembling of the dish, his water gel layer was not set and his dacquious broke, he was having a shocker, but props for keeping his sense of humour;
- Jimmy using the wrong cake tin and piping the cream down the sides of the cake. Jimmy will never get a sponsorship of handee wipes as he work station is such a mess.
- Zumbo telling Callum he had flipped his cake the wrong way, hopefully Callum when gets his engineering degree this won’t happen on his work sites.
- Courtney’s cake looking fabulous until she decided to pick it up with her hands, the normally together Courtney was in tears.
- Adam getting some great editing and a lot of air time, but then he and Alvin are the only two left that spark up on camera.
Adam was first to serve and Zumbo said “I wouldn’t be disappointed if someone served it to me”. However Adam forgot the ganache.
Alvin’s cake looked a bit more ragged and was criticised for having ”no definition between the layers” by Gary Mehigan.
Interesting to know that like the rest of Australia the judges also think Jimmy is a one dimensional cook. I think Gary was so shocked that he actually plated up something half decent that I think he judged him from a lower base then the others.
However Matt Preston concurred and said “Flavours are all there”.
Callum’s cake was seeping due to the water jelly being at the bottom, and Gary thought it was more like fudge cake.
Claire’s cake did not have chocolate, also the ganache is missing, but the layers looked snappy. Zumbo said what she did have was spot on.
Courtney’s car crash cake looked good at one end and was wonky the other side. Gary did not think the flavour hit the mark.
I found it ironic that two of the bottom three, Alvin and Courtney, had had the supposed advantage of the recipe the night before. And Callum was the first one to be made safe. Gary said ”You survived because you had all the elements on the plate”. He then gave him an Obi Wan Kenobi mantra by saying “Be on your guard”.
Unfortunately Alvin was eliminated, and after he finishes romping on his king sized bed (well he has been filming for 8 months) he might open an asian tapas bar, but in the meantime he has just launched his food website Cinnamon Pig.
The winner was Jimmy who Matt reckons is hitting his stride at this point of the competition. And he will continue his advantage by getting to pick the ingredients to be used in tomorrow night’s challenge, and you guessed it is going to be spicy.


-->
104 comments
Nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo…
That V8 cake looked AMAZING! Bummer Alvin is gone, the tallest midget is getting shorter by the day.
Thought the chocolate lab was a goner with his presentation … who will be next? Not Adam, pleeeeeease!?
I know you aren’t a fan of Callum’s, but surely you’ve got to admit the way Gary speaks to him and treats him is borderline disgusting. He snaps at him, patronisies him and condescends him on a regular basis. Telling him to leave them in peace, insulting the way he cooked at various points and then to put him in the bottom 3 when Claire didn’t even do the drops, chocolate or outside! I love Claire, don’t get me wrong but I hate the fact that George & Matt have to constantly calm Gary down about Callum. I understand he’ll win over Gary’s (And maybe yours
) dead body but at least treat the poor kid with respect since he gives it to them, he’s been doing it for weeks now!
Agree, Laura! Nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!
And congrats to Alvin for not using the that most over-used of words in the reality TV world – “journey”. We will miss you Alvin.
and speaking of George – where was he? Did I miss something?
The highlight fr ne was Alvin’s statement about having a romp in his ed and the others’ reactions to this. Just superb, bless him.
I think Jimmy’s delight at being the puppetmaster tomorrow and his piece to camera about exploiting his advantage and “the fun starts” adds weight to Matt’s theory that he is the best strategist of those remaining (see his post about the challenge that saw Marion ousted). Nice work Matt.
Not sure where George was tonight but I would be miffed were I a contestant and he judge if the past months suddenly went MIA at this stage.
I have refrained from commenting about Claire thus far for a few reasons but I am well over her repetitive first reaction “there’s no way I can do it” followed by a simpering self deprecation to the judges ending with a disingenuous “moi? did I really get through?” look at the end. Bah! Chuck her out.
And finally- thankyou RR for this great forum and timely posts. I see you were uncredited again in The Age when it was stated that elements of The Apprentice had been appropriated by MC (your on camera opinion of a week ago). Poor form, methinks.
Most perceptive line – Jimmy saying he wasn’t the best cook in the competition. Too right.
Well, the best cook won and I for one -snort- bwahahahahahahaha. Sorry, couldn’t finish that with a straight face.
There will be an unimaginable manure-storm if Jimmy did win this competition – I hope for his sake that he doesn’t, because he would face the kind of flak that would make last year’s winner seem like it got universal approval in comparison.
Also, my spidey-sense makes me guess that his comments about ‘I’ll be a laughing stock if I screw this Mystery Box up’ were done in the pre-cooking interview, not at the end.
