Masterchef Australia – Well My Definition of Master is Completely Different To Theirs…
This is just getting ridiculous now. To have one of the best cooks eliminated from the competition is an aberration but to have two go before final’s week indicates Fremantle and Channel Ten don’t know how to run a cooking competition.
With Jonathan Daddia’s elimination we now have a top seven where approxiamately 50% of them are pretty poor cooks.
Jonathan’s dish probably was the worse of the night, if the editing of the comments are correct, but wouldn’t you think the judges would think the overcooked liver was the greater sin just to get the weaker cook out. Seriously Padma Lakshmi, Tom Collichio and Gail Simmons need to be brought in from Top Chef to kick these three amigo’s butts. They always ensure the best make it to the finals. After that it can go a little crazy. Which is a bit how I am feeling at the moment.
Tonight Christine Mansfield was the special guest judge, with the Jonathan, Courtney, and Jimmy having to cook Squab, with Cabbage Roll and Turnip Cake. It was a complex dish, with 55 ingredients, and just about as many steps in the cooking process.
The peanut gallery appeared to be calling out to Jimmy and Courtney to help with the recipe and burning pots, but Jono was a lone wolf. And I think that is how he likes it. I have written this before but I actually don’t think the peanut gallery should be allowed to call out assistance. If this was the case Courtney’s turnip cake would have been smoked, because the pan ran out of water.
On the plus side Courtney gave one of the few highlights of the episode when she got sassy with George when he was questioning her lack of measuring the ingredients. “I have been cooking for ten years, I know what a teaspoon is”, and George then gave her the death stare and walked away.
Jonathan did make a fatal mistake when he cut the breasts off the squab prior to deep frying it. And as we had been told at the beginning of the challenge this was the most important part of the dish.
Also his stock was “astringent”. The only downside of Courtney and Jimmy’s dishes was the overcooked liver. It was at this point I knew Johnathan was not going to be there for much longer.
The judges did look upset. Something Claire didn’t when she was talking to camera once she knew he was gone. She must know she now has a real shot at taking out the title, murky private life or not.
But maybe they might have to change the title of the show, if Aaron, Callum or Jimmy win because none of them are worthy of the title Master. Even Julie Goodwin showed much more consistency then these three.
Oh and props to the script writer who wrote the line that managed to get Gary say the words Paramount and Universal in the one sentence, which are the names of Christine Mansfield’s restaurants.
UPDATE: Quotes from Jonathan from the press release:
“I’m now planning on what I do next and assessing the options, whether it’s following my dream and opening a little French bistro or potentially a nice small wine bar that sells good food and wine.
“I’m not sure what the future holds but I’ll definitely be working in the food industry in the coming years.”
And for a bloke who seems to have polarised viewers, he has a message: “To everyone that loved and hated me, thanks for their support and I hope in some way I’ve stimulated their palates and excited them with some of the food I’ve cooked.”




104 comments
I’m going to miss Jonathon! He’s been a favourite of mine from the start. I agree that the other contestants shouldn’t be able to help their favourites. It doesn’t really give everyone a level playing field.
The Eliminator has been ousted by the One-Note Wonder and the Bartender. Oy vey.
Devastated. I loved Jono, flaws and all.
He adores cooking, you can tell.
Only Adam left now who can pull it off. At this rate he’ll be gone on Thursday….
Jono walked into Christines Minefield, no point squabbling about it….now leaves the battle of the A-team vs the C-team, and one J (walker)
And now the conspiracy theorist can start their ruminations … a con, a rig, a sham, a ruse, follow the money trail… Here come the theories in great detail and consideration. How I love the comments left here, just remember to play nice commenters- with the shock elimination of Jonno RR will be in therapy tomorrow rather than writing her posting protocol and I want to hear everyone’s point of view.
Nooooooo!
Say it isn’t so.
Ah me.
I guess Jimmy is Ok at cooking with a recipe. And courtney is looking very good.
For once the editing faked me out – I thought George would be saying courtney’s broth was far too salty, due to the lack of an exact teaspoon.
He was smug, an IT geek, a prat, but by GOD he could cook, especially under pressure. He deserved to finish ahead of Jimmy & Aaron (aka dumb & dumber). I would definitely go to Jono’s French bistro for a meal.
Christine Mansfield keep on emphasizing about following the recipe to a T and to follow the timing to the T as she has cooked hundreds of them and it is always right.
Courtney didn’t do any of those things and she said yeah, follow your instinct. Does this mean her recipe is not perfect??? and did Courtney actually got it right?
Waste of time when the judges said that the dishes are all quite good and need to ask the contestants about their commitment. Jimmy gave a dud answer and they still kept him in the competition.
This show is a joke. I want Jimmy to win now !!!!!
GeelongDeano- Have a read here (from the Heradsun) He is not a smug.
ELIMINATED contestant Jonathan Daddia has roasted MasterChef for giving him a bad image.
Daddia claims that the way he came across to viewers on the hit TV show was partly cooked up in the editing suite.
Daddia was widely perceived as the least likeable of the MasterChef contestants.
The 33-year-old IT consultant was booted off the Channel 10 reality show after serving up a less-than-spectacular version of celebrity chef Christine Mansfield’s spice-roasted squab pigeon dish.
“You only see certain sides of people on the show, but it is what it is,” Daddia said.
“The funny thing has been meeting people who talk to me then say ‘you’re not what I expected – you’re nice’.”
Daddia said his public standing took a tumble in April, after a beef wellington pressure test when his comments to camera were cut.
Start of sidebar. Skip to end of sidebar.
End of sidebar. Return to start of sidebar.
“What went to air was me describing my dish as ‘bloody brilliant’ but what I actually said was ‘it’s bloody brilliant it worked out’.
“I then went on to give them (the judges) five reasons why it wasn’t right, but none of that made the final cut.”
Daddia had been accused of cockiness by Matt Preston.
“I might show confidence on the outside but I’m not really like that on the inside,” Daddia said.
Last year’s MasterChef “bad boy” Chris Badenoch accused the show of editing out any shots of him smiling.
Daddia, who was tripped up attempting advanced recipes, admits that his “advice” to other contestants may have been seen as showing off.
“For me, it was about sharing as much knowledge as I had, but perhaps that got people offside. Maybe I need to learn how to sugar-coat my answers,” he said.
In Monday night’s challenge, Daddia’s ninth elimination round, things went downhill when he failed to read the recipe properly and cut the squab breast to cook separately instead of cooking the whole bird together.
“I was never cocky, you just can’t afford it,” he said.
I was half-expecting Jono to be eliminated before finals, due to an interview Aaron gave on the radio after the Marion elimination where he referred to Jono in the past tense – it could have been me misinterpreting grammar at the time so so I didn’t mention it as a possibility in a spoiler thread, but it did make me think Jono could be in trouble.
Shame. I’ll miss those crazy eyes. His departure means there’s not really much in the way of interesting personality left in the people remaining. Aaron’s pretty much the only non-vanilla personality left. Adam and Alvin have their occasional moments, I guess, but Claire, Courtney and Callum all bore me.
Waaaaaaaaiiiiiittttttttttt a second….. 3 As and 3 Cs (and a J) left? If Jimmy goes on Thursday, I think the real conspiracy of Masterchef has been revealed!
Having said that, only the signature dish challenge is left, and from all reports Jimmy cooks a mean curry so he’s got a good chance of getting through that (oh hell, dont tell me he does make it all the way to the final 2 or 3 and that’s why Zumbo nominated him due to inside knowledge or something…).
I’m with you Littlepetal. Jimmy to win! Even better Callum!
There was no way Courtney was going. That would leave only one woman.
Reality Raver, Claire looked shocked as hell when Jono didn’t come down the stairs! And there was no trace of smirking in her piece to camera, so I think you’re letting your dislike of her colour your impartiality as a recapper.
Say what you like about Claire’s cooking, but I don’t think arrogant or smug are words you can apply to her at all. She’s never crowed about anyone leaving or talked herself up – if anything, she’s way too hard on herself to the point of it being annoying. She’s been growing on me a lot in the last few weeks, though. I hope she gets to the final two, although by the looks of the commercial for tomorrow night, she crashes and burns. Of course, that probably means she wins. Which is fine with me.
There’s been a lot of Claire hate on here, but I honestly can’t see why. She might not be the most exciting person in the world, but she’s never been horrible like Jono has, or cocky and show-offy like Aaron. Jimmy’s just a joke, Callum’s a kid who doesn’t listen. Courtney, Adam, Alvin and Claire for the final four, please! I don’t mind if Adam or Claire win. They’re both solid enough performers, and seem like smart and decent people. Maybe neither of them will set the world on fire with excitement, but I’ll take nice over a flash in the pan anyday.
ah i can see it now, jimmy is the winner , he brings out the famous masterchef winners cookbook . curry chicken noodle soup, followed by a curry beef wellington with a lovely curry side sauce and finish the night off wait , wait , a curry!!!! pavlova . callum is the runner up he brings out the dessert cookbook because we all know he has a gift with deserts , square jelly with a runny ice cream , rectangular and round lamingtons ah! the list is endless . i loved last years series everyone cooked excellent meals this year what the!. i could not believe that george did not berate courtney for the way she spoke to him and not to mention her cooking style at the table he jib out that mr tippy toes .well i’m off to bed now to think about callum’s and jimmy’s curry mousse yummy . tata kingfisher
Damn it…I liked Jon. And ‘Come on’ #12 I don’t think Jono has been horrible etc(as Herald Sun says its all in the edit). But agree with you regards Jimmy and Callum-and Aaron.
I also agree with RR, Top Chef most certainly judge their chefs (who are chefs) based on not only their dish but appear to take overall performance into account. Bet Jono wanted to curry Jimmy and debone Courtney especially since they had been home and returned while he has been fighting through the weeks challenge after challenge without his new wife(although his love in with Heston must have made up for that).
Well ho hum…sad to see J go(not as much as Marion of course, but in all reality it doesn’t really matter who wins as last years result showed:which as many have already elaborated on this topic I will not regurgitate it again)-now lets see if they will crown Australia’s best Amata cook-Jimmy, Callum or Aaron(I like Claire, Courtney, Adam and Alvin although don’t think ANY of them are great cooks).I wish they ould just make it a 100% reality show and stick them in the house for three months and have them cook challenges each night and ply them with alcohol(with an R rated up late show). Lets not pretend its about cooking ANY LONGER.
And you go girl Courtney-tell George to F Off: its about time. And of course Christine was not going to tell Courtney off-we look after our own
And the music seemed extra dramatic tonight.
Now I think I want to go get a Pho and a stuffed chicken wing for dinner as no Squab etc round here.
Thanks RR…RIP MC and thank god its almost over
Come On – I don’t think I implied it was a negative thing that Claire was smiling to camera. if I was on the show I would have been doing cartwheels with Two of my biggest competitors out in 5 days. With some pretty average contestant’s left in – $100,000.
Not sure what you mean about not liking Claire because of her colour.
The ONLY reason I am not a huge fan of hers is she is a tad bland on camera. Best was when she went up against Adam Melonas.
Little Petal – Agree Jimmy to win, but I will probably feel differently in a few days. Thanks for Herald Sun article
Why is Aaron doing radio interview if he has not been eliminated???
RR maybe Come on means her hair colour-are you an anti Ranga?
RR are you taking the piss re: Jimmy to win? You don’t want him to win do you?
Jimmy’s too good for reality television. He was being honest saying he didn’t know if he had what it takes to win the alleged competition. You could knock me over with a squab feather to hear that.
I want Jimmy to win now. He’s keeping it real.
good question littlepetal
Jonathan back on twitter
“Finally my gag has been removed! Thank you to everyone for all your support and good wishes. I look forward to sharing my food thoughts.”
Jono is twittering:
1. Finally my gag has been removed! Thank you to everyone for all your support and good wishes. I look forward to sharing my food thoughts. 3 minutes ago via web
Oops crabtech-we thinks alike over here in the West :p
And the Telegraph:
http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/entertainment/masterchef-ratings-still-smoking-hot/story-e6frewyr-1225890688728
FIRST saint Marion Grasby, now sinner Jonathan Daddia has finally fallen from favour on MasterChef, exiting the competition tonight.
And despite threats to boycott the progam after Grasby’s shock chop last week, the sizzling show increased its ratings to 1.84 million viewers on Sunday night – 101,000 people up on the same time last week.
Wow the articles get online really quickly don’t they?
http://www.arnnet.com.au/article/350884/daddia_dumped_from_masterchef_/?
JONATHAN WAS MY FAVOURITE!!
As much as I love him, I think the judges need to be fair and I’m glad that Jonathan went when he deserved to go. I would have hated for one of the other two to leave when Jonathan’s dish didn’t deliver…
He will be missed! I really wanted him to be in the final 2
littlepetal – Random Masterchef contestants sometimes phone in to various radio stations for quick interviews on the day after episodes, so it doesn’t mean the person being interviewed is eliminated. It’s just a normal PR exercise.
RR, I meant I thought you were letting your Claire dislike “colour” your writing! Not that you dislike *her* colour. LOL. I don’t even know how you’d describe her colour. Slightly pinkish?
I guess I don’t see her as bland. She seems reserved, but I don’t mind that. She seems dignified, which is more than you can say for most people on reality TV.
Well, now Masterchef has officially turned into a joke. There is no way that they can honestly stand up at the end and say that the best chef has won, considering 2 of the best chefs have been eliminated. The funniest part is, the producers have totally shot themselves in the foot in that they know have virtually no chance of ending up with a winner who is marketable enough and has a broad enough appeal to sell lots of cookbooks. I’ll run down my thoughts of the remaining contestants and their chances-
Jimmy- His cookbook will be all curries, of course. All very well, but is it a broad enough concept to mass market? It feels to me like more of a niche cookbook. Plus I just find him irritating and I don’t think he deserves to be there.
Callum- Probably a desserts cookbook. His concept would be more appealing, but is he marketable as a personality? He is quite young so I’m not sure how many of the middle-aged/older ladies out there would trust him enough to buy his cookbook.
Aaron- Pasta and mexican, again not a very broad appeal. As a personality, not very marketable. He is too rough. He may manage to get a niche TV show, as hinted in newspaper/magazine articles.
Alvin/Adam- Quite similar at the moment to me. Adam appears to have a broader appeal but they are both Asian-influenced so it will be tricky to separate them if they both reach finals. They need to be differentiated. Their overall concepts come across as very similar.
So that brings us to the girls.
Claire- By far the best cook left. But marketing-wise, she is a PR nightmare due to all of the bad press early on and her overall blandness.
Courtney- Might have a chance. She seems to be coming into her own since coming back. She could do alright, marketing-wise. She’s pretty, outgoing and friendly. Not sure what her concept is though. Her lack of ‘identity’ could be her downfall.
Just my thoughts. What do you guys think?
Seems we do Hine
What would really be interesting is to find out what the to 20 fom 2009 are doing now. We know about Poh and Julie and Julia and Joshua.
But what about all the others? Andre, Trevor, Tom, Sam, Sandra?
I think 09 Aaron gave up his apprenticeship at the Pess Club.
Was the time they gave up to be in the house worth it? Did it change their life one year on.
I wonder if c10 will drag MC2010 out and do show on 2009 contestants ????
crabtech:
http://www.news.com.au/entertainment/television/masterchef-ausralia-09-where-are-they-now/story-e6frfmyi-1225876037436
or closer to home
/2010/06/06/masterchef-australia-season-1-where-are-they-now/
Very sad to see Johno go.
I’m barracking for Callum to win. Because that’s what the show deserves.
Past challenges have been set up to favour the better contestants (even if they still managed on occasion to stuff it up) – satay sauce for the Thai specialist etc. But J the french specialist gets a 50 ingredient asian style dish – too unfair.
And particularly excruciating to force them to do the ‘how much it matters’ speel and then completely ignore what they say.
Losing tow of your strongest contenders in the week before finals and leaving behind several who shouldn’t have made into thte top 24 just shows how badly designed the whole thing is.
Looking forward to trying J’s bistro or wine bar or whatever.
I knew jonno was going tonight. They’d shown their intent and wouldn’t keep him once Maid Marion was gone. Adam or Alvin will be next.
Not sure what they’ll do with the 2 wimmen, unless the editing suddenly allows for new depths to their blancmange, though Courtney looked promising personality-wise tonight. But little G. may pay her back for cutting him off (fear the Greeks, even their gifts).
I think Aaron will win cos Callum is too talented – even if he does stuff up half the time, the other half is potential on display.
Not sure where Jimmy fits – he doesn’t know either.
RR – what is going on with you? Off memory, the week before last you wanted it to be NOT Marion going and then a few days later she goes. Again, just a few days ago wasn’t it Jono that you wanted to be NOT going, and voila tonight Jono’s gone.
Who do you want to NOT go, one by one, here on in and then we’ll know who’s going to be in the finals/win this thing?
Oh, while you’re at it can to tell us what are NOT the winning numbers for next Saturday’s $20m Lotto, so we can all put our money on those. Thanks muchly.
Consider my gob soundly smacked.
*LOL kingfisher. You’re very funny!
Let’s face it, which one, out of the final people remaining can you see hosting a cooking show (like Poh) or appearing in cooking segments like Julie does on the Today Show? I didn’t want Julie to win and I still don’t think she’s a super talented cook BUT she seems like a nice/funny person. Will her “success” continue when her reign is over? If the rumours are true Aaron is probably “personable” enough to do a “rock and roll” cooking show, emphasis on the celebrity guest(s) perhaps… With Marion gone, to me it now comes down to…. Who do I want to see win the woefully inadequate prize (considering how much money the show generates)! Answer = Claire
Thank you Hine
“15 are now working in the food and hospitality industry in some capacity.”
I wonder how many will be in the industry from this year’s lot.
As to who will look good on a cookbook cover? Claire, or Adam are the most likely. They seem to be the better cooks especially in terms of cooking ideas. But this is not about the best cook but who “survives”.
Oh wellonly 10 more days to go.
Hey Liberty, I never really thought about it before, but it *is* woefully inadequate, isn’t it? I mean, Channel 10 makes tens of millions from this show. Hell, they make almost as much from one single commercial (70,000) as they give the winner. Cheapskates! Although I read some article today that suggests Marion will be worth a million pretty soon, and I suppose Julie’s done just as well with all her endorsements and stuff, so here’s where I stop feeling sorry for them.
Any fool thinking of appearing next season would do well to get eliminated around the middle to later weeks, before attempting a comeback.
Jono’s never been my favourite, but won’t deny he can cook better than most remaining, and I felt sorry that he was eliminated by the two returnees. If it had been any of the original top 7, it might be a little bit easier to take (though only just if Aaron or Callum beat him). He should have just been thrown in the towel at one of his previous 9 attempts, gone home, had a break, spent quality time with the wife, practised like crazy then tried again.
Contestants in the series two applications were told to expect filming to take approximately 22 weeks (after top 50) – October through till June with a break at Christmas/New Year. So no wonder the originals are looking jaded and making silly mistakes. In case anyone at this point cares, the link is below :
http://chefaustralia.blogspot.com/2009/08/rules-to-be-contestant-on-masterchef.html
Littlepetal : apparently Aaron was interviewed on radio because of backlash against him cooking a good satay sauce. Poor guy had to apologise publicly to Marion fans – I think it was brain dead dave who mentioned the radio interviews last Friday on another thread.
@pluck a duck: very funny! Now the psychic octopus is finally freed up, why don’t we ask him to pick the winner for us or has he gone into retirement or hiding from the Germans? It is really anyone’s game now.
Yeah we had this discussion on another thread(regards Paul being put in a tank to select a winner)…it seems Paul likes rancid fish curry so Jimmy may be a shoe in unless we can come up with a tender morsel to match up with another amata cook(they are not chefs guys) that may tempt Paul to choose them. Paul does have a good record-wonder if he could be contacted as MC is pretty big, he may be interested with WC over.
btw don’t forget to vote over ay ninemsn.com.au as they are asking if you believe Paul is psychic?(of course he is)
@Hine: I’m a definite believer! Good point re: rancid fish curry but do you really think Paul can be bribed? He stayed quite firm despite the Germans baying for his blood. MC is big but I don’t know if we can afford him now post World Cup. We should have secured his services before it started
I have voted at Ninemsn but it looks like we’re in the minority. Cynics!
Yeah I know-Paul is the oracle! Nah its not a bribe-as you need to put a tasty morsel in the box with the photo of the amata cook then Paul lifts the lid and makes his choice: I want a pet occy now
http://www.dlisted.com/node/37992
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/07/11/paul-the-octopus-makes-tw_n_640575.html
A few things that I have to vent out now … Thanks for taking the time to read the below:
1) Extremely devastated to see JONO getting the boot, bt we all kno he would soon be absorbed by one of the renowned chefs plus will get several interesting deals worth considering. Due to his sting on master chef, his IT firm would certainly start getting heaps of business. Not only him but his wife’s wedding planner business will reach heights too. Whatever it is, I want to send him my best wishes as it takes heaps of patience for someone to face those treacherous elimination tests , not just one but 9 .. far out. So yea, Good Luck Jono, you will be missed onthe show and hope to see u on TV soon.
2) My next Rant is about the celebrity chef in tonights elimination and the spiel she gave about how she is a perfectionist blah blah blah,, I agree with littlepetal on this too… how come then she liked what courtney splurted of her dish as courtney shamelessly admitted that she did not use perfect measurements from the recipe.. Either Christine whatever didnt know what to talk of her own repertoire or She reaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaallly liked what Courtney made and would have changed her funda to cooking by doing guess work … not happy.
3) This one is for all those who believe and have made a hateful( if ever there is such a word ) opinion about Jimmy and for all those ppl who think he only makes curry…My question to you is ,, why shouldnt he??????? Whats wrong with that,, especially when every one else in the competiion is also staying in their comfort zone.
Aaron – only cooks pasta whenever he gets a chance..
Adam and Alvin – have been cooking asian recipes since the beginning of the show 0 remember drunken bruised chicken?? was no invention of his but a common dish in chinese cuisine… and Adam with his dumplings every now and then.. ( although Adam does variate sometimes and I like him)
Coourtney – seems comfy making prawn, fennel related dishes most of the times and sticks to basics
Callum – only makes desserts…
So then why is only Jimmy accused of making curry all the time… I think its not fair.. He seems to be a decent cook and can certainly cook better than courtney and aaron/
Oh Yea how can I forget.. Peter and Phillip – greek touches everywhere… and how could I forget Claire.. she doesnt have any specialisation and she looks quite boring and plates boring food. She is there n the comp only cos she looks good.
anyways .. my rant is over.. Good Night Y all..
JONO YOU ROCK and we will MISS U.
Peace Out.
Jono agrees with many of us (news.com)
Daddia admitted his “advice” to other contestants might have been seen as showing off.
“For me, it was about sharing as much knowledge as I had, but perhaps that got people off-side,” he said.
While his technical skills kept him in the competition for this long, he revealed his palette was a little more simple: he scoffed chicken nuggets when off duty.
“The food we ate on set was always really rich, from roasts at lunch to the stuff we were cooking. You can’t eat like that all the time, so I ended up ordering nuggets for the [MasterChef] house.”
Daddia also agreed with the majority of viewers outraged by Grasby’s shock departure.
“I don’t want to seem disrespectful to the people that are left, but Marion’s the only cook with natural ability,” Daddia said.
Read more: http://www.news.com.au/entertainment/television/masterchef-evictee-jonathan-daddia-takes-swipe-at-hit-show/story-e6frfmyi-1225890955477#ixzz0tTqHrWmc
RACE to the BOTTOM.
This is getting silly and insulting to the viewers.
Clearly the judges and the producers got the feedback about favourtisim and rigging and are going out of their way to try and make a statement. Eliminating the two best cooks before we even get to the top-5 never mind top-3 is ridiculous.
And poor Jono. No Coles or other deals for him!! He is left to his own devices to start up his French bistro or wine bar. He was starting to get a more positive profile in recent weeks but his rehabilitation was cut short.
Rigged? You betcha!! But what the hell are the producers trying to achieve? If any of the non-cooks like Jimmy or Callum end up winning, MC will lose all crediblity and I would be shocked if any respectable “top chef” chooses to associate themsleves with the brand going forward. Claire is a bore and a whore and can’t imagine how they would package her if they allow her to win. I respect Courtney (more than Claire) but her personality won’t cut with the mainstream.
I can only imagine Adam or Alvin winning and at this point. Package them up as male-Poh’s, personable little Tetsuya-wannabes. They will have a shelf life of less than 12 months: even less than Julie G.
Other salient observations from tonights episode: loved Courtney giving George some lip and then Christine siding with George when he tried to dob her in during the tasting. And did anyone else notice Matt’s DANDRUF…yucko…so disgusting, why wouldn’t a stylist be on hand to wipe it away with a lint brush, esp during a taste test!!!
re post #44 : meant loved it when Christine Manfield sided with Courtney (not George) re measuring out ingredients and cooking based on ‘feel’. I’m sure this will come back and bite Courtney at some stage as Georgie does not like to be showed up!!
My son who is a cool 19 year old and myself a female at 54, both loved Jonathon. I am devasted he was eliminated, but not surprised, as I have observed some very manipulative decisions made by the judges. My son and I found he had a sense of humour. He came across to me as a really lovely,caring guy all along. It appears his fellow contestants seemed to be very fond of him too. I am surprised that some people over looked his great qualities. As he was an intelligent, articulate, poised guy with class, I think some misinterpreted this for all the dumb negative things I have read. I feel, people sometimes feels threatened by this. He actually had a very warm smile and eyes. I thought he used his eyes during eliminations in a humorous way not scary. I found Marion sickly sweet and she came across to me quietly up herself. Glad to see her eliminated. I think she thought she was pretty good, however I didn’t. I was certain that Jono stood a great chance to win. I cannot understand how Callum as sweet as he is, has slipped through and actually been the cause of two people being eliminated when he should”ve gone ages ago. The first case he cost Fiona”s position, second Jonathons in a sense following that army challenge. He was clearly the weakest link and ironically Jono one of the strongest contenders that day. As it was a group challenge rather than choosing the least impressive dish, the weakest team all went out costing some stronger contenders elimination challenges.Poor Jono had proven how tough he was during those gruelling eliminations. I agree, following that awkward non convincing
response from Jimmy tonight…why on earth was he chosen!
I suppose giving Courtney a go seems appealing as it would be
the barmaid that made it big which is fair. However, I am really angry that contestants that were clearly eliminated from the
show were invited back just to spice up the show more. I am angry that Jono who poured his heart into all was outdone
by return contestants, C and J. I agree, if Claire wins she is too
boring…Adam is lovely but too quiet.. I honestly have lost
interest now….Clever comments from CG above…I agree with your observations, well written! I agree it is now losing
credibility. I am disappointed. If Callum wins that would be a joke….I have nothing against the kid. I think they want an
underdog to win….Alvin I suppose is a contender, at least he is a personality…but not a darkhorse. I feel angry at times when I see the how the judges can manipulate their final decisions by playing up or down to any degree on certain aspects of the contestants dishes….they ultimately choose the winners. It is not always about the dishes served up as they say.
Having said that, I am fond of George and Matt, but I find the other judge cold and arrogant. I felt sorry for Callum when
he was stalked and harrassed whilst cooking a few times by that judge…it came across to me that he was deliberately trying to
throw him off. I’m not a bad cook, but could never function with that sort of pressure. I wonder if it bothers anyone like me
that I don’t seem to see anyone ever washing their hands during preparation etc. I was mortified when I saw everyones hands
all over the food at the camp. When I cook, I avoid using my
hands as much as possible and wash in between stages to avoid cross contamination. What happened to hygiene? I wouldn”t taste the food. I see people scratching heads etc. then touch the food…I do appreciate time is an issue. Sorry no paragraphing.
I do hope Jonathon fullfills his dream with cooking. I also think they get rid of people they think already have steady jobs, futures etc. so perhaps the two lawyers and Alvin will be next on the hit list. I truely looked forward each night watching Jonathon…he made the show more interesting….will miss him
and can”t believe he is not in the final! That is a joke. Thought the girls looked lovely in their photo shoot. Apologies for the random comments here and there. Jonathon if you read this,
I believe you are a genuine person….great qualities to have determination, confidence and to be competitive…in this tough world we live in, one needs it. By not being like this myself,
I gave away many great opportunaties that came my way.
My son and I had a real soft spot for that very real and funny sweet guy…Jake the cement guy….I find the band manager
funny, honest, hard on himself…I like him too…I like his quirkiness…Jimmy is nice, but what , a MasterChef who always cooks curries? I think Peter was probably the nicest guy on the show…adorable. Phillip was a gentle guy, very handsome….what’s wrong with few greek touches here and there…someone commented…..it were the greeks and italians that introduced tasty food here originally…thank god! for garlic!
…does anyone remember the traditional bland boiled vegetables and some type of meat with no herbs etc? I was lucky to be born here, but of ethnic background…My mum had a reputation for her wonderful cooking …she cooked everything ethnic and some of the lovely more traditional things like passionfruit sponges, pineapple upside cakes etc. etc.. (she was born here) I do love the humble lamb cutlet, mash and peas….however with some added herbs etc. I have been lucky to enjoy and appreciate the mix of the ethnic and some great aussie classics. Whilst it is interesting watching real Masterchefs present their upmarket food …( I hate all the drippy sauces supposedly adding to presentation… a messy turn off for me)……nothing beats my late mums tasty, real hearty and outstanding cooking…she was truely a Master Chef. .Less is more…wrapping chicken skin around fish….what the???yuk… Too much emphasis is placed on presenting food on a plate like art …(and I am an artist)…Too many wierdo
try hard combinations of ingredients. I do not find it enticing to eat a creative piece of food on a plate, portions for a sparrow, surrounded by messy drips and drops of sauces etc. Hence, I hardly go out for dinner and if I very seldom do I never go upmarket. My daughter always tells me…. you wouldn’t like it
there mum (upmarket places she goes due to the above)
Sorry, gone off on tangents….getting back to the show….at this point now I have no idea who will win…but I’m certain the judges know…(super long comment sorry)…I talk as much as I write.. …damn, now that Jonos gone, I don’t know now who to follow…..bye from me now…an annnoying mum
Reality Raver, is it honestly all right with you to have comments on your blog calling a contestant a whore???? CG, boring is one thing, but calling Claire a whore is WAY over the line. Where do you get off?
Disappointed Jono went. Back when the season started, I didn’t warm to him, but as the weeks went on (okay, when a friend said he reminded her of my partner!) I came to like him. Plus he seemed as though he could cook (and he has a a Heston crush).
Eh, I’d say it was “rigged” if we ever saw scores and things were blind-tasted. As it is, we get a spoken opinion of what a dish was like with no evaluative grade – gives the judges too much wriggle room to select the “winner”. I’m not sure what the aim of the baggy judging is – it certainly doesn’t seem to be activated to keep the “best” cook in the competition – but maybe that’s where this comes back to bite them. As viewers, we are completely in the judges hands throughout the comp when it comes to our perception of who the “best” is – we can’t taste the food and we see selective edits of someone being clumsy in the kitchen/in a moment of panic reading a recipe/seemingly breezing through a variety of processes. We allocate “best” to “worst” on that basis, and then have to deal with a judgement that seems completely at odds with the perception that has been created.
So, I guess I don’t think it’s “rigged” as such. Like Sourkraut, it’s a long con. A however-many-week advertisement for paper towels, manufactured stock, plastic cheese… exactly what the first “soap” operas were: programming designed to shift product. In fact, with the changeability from hero to villain, sweetheart to seductress, that’s exactly what MC is – a soapie.
Will watch at a remove from here (i.e. through this blog and people’s comments) since any mention of “straya’s best” anything is bound to raise my ire.
am I the only one becoming bored with this show ?
I agree that the ousting of Jono lowers the average cooking level again….
But at least he went out on a real cooking challenge and the others did a pretty good job of it. Unlike Marion and the 15 minute sauce.
I too am now watching at a bit of a distance.
Joanna, are you sure you’re not jonnos wife?
As an ex-neighbour of jonnos in lane cove I can now confirm that he isn’t a very nice man – arrogant, lazy, dismissive and highly unpopular in the block. Worse, he made no secret of his disdain for people with an asian (esp Indian background). Personality aside he was a terrific cook, and i think the comp quality will suffer now.
What’s with George at the mo? He’s been really narky lately, and I thought he was trying to stitch up court last nite … Glad Christine was honest about how well her dish turned out.
I think I’ll also skip the show and catch up thru this post – the heavy product placement and sad puns are getting to me!
I can’t remember her name, but the emotional lady from early in the season is now cooking with people with disabilities … What a lovely way to give back to the community.
I would eat at jonnos bistro, marions wine bar and aarons pasta rest. Not sure what Claire has planned but if it’s a small estab I would check it out. I think Jimmy will be a great curry-master! Feel a bit sorry for him at the mo, he’s trying to be diverse with not much success.
So looks like I’m up for a trip to Adelaide to test out Jono’s bistro / wine bar because he seems like a very passionate and inventive chef. I loved the way he was kind and generous with the other contestants.
Not so interested in the outcome now that the 2 large personalities have been alliminated.
Claire is a sweet shy little thing but not really a contender. Alvin is likely to end up as in-house chef to the stars in LA. Aaron … pasta joint in Leichhardt? Callum … Adrian Zumbo’s dish pig? Jimmy will be ok. Courtney … moves up to a yacht club? Adam to win?
Come On: I see you are a big fan of Claire’s!! You object to her beign called arrogant, smug, a whore and any criticism of her behaviour and abilities. I assume you either are Claire, are related to or know Claire or she is simply your favourite in this reality show “competition”. Fair enough!
For your edifiction, definitions of whore include: “A person considered as having compromised principles for personal gain”. and “A person who seeks that which is immoral, idolatrous, etc.” (Source: Collins English Dictionary). You will also know that the term “whore” is used widely in various slang expressions such as “attention whore”.
It was pointed out to me over the weekend by a solicitor that the legal industry newsletter known as “Firm Spy” published the details of Claire’s affair with her then-married colleague at Clayton Utz. They may or may not have been the original source of the story, I do not know.
This newsletter has been required to retract a number of stories over the years (after all, they are writing about lawyers and law firms). However, there was no call for or actual retraction of the story about Claire Winton Burn. Further, Clayton Utz (the firm Claire used to work for) moved quickly to remove her and her colleague’s details from all their public records.
This in my view and in the view of many in the legal profession, confirms the legitimacy of the story of Claire’s affair and the fact it was instigated while her lover was still married and with his family (these were part of the published details). Clearly, if the story as published had been false, Clayton Utz and Claire herself (and perhaps Ch10/Fremantle) would have insisted on a retraction. They did not.
Having an affair with a married man is, in my opinion, to compromise generally accepted principles of social, moral and professional conduct. Therefore, in my opinion, the label “whore” is an accurate one in this instance. I also think “whore” in the attention-seeking sense also applies to Claire. Her coy, helpless, bitchy (won’t have a drink with the returning contestants) persona is all intended to bring about a certain type of attention on herself.
Sad to see Jonathan go – I think he was one of the better cooks. I believe that some of the net hatred for him was because his geeky awkwardness came across as arrogance. A lot of IT people are socially inept and I think this hurt him in terms of TV presentation.
I can’t deny that his dish made the elimination deserved, but there was one point when Jimmy admitted that he wasn’t sure he deserved to be in the competition and wasn’t sure he wanted to be there that I thought the judges might use his bad tempura liver as an excuse to whack him instead. I have no idea why they do the whole interview thing before elimination whackings when, unlike MasterChef UK, they don’t actually take the contestant answers into account in making their decision.
On a side note, did anyone see the story on Today Tonight last night where some woman is claiming that Masterchef stole her idea of the Seven Deadly Sins. What an idiot.
Firstly, the concept of the Seven Deadly Sins is hardly an orginal concept, its been around for years. Its even been used as a challenge in a cooking show before, in Top Chef. And as for her whining about George ‘copying’ her pose on the couch for sloth, uh lying on a couch being fed is a pretty iconic representation of sloth.
And secondly, from the excerpts of her little webcast thingy, she’s ripped off most of her stuff from Masterchef. The name of her show is Mastercook and she holds Masterclasses, hang on that sounds awfully familiar.
She’s just some bitter idiot that can’t handle the fact that she was too crappy to make it on the show and now she’s trying to get her 15 mins by starting some stupid ‘scandal’. The lawyer in the story basically said that she hasn’t got a leg to stand on, legally. And I doubt she has enough ‘fans’ to put much of a dent in Masterchef’s ratings. She ‘s cashed in on the Masterchef concept with her crappy little webcast and now she has the nerve to accuse them of ‘stealing’ the Seven Deadly Sins. Thats just ridiculous.
CG – that’s my TV girlfriend you’re disrespecting!
‘come on’,
Don’t believe in freedom of speech of views contrary to your own, do you? if you want nice sanitized blogging that fits your personal view of how the world ought to be, why don’t you just ‘get off” yourself?
You’ve only just arrived at this blog but have wasted no time in getting stuck in to criticizing other contributors, even the blog owner, just because they don’t care for your favorites.
Well, I don’t care for yours, babe. Personally, I find your use of the words “horrible” and “cocky” highly offensive to describe two contestants.
Really, some people just don’t know where to draw the line!
QED, Matt! Claire’s little seduction act IS working its magic both in person and over the airwaves. I think you described her the other day as “smoking hot”. Personally, I don’t see what is so “hot” about the woman. Then again, I have seen her type before in real life and it seems to be a universal formula. What is it with the pale + woeful + listless + brains combination that turns guys on. I don’t get it!
CG, I am not Claire, nor do I know her or any of her friends. She is my favourite contestant, but that doesn’t make a difference in this particular case. If you’d called any of the contestants a whore, I would have said the same thing. It’s a bloody awful word with terrible connetations, and nobody deserves it.
As noted by a poster previously, the comments here are proving more fun than the actual show. What with ‘coloured’ contestants being called ‘whores’ and jonno’s mum leaving a 50-page character witness statement drawing our attention to his ‘warm’ eye gestures. And here I was thinking he just looked slightly deranged in a ‘One Flew Over The Cuckoos Nest’ bit-part actor kinda way. To quote a cartoon Zebra, “you guys are cra-a-azy!”.
Back to the even more superficial. Claire’s ‘colour’ would have to be categorised as ‘snow leopard’ – that is, pale white with spots. And good luck to her if indeed, as alleged here, she is a ‘whore’ – the more, the merrier says this little Boner.
Hey kingfisher, perhaps Callum can perfect a dessert I’ve always wanted to see ever since being read Charlie and the Chocolate Factory at primary school – square lollies that look ’round – or in this case ‘lamingtons that look round’.
While last night’s elimination was fair it does leave the cupboard pretty bare in terms of quality cooks.
Oh, Angel86, unfortunately I did see that very peculiar woman on TodayTonight. Whilst the whole thing was absurd, her claim that George stole her come-and-get-me-boys couch sprawling pose was effing hilarious. George at least kept his legs together.
@Hines: I want my own occhie too
@Aussiegal: I agree with with you in regards to Jimmy. I think it’s actually a clever long term marketing strategy to have a signature dish. He has a unique selling point and differentiated himself from the other contestants. I think his range of sauces will sell very well.
Oh, and why must every french eating establishment be referred to as a ‘little french bistro’.
FFS jonno. Be bold! Buck the convention and open a barnlike carvernous french bistro.
Was last night the first elimination Jono was in where he didn’t wear his pink shirt?
Injera-exactly!
you whore you
‘A however-many-week advertisement for paper towels, manufactured stock, plastic cheese… exactly what the first “soap” operas were: programming designed to shift product. In fact, with the changeability from hero to villain, sweetheart to seductress, that’s exactly what MC is – a soapie.’
And like the best soapies the viewer gets emotionally invested until it goes beyond ridiculous(ie. who shot JR). At work we used to talk about MC, now we don’t bother beyond: Did you watch MC? Yeah its a joke/crap and then move on to other topics. This is the only place I discuss it anymore but it is a. a joke b. crap c. a money making monster which will implode soon i hope (oh dear Julie Goodwin is on Today cooking beeef strog)
and CG think Jono went blue shirt for some elims
I will be responding to comments shortly, but just for the record I was on The Morning Show with Suzee the one who claims M/C stole her ideas.
I pointed out that the seven deadly sins challenge actually was more similar to season 2 Top Chef challenge, as are a lot of their challenges.
Go RR
cool will have to check out The Mornng Show. Is Suzee cwazy? Actually fell asleep during TT and woke up half way through Suzee’s piece-thought it was a joke
I wondered if that was you, RR!
Pity they did’t give you more airtime. Im sure you had a lot more of interest to say than her.
noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo Paul is retiring!!!!!!
http://www.dlisted.com/node/38005
RR-So now you are a TV star !!!!! Must try to catch you on TV.
@hine: it’s disappointing but good to end on a high!
@RR: congratulations on appearing on The Morning Show! Where do you find the time!
Hmmmm, I now wish the judges had asked Jimmy, “who deserves the be here, you or Jonathan?” Poor Jimmy is so honest no doubt he’d struggle with saying himself but had he said Jonathan, it may have saved Jono… then again, it all could have taken place and it was edited out otherwise Jono’s fans would be rioting.
Also, people have been saying Alvin and Adam cook similarly and there is little point of difference. Ok, both cook Asian, but just because what they cook can be eaten with chopsticks doesn’t make them the same at all. Adam has the edge I think because while his ethnicity is Chinese (though not sure if that means if his grandma mainly cooked Malaysian, HongKong Cantonese, Chinese/Taiwanese etc style food), he’s now an exponent of Japanese techniques and flavours and has both in his background. Japanese and Chinese food are very different! Alvin though, does focus much more on the Malaysian/South East Asian flavours ie hot, sour which Adam doesn’t focus on as much. Alvin is very good at packing big flavours, Adam perhaps not so much. Adam also can cook some non Asian dishes (not just dodgy koftas and 3course pizza, there are a few things on his blog) and I’ll always be impressed he could make bearnaise sauce (remember even Aaron couldn’t do that) but Alvin had never made mayonnaise before the schnitzel test.
Also Adam and Alvin’s cookbooks, while being Asian, would be quite different and their concepts for their restaurants are quite different as well.
So saying Alvin/Adam cook alike would be like Jono and Claire cooking alike. As Jono said last night – he is unfamiliar with the flavours he used last night, whereas Claire has cooked many dishes on the show with “Asian flavours” ( eg her chicken in Top 50, the quail for Qantas challenge, family meal challenge she worked alongside Adam and Alvin, Margaret Fulton challenge) . In fact, Claire, along with Courtney and perhaps Adam are the more versatile of remaining contestants. Jimmy the least. Alvin is at least adventurous and can pull it off his yumyucks with big, interesting flavours.
I think the editing of Claire crying and “in a world of pain” on the ad for tonight’s show is a curve ball. I predict chilli on fingers rubbing eyes or a burn / injury but not an emotional breakdown (more’s the pity – we haven’t had one for a while).
CG: Perhaps if Come On is Claire, you are the scorned wife of her lover? Now there is a conspiracy theory and could explain your vehemence.
And back to the food – was anyone else disturbed by the notion of a baby bird shackled to its coop and force fed so that its breasts are disproportionately large?
Wonder how the hordes of parents watching with the kiddies explained that concept? @MolksTvTalk summed it up on twitter when asking Coles if squab was to be available in the deli section or whether we should just follow the PETA picket line?
pinto: “@MolksTvTalk summed it up on twitter when asking Coles if squab was to be available in the deli section or whether we should just follow the PETA picket line?”
My favorite MasterChef/Coles comment on Twitter was a couple of weeks ago when someone asked whether the Coles deli counter was going to start featuring snails :->
nice one re. the squab, pinto
and Claire is almost permanently in a world of pain – what’s new? she really needs a Melonas injection every other day.
All of the contestants are whores -but Jimmy’s having second thoughts.
Gary,George and Matt are the pimps.
I can tell the difference between CG and Mel Gibson and wasn’t offended.
my ex used to call me a whore ( a “huurr” actually), as in “jesus, you’re a whore for the tea-drinkin’!” about my 10 cups a day habit. I can’t say I found it offensive.
Then there’s “bastard” – terribly offensive to the English, but (once) a common term of endearment for Aussie males.
Likewise “bloody”, which could be considered very rude still in some English-speaking countries. Remember the Bingle tourism campaign?
then there’s “come on” – is that COME on, or Come ON ? hmmm, curious screen name …. now that’s a double entendre if ever there was one.
Linguistic lesson over.
I do love the fact that Coles were advertising menu cards with “Alvin’s caramelised pork belly with chili vinegar”.
Or you can just buy the Longrain cookbook, which is where Alvin stole this one from.
What was the old joke about ‘come on Aussies’?
What could Lleyton Hewitt mean when he yells it?
Nice one b/d dave.
Lleyton has a lot to answer for.
http://www.perthnow.com.au/sport/tennis/aussie-tennis-ace-lleyton-hewitt-loses-battle-for-come-on-catchcry/story-e6frg273-1225890681905
Pluck a duck – LMAO, yes I am officially Masterchef douche. Therefore since I emphatically stated about 2 months ago on this blog that Claire would not win because of the murky articles on her private life, she will NOW win.
Come On – To be honest I am pretty neutral re: claire. I think now she is probably the best consistent cook left in the competition, however she hasn’t really done much on TV for me to make an emotional connection with her. But hell who knows a week is a long time in Masterchef and my two faves have just had their heads lopped faster then a royal during the French revolution.
Re: the whore comment I don’t think Claire is one. Yes I have blogged her personal life, but I don’t find it particularly salacious. But I blog on it because it brings reader’s to my blog. Claire Winton Burn is one of the highest searches for people hitting this site.
I have removed posts previously when reality contestants have emailed me and said they consider them offensive. I will do so again if this occurs. This has always been my blogs policy.
Pinto – LMAO – I wonder if CG is Claire’s ex, and Come on is Claire or Trevor….. I would be very surprised but weirder things have happened. Mmm I doubt if Kylie Kwong would cook squab if their growing conditions are like that.
Gillian who are you barracking for now?
Rusty – I think a lot of women would like a Melonas injection…btw you saw the show, not often I am the more rationale one appearing on those segments… I think she told some porky’s about the number of facebook followers she has. But maybe I misheard her.
Culinary Boner – LOL re: the George pose.
Brain Dead Dave – Isn’t Jimmy pimping out his curry sauces. Are they out yet? Or are they in the conceptual stage.
Animotek – hilarious, I remember only seeing bone marrow once in coles and that was on the last weeks of Masterchef last year.
Fides – I think Adam is more technically proficient then Alvin. I find Alvin, maybe wisely, stays within his comfort zone a lot.
Little Petal – I am like many people whose stars shine during Masterchef, but post the show, my profile will diminish..
I will post a link when it works and in the links to the lady’s website.
Angel86 – I think she actually believes they did rip her off. But she needs to watch top chef, as that is where at least 50% of their challenges come from. However she is trying to get media attention for herself, and I am not going to throw stones at her for that… I will comment more on that story on a separate blog post.
Rarely Seen – I like your form guide on the contestant’s. FYI Jono is from sydney
Buzz – I definitely would eat at all their eating establishments. In fact my partner will be eating at Andre’s new place in Adelaide on Friday. Maybe living in a house with an Indian and some asians may have made him more racially tolerant. Fingerscrossed. I would have thought working in IT he would have to be tolerant of both of those cultures.
Aussiegal – maybe because we are more aware of asian derivatives we are more tolerant of Adam and Alvin doing them. Whereas a curry is a curry, even though it could be flavoured with completely different ingredients. The curry rissole was pretty poor for 90 mins of cooking time. BTW JOno was one of my faves too.
DMC – yes it probably was the worst dish of the night.
Injera – like your synopsis. Hey have the judges said you are the (insert number) best amata cooks for awhile.
Joanna – thanks for your lovely considered comment, agree with the hygiene issue. I don’t believe you are Jono’s wife or mother.
Crabtech – I am surprised it is 15 as pointed out how many will be in 12 months. What is going to happen to last year’s contestants of Julia, Justine etc are their 15 mins up. Chris B releases his cookbook on the 25 October it is called The Entire Beast!
Liberty – you have a point about the prize money, or I would like money for the top five place getters.
NT Kate – Callum is a fave of Georges.
Anonymouse – Who is your fave now?
Kingfisher – you are too funny. Hope you did not dream of the mousse.
Seepi – I agree I thought this has to be a fake out, as they could not have Jono and Marion going when there have been some spectacular underperformers still there.
Pollywaffle – your comments always make me laugh.
Cravatwatch – Oh vey is correct.
BTW news just in a psychic has predicted Alvin to win. well on First dog on the moon
B/dead dave, I see.
Surely Lleyton isn’t claiming to have invented fist pumping as well?
Matt – maybe that is the way to win masterchef take high end recipes and pretend it is home cooking.
RR- Fair enough, she’s clearly deluded. Lol. What about the fact that she ripped off the name Master and the concept of Masterclasses from Channel 10? Thats a much more original concept than seven deadly sins.
RR – I thought that, considering his clearly close friendship with Jimmy, jonno may have found someone of Indian heritage that he doesn’t ‘look down on’. The comments to me about Asians in general actually related to his IT job, along the lines of hopeless, poorly trained and lazy. However I know a lot of aussies who are generally racist, except when it comes to ‘Sanjiv my neighbour’ or ‘Tran from school’ they make an exception cos ‘he’s different, he’s a nice guy’ cos they actually know them.
RR .Certainly Jimmy expressed his intentions to use the show to pimp his curry sauces. Then he showed a glimmer of humanity with his honestly expressed doubts about his abilities at Jono’s elimination the other night.
Anyone see Julia Goodwin’s Strugglenoff on the Today show this morning? She was throwing a shizenload of cream into the mix and when queried said she was more worried about chemicals in food than fat. How come a doctor has never told me that? Or should I believe an obese winner of a reality television show?
Julie was asked about the shock elimination of Marion-” just had a bad day” and said the show couldn’t be rigged because ” Gary and George have careers to go back to and would lose their credibility”.
“Julie… said the show couldn’t be rigged because “Gary and George have careers to go back to and would lose their credibility”.
Yeah – never thought much of her brains before now and this comment doesn’t help. I’m not meaning to express an opinion either way about whether the show might be rigged but I doubt that diners in their restaurants would really care if George and Gary were revealed to have listened to their Channel Ten overlords about the desired result of a TV cooking show.
RR: Wow, if I am Narelle (isn’t that the dumped wife’s name?) then I am not only bitter but an ORACLE!!! As those good ‘ole IP records that Paul requested will reveal, I had the prescience to start coming to your blog last year. Were Season 2 MC contestants picked out of the audtions for MC1 so they could spend a year learning to cook? Makes sense, no?? ‘Cause the MC2 boys and girls are soooooooooo much better cooks than the MC1 mob??
CG Paul is an oracle
@RR: I don’t really have a favourite now … sigh. I hate it when this happens one week out. I don’t mind Adam. He has a lovely smile and is quite humble.
I really don’t want Claire to win. She appears to me as being quite manipulative on and off the camera and is very good at playing the game. I’ve worked with a lot of ‘Claires’ in my time.
If she does win, I don’t think she will resonate well with women viewers.
Gillian: Totally agree with your last post. I reckon all working women have all come across at least one Claire during their careers. In my experience, the species seem to be particularly prevalent in professions such as law, accounting and finance. It seems that a good education can help one become a good manipulator. And perhaps the competitiveness and ruthlessness of these professions leads some to be more competitive and ruthlessness in other areas of their lives?
rr- i didnt dream of jimmys and callums curry mousse but i did dream that jimmy produced a tower cake of curry marshmellows and i had to eat all of it !!! when i woke my pillow was missing. boomboom
KF – For MC Finale week, I’ve heard Jimmy’s working on a Samosa staircase or Pakora Palace ( both with roti)
AniMotek comment 90 – true. Matt, on the other hand, does have his reputation tied to his career. If no-one believes what he says in a food review, then people will stop reading (once he’s no longer living off the fame of being in the Masterchef spotlight), and that could lose him newspaper column deals in the longterm. One has to note that he wasn’t one of the two judges there on the night that gave Jimmy and Aaron a tie to stay in as a completely random example that infers absolutely nothing. Ahem.
RR – well, my fave in personality is Aaron but he’d probably need the stars to align for him to win the whole kit (ie, no pastry dish challenges between now and the end, with the final challenge dish being Ravioli wrapped in Tacos.)
As far as fave to win on talent, I’d go with Adam. Claire and Adam seem to be the two most well-rounded cooks left (can’t forget that Adam won his immunity cooking 3 dishes of which only 1 was asian, and to get to that immunity challenge he cooked a curry). Claire seems to fold easier under pressure than Adam (although she seems to be improving the last couple of weeks), which is why I’d choose him over her.
Jono was my favourite although I didn’t think he would win. Partly because he created his Twitter account about 3-4 weeks ago and started following a list of foodies which was around the time last night episode was filmed. I have mentioned it on the spoiler thread. I was more upset to see him go than Marion because I can see his passion and drive to be a cook / chef and his real intention to start his french bistro or wine bar vs releasing a range of bottled sauce. I will truly miss him.
I made Alvin’s Greed dish, and when I went to coles they had recipe cards, but were missing one of the ingredients, cooking caramel. When I inquired about this the assistant informed me that they did not stock any, and gave me a customer complaint form.
CG,
having just seen Claire play the struggling victim for all she is worth – I agree with you .
I’d like to have seen Adam or Alvin or even Courtney, (who is proving to be anything but a bimbo, NT Kate) tackle that sushi dish. That challenge was wasted on Wet Knickers.
Coles are grinding the gears on the gravy train for the final weeks. Tonight every single aisle in the place had a “shop where a Ma$terchef shops” shrine hanging above it.
Brain Dead Dave and Animotek – Of course Julie could say the show was rigged then she would have been admitting the best cook did not win last year.
CG – Well I know you aren’t but I thought it was a good theory. Not sure I get your IP address comment.
Gillian – I don’t think your views of Claire are going to change after tonight’s episode. This is one of the reasons I don’t think she will win as she has not had great editing.
KF and PW – very funny
Paddlewhack so no cooking caramel in coles, but it just happened to be in the Masterchef pantry, for Alvin’s caramelised pork. Methinks they have enough time to ensure the required ingredients are in there.
@CG: Yes, intelligence is definitely a criteria of a manipulative person. I’ve just realised why I’m not person. I’m just too stupid to think of these things haha. I’ve worked in PR & promotions in media & entertainment companies & they are a lot of women like that who work in those industries. Scary!
I have never worked in law, accounting and finance but I can just imagine! I watch The Good Wife and they make me shudder. Such an awesome show!
@RR: I just don’t feel any emotion when Claire cries. She’s one of those women who just switch on the charm when a good looking man is around her and obviously enjoys flirting with the chefs.
WHO CARES?
Leave a Comment