for those who have reality tv as their guilty pleasure
Reality Ravings | Australia's leading Reality TV blog!

Masterchef Australia – Marion Gone – So They Can Rig It Last Week?

Well Masterchef Australia is not rigged, unless of course one of the contestant’s gets run over by a bus next and the last person eliminated comes back in ie Marion Grasby.

Well if the show is not rigged it should be. Last week they had a bullshit elimination challenge where the two underwhelming contestant’s, Jimmy and Aaron, were kept in the show, and this week one of the alleged best cooks in the show is not going to make it to final’s week.

And don’t I look like a douche proclaiming to New Idea that Marion is going to win, that is what happens when you are not prepared to swim against the tide. I suspect they already knew and I fell right into it. But that is cool still great publicity for the blog.

On the plus side I have saved myself some $$$ on prizes for who will win season 2 competition.

Was Marion eliminated because they thought it was obvious she was going to win and they wanted to create some controversy and a more even playing field, or was her satay sauce actually the worse in George Calombaris and Gary Mehigan’s opinion. Not two people known for having great asian palates. I would have liked David Thompson guesting for this episode.

Also Channel Ten fail when about 20 minutes into the show there was an ad for Sunday night’s show there was Aaron wearing his beanie, so I knew at that stage either Jonathan or Marion were gone. This is on top of the TV Week having photos in their edition on Monday showing both Alvin, and Marion in army fatigues when they were up for elimination in the Monday night episode. Is this some new media strategy they have to put spoilers in their show’s publicity?

When I saw an article of her yesterday in the Daily Telegraph I thought to myself this looked a bit like the week Joanne was eliminated where she got a lot of publicity, but I thought no way it is time for Aaron to go.

On the plus side for Aaron props for him for not curling up in the foetal position when he saw he was going head to head with Marion cooking satay sauce.

Also the taste test was fairer with the competitors having to name all the nuts not being rolled when they named one that was wrong.

Marion is launching her own food range, but how well will it go now she did not get to the final week, I know we won’t forget her, but I am hard pressed to name any contestant outside the top six from last year.

This fuckery would not happen on Top Chef.

So guys how do you feel about this?

UPDATE: Some quotes from the press release.

“But since going home I have made plenty of satay sauces – and, yes, they are thick! In fact, I’m bringing out my own satay sauce in a range I’m working on now.”

“My mum makes satay sauce all the time and I’ve made it loads of time too,” admits Marion. “I wanted a thick satay sauce but I was trying to get the right balance of trying to make a sauce the way my mum makes it, and getting the consistency right. But it was slightly too thick and didn’t stand up to Aaron’s sauce.”

Both satay sauces were outstanding, but the judges couldn’t ignore the thick consistency of Marion’s sauce and she was pipped at the post by Aaron’s flavoursome creation. When the judges broke the news that Marion’s time in the MasterChef kitchen had come to an end it was hard to tell who was more shocked – Marion, Aaron or the judges.

Mmm why would the judges look shocked when they were the ones that allegedly made this decision…..

Share:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati
  • TwitThis
  • email
  • MySpace

Related Posts

186 comments

1 Pollywaffle { 07.08.10 at 10:28 pm }

there were 2 more nuts everyone forgot to name

2 littlepetal { 07.08.10 at 10:32 pm }

Ridiculous !!!!! George taste testing is taking spoonful of satay sauce and said it is too rich or something like that !!!! Satay sauce has to go with chicken or some grilled meat.

Aaron’s sauce has too much turmeric. Depending on which region some satay sauce do not have turmeric and coconut milk. Mine don’t have turmeric and I use fresh lemon grass and galangale.

Maybe they will bring her back.

3 skye { 07.08.10 at 10:35 pm }

Will they bring her back Poh-style?

Maybe they did think they needed a more level playing field to keep viewer interest – I’m assuming at the time this was filmed they weren’t aware of how popular Marion would be with the public despite her un-Julie-like levels of actual cooking ability.

Do not like Jonanthon, do not think he is marketable – don’t know who else they will put through to win. We like Adam, but he doesn’t seem like much of a sell to the aussie public. Maybe aussie chick Courtney is the new anointed one?

4 GeelongDeano { 07.08.10 at 10:36 pm }

This is the biggest scandal since Watergate. Marion was super super. My fave. She would have been better off getting eliminated early and making a comeback like dumb & dumber did….

5 KateBurns76 { 07.08.10 at 10:38 pm }

Yep, it’s bullshit. I mean if you want to stuff around with bringing people back and letting people stay that’s fine, but the good people need to still get through!!

The problem is I now just think the whole show is crap and I don’t want to watch it anymore. Which won’t work for my kids!!

Stupid, stupid, stupid.

6 pinto { 07.08.10 at 10:40 pm }

I was outraged by the sight of Aaron’s beanie 20 minutes into the episode. Bah! Really poor effort Channel 10.

I will say that I liked Aaron’s approach and idea that “if you want to win Masterchef you have to beat Marion at some point” so again he endeared himself to me.

I was intrigued that Marion refered to her Mum as a “Thai Chef”. Does that mean trained chef ? Had she already told us that? There is no way I would refer to my Mum cooking in the kitchen as an English chef (her version of Apricot Chicken and rice aint exactly restaurant quality). Maybe she would have been better to go the crunchy peanut butter, coconut milk and a splash of fish sauce method my Mum uses? Now that’s a satay sauce!

7 Sooty { 07.08.10 at 10:40 pm }

My feelings seem to echo those of those left in the house to compete….

1) I don’t believe that just happened – when every aspect of the elimination seemed to be set up to make it easy for Marion to win it…

I just keep waiting for the tv to light up with a big fireball and a Just Kidding Folks! (and I changed the channel an hour ago)

2) Game on, molls!

8 Pollywaffle { 07.08.10 at 10:40 pm }

Matt P actually gets out and tries aysan, where was he…..polishing off the army scroggan?

9 Paul { 07.08.10 at 10:41 pm }

Thought something big was in the air when the regular 30 minute Thursday episode was extended to an hour tonight.

Marion was slipping slightly. This last week wasn’t her best and I have to say from looks alone, that Aaron’s satay clearly looked better.

Have absoloutly no idea who is going to win now. All of them have weaknesses. Maybe Adam. Maybe even Courtney.

Favourites get beaten. Happens every Saturday at the racetrack.

Still not happy about it because I really like Marion and think she has a lot of talent.

10 Suzanne { 07.08.10 at 10:41 pm }

Oh no! Didn’t watch it as we were out, no video up yet on the website, so couldn’t wait any longer and read it here.

What a shame! Will really miss her attitude and cooking ability. :-(

11 David Allen { 07.08.10 at 10:42 pm }

Bit of a shock. When Gary tasted Aaron’s sauce he was surprised and I think worried, not because it was good, but that it wasn’t going to be an easy decision. Same look from George. When Marion’s sauce was tasted there was the opposite look, that her sauce was not clearly better than Aaron’s. Aaron never said he couldn’t make the sauce but that Marion’s should be better.
If they wanted to rig it they would have asked them to replicate the sauce on display which would have favoured Marion, I think.
It was a bit of a concern that they got any of the nuts wrong. It was an easy test. Did any of you get any wrong?

12 rusty { 07.08.10 at 10:45 pm }

I got the candlenuts wrong, but then, I don’t cook Indonesian.

best moment – the remaining contestants’ faces when they saw Aaron appear, then Alvin and Adam shattered.

13 Pollywaffle { 07.08.10 at 10:48 pm }

A marionette is a puppet controlled from above using wires or strings (wires being the standard now due to increased durability). A marionette’s puppeteer is called a manipulator.[1 any MC host] Marionettes are operated with the puppeteer hidden ( Matt P) or revealed to an audience by using a vertical or horizontal control bar in different forms of theatres or entertainment venues ( or CWA bogged windy plains)

14 Sourkraut { 07.08.10 at 10:49 pm }

Rubbish
Of course its rigged. Its not tens fault that she went out through her own incompetence. FFsake how much easier could they have made it for her with the candlenut (Asian nut with which she was familiar and which Aaron would not know) trouble was she could not even recognise chestnuts
Awwww NUTS!
Then along comes the sate . Gimme a break.. she would have made it thousands of times. Geo gave the game away when she was cooking it, and even said so to her, and she agreed.
I nearly shat myself larfing when Aaron burst out laughing as well when the sate test was announced. His comment said it all. He knew! Bet he gets a smack on the wrist for that later!
Anyway pride goeth b4 a fall. M. was boasting to the camera how she felt sorry for the guys cause one of them was going home HAH
well it was a nutty ep. Geo should know all about nuts and my only other comment was “nuts to you gary”
Next taste test judges how about alternating whose dish you are going to taste first, and how do you taste one sate sauce after another without a cleansing ale in between? Who cares?
Nice of the other Bogans in the room to welcome Aaron back!
Hope he or Courtney wins.
anyway if Aaron does not win he at least has a gorgeous looking wife to go home to. good luck to you

15 pinto { 07.08.10 at 10:50 pm }

btw RR – I love the adjective “fuckery” and when is Top Chef coming to Arena? I know they have started filming the new series with Eric Ripert as a permanent judge no less.