George was probably away at the soccer, I mean ‘consulting’ to his Mykonos restaurant about sourcing olives from his Mums plantation. Maybe he will shout Alvin an apprenticeship there?
Donna Hay was to judge alongside the panel tonight but apparently threw a tanty when they refused to match the cake to her dress – wrong shade of white
Callum over Alvin?
Noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo
Say it isn’t so. As happy as I am for Alvin and his opportunity to romp in his bed (gotta love him), I am going to miss him. My selection from day one, I now switch allegiance to Adam.
That Zumbo creation looked stunning. Would love to have a taste. The man himself is pretty cool too.
Zumbo looks like the crazy scientist from the Simpsons.
I hope for gods sake that Adam wins.
If Claire wins, TV is going to be swimming in interviews with the winner of Masterchef and embedded within is going to be an endless pool of her droning, monotone voice. Sorry to be so harsh but ergh!
Also, may as well mention here one thing which I heard in an interview with Adam today – he says that for the house cooking they pick the ingredients they want from a list and Coles supply them – this could explain how Callum got his hands on pheasant to practice cooking for the signature dish challenge a few days ago and how he didn’t know how much they cost (I know pheasant wouldn’t be a normal Coles ingredient – maybe they’d supply it in some of the more upmarket suburbs. But Adam didn’t specify whether Coles only supplied what they normally had in supermarkets, or whether they went further afield to supply food).
Adam was pretty humble in the interview – he said he finished school so early (15) because he started when he was 4, not because he was a genius.
I am backing Callum now that my two fave’s (Marion & Alvin) are eliminated. He is the best rising star and a Jamie Oliver apprentice. Jimmy has impressed and is now the two dimensional chef. Paul: If you were a real bookmaker your arse would be twitching now…
if Adrian Zumbo ever decides to stop cooking, he could get a job as a mime.
Is everyone else actually getting ads during the shows. the crawl for Greens Cake mix is running over the top of the contestants cooking, and is driving me crazy. I really hope this is not the future of TV advertising.
The cake did look pretty good – I’d like a piece too. Except the water jelly – it sounds pretty awful, but the rest looked good. The recipe must have hidden the ganache layer – why else would several of them have forgotten a relatively easy layer.
That smug look on Jimmy’s face…I just want to smack him one.
HOLY MOLY!!! 8 months have they been there? Ultimately is it really worth it in the end? It makes the whole contestants coming back in even more unfair because they actually get to go back home after so long…Sorry I can’t get over it but it irks me that a cook of Jimmy’s calibre (I don’t for one second believe that Jimmy being able to make a cake makes him a 2 dimensional cook because HE COOKS CURRY AGAIN! Can he actually cook anything else that he thinks up himself? And do it well?) stays over some of the much better eliminated contestants.
I honestly don’t think next MS they should have the eliminated contestants come back so late in the competition, or else make it so that only one person gets to come back because it means rejuvenated contestants that have had time to hone their skills and relax are allowed another chance.
I felt kinda bad for Callum, if he actually didn’t listen to Adriano Zumbo and tried to fix it there and then, he might have actually come out with a better outcome. I don’t know what it might have ended up like but his cake making process seemed to be going so well other than that one mistake. If that comment he made about stuffing one thing up will stuff up the rest was made in the post-show interview, it makes a lot of sense.
The more time gets spent on Jimmy the more me and my mum dislike him. He seems so up himself now and smug and how I wish he will FALL ON HIS FACE! FALL JIMMY FALL! But he won’t. Because he’s making curry. Wooh. I hope Adam or even Callum makes something inventive to win this challenge. And I hope the judges see how one dimensional Jimmy still is to eliminate him. ARGH! WHY IS JIMMY THERE?
Poor poor Alvin…I really found him so funny and he was one of my fave contestants to watch and listen to (his cooking was too good and bad so he wasn’t one of my top faves)…Too bad this was a dessert challenge. Anyone found his website?
I noticed how they get handed their cake before they actually do that walk to the Judges – bet Jimmy’s was replaced with another. :\
I think Courtney is a personality, ’cause she will at least tell the Gs off for the things they do, rather than just bow down and pander to their every need. :p
Adam should have won. Claire… ehhh. Neither way, really.
Callum and Jimmy? pfffft. Both hopeless.
The first two (Courtney/Adam) I would buy their cookbook and perhaps make a trip to try their food. The third (Claire)… might borrow from the library.
Those last two? Hell no. No, no, no, no, no. No. Nonononono.
At least Alvin could cook and was slightly funny.
Callum could blow his nose in a tissue (and it would probably be someone else’s tissue he used – oh sorry, did you wnat it back?) and serve it up and he’d still not be evicted. I am getting a horrible feeling come ten pm Sunday night we will be watching Callum’s winning cookbook title being announced: Some cakes and stuff I thought up that don’t require basic stuff like creaming butter and sugar. Basically filo layers with lots of cream and fruit. Enjoy!
I’d almost rather Jimmy won at this point.
Recipe is out on the MC website. Anyone game to try? Initially I thought I will give it a go (but I am a chocoholic and vanilla cake doesn’t tempt me). After looking at the recipe I think I will just buy a piece (if Zumbo sell them) from his shop.
Agree with comment 1 nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo (Alvin out and Jimmy still in)
Hope some of the things over on the spoiler thread can’t be true(great thread btw) /2010/06/15/spoiler-thread-masterchef-australia/
And agree-Gary talks to Callum like a kid-not that I like the fact Callum is still in there(or care about the stoopid program) but yeah thinks he takes some pleasure in making him blink/sweat etc
Zumbo sells them petal but join the q if history repeats after the bouche and macs
Zumbo will be laughing to the bank. Hubby will not have the patience to queue for some cake !!!
Comment 18-yes would love to see that(Jimmys getting a slap – his smug face makes me ill) And RR popped a link to Alvins(bless his heart) site above http://cinnamonpig.com.au/?page_id=286
Great article Reality Raver. Did you actually mean to write “tampering’ her chocolate? Chocolate is tempered not tampered unless the chef is awful!
Seepi-we are getting those Greens scroll bars as well with some code word for a radio station we have never heard of.
Agree that Jimmy comes across as unbearably smug to camera. Hope he gets eliminated tomorrow but what are the chances of that?
Sad to see Alvin go.
Think that necklace is Courtney’s lucky charm as she sees always seems to wear it at elimination.
I guess titanium dioxide is the ‘in’ ingredient this year.
http://www.theage.com.au/entertainment/tv-and-radio/alvin-creamed-by-cake-of-death-20100719-10hne.html
Anon-Yes I use titanium dioxide everyday !!! In my sunblock.
It takes 13 years to finish school, (kindergarten- year12) so Adam taking only 11 means he is pretty smart.
Well, I’m just quoting what he said (in regards to finishing school early) – he completely downplayed it in the interview. Kindergarten’s not compulsory in some states (or at least wasn’t when Adam was a kid), by the way
AnonyMousse – So he could have started Year 1 at the age of 4? That’s impressive!
Yeah, that’s how I interpreted it Fides – that he started Year 1 (not prep or pre-school) at age 4.
I am so sick of everyone gushing over Adriano Zumbo!
He doesn’t have particular charisma, he is inarticulate, and he is a total sadist. PLUS: I cannot see why everyone thinks his ‘creations’ are so amazing! the macaroon tower was just macaroons, stuck on foam. more craft than cooking. flavours… hmm, olive macaroons?
and his cakes! i thought the mousse cake from last year looked like roadkill, and the vanilla cake just looked weird. water jelly in a cake? it’s just hard technical stuff for the sake of it.
how stupid. and the fact that it eliminates the better cooks, like Alvin, based on some obscure dessert skills that are more luck than anything else, and lets people like Jimmy control the finals week with his ridiculous curry crap, fgaflghhalfghalg;! i’m so frustrated!
Errr, not that it would have made a difference to who was eliminated in the end: but Claire’s cake didn’t have two ingredients – including the hardest: the tempered chocolate – yet she is in the top 3 without a word? Give me a break.
I am picking Adam to win at this point (along with most of you). My pick from Day 1 was Aaron btw as I’ve always believed this year’s winner would be a male.
There were three Asians in the final 6: Adam, Alvin and Jimmy. All male. Asians represent 8 – 10% of the Australian population. What are the chances of three in the final? Jigged, you ‘betcha.
Adam will is clearly smart, presentable, an OK cook by all accounts (but far from a brilliant one), and his Asian style of cooking is a great contrast to Julie’s Aussie homestyle.
Claire is really getting bitchy isn’t she? Her true self is coming out the last few days. She is just so BEIGE and yes, her monotone whiney voice GRATES.
I suspect though she makes it to the final three: Adam, Claire and ether Jimmy or Callum.I’m looking for Courtney to go next.
Great SPOILERS thread for those who want to engage in some spoiler theories. Fides now has a great method of picking the winners. Check it out if you are so inclined!
PS: absolutely loved and cracked up when Alvin made the comment about romping around in his King Sized bed. I reckon this was his way of getting a little dig in at the producers who have been pretty good but probably cautious about talking too much or too explicitly about contestants in same-sex relationships.
Should have picked the winner of this challenge when Zumbo was in the media a few weeks back saying Jimmy was his top picks of the bunch… and everyone was like whaaaat??
Capsicle, re Adriano Zumbo’s creations. As I read earlier this week, we (at home) are judging the food purely on it’s visual aspect (and the comments made by the judging) whereas food is normally judged by our own taste and smell.
I take it from your comments that you have never tried any of his creations, otherwise I think you would know how amazing they are.
Awwww, thanks CG! Getting totally confused by it now, but with lots of other people’s input, it looks like we’ve determined two of the final three.
AnonyMousse : Adam’s birthday is in September, so that would still make him a young 4 to have started school if it was Kindy, let alone to jump straight into Year 1. Still must be a smart cookie to have been accelerated somewhere along the line, despite what he says.
And are all the remaining finalists all over the radio this week? I don’t listen much, but last night on my way home from work, I apparently missed Callum on Sydney radio. The radio station was giving his DNA (saliva from a brussel sprout) away as a prize…
“Be on your guard, Callum. It’s getting harder to protect you when you plate crap like that.” — Gary.
Jimmy and Callum for the final! The sleazy grin versus the blank look. Whose cuisine will reign supreme?
Oh and random thought – Jimmy stealing Adam’s macaron tray thinking it was his is quite inspired. From what I saw, Adam had neatly piped the macaron layer in lines back and forth, Jimmy we see just smearing it across the tray with a spoon.
And apart from squashing the bottom layers, would Callum’s upside down cake really taste different? LOL I was telling the judges (not shouting, mind you, but loud enough) to solve the problem with their spoons rather than stare at it thinking “Oh this is so wrong, the flavours are upside down!”. Idiots.
Sooty – I’ve got the same horrible feeling as you about the 10pm Sun announcement of Callum’s book title. I think it was CG that was speculating at one stage that there were probably focus groups out there sizing up Gollum (as another RR blogee has now christened him?) for this gig. Anyway, at least, I’ll be smiling if I can ever track down Paul to collect on those 16:1 odds he was offering last Fri on Gollum.
Didn’t one of those umpteen gossip magazines on the MC contestants actually suggest that Adam was super bright, which is probably a disadvantage for MC as the three Amigos could well fancy themselves in this category as well.
Great comments guys, I will respond later, work is just a little bit crazy.
Agree if Jimmy wins, Julie Goodwin will look like a three star michelin chef.
pluck a,
If you want to collect you need to deposit first. Thats the way it works !!!!
As for focus groups busily beavering away determining the winner – LOL.
Like it makes a lot of difference to the people that matter who the winner is.
Dakota, Gary might be tougher on Callum then he is on others, but if Callum was to go to a commercial kitchen as an apprentice he would be treated a lot harsher.
Callum keeps on making dumb mistakes week after week. hell he didn’t learn that butter has to be soft before it’s used. Same mistake two weeks in a row.
With the V8 cake he didn’t learn the recipe and his cake was an upside down V8 cake.
The list goes on. He should have been out weeks ago
In Alvin’s exit article in news.com this morning, his post MC plans are described as “realistic” and he fans flames of Neil Perry’s comments saying any MC contestant that thinks they can start up a restaruant right away are “delusional”.
from today’s article:
“Realistic about his food future, Quah is working towards a new website, where he will feature his own recipes, family favourites and restaurant reviews.
Fanning the flaming comments by top chef Neil Perry, Quah said he thought anyone leaving the show expecting to start a restaurant straight-up was “delusional.” ”
Love, love Alvin! Too bad a gay Asian winner was a step too far for MC.
This was actually the first episode I’ve watched since about four weeks ago, since I was on a Eurotrip and didn’t really feel an immediate need to watch the series when I came back last week. First thing I noticed was how much weight Callum has put on. Wow, he’s quite the porker now!
Disappointed that Alvin left, but in all honesty I knew he wouldn’t make it to the end. The MasterChef producers wouldn’t dare allow a homosexual Asian to win the series.
I’m nonchalant about all the remaining contestants. I’m silently rooting for Callum as it’d be an unexpected twist and I predicted that he would win at the start of the series, but, really, so long as it’s not Adam (tool) or Jimmy (obvious reasons), I don’t care. Have any of you actually delved into the depths of Adam’s twitter? If you did, you’d all most definitely change your sunny views of him very quickly. Some of his old tweets are borderline creepy.
Strategy thoughts:
And Jimmy is about to redeem himself! After stuffing up (strategically, not with his cooking, for once) on the crustacean challenge by saying they’d been following Courtney’s lead, Jimmy’s about to get a massive strategic advantage.
And thank the gods it’s gone to the only MC player with some sort of strategic nouse. Imagine if Claire or Callum had won and picked some bland Frenchy dessert-style mystery box.
The look on Jimmy’s face was priceless – he knows the strategic implications of getting to pick the ingredients, and he’s going to use that advantage mercilessly.
Expect some Rajasthani curdled goat milk curry or some such. It’ll be the monkey’s eyeball scene from Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom all over again. I agree with one of the earlier posts, that Jimmy’s apparent shakes in the preview are a pre-cooking piece-to-camera. They’ve pulled this trick before.
In terms of cooking strategy, Jimmy was (fairly) spot on. Apart from the pan mix up, he managed to get all the steps done, to a reasonable level. And with a Zumbo challenge, your strategy has to be (more so than ever) keep it simple and don’t stuff up. Because you know there’ll be a few others who do, so simple avioids elimination. I don’t think Jimmy (and let’s stick with the meme of him being an inept one-trick pony) actually won, so much as everyone else stuffed up.
Whee he did go wrong (sort of) strategy wise is forgetting to ask himself “WWERD? – What Would Evil Russell Do?”. And Evil Russell wouldn’t have owned up to stealing Adam’s ingredients. No way, in the bin with them.
On this theme, CG pointed out that I was wrong on Callum pinching the lobster as strategy, arguing that It was simply Callum being his usual stumblebum self. I agree – my thoughts re Callum were in the vein of wishful thinking. Just remember – WWERD!
Where Jimmy did shine strategically last night was by actually reading (and understanding) the recipe. I mean, three of them had it overnight – they should have had it all but memorised by the time they got to the challenge, and rehearsed the critical steps. This is where you pull the all-nighter, practising the recipe when everyone else has gone to bed.
Jimmy seemed to have at least a passing understanding, while Courtney and Alvin (especially) clearly didn’t.
And did anyone else notice that the other two top three were lawyers, who’ve had years of practice reading a difficult brief and understanding it in detail?
From a game strategy perspective, I’m glad Alvin went home. I disliked his play from the start, when he and Skye appeared to have this little “cool kids” club in the house. That’s fine and all, but he didn’t use it to his advantage by forming an alliance against the stronger cooks. Weak as.
And can I say again – HE HAD THE RECIPE! No excuse.
Looking forward to tonight’s Elephant testicles in a vindaloo jus.
If Jimmy’s smart he’ll be rehearsing and studying beforehand.
Too bad his dish was the worst for the night and he got eliminated accordingly.
However I’m sure that Alvin would love it if his sexuality and nationality was used to keep him in the competition longer at the expense of others whose dishes were better.
“Alvin, your dish was the worst tonight. But because we must be seen not to be discriminatory – we are now going to discriminate by keeping you in the competition. So you’re safe.
Sorry, Courtney, piss off. Oh, you’re a lesbian. Okay you’re safe too.
Hmm, lets pick someone out. Callum, you will do. See you son. Yes, I know your dessert was better but you see we can’t be perceived as being discriminatory. I know, it doesn’t make sense that we are now singling you out but life’s unfair so suck it up and move on.”
Muru – It’s funny I know Callum’s piled it on, but must say I hadn’t noticed as it’s seemed so gradual.
I’ve looked at Adam’s tweets – sure there are a few odd/out there ones, but overall I find them quirky. Anyone who has Michael J Fox/Back to the Future weekends is OK with me.
CG : yeah – good on Alvin for keepin’ it real. He’s a sweetheart. And yay, how refreshing to see no sauce range from him.
Fides @ 43 – Yes, there was quite the physical contrast between Jimmy’s tray and Adam’s. On one hand I find it amusing, because I always wonder why we don’t see more pilfering shenanigans when they share freezers, etc, but on the other hand it just gives me more reason to despise him!
Matt-you are soo right about Jimmy: its all about strategy wih him. Certainly not his cooking-sure his family are rubbing their hands together regards the sales his appearance/win on MC is/will generate for the family sauce business(and his book will help won’t it Paul).
Anonymous,
Anyone who thinks you can be a millionaire selling sauce bottles is dreaming. Actually anyone who thinks they can run a business selling sauces is supremely optimistic.
There is a reason why the market is dominated by the big conglomorates such as Heinz and Campbells. Its a low margin business and only they are capable of mass producing and selling enough to turn a profit.
Anyway, I won’t let facts get in the way of a good story so carry on.
http://www.theage.com.au/entertainment/tv-and-radio/masterchef-recap-deluded-jimmy-wins-the-day-20100720-10i80.html?autostart=1
http://www.theage.com.au/polls/entertainment/tv-and-radio/masterchefs-jimmy-wins-the-day/20100720-10i8u.html
Wow Jimmy looks hot hahah
Paul (at 46) – where do I deposit the money?
Will have to tell Mr Patak that ah? Who lets Paul out of his box? Put the morsels out and he comes for the bait. btw apparently Australia has its own occy and it reckins Gillard will win. Just need to get him onto MC. Alvin and Geo were on The Circle tiday-I like Alvins shirts…he was wearing his orange patterned one today.
Anonymous,
Pataks are the worlds largest Indian brand for sauces and Indian breads.
It was recently valued at just under 400 million US dollars.
Hardly a Mom & Pop operation.
Paul I have better things to do-please go away and don’t spoil the last week of MC for the readers of RRs blog. Bye
Sorry anonymous,
I have no place contradicting some of the ‘statements’ made in the comments section. How dare someone disagree?
Pataks a small company – LOL – some of you are hysterical.
pluck a,
I’m still waiting to get paid from all the punters who backed Marion & Jono !!!!!
Enough with the slamming of commenters please. RR asked all commenters to pull their heads in last weekend.
As soon as Paul reappears with comments that he is entitled to make he is slammed.
Zumbo should have been on the mass debate after mc . However I doubt that his 97 layer cake (with a trace element of vanilla) would have changed the result (ie food is not better than sex) He’s not a sadist, just a mass debater!
Calamity’s upside down salt lick deserved to see him leave. what a travesty this show has become. It should have been on the debate as well. …Arguing for the negative, ie as proof that food chefed up by mc judges and contestants is not better than sex.
Hooray. one in the eye for the food snob, curry haters. HO HO would love to see a Courtney- Jimmy grand final
Good on you Paul
even though I dont agree with much of what you say.
I hope Jimmy picks some way out ingredients and I would love to see the contestants forced to use ALL of the ingredients. That’s what should have happened before.
Jimmy, just dont pick sugar as an ingredient, that’ll screw the ickle pritty dessert makers like callum
I think I heard in the preview that they have to make two courses, so maybe some dessert items have to be included.
Thanks pinto and Sour,
Thought it was time for a bit of spring cleaning.
Cmon CG
Fess up. either u r “anonymous” or you have a ghost writer
Suzanne @ 69, I think you’re right, an article I read said that they need to make two dishes using 12 ingredients. Mind you, I think it was in the Herald Sun, which isn’t exactly a bastion of journalistic excellence, so I don’t know if it’s accurate or not.
I saw a good comment attached to one of The Age articles on last nights episode. (Not my comment by the way)
Basically, it said that one of the good things about Masterchef is that it doesn’t pigeon hole contestants according to nationality, sexuality etc.
They are all presented as normal people (which they are of course) with no emphasis on stereotyping. I really think we as a country have grown up as when a television show as popular as Masterchef can do this knowing that the consequences are basically zero.
They are just people who like to cook.
go jimmy!!!!!!!!!!!! great to see alvin go ,he ran out of relatives who cook desserts . how funny was it when jimmy’s reaction , when the penny dropped that he will supplying the ingredients for the mystery challenge, GOLD!!!. callums upside down cake was the best put together cake all they had to do was to turn it upside down again . who cares about the water jelly, it’s bloody made of water!!!! as for claire missing 2 layers not putting any chocolate around it but ends up top 3 are you kidding me , callum’s crapped all over hers . ah the power of a girl’s smile !!! bloody dumbo zumbo and his silly cakes , stupid challenge who has the time to make a bloody v8 (4hours) and it takes bloody 10 minutes to eat it give me a break , just let them make something we all can make and send dumbo zumbo back to the shed to create a cure for cancer or something worthwhile NICK OFF . i ‘d love jimbo bimbo to win just to make this series look utterly silly . GO JIMMY !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1
Anonymous – Paul has just as much right to comment on the blog as anyone else. He is just voicing his opinion about whether there is money to made in sauces. Out of all of them I think Marion will be the one who will make the $$$, but she is being backed by Coles. Actually getting your product stocked in a supermarket can be a huge hurdle for any producer to overcome.
BTW Sour – Anonymous is NOT CG. CG usually comments under her non-de-plume. Also she ‘fesses up when she does it under anon (accidentally). To be honest she has commented for so long, I know her writing style as well.
BTW Pinot and Sourk thanks for moderating. Appreciate it.
OUR PAPER today said that Callum will be on Junior Masterchef! (This was in a rambly opinion piece though, and mentioned in passing, but I hadn’t heard that.)
That could make it worth their while to keep him around thru the finals, he could come third or second, and then pop into junior mastechef as a judge or mentor or something. I don’t normally subscribe to the conspiracy theories, but I can see this would be a nice flow on for them.
Also the junior masterchefs can be up to 17 – I had pictured little kids for some reason.
Matt – loved your post! In particular, the thought that the three top recipe-followers were the two lawyers and Jimmy put a smile on my face. I wonder if that same advantage works for Jimmy also? Alvin had a career in science as well, I think (pharmaceuticals? I could be wrong), but it seems like Jimmy’s pretty accustomed to laboratory work specifically, where he’d presumably have to follow detailed lists of instructions on a very regular basis too. It gives the game another dimension I hadn’t considered.
Matt
how do you explain Jimmy’s failing to put the cake in the right tin and then having to stuff icing down the sides strategy?
LOL when fat Matt said how controlled Jimmy looked this time. it was a effin’ shambles when Zumbo passed by.
Adam’s cake looked fine except fro missing one layer. He should have won, if they were judging it by cooking.
Just another saucy word – the late Paul Newman came up with his range and gave all the profits to charity off memory?
Seepi – nice conspiracy theory – what paper did you see the related story in? Equally, did not realise that Junior MCers could be as old as 16 or 17 until today when there was something similar on one of the websites.
RR: Thanks for clarifying I am NOT “Anonymous”.
If I have something to say, I’ll say it. I saw Paul’s bullying comments but respected RR’s directions the other day to not attack other posters or to derail threads and the blog.
When I read the comments I knew someone would make that accusation. That is what Paul intended no doubt. IP addressses will also prove that we are all different posters from different locations.
Why is it so surprising that others are annoyed by Paul? Sadly, he drove Airwalk and a few others away from the board. The minute he comes back after several days absence problems start up again!
Sour: Really sorry that you would jump to conclusions,make the insinuation you did and support a poster who has a history of bullying and bringing down this otherwise wonderful forum.
Comment #76: Wonderful attempt at covering up your true character and being politically correct. You have spent all season making derogatory and snide comments about Courtney because she is a lesbian. Using terms like “bats for the other side” or some such tasteless labels. You are as f*cking transparent as Zumbo’s water gel. Go on, start talking about some Masterchef UK contestants to soften your virtual persona, generate some friendly comments and fluff up your image for new readers who are coming here during MC’s final week.
correction for above reference: comment #76 is really referring to #73
Mr Swinger (and how my skin crawls trying to think of how you came up with that name
) – Not sure how to explain Jimmy stuffing it in the wrong tin, although that was the only mistake he made, compared to everyone else, who made a few more.
Anyway, it wouldn’t be Masterchef without Jimmy cheerfully stuffing up.
And for all those who think the show’s rigged, how’s this for a conspiracy theory – if you wanted to pick one contestant to select the mystery box ingredients, one contestant who would create a fiendish challenge that would cause Claire to break down (not hard, admittedly), Callum to sweat and blink (ok, that’s fairly easy too), and be just as likely to completely stuff it up himself, in the process creating excellent TV – well, you’d pick Jimmy, wouldn’t you.
Just sayin’.
Anyway, it wouldn’t be Masterchef without Jimmy cheerfully stuffing up.”
that’s Callum, Matt, who stuffs up. Jimmy wasn’t even around for weeks and weeks.
sure you’ve got the right MC?
Once again people are out in force trying to degrade one commenter over another.
This is to neither one nor the other, but seriously? Those types of comments brings down the mood of the board and makes me just want to not visit anymore.
Ya’ll are driving people away.
Just now caught up on last night’s recorded episode barely in time for tonight’s. Glad other people besides me thought it was grossly unfair that Claire just ditched the whole tempered chocolate aspect of the challenge and skated in, when it was arguably one of the most difficult and time-consuming aspects of the challenge (and one, I might add, that Alvin did well).
I thought this challenge was really absurd: no one except a pastry chef is ever going to make a cake like this, or need the techniques it entails, so I thought it was totally unrealistic and a stupid basis for an elimination at this point.
Finally, I’m very surprised no one here mentioned Matt Preston’s shoes, which to me were probably the most memorable aspect of the evening’s show :->
Can I just clarify one thing.
I have never, ever, ever made a deragatory comment about Courtney.
NEVER.
In fact I don’t think I’ve ever made a deragotory comment about any of the contestants. I’m almost positive that I haven’t. Its not my style.
And I’m happy for every post of mine to be dredged up and examined.
By all means have a go at something I’ve posted but to make stuff up is frankly pathetic.
AniMotek: yeah it must have come down to the taste aye? Alvin was one of the contestants who tempered the chocolate and got kicked out. I agree its a ridiculous challenge as well-only pastry chefs would require the skills but it makes good tv i expect(and makes good business for Zumbo) Considering the success of US progs like Cake Boss etc maybe Zumbo will next do ‘Cake of Pain’ reality cake shop series?
Yeah and I agree the music intro and shot of Matts boots was one thing that stuck out in the intro for me and the person who wrote the story for The Age today ‘The camera catches Matt’s cowskin boots, there’s a little drum roll. It’s like a Western.’
CG – To be fair to Paul, he did not drive Airwalk away from the blog.
Both of you have strong opinions and you write them, all are welcome but as I have said before please don’t direct them at each other. Kaylen has a point.
I think a lot of commenters, including myself have had strong opinions about contestants and voiced them which could be construed in many ways but in the majority of cases they are hopefully meant to be inoffensive.
Also I would appreciate it if people did not swear at people on the blog.
Did someone try to say “derogatory’?
(Matt – not that it matters very much, but you attributed someone else’s comments to my screen name. I’m actually… a Jimmy fan *ducks*)
CG
I apologise. The sentiments uttered by anonymous were similar to yours. I guess many people feel that way BUT und ziss isss a big BUTT. I don’t think Paul has ever Bullied anyone on his posts. I suppose you could take his comments the wrong way but he has in MHO never bullied anyone. If he did I would jump on my noble white steed and commit horrors upon him as I CANT STAND BULLIES.
I like reading his opinions which are generally totally contrary to mine, but sew wot?
Matt – your strategy post was hilarious and suspect Claire would have preferred to be cooking with elephant testicles than lentils
Matt
HOW DARE YOU CRITICISE “frenchy desserts”????? Schlock horror and ghasps of utter disbelief!
#87 – NEVER?
Ok – so what is this:
Paul { 07.08.10 at 12:43 pm }
Pity that Courtney bats for the other team.
Anyone – including RR – can go back and check this post by you on 8 July. I am not – as you assert – making this up.
You have made at least two and possibly more derogatory references to Courtney’s sexuality. And Sour has called you out on these disgusting comment each time.
Pathetic? Indeed.
RR: It is your blog and I agree everyone should be free to come and comment. But I really fail to understand why you allow this guy to continue to come here with the objective of stirring things up, insulting and attacking other posters, creating a negative and hostile environtment and lying and falsely attributing statements to others / denying statements he has made in the past.
Absoloutly hilarious.
Maybe you should post the comments preceding it to see how that comment was used in context. It’s hardly derogatory anyway. I’m sure Courtney wouldn’t mind that description.
Wasn’t it you that called Claire a ‘whore’?
Now that is deragatory…….
You said “never”. A quick check of the facts proves otherwise (again). Then we get more excuses (again). Hilarious.
And as you fashion yourself as some sort of intellectual and clearly consider yourself smarter than the rest of us on virtually every subject that comes up, please figure out how to spell derogatory. Brilliant.
Since when is saying ‘bats for the other team/side’ derogatory ?
Are you serious ?
And I note that you did not repost the preceding comments for the context in which it was said.
It went along the lines of :
Poster A : The soldiers were flapping their eyelids at Courtney.
Me : That would be fruitless. She bats for the other team.
Yes – terrible stuff right there. I’d better contact my lawyer for the impending slander lawsuit.
Anything else that you can come up with.
Gold star for correct spelling of derogatory!! Finally!! Yeah!!
Apologies to RR and blog readers for going off on this tangent with Paul. I just couldn’t sit back again and let this guy get away with more attacks and half-truths.
I’m done. But go ahead, get the last word in Paul like you always do.
Expect something Doh!rogatory….
Ah – so that would be nothing else then.
Whats a bit of slander between friends hey CG – accuse people of being homophobes and then back off like a coward when it gets a bit hot for you. “oh RR, he’s picking on me”
I’ll give you a tip – don’t hand out accusations if you’ve got nothing to back yourself up with. I will keep making you look like an idiot all day long if I have to as I won’t have my name dragged through the mud.
Now back into your box – Claire’s still in the competition. Maybe you can think of some stuff to say about her. Certainly hasn’t bothered you on the past and unlike me she can’t answer back.
Probably a bit easier target for you.
hi cg check this link out
http://news.ninemsn.com.au/entertainment/7932754/masterchefs-claire-likes-control-courtney
adriano zumbo is the sexiest, most talented, most creative, beautiful, humble and gorgeous chef to ever walk through the doors at MS…all u haters on this blog shouldn’t be too jealous…
Leave a Comment