With Tom Colicchio in Adelaide I wish I was there stalking the restaurants and wineries in the hopes of a glimpse/drool. Is he going to be allowed to visit the country and leave without doing ANY press at all? For Shame.

16 K.C. { 07.08.10 at 10:50 pm }

I’m with you Rusty – and when someone asked if it was a joke and Marion was about to come walking down the stairs – gold! Poor Aaron, I don’t like him, but I felt sorry for him tonight.

You could see the light dawning on some people earlier than others the real implications of Marion’s elimination… it is anyone’s game now.

17 librarygirl { 07.08.10 at 10:55 pm }

Remember, Justine was a favourite to win last year and was eliminated in Hong Kong, brought back, and eliminated again, cooking a really difficult Zumbo cake.
Sorry for Marion, but sucker or not, I’m happy to be manipulated by the show. Now it is more interesting to me, anyway.
Go Jono!

18 Heléna { 07.08.10 at 10:55 pm }

we only have what we can see to go by – and I thought Aaron’s did look so much better – I was so shcoked to see Marion go – my husband is devestated ;p

19 Pollywaffle { 07.08.10 at 10:56 pm }

Aw well at least Alvin got his rocks off at the reward lunch – straightforward ingredients for the queer guy

20 NT Kate { 07.08.10 at 10:57 pm }

Yes I thought it was a pretty easy list of nuts – until that last one, and agree kudos for not making it sudden death (though I suspect the producers are regreting that decision now!). Though candlenut perhaps not as obvious – unless you are asian food enthusiast! Very surprised that chestnuts fazed Marion.

And didn’t the judges look surprised when it became obvious that Aaron knew how to make a proper satay sauce!

Aaron showed some considerable pluck in his approach, seemed to win fair and square (judges limited Asian palates notwithstanding) – colour aside, the texture of Marians did look far too thick to coat meat.

Aaron may not know what an older generation consider the classic dishes, but maybe does know about the kind of food many Australians actually eat now.

Now we know why Matt said a little while back that Marion was disadvantaged by not having done enough eliminations….

21 rusty { 07.08.10 at 10:58 pm }

That test was purely subjective, nothing to do with skill, knowledge or whatever, just personal preference.

So it was obviously set up that way so that the one they wanted to stay, was safe. Why else not have them taste it and test their ability to replicate it?

22 Anon { 07.08.10 at 10:58 pm }

OMG was the first reaction. Bet the producers are kicking themselves that their no-elimination week was wasted on weaker competitors.

The competition is wide open now but don’t really think there are any really outstanding (media) candidates left. Certainly not anyone who could parlay it into a media career.

Mmm. Be interesting how the smarter players are going to start strategising now.

23 Reality Raver { 07.08.10 at 11:01 pm }

Pollywaffle – two nuts indeed. This decision would have been made in conjunction with the producers.

Rusty – Agree the contestant’s looked shocked, but they should have started doing backflips.

I wonder if they judged Marion’s satay at a different level. To make it totally fair (well I didn’t want it fair tonight) it should be a blind tasting.

David Allen – I got one wrong, blanked on the candle nuts.

Sooty – Game on indeed.

Kateburns 76 – I suspect by the middle of next week we will all be like Marion who?

Skye – you might be right about Courtney.

Ironically I was so sure Aaron was going tonight, I thought I won’t bother with the usual post elimination poll of who do you think should have gone. I will do the poll as a commenter suggest who has been your favourite guest judge. Hilarious.

Little petal – those two judges are just not great on asian cuisines.

Geelong deano – Do you think in three years time we will be having where were you when Marion was eliminated?

Paul – shouldn’t you be working on some new odds, the field will shorten considerably.

Pinto – yes poor form ten, maybe the show isn’t rigged because there are really amateur mistakes like that.

Suzanne – still worth watching.

24 seepi { 07.08.10 at 11:01 pm }

I have never even heard of a Candlenut. And would not have got the pecan either.

Asian Candlenut may have favoured Marion, but the traditional european Chestnut tripped her up.

With this test, surely if they wanted to keep her in they could have just said her satay was better, and none of us would be the wiser? I mean they both looked Ok, but only G and G tasted them.

So I guess Aaron’s was just clearly better.

Or perhaps Marion was tripped up by trying to cook a ‘posh’ version of what she makes at home.

25 choco { 07.08.10 at 11:02 pm }

fuck master chef its all bull shit.

26 Paul { 07.08.10 at 11:03 pm }

RR,
I’ll have to sleep on it as am too confused at the moment.

27 AnonyMousse { 07.08.10 at 11:06 pm }

Have to give complete props to Aaron. He knew he’d been completely screwed over in the second contest with the dish loaded towards Marion’s skills – his laugh gave that away – and he still managed to pull a victory out.

I’m really puzzled as to how people (especially on the Masterchef forums) can say Marion’s dish was better. Sure it was better – if she was aiming for chutney. Seriously, it was solid. It was in no way a sauce.

28 Reality Raver { 07.08.10 at 11:10 pm }

BTW – can anyone remember any of the other times Masterchef had spoilers in the previews. I know I am being lazy I could look through old blog post comments. I just thought there maybe a masterchef savant amongst you.

29 KC { 07.08.10 at 11:11 pm }

This is shit.

Marion deserved to win.

But I guess this opens up the competition and now I’m gonna move on and put my bid behind Jono and Callum

30 Reality Raver { 07.08.10 at 11:17 pm }

Will Marion be the Ricki-Lee of Masterchef?

31 Sourkraut { 07.08.10 at 11:17 pm }

Anony mousse
Just so

32 rusty { 07.08.10 at 11:30 pm }

I don’t se anyone can say one sate was better than the other, just by seeing it on Tv.

It’s still a personal preference thing only, since no benchmark for “Good” sate was set, beforehand.

33 Sourkraut { 07.08.10 at 11:32 pm }

Rusty
isn’t that the same for every single taste test?

34 Anon { 07.08.10 at 11:34 pm }

Hi Paul,

Yes, I am well aware that the candidates futures are not the main concern of the producers. Certainly, I think they should have been more mindful of certain contestants’ comments regarding their employment been broadcasted.

I never meant to infer that the ‘cookbook’ was the key revenue item for the franchise. Even we bogans are not that naive and do occassionally read the SMH where at the commencement of the season an article appeared in the TV guide discussing the revenue and sources that the franchise generates. Also, as a regular reader of this blog I have noted your numerous comments on this point.

However, there was a certain emotional investment that Marion would be in the final week. The producers have, through their editing created personalities, which garner more support than others.

Unlike last season, I have the impression that some candidates (not all) have been more explicit in their bid for a post MC media career (eg Phil). Of the remaining candidates , none really stand out for me as potential media hosts. But hey, thats just my opinion…

35 Fides { 07.08.10 at 11:35 pm }

I’m with others whose opinions of Aaron’s rose again after tonight. His sauce did look delish and I admired his attitude. I was so certain that they’d give it to Marion anyway, despite its appearance, knowing only they can know the truth about how it really tastes so I was feeling so bad for Aaron and all his fruitless efforts… in a way, with her elimination, it’s a relief the show is not rigged. But she should still be there anyway! Raver, you foretold it last week after Thursday’s non-elimination.

And did they change the format of the nut naming because of criticism towards the mint debacle – ie specifically saying they weren’t after a botanical name, just the common name, and not making it sudden death? It’s good to see that the show does respond to those criticisms, but it’s such a pity they can’t work out how unfair and unreasonable it is at the time. Now all they need to do is work out how to get rid of the weaker cooks to give the title of winner of Masterchef some credibility…

36 Reality Raver { 07.08.10 at 11:41 pm }

Anonymouse – Gary said she had all the flavours in there the salt, sweet etc etc. Agree in other circumstances if she had been up against and beat Jono or Adam I would be screaming they had rigged it in her favour.

37 Buzz { 07.08.10 at 11:51 pm }

Hmmm … crazy-eyes jono is the eliminator but not a fav of mine, ‘callumity’ is way too scatty, and no one else has been truly consistent besides marion.
It now about picking the tallest midget.

38 crabtech { 07.08.10 at 11:57 pm }

Sourkraut I agree with you. They played to Marion’s strength in selecting the satay which we thought was unfair. When she was mixing her satay you could see whole peanuts in it!!!! She was the one who said they had to be chopped to the right conistnecy. Her satay looked like a dip not a sauce. If she had won then that would have been evidence of rigging.

I’m soy she’s gone but on the night she didn’t make the grade.

39 rusty { 07.08.10 at 11:58 pm }

sour,

Aaron and Marion didn’t taste the sate sample first, to know what the judges might be looking for. If they have set a benchmark beforehand, by having the contestants taste the sample product, then replicating it as closely as possible: the judges are then not judging the “best” (because who can say which is the best or correct version of a dish), but the closest to the sample one.

that’s what a cooking contest would do – judge against standards, like the CWA did.

Butt then, we know this isn’t an actual cooking contest. It’s got nothing to do, really, with the best amata chefs. I just wish for some consistency, that they wouldn’t change the rules every second day to suit the ratings.

(probably I ‘m just appalled that someone like AAron can actually get away with such shit food. So he can make a sate and a bit of tex mex)

40 crabtech { 07.08.10 at 11:59 pm }

I maent I’m sorry she’s gone

41 littlepetal { 07.09.10 at 12:00 am }

Actually satay sacue is a dipping sauce. It need to be slightly thick so they can stick onto the grilled meat. If they are more runny, you used them for cooking like making the Satay bee hoon.

42 Pollywaffle { 07.09.10 at 12:01 am }

will Aarons satay range come with greasy beanie lids?

43 Matt { 07.09.10 at 12:01 am }

End of the day it’s a competition and she didn’t measure up.

Ironic really that after an afternoon’s discussion on one of the other threads about strategy, we see that Jimmy and Adam’s (independent) strategies worked. (and I don’t buy for a minute Adam’s crocodile tears).

Strategy is this: Adam picks the two strongest cooks for group challenge. He’s got immunity so he knows there’s at least a one in four (and hopefully from his perspective, if the last person chooses the other team), a one in three chance of Marion/Jono going home if they lose.

Jimmy, the last one picked, picks the weakest team – and crucially, the team without an immunity pin, meaning that if the team loses, he’s got a one in five chance of being eliminated (against the “weaker” cooks), not one in four (because of the immunity pin), against the “stronger” cooks. And by making Marion/jono’s team smaller, he’s guaranteeing a one in three chance that the strongest cook will go if that team loses.

Everyone disappointed at losing the “strongest” cook needs to realize two things (1) this is a competition and you can, as George said, have bad days, and (2) it being a competition, you have competitors trying to beat you. And, just as in the real life food world, that beat down doesn’t (and shouldn’t) have to start only when you hit the kitchen.

Jimmy was at least honest enough to say that it opens up the competition. Marion,like everyone else, was fallible. All Jimmy and Adam needed to do was to make sure she was in a position where that failure would be fatal. This was certainly the time to do it- i reckon group challenges won’t be happening in a week or so.

44 Pollywaffle { 07.09.10 at 12:02 am }

Im going to the Press Club tomorrow night to rate Geos tarama in one heaped spoonful without 17 feckin flowers, chicken oysters and bewtiful baby veg

45 rusty { 07.09.10 at 12:04 am }

Matt

in the real life food world ie. in a professional kitchen, you still have to be able to cook well 7 days a week, not once a month.

46 Pollywaffle { 07.09.10 at 12:06 am }

Matt – you are a genius and obviously not into the WC or TDF as your brain would not be as clever – Jimmy and Adam can strategise till the marcaron cones come home – the key is Matt P’s pantaloons – primary color or pastel, thats how you know you’re going home

47 Reality Raver { 07.09.10 at 12:07 am }

Matt – your theory is still cracking me up, I hope you are right that they are being strategic.

Pollywaffle – have you been before, report back if it lives up to the hype.

48 Skeletor { 07.09.10 at 12:11 am }

Please go back and look at the point where Marion looks to both Jonathan and Aaron and piously states that one of them will be going home. She should have been sent home right then off the back of her arrogance. Aaron deserved to stay, he’s doin great, good attitude and he’s not up himself, give the poor bugger a break!

49 Matt { 07.09.10 at 12:11 am }

Polly – what’s a WC and TDF?

Bet Matt P not being there threw them. “Will it be the pink pat,s or the white ones? Oh no, where is he?”

Gotta say though, Marion’s satay looked like sh*t. Knew she’d lose from the moment I saw her sticking in the peanut butter.

Love Aaron for deciding to go down fighting. A few of the other contestants would have thrown in the towel at such an obvious rigging.

50 Pollywaffle { 07.09.10 at 12:12 am }

RR, have been there before in the pre-Geo Ga Ga era, when feta foam would have been frowned on, but Im wondering if booking under M Grasby and bringing my own personal sample of ‘proper pink’ tarama is a good thing

51 rusty { 07.09.10 at 12:13 am }

Matt

All the game playing in the world won’t get you past customer satisfaction. It’s not a monopoly game. If your food is consistently shit – you’re out the door.

PS. TDF – Tour de France

52 Pollywaffle { 07.09.10 at 12:13 am }

Matt – The soccer thingy and the bike thingy

53 Reality Raver { 07.09.10 at 12:14 am }

Skelator – I loved her trash talking and thought she was doing it to psych them out.

Matt – WC – world cup, TDF is tour de france.

54 Fides { 07.09.10 at 12:15 am }

Group challenges should stop with the top 10 so the weaker cooks have nowhere to hide.

55 Matt { 07.09.10 at 12:15 am }

Rusty – agree with being able to cook well. My point is twofold though – first, real restaurants have to deal with competitors trying to put them out of the game – everything from gossip, to ambush marketing, to locking up suppliers.

And second, this isn’t the real world. These peole are vying for a TV prize. Having put themselves in the show, they need to accept that it has different rules than the outside world.

56 Pollywaffle { 07.09.10 at 12:16 am }

Do we think Aaron might be a tough ‘nut’ due to all those probable record deals for his band ” Beanie-Tortellini” that he ‘won’ and then eventually fizzzzzzzed into MBop land

57 Matt { 07.09.10 at 12:16 am }

Polly – might have just proved your point by questioning on the acronyms…. :)

Although if you’d said RWC or SOO…..

58 Injera { 07.09.10 at 12:27 am }

Okay, so… what happened while I was eating? You’re kidding, right?

Huh.

Kind of glad I wasn’t watching, although of course I now have Harlan Pepper naming nuts in my head (but that’s probably because nearly everything in life reminds me of something Christopher Guest has done…).

Still… huh.

59 Sooty { 07.09.10 at 12:42 am }

I’m still stunned. But when George comes up to you when you’re cooking and says sternly, “Don’t you think it’s a bit thick?” Then you thin it out. Right?

Maybe they’ll bring her back in a shock!!! return. This thing isn’t ending in an actual week, surely?

That said, well done Aaron. For cooking up a storm like a condemned man, making a good satay, and returning home to face all his ‘friends and well-wishers’ in the house and not staying the night in a phone box, which is what I’d want to do in his position.

60 CG { 07.09.10 at 12:44 am }

Well I did say yesterday (post 114 under Army Challenge Open Post): “Probably about time for a shock elimination to keep things interesting”!! Although I thought it would be Jono, not Marion.

But tonight when Courtney said twice “Marion is going to win this”…I knew the fix was in.

Think about it: how boring would it be if favourite Marion took out the contest after being the favourite pretty much since day 1? It was only a matter of time and I give them credit for cutting her loose with 8 persons still in the competition.

How’d everyone go on the nuts guessing. It is nice to have a challenge that is somewhat interactive. I only got one wrong – the candlenuts.

So Marion’s departure also throws a spanner into the oddsmaking doesn’t it?

Oh, and did y’all notice that Marion caught up with her family in some apartment in Sydney – somewhere near Pyrmont Bridge…even though she is from SA and her parents (or at least mother) live in Darwin? Does this mean there is a possiblity of another Poh-esque re-entry..surely not after three others already coming back into the comp and the news that Marion is already set up to release her own line of Asian cuisine?!! Still strange whey they would have her homecoming in Sydney and not SA where I thought she lived on a farm with her partner Tim?

61 Injera { 07.09.10 at 12:46 am }

CG – I’m a bit flummoxed that Marion flubbed chestnuts. How were they presented? Pureed?

62 benrp { 07.09.10 at 12:46 am }

OMG people. She made the worse sause, can’t peope accept that with out claming it is rigged. I mean there is no evidence to suggest it is and why would they want the favouite to go.

63 CG { 07.09.10 at 12:52 am }

RR: just re-reading your recap, as I attempted to say in my post, I reckon Marion going helps make the case the show is rigged. Not sure why you think Marion going proves the show is not rigged?? Marion’s “shock” departure at this juncture maximises publicity for the show, rekindles interest (for those who thought Marion’s win was inevitable), and paves the road for a male winner that many of us predicted from the beginning.

64 CG { 07.09.10 at 12:54 am }

Injera: I too was shocked Marion didn’t get the chestnuts. They were presented in their shell. Even though Marion has an Asian background I don’t think she has travelled much. Anyone who has travelled to Hong Kong or China in the Fall / Winter will be very familiar with roasted chestnuts sold in the street markets.

65 Fides { 07.09.10 at 12:54 am }

CG – I thought Marion’s return was to her parents’ place (according to her blog, they live in Brisbane). Will have to look again to see the bridge.

66 Injera { 07.09.10 at 12:57 am }

In their shell? You’re right, CG, with “not travelling much”! I’ve seen them in so many places (in Asia, but also here in Aust). Perhaps she’s never been to, say, a farmers’ market in early winter? Wow.

67 CG { 07.09.10 at 1:13 am }

Fides: It could have been BrisVegas. I only noticed it for a second and it looked like the Pyrmont Bridge..suppose it could have been the Story Bridge? I will also go back and have a closer look. At any rate, I was looking forward though to seeing this farmhouse she and Tim live in. BTW – totally agree with your point that group challenges should end after top 10 so weaker contestants have no where to hide.

68 CG { 07.09.10 at 1:28 am }

Fides: had another look; must be Story Bridge in BrisVegas and the apartment which I first thought looked like one of those serviced apartments does look like it is her parent’s home. Still wished they had shown her farm house in SA.

69 luciabean { 07.09.10 at 1:32 am }

marion made the worst macaron, and should have been eliminated on sunday. the judges lacked the courage to do it, and had to use the excuse of “adrian zumbo thought peter’s was the worst”. some of peter’s may have lacked filling, and were different sizes, but at least they weren’t burnt. i wish marion well, as she is clearly talented, and passionate about cooking.

70 hestonrules { 07.09.10 at 1:46 am }

at least gary did not cry

71 NT Kate { 07.09.10 at 2:48 am }

CG – Much as I love conspiracy theories, I think the reason it shows that it was not rigged is pretty clearcut. The challenge was totally set up to favour her winning.

It was pure luck that Johno recognised a candlenut – I think he said he only knew it because Adam had cooked a laksa at the house using it a few weeks ago.

And Marion not recognising or going blank under pressure and not getting chestnuts is something that couldn’t possibly have been anticipated – not really a very exotic ingredient! In fact I was surprised she didn’t get the pecans.

And then the cook-off is a satay sauce!! Not exactly one of the classic dishes everyone could be expected to know how to make in 15 minutes flat!

They had totally set it up to keep her in.

It must have been a hard discussion with the producers on whether or not they could do a repeat of last week’s no elimination.

Upping the tension and throwing open the game might work out for them – but high risk indeed to eliminate one of the few people everyone likes and respects.

Frankly I wouldn’t put it past them to find a way to bring her back again…

72 CG { 07.09.10 at 6:53 am }

NT Kate: I understand what you are saying But look back at the last few episodes. Several comments like “crazy not to pick Marion first for the team”, “of course Marion is going to win”, Marion, Marion, Marion, as Jan would say.

I think it is actually an amateur attempt – like the bloody amateur editing and production of this show (who the hell wouldn’t make sure contestants up for elimination didn’t appear in adverts for next week’s show!) – to make her departure even more dramatic – oh, Marion is up against Aaron, of course she is going to win. Oh, its satay sauce, of course Marion is going to win.

If Marion had won the series, the show would have come under criticism for it being boring because she led from the beginning and/or was favoured throughout the competition, etc. By knocking her out they get a lot of extra publicity and any calls of rigging and favouritism are silenced: very amateur stuff.

And Marion walks away with a food deal? Lets see who is behind it and how much money someone is putting into that? Jimmy’s Simmer Sauces sold at the local market is one thing, a “line of food” is quite another. Could be her good luck or part of a deal as part of her early departure! Like RR said, when do we remember the person who finished outside the top 3-4 of a RTV show and when do they go on to strike significant commercial deals in the RTV “field” (if it in fact there is a lot of money and a big chain or manufacturer behind it?).

73 CG { 07.09.10 at 7:25 am }

NT Kate: should also add that IMO keeping Jimmy and Aaron both in last week – a tie because both dishes were equally “not quite right”…but an unexpected winner this week when both dishes were “really good” – adds to the feel of manipulation, fixing and amateur hour producing IMO. I think they (the producers) have their minds set on picking a male winner this year and have had this objective from the beginning. Someone made the decision to eliminate Marion now..rather than closer to the finish – to get some controversy going, try to make it look like things are not rigged, give Aaron a little cred, and ensure Marion was not in final 2-3 and make their pre-determined winner look even more undeserving. Time will tell!

74 dmc { 07.09.10 at 8:06 am }

CG is right on the money. Yes, it’s a competition, but the rules are clearly jigged to produce outcomes that suit the show, rather than finding the best cook. And it’s absolutely shameful that they showed Aaron in that promo. Schoolboy stuff.

I like the comment above about the ‘tallest midget’.

75 Paul { 07.09.10 at 8:33 am }

This is a joke right.

The competition is ‘rigged’ because Marion is now out. Yeah, that makes complete sense.

Lets get rid of the most marketable contestant, the most popular contestant and the best cook who the audience thought would be most worthy of winning.

I’ve heard it all now.

I thought last night would have put an end to all this nonsense talk but it seems I was wrong.

One of the media buyers was saying in the paper last night that Marions elimnation could affect ratings by up to 10% downwards.

What a great result for Ch Ten and Fremantle Media !!!!!!!!

76 CG { 07.09.10 at 9:00 am }

Channel 9 Today show – yes, Channel 9 – has had three segments this morning discussing Masterchef and Marion’s “shock” elimination. Have we seen anything this before: for a domestic reality show? Publicity like this on a competing network cannot be bought at any price! It wasn’t elegant and their record of having spoilers in their own advertising is shocking, but Ch10/Fremantle are laughing all the way to the bank. Ratings would be down if the frontrunner coasted to a win. I am willing to wager that (i) knocking Marion out now guarantees publicity and renewed interest that will sustain or increase ratings for the duration of this series and (ii) the ultimate winner is a male per my prediction at start of MC2.

77 dmc { 07.09.10 at 9:11 am }

I said ‘jigged’ not ‘rigged’. ‘Rigged’ implies that they were setting it up to favour a particular individual and I don’t think this happened. What I do think however, is that the elimination ‘challenges’ have been very inconsistent recently and that this hasn’t allowed for either the cream to rise to the top, or a favourite to be toppled by a great performance.

Firstly, the muppet non-elimination. Then the macaroon tower (the only true test in my opinion). And now the 15 minute satay sauce. At this end of the competition you want the challenges to be hard so that either the best guys win, or they are beaten by a great performance.

Paul, I actually agree with you that this result is not what Ch 10 or Fre Media would have wanted (though that is also debatable) but is the outcome of a flawed elimination system in the past couple of weeks.

I have no real love for any of the contestants, but I am quite sure that if Aaron and Marion went head to head in a real cooking competition (like a two course invention test) Aaron would have had much less chance of winning. A 15 minute satay sauce gave Aaron a real shot and to his credit he pulled it off.

To give an analogy, at Wimbledon Federer is tested in a best of five set match every round. If an opponent beats him they have earned it. This reduces the element of luck and increases the validity of the results. And it makes an upset a genuine achievement.

78 blueice { 07.09.10 at 9:26 am }

RR and all of you – thank you for your excellent discussions about MC. I am addicted to reading your take on proceedings. I’m a first time poster. I am sad that a strong cook like Marion has been eliminated while weaker cooks go on. Fides is absolutely right – it becomes too easy for the weaker contestants to hide behind a successful team in group challenges, like Callum. I still find it weird that someone who made such perfect macarons in London then can stuff up a simple cake twice! Callum lacks some basic skills but is coasting through. Don’t get me wrong, I like Callum but his performance has been very inconsistent.

79 Paul { 07.09.10 at 9:26 am }

dmc,
I know – don’t like the elimination’s myself. Doesn’t allow the cream to rise to the top.

CG,
Wow going out on a limb there. A male contestant to win !!!!!
Considering 6 of the 8 remaining contestants are male and they account for about 80% of the betting market then you could be on to something there…..

And ratings will go up for the rest of the season !!!!!
Another bold prediction there considering every reality show in the history of television sees increased ratings in the final weeks as the show reaches its conclusion.

Any other predictions ?
Labor to win the next election…..
The sun coming up tomorrow……

Lets face it, Heston Blumenthal could win this years Masterchef and you would still claim its rigged.

80 Injera { 07.09.10 at 9:30 am }

Paul – I recall CG and others discussing the likelihood of a male winner this year right from the beginning. It seemed that with Marion’s ascendancy this wouldn’t happen, but now it’s back on track.

81 Lindy { 07.09.10 at 9:40 am }

My biggest disappointment for the night was not Marion’s shock elimination (although I was seriously disappointed by that); my biggest disappointment was channel 10′s showing an ad for next week with Aaron in it. Kind of ruined the rest of the episode for me. Rigged or jigged contest notwithstanding, that ad thing was totally wrong! And that’s the kind of thing which would make me want to stop watching!

82 smauge { 07.09.10 at 9:47 am }

Sorry folks – Aaron’s was a better sauce. There were people on here this week claiming you’re only as good as your last dish. Marion’s last dish was shithouse. It wasn’t even a sauce. If she’d got through on the back of that goop, you would have all cried “RIGGED!” I know I would have.

83 dmc { 07.09.10 at 9:50 am }

I’m sure it’s not easy running a show like this. I design experiments and competitions myself and it’s challenging. But they made mistakes last year (which they corrected) and they are making other mistakes this year in the design of the competition. And they are doing some really dumbass things as well (like the promo).

I watched the elimination last night and thought to myself: a satay sauce? Even I could have a chance of beating Marion at this, even though I’m a rubbish cook. When it comes to a process for finding Australia’s best amata cook, I don’t EVER want to think that I could actually kick out one of the favourites!

84 smauge { 07.09.10 at 9:53 am }

I don’t agree. I was like Aaron, thinking she’ll poop a satay out of her arse and beat Aaron. But she choked. Sorry folks but she did.

85 sourkraut { 07.09.10 at 10:09 am }

NT Kate
The reasons you correctly state (as i have already stated earlier0 are exactly why it is rigged. everything was set up for her to win. Its not tens fault she could not recognise a chestnut or even a pecan nut. Also not tens fault she produced a lumpy sate which she no doubt had prepared many times before.

86 Injera { 07.09.10 at 10:13 am }

“Lumpy Satay” is a good band name. First single: Couldn’t recognise a chestnut.

87 smauge { 07.09.10 at 10:16 am }

Buy Lumpy Satay’s debut album – every song a chestnut!

88 Injera { 07.09.10 at 10:18 am }

Oh, Smauge, that old chestnut! Anybody got any mad musical skillz so we can make this happen? It’ll be bigger than Six and Out!

89 louattheend { 07.09.10 at 10:19 am }

I dont think it was rigged at all.
Much as I liked Marion and thought she’d win this, I just think Aarons sauce looked (and obviously tasted ) better!
I was surprised she lost but…I think it was fair he won….who wants a claggy Satay Sauce…?

90 Chris Owens { 07.09.10 at 10:27 am }

I’m with smauge. She choked. 2 million people would have been yelling out “chestnut”. She got candlenut, how could she not have got chestnut? (By the way, I didn’t know candles had nuts… ha ha). And her satay just didn’t look right to me.
Her face at the end suggested to me that she thought she was a lay down misere to win the comp. That’s enough for me to be glad she’s gone. Aaron on the other hand has been quite humble in recent weeks, so much so that I now want to see him win. Just for the fact that it would annoy people.

91 MolksTVTalk { 07.09.10 at 10:30 am }

I haven’t blogged all season about MasterChef, however last night’s elimination ep has prompted me to do so.

…But now I can’t be stuffed, so I’ll just drop a comment here. ;)

I was, at first amazed at Marion’s elimination. Lots of “NO”‘s & “IT CAN’T BE SO”‘s ran through my head. This was, after all, seemingly the best cook in the competition with the carefully manicured profile from the producers. She was going to be THE new MasterChef pin up girl. She already was in the News Limited papers over the weekend.

Then it hit me. She had to go. HAD to. MasterChef thrives on twists, slight of hand, skullduggery, fake drama. We all hang off it. We watch the show waiting for the twists. Marion’s elimination (Ch10 showing ads with non-eliminated contestants aside) was a better twist than neither Jimmy & Aaron being eliminated last week. NOBODY really picked it. So many people are up in arms over it. Twitter is a buzz, with it being labelled #mariongate (THE HOTEL WAS CALLED THE WATERGATE, NOT THE WATERGATEGATE!!!). It’s all falling into place. Marion staying in the competition would have lead to the most telegraphed winner in the history of arranged marriages.

With 3 weeks left, it’s a producers/promoters dream. The remaining 8 contestants are now closer than ever. Marion was lengths ahead – even by the other amatas own admissions – and now the pack is all closed up again. Betting agencies will be freaking out. I’d picked Marion as the winner against Jonathan and either Adam or Claire in the final 3 or 4. Now, it’s anybody’s game – even Aaron’s.

As far as I can see, Marion had to go. She’ll be right – everyone loves her, and whatever she does now will likely be a success. I agree with RR in saying Marion is this season of MasterChef’s Rikki-Lee. She’ll kick on without the help from the franchise. Her profile is built. She just needs good management.

I don’t think they’ll bring Marion back, either. That would be massive shenanigans. I’m not sure she’d want to come back. Marion seems to be a very straight player. I don’t think it’s her style to do a Lazarus and come back. As for no tears from the judges, I think they aren’t as attached to the contestants this year as they were last year. They’re media hardened. They’re aloof. They like the amatas, but they’ll all never replace Justine.

As to who will win now… Jonathan, Claire & Adam are still top3 for mine. After last night’s ep, it continues to show that the game can turn on something as simple as a satay sauce. It remains anybody’s game to win.

Loving MasterChef. LOVING it. The final 3 weeks are almost upon us.

Bring. It. On.

92 smauge { 07.09.10 at 10:33 am }

Molks – that whole whatever-gate thing has bugged me for YEARS! I thought I was the only one. Right up there with something-oholic. It’s alcoholic because its about alcOHOL!!

93 Chris Owens { 07.09.10 at 10:36 am }

So smauge, what would really bother you than would be a scandal involving a shopping addiction. SHOPOHOLICGATE!

94 smauge { 07.09.10 at 10:37 am }

Stop it! My ears hurt!!

95 Matthew goodwin { 07.09.10 at 10:39 am }

Masterchef is such a false show and so edited that one tends to watch it just to see what they will do next .It does have great elements and I admit I have learnt many skills watching it .Last nights episode was a shocker as it was dragged out and I knew Marion was going to go as the week previously one of the evicted contestants on the circle had mentioned that the ones to watch are Adam and Cullum and side stepped the issue of Marion winning the show .I was disappointed when Marion was so confident and said that no way would she loose the contest and that one of the boys would be going .Jonathan is certainly a strong competitor as is Arron and I think the contest is not diminished by Marion going , in fact she is only 27 and has a lot to learn .keep in mind most professional chefs train for years and these contestants should not be called Master Chefs , perhaps just good cooks . I wish this show was not so rigged and hate all the comments that are interspersed through the segments , as they are often said after the fact , and one can’t help think the food is re styled , cold and not what was cooked originally .Let’s hope next seasons show may be more honest and a lot more honest , as the concept is good and the judges great and so are the chefs .Matt should also not do those ads for kitchen wipes as it cheapens him and makes his obvious skills as a food critic seem diminished . Bring on the final !

96 Chris Owens { 07.09.10 at 10:40 am }

What about a scandal about an addiction to scandals? GATEAHOLICGATE!

97 Injera { 07.09.10 at 10:40 am }

Molk – love it! Agreed it has just amped up the drama by eleventy hundred percent but I’m going to tread carefully in my viewing (i.e. put any missiles in lockdown) since I can’t be at all confident that G, G and MP will abandon saying “best amada cooks”, prompting me to scream and chuck stuff.

Another one here for a hatred of the -gate suffix and -aholic! Anyway, I think chocalatic sounds so much better, particularly if you put the emphasis on the “at”. (Shopaholicgate FTW!)

98 smauge { 07.09.10 at 10:41 am }

I am SO saying Chocalatic from now on! What a great word!

99 Chris Owens { 07.09.10 at 10:43 am }

Chocalatic sounds too much like an intestinal disorder to me.

100 MolksTVTalk { 07.09.10 at 10:49 am }

Chris, Smauge – I prefer to think of a person addicted to shopping for a specific kind of footwear, and being revealed as such:

Crocashopaholicgate.

101 Reality Raver { 07.09.10 at 10:52 am }

Paul – CG has been picking a male winner from the beginning of the series. This blog including the writer floats a whole lot of hypothesises for discussion, because we cannot discuss flavour of food, other stuff arises.
I have to be honest I am still processing the Marion elimination, about whether it was contrived or not. I wouldn’t have problem with it, however over the past few weeks or even over the two series there have been ways of faves ie better cooks staying in.

BTW – where are the odds, I suspect a few readers are eagerly awaiting them like myself.

Blueice – Thanks for commenting George really likes Callum, and I think Callum and Matthew will be the two contestants that will actually work as professional cooks.

CG – INteresting Marion’s sauce range. There are a lot of thai style bases on the market, from the cheaper ones from thailand, to the more upmarket Christine Mansfield, and Charmaine Solomon. So I am wondering what her price point will be. I thin would advise a cheaper version just priced above the imported stuff. Stocked in Coles? Likely. I would try them, as I would Jimmy’s but the flavour would have to be there to make me continue to buy it.

102 Chris Owens { 07.09.10 at 10:52 am }

Is the scandal that it’s Aaron, Mr cool himself, who wears Crocs?

103 seepi { 07.09.10 at 10:58 am }

The producers can try to rig the show all they like, but at the end of the day, if someone cooks something far better than someone else, there isn’t much they can do. You can lead a horse to water, but you can’t make it recognise a chestnut!

I think Aaron was battle hardened too. Despite the odds against him, he just got on with his satay sauce. Marion could have been flustered by the 15 minute deadline.

Also, the way she cooked her satay could well be the way her family eats it at home.

The last few evictees have had quiet family visits instead of big parties in the garden. I think it might be about not giving much advance warning of who is eliminated – it would take time to organise the bigger getogethers.

RR – George also predicted Marion and Callum as the ones to beat in the current new idea, so you’re not alone.

104 Fides { 07.09.10 at 11:02 am }

I’m now dreading that it will be Jimmy and Callum in the final 2. Please no.

CG : about the farmhouse – yes I was hoping to see it as well. I wasn’t paying much attention when she arrived “home”, so when they showed the inside of the apartment, I’m thinking – wow that’s a rather swank little farmhouse. And with water views too!

Last year towards the end, they didn’t do the group offsite challenges eg wedding challenge (which is still my favourite ever challenge – who among this year’s group could have decorated that cake… or even made cake) , cooking for the navy and the culinary legends. The producers may have tweaked the formula to try to improve the Thursday eliminations (hmmmm, debatable), but they should be focussing on getting the judging for the Wed challenge right first.

105 Gillian { 07.09.10 at 11:10 am }

I agree that the satay test was for Marion’s benefit. They basically handed it to her on a plate and to Gary and George’s disappointment, she couldn’t deliver. This has certainly made the competition a lot more interesting. I think the chef challenge where she won the immunity pin was rigged as well. I’m not enjoying the show as much as last year.

106 AniMotek { 07.09.10 at 11:13 am }

People need to keep in mind that this isn’t just a competition to find the best chef: if it were, they’d just set cooking challenges day after day, judge all dishes on flavor and presentation, and come up with a winner. This is a game show competition and the person who will win might not necessarily be the best cook. S/he will be the person who manages to get through all the challenges/twists/eliminations and make it to the end of the show. That said, I don’t think a really weak cook will make it through to the final 3 (that means you, Jimmy) but it won’t necessarily be the best pure cook. Just live with it, everyone.

As a side note, I must say that although I haven’t particularly liked Aaron ever since he didn’t put his hand up for elimination when his team lost (and poor Jake got it instead), I was impressed that he didn’t take it personally after this round when everyone’s reaction when he stepped out of the elevator was shock and disappointment.

107 MolksTVTalk { 07.09.10 at 11:17 am }

AniMotek – there is some conjecture that the return of Peter, Courtney & Jimmy to the show has brought with it knowledge of how the amatas are being perceived. The amatas have very limited ability to communicate with the outside world, so in being sheltered, don’t know what we think of them until they get out. The rumour is that the returning 3 have reported back, & that Jonathan & Aaron (particularly) have altered their approach a little to try and alter the perception.

No matter which way you present it, however, Beanie Douche is stil the douchiest douche that ever wore a beanie.

108 Jenny { 07.09.10 at 11:30 am }

I am disappointed to see Marion go considering she beat a chef, won a number of challenges, and overall was a fairly competent & diverse chef. In addition, she had a great on screen presence – she was always smiling, gracious in defeat and seemed like a genuine and nice person. But I suppose that is how life goes – it isn’t always fair and she did seem to present a less than great satay dish than Aaron’s – his satay dish did look more appealing. You are only as good as your last dish as they say.
However as an aside if Jimmy makes another bloody curry I will be pissed off. I like Jimmy – he is a nice guy but he hasn’t shown much diversity in his dishes. I would like to see him try something different for once! I am only saying this because I think it is unfair that he gets to stay (when he only ever seems to make curries) and Marion doesn’t. But then again if he opened up a curry restaurant I would be there in a flash.

109 Reality Raver { 07.09.10 at 11:32 am }

molktalkstv – I like your thought processes and you could be right about even increasing the hype. Could Claire win?
Chris owens – missed the crocs

Matt Goodwin – the editing has been more obvious this year or the viewer is more savvy. I still cannot get over the spoiler in the preview ad, so when Jono won the nut test, you knew Marion was gone half way through the episode.

110 Culinary Boner { 07.09.10 at 11:36 am }

This show is now playing out like Idol in my opinion. All the contestants, and this includes Marion, are just looking for a fast and easy way to make a buck in the food industry.

MasterChef, my arse!

Let’s try MasterProvidore, MasterCafeOwner, MasterJamMaker, MasterCookbookCeleb, Master-fuck’n-ToastBrowner& EggFlipper.

None of this lot actually wants to, truly, deeply, be a Chef. Clearly Cheffing is just too hard (and, to be fair, they are onto something here).

Just like the no-talent warblers on Idol, they want us, the public, to recognise genius where it clearly doesn’t exist and fork out our hard-earned on whatever mediocrity they produce. Whether it’s a CD of kiddie-pop ballads or a sauce bottle containing mashed-up peanuts, some oil and spices.

Sorry Marion, but if I want to waste my money on pre-prepped sauces I’ll go with proven, quality products like the ranges made by people who have done the hard yards in kitchens: Christine Manfield, Charmaine Solomon and David Bitton.

Marion clearly has more talent than the rest of this sorry bunch of homecooks. In my opinion, if she really wants to shine in the culinary world, she needs to commence a restaurant career. Virtually any fool can boil up jams and sauces and tip them in jars – this is industrial food preparation. Well, except maybe for Private S Baldrick, aka Callum.

Last night’s program was clearly a major success in terms of manipulative reality TV but a big, big fail in terms of MCA’s big pretence that it is about finding the best Chef.

The nut challenge was absurd. As an innocent young lady with a penchant for dressing like a choirboy they’d've known Marion hasn’t seen that many nuts in her time.

And since when would anyone have rated Mr Chip Butty and his trusty sidekick, Mr Moussaka Arse as experts on Asian cooking. FFS, Moussaka Arse bitches everytime he gets a whiff of chilli. Maybe he needs to be forcefed a plate of Thai deep-fried chillis to get over his aversion.

Marion’s expulsion from this show is a traversty. There I said it.

Hopefully Jonno’s cookbook also comes with some hints for getting my computer to run faster.

111 Reality Raver { 07.09.10 at 11:39 am }

Animotek – my theory on Jimmy and his curries, is that his aim was to launch a curry sauce line. Hence the plethora of curries he is cooking.

MolksTalksTV – tried to twitter you but it is balking. Axle Whitehead’s career has not been hindered by not even getting into the finals of Australian Idol

112 MolksTVTalk { 07.09.10 at 11:48 am }

RR – Axle has had a harder road (boy, pants, now!). It wouldn’t happen again – we’re all too hardened. I think, in the last 2 weeks, we’ve seen signals that MasterChef will not last for years. I give it 2 more ‘proper’ seasons at best. It’s a shame, but when the producers show they don’t /really/ have that many new ideas, just twists on the old ones, then the show isn’t that long for the world. Advertising/promotion will keep it alive possibly longer than it should be.

Now… let’s get ready for those pretentious little kiddie chefs!

113 Jenny { 07.09.10 at 11:53 am }

Ah of course RR that is why Jimmy is always making curries – to promote his curry sauce line. He plays to his strengths by always making and promoting his curries knowing that he won’t be there for very long, hoping to strengthen his post-masterchef business life. He is a genius.

114 Matthew goodwin { 07.09.10 at 12:04 pm }

Let’s not bag people personally , after all they are just cooking food , not running the country !

115 Culinary Boner { 07.09.10 at 12:27 pm }

Raver, Axle Whithead’s penis is only the reason why he is still – somewhat – famous…well, let’s phrase this better ‘known to the general public’.

Matthew G, can we cut the sanctimonious crap about not ‘bagging’ the contestants. Sure, any racial vilification or outright hatred is outta bounds, but they all gave up on their anonymity and privacy by becoming reality TV exhibitionists, so they can cop some bagging about their performances, attiitude, appearance, personality etc… Afterall, as last night showed, this program ain’t about cooking, it’s about staged entertainment and manufactured controversy.

116 seepi { 07.09.10 at 12:28 pm }

Just saw Marion on the Circle. the Circle girls seem to be really into Masterchef. Ksate Langbroek was crushing some spices and pretending they were Aaron. She and Chrissy had a big laugh about Kate and her mayo and microwaved chicken.

Marion was supposed to be cooking chicken larb, but I think they ran out of time. M did say that there was about an hour in between G and G tasting the satay, and the announcement that she was gone.

117 Pollywaffle { 07.09.10 at 12:38 pm }

Its true that Aaron doesnt hold a candlenut to Marion, but maybe she just sensed a gap in the market – a MC eliminated contestant that can actually cook.

BTW, and this news is SUPER SCARY, just found out that Im related to Geo ( dick-relation only thank god)….. explains the observation that this part of the family always seem to have scallop burns from hoeing into the donuts there

118 Fides { 07.09.10 at 12:42 pm }

Oh wow Polly! That’s why you’ve always had that special connection that can only come from family. You really need to publish your Geothaurus!

119 MolksTVTalk { 07.09.10 at 12:45 pm }

Chrissie is a massive MasterChef fan. I hear Kate is also.

120 NT Kate { 07.09.10 at 1:10 pm }

I don’t think one should read anything into the comments leading up to Marion’s elimination (the ‘she will definitely win’ etc), or even her own ‘I will be the one on the night’ stuff – this is all down to the editing, and once they knew what was coming, pretty easy to manipulate people in this kind of situation to say the things needed to get the spin you’ve decided to go with (the competitor comments on the challenge surely have to be filmed the day after the challenge, not before or as they go along given logistics and the nature of some of the comments)…

I didn’t see the promo ad, but I suspect that it was a very deliberate decision – foreshadowing is a fairly standard tool of drama – hint in advance to make it more believable when it happens.

Moreover not a total giveaway – so you knew that Aaron was going to survive – but did you really truly believe they would eliminate Marion before you actually saw it happen?? At worst, thought another let them all stay…

Going on the forum and other comments, it was still a pretty shocking outcome when it came.

Similar point could apply to the spoilers inherent in the promotion of the army thing – which was more important to them, giving away who was out, or getting people to watch the army challenge over state of origin? And it worked.

On the odds, I think Aaron surely has to move up the pack. Personally I enjoy his dry, sardonic sense of humour.

And I admire his enormous resilience and strength of mind in enduring the constant fakeouts and blatant ‘we’re out to get you’ stuff from the judges.

Has the ‘not Julie’ factor in being a male and much more creative dishes.

But I’m also impressed by the fact that he listens and learns (unlike say Callum) – in earlier challenges his sauces became too thick, not plentiful enough etc, and so he really focused on pitching his product to the judge’s sensibilities (though to his credit he obviously didn’t go too easy on the chilli even for George’s sake).

Nonetheless, its now blatant (if it wasn’t before) that the silly set up of the team challenges means that this is a game show not a real cooking comp, so it really is anyone’s game.

121 CG { 07.09.10 at 1:24 pm }

Molks: great posts.

Paul re your post #79: why are you such a bully?

Re picking a male to win: As RR has confirmed I have picked a male would win from the very beginning because I think MC simply wants a girl-boy sequence of winners. You are expert at searching back posts, so go for it.

Re ratings post-Marion: You have been the one posting that Marion’s departure was not good for Ch10 and Fremantle (post #75) and quoting sources that viewers would now drop by 10%. In my post, I am disagreeing with you and the other “experts” and suggesting that ratings will in fact go up due to Marion’s departure (and more than they would had Marion stayed in) because the winner is now not inevitable and people will now be re-engaged.

Based on a review of this blog, Twitter and comments in today’s papers, I’d say opinion is 50:50 that the show is rigged / jigged: meaning the decision to eliminate Marion was done to make the show more interesting and get to a premeditated result. And as Molk said, why would anyone be surprised or defensive: this is what Reality TV is all about: this is not a show to pick the best amateur cook / best cook of the group like its namesake Masterchef UK.

BTW I don’t think Marion is necessarily complicit in the rigging and jigging. Of course Marion wanted to win! I think MC producers make decisions on the fly with a pre-determined winner in mind. This would mean the contests like the nut guessing or ingredient tasting/guessing are not rigged but subjective “taste” decisions (like the satay sauce, the coq au vin, any cooking challenge) are made by committee based on the strategy for the show set by the producers.

Isn’t it interesting that Marion reportedly told media today that it took an hour for G&G to emerge after tasting with their decision. You taste the sauce, you have a view on which is better (without cleansing their palates in between which is ridiculous with such a spicy dish). But why did it take an hour to discuss who to go unless they were working through the scenarios and ramifications with the producers?? I reckon Marion may have been eliminated a few weeks earlier than producers had planned but they had to take advantage of the opportunity thus the hour-long deliberation.

122 brain dead dave { 07.09.10 at 1:37 pm }

I’ve just seen a teaser for tonight and am seeing prawns ,eggs and flour/pastry. To quote Warren Zevon ,send lawyers ,guns and money because the shit’s about to hit the fan. The mother of all rewards awaits the winner…Fremantle Media really know how to burnish a turd.

I agree with Culinary Boner, this culinary crapshoot is just like Australian Idol. Same organgrinder,different monkeys.

Marion’s made the cover of Who with her amazing weight lo$$ story. Maybe she plans on shoving some purgatives in her line of frumpjuices.

123 Fides { 07.09.10 at 1:49 pm }

CG : re the hour it took to tell Marion/Aaron the decision. I watched the Circle and it was all great fun. They told Marion that most likely it was frantic with the Gs ringing producers saying “OMG Aaron’s made a good sauce! Marion’s is lumpy!! What the hell are we going to do?!” And probably that was what took place.

Also funny when they tried to stir up friction between Marion and Claire, asking her if she saw Claire’s smirk at her being eliminated. Marion was a great sport about it all.

124 Paul { 07.09.10 at 1:53 pm }

CG,
it takes an hour because they film the contestants pieces to camera in that timespace. Nothing more. Nothing less.

As for the rest – I can’t be bothered anymore. You thin it’s rigged. Nothing will change your mind despite all evidence to the contrary and it’s just becoming a waste of my time.

Enjoy the rest of the show.

125 rusty { 07.09.10 at 1:57 pm }

NT Kate

YOu and I must be watching a different AAron. Maybe a different MC? I haven’t seen the Beanie do anything for weeks but fail to learn.

In the London tea time, his attitude was ” I can’t do pastry so I won’t bother”, a theme he has continued ever since. And only last week he botched his scones about 4 times. Courtney blotched hers once – then learnt form it.

I guess if you like a contestant, you interpret everything they say or do positively. And vice versa. Sour hates Jonno and so thinks his every twitch is loaded.

I’m trying to be indifferent to their personalities, because of the editing, and just focus on their cooking skills.

which is obviously proving to be a waste of time in this show. Perhaps I had better just go back to hating Claire and have more fun?

126 dmc { 07.09.10 at 1:59 pm }

I think people are missing the point of what I said about ‘jigged’. The show isn’t rigged (well I’d like to think so) – that means the results are predetermined. ‘Jigged’ means tinkering or manipulating of events to create excitement or surprise, which can cause strange or unintended results that undermine the credibility or equality of the process.

Sure Marion might have been expected to make a good satay, but do people REALLY believe Aaron would have had a better chance with a longer, more elaborate cook-off? Really?

I think this is one of the issues with this type of reality television, and partly explains why shows like Idol and sytycd are dead or struggling here. They trumpet that finding the ‘winner’ is the goal of the show, but actually it’s all about the journey and the manipulation. Sure we all love it, but if we don’t also care about the quality of the winners problems can happen. Over time the public gets blase about the winners as they fade into semi-obscurity (with only a few exceptions). If the winners don’t go on to fame and fortune, are we still able to invest as much year after year in that journey? I think Idol here told us no. It had run its course.

I quite like Masterchef and I also like the possibility of it really unearthing gifted amateur cooks, but if the show ends up being a parade of ‘almosts’ due to tinkering I wonder if we will continue to care as much. At this stage obviously we are, but I wonder….

127 CG { 07.09.10 at 2:10 pm }

Paul: You promise! You really, really promise!!

But before you go: No apology for accusing me of picking male winner now that ratio is 6:2? No apology or explanation for trying to recant/correct your own assertion that ratings will fall 10% with Marion’s departure? No adjustment of your original claims that this is a cooking show and the winner will be the best cook of the bunch? Shucks. Must suck to be the expert on everything and have to suffer so many of us fools.

128 Paul { 07.09.10 at 2:25 pm }

dmc,
understand what you mean by jigged as distinct from rigged. FWIW I tend to agree but there is a big difference between the 2.

129 Reality Raver { 07.09.10 at 2:29 pm }

Looking forward to next week now that I have gotten over the shock and horror that Aaron has survived again. Christ CG you could be right you picked Aaron in the competition to win, you may win that Masterchef cup after all!

There is no way George and Gary would have made the decision to let Marion without consultation. On most shows, and to be fair I have not seen it at the end of the credits here, but I have not looked, most shows have a clause which says the decisions are made in consultation with the producers.

Top Chef judging can go on for hour and hours, that is why they feed the contestant’s alcohol. BTW for fans of this show, Top Chef Washington DC has started in the US. No news on when it will start screening here. Toby Young is no longer a judge but Eric Ripert is.

130 AniMotek { 07.09.10 at 2:35 pm }

I honestly don’t understand some people’s reasoning here. If you’re so convinced that it’s a disgrace that Marion got eliminated because she was clearly the best chef in the competition and was obviously going to win, then you’re really saying that they should have stopped the show last week and just named her the winner. Otherwise, the only reason to watch it the remaining weeks would be to see the order in which the other contestants got eliminated, which is both heartless and pointless. If it’s a true competition, then there was always going to be the chance that Marion might get eliminated. And if it wasn’t a true competition, then why would you want to continue watching it and want them to continue it? Either one or the other, folks!

131 Culinary Boner { 07.09.10 at 2:38 pm }

Thanks for the update on Top Chef, Raver. Eric Ripert should be a dryly amusing judge, with the added amusement that he can’t seem to hide his ‘thing for the ladies’.

132 sourkraut { 07.09.10 at 2:43 pm }

Chris Owens 90
Agree. her arrogant comment at the start just made it worse.
Mathew Goodwin 95 and Gillian 105
well put.
Jenny
whats wrong with Jimmy making curries. Its a pleasant change from seeing all that french stuff all the time especially when its catering to the strengths of some of the contestants!
Brain dead dave 122
maybe the purgative got added to the sate?
Rusty 125
FFS when have I ever said I HATED Johno, and why pick on me? Others have said far worse things about some of the other contestants than I ever said about Johno. (and please dont make me go back through the post to dig them up)

133 sourkraut { 07.09.10 at 2:46 pm }

Rusty
In fact you are just as bad if not worse for your constant carping about Aaron

134 Reality Raver { 07.09.10 at 2:48 pm }

Looking forward to next week now that I have gotten over the shock and horror that Aaron has survived again. Christ CG you could be right you picked Aaron in the competition to win, you may win that Masterchef cup after all!

Culinary BOner – hilarious as usual, and agree regarding your assessment of the sauces, but people who don’t usually cook asian at home might like them. As asian food stores are overwhelming and it is hard to know whether you are buying a good tasting brand of sauce or curry paste.

Animotek – good point and agree. I suppose much frustration comes from the inconsistency from week to week.

DMC – Where Masterchef is different is that there is no viewer voting, and nor should there be, and Idol and SYTYCD is more the ‘favourite’ dancer or singer. I like to think with “professionals” judging ensures the best person does win.
BTW speaking of obscurity who did win this year’s SYTYCD? I am going to have to look at old posts. I remember the first two seasons winners.

I won’t be blogging Junior Masterchef.

Also been meaning to mention to say, Marion’s partner seems like a cutie.

There is no way George and Gary would have made the decision to let Marion without consultation. On most shows, and to be fair I have not seen it at the end of the credits here, but I have not looked, most shows have a clause which says the decisions are made in consultation with the producers.

Top Chef judging can go on for hour and hours, that is why they feed the contestant’s alcohol. BTW for fans of this show, Top Chef Washington DC has started in the US. No news on when it will start screening here. Toby Young is no longer a judge but Eric Ripert is.

135 Reality Raver { 07.09.10 at 2:52 pm }

Hey sourkraut look on the bright side at least someone is reading your comments…. So who do you think is going to win? Are you backing in Courtney now?

Rusty – however, I do agree with you about Aaron

136 blueice { 07.09.10 at 3:05 pm }

Robbie won SYTYCD. Good point about the lack of viwer voting means we should see the best win MC. What I don’t get was why the teams had to serve diferent food to the troops in the challenge. It might have been a more fair assessment of cooking ability if they made the same thing and the troops voted on the best versions.

137 rusty { 07.09.10 at 3:07 pm }

sour,

Okay “hate” is too strong – sorry, don’t get all ruffled.

You’re quite right about me on AAron, but it’s his lousy cooking that gets my goat, not his personality. And one of your recent posts did go in detail into Jonno’s failings, and also Marion re: about your perception of them as arrogant. ( I didn’t care for the jolly hockey sticks either, but I did think she could cook).

As for” why you” – cos I always read your posts and I don’t read some of the others. Your name was the first I thought of.

138 homecook { 07.09.10 at 3:36 pm }

Jono out at 6, Courtney out at 5, top four: Claire, Adam, Callum and Jimmy.

139 AniMotek { 07.09.10 at 4:26 pm }

@Molks: Interesting theory about the returned contestants providing personality tips to the cloistered ones!

As for Aaron, I think the public would think better of him if he appeared to be taking his screw-ups seriously. Laughing them off doesn’t give a really good impression – if the audience is taking the show seriously, you’d hope that the contestants would too! And, as I said before, the fact that when he was team captain he didn’t nominate himself to be one of the three people sent to the elimination trial is what put him on my “Hope They Get Eliminated” list permanently.

@sourkraut: There’s nothing wrong with curry. However, I think the competition needs to at least be able to pretend that the contestants are all-around cooks rather than just amateurs who do a single cuisine well. Even Alvin, who mostly only does Asian well, at least submits unusual flavor combos and unique dishes.

140 brain dead dave { 07.09.10 at 5:17 pm }

Aaron( interviewed today on radio in SA) reckons he’s lost 13 kilos during the show. Twelve of those would have been when satay was announced as the challenge last night.

141 dmc { 07.09.10 at 6:05 pm }

RR – with Masterchef being a non-viewer voted show, there is an even higher expectation that the ‘best’ will win.

I actually agree with Paul about the rigging. I just believe it’s been poorly planned these last two weeks with the eliminations and we have had some wacky results.

AniMotek – my point is not that Marion is the best cook and so should win, but rather that at this stage of the competition the elimination challenge should be way more than a 15 minute satay sauce. Beating Marion should be an achievement for Aaron, and he looked embarrassed actually when he won. Not because he didn’t make the best sauce (he probably did) but rather that it had been so easy to knock her out. I would have really enjoyed seeing Aaron pull off a spectacular Mexican dish and showing his mettle.

142 Pollywaffle { 07.09.10 at 6:30 pm }

I’ve been waiting all day for a Marion was bought conspiracy to emerge, hey, might have missed it with so many comments to graze over, BUT does anyone see a Slugworth style offer having convinced her to throw the challenge? …..

“Marion babes, you’ve got 2 paths here – win masterchef and you’ll be Julie’s stand in when shes not beeswaxing about her spag bol, but take the money and run honey and we’re cooking with soy”

( sorry Paul, but from what I’ve read you dont live here anymore??? But you’re having a better run with the soccer anyway)

143 Pollywaffle { 07.09.10 at 6:50 pm }

OMG, Marion has announced she is releasing a satay sauce, alright then, what else might be in the range olive macarons, rainbow cake…..its all going to be AWESOME.

Gee does this give Kate license to launch a May0-Tattie slice?

144 CG { 07.09.10 at 7:01 pm }

Polly, early on in this thread I raised the possiblity that Marion was offered a more lucrative deal. Will be interesting to find out who is behind her new food/sauce line? Follow the money.

145 Shibumi { 07.10.10 at 12:44 am }

Yep, Paul, don’t plate it up and send it out on the floor if you can’t handle it being sent back to the kitchen. TTFN.

146 Chuck { 07.10.10 at 2:38 pm }

There’s a saying that if it’s a choice between a conspiracy or a stuff-up, put the money on a stuff-up.

My spin on Thurs night’s elim of Marion is there were stuff-ups. Marion stuffed-up by underestimating Aaron and under performing herself; Aaron stuffed-up (in a positive way for him) by cooking the better dish; and the producers stuffed-up by overestimating Marion’s skills and underestimating Aaron’s nothing to loose mood.

Where to from here? I’m not necessarily a Callum fan but I have had a feeling for a long time he’s going to do a Julie and be there at least in the final 4. He gets so much negative edit on the show he is either playing dumb cook to surprise everyone at the finish or he is just dumb and will go soon. This week should show one way or the other.

147 Paul { 07.10.10 at 2:47 pm }

Its a terrible day weather wise today and was a bit bored so just decided to have a look at some posts of a certain poster. Remarkably she claimed only a week ago that.

“This season MC is clearly going for a different demographic profile to extend the MC brand/advertising pull/revenues/syndication as evidenced by the contestant pool and now the top 10. The winner will be young, urban, and childless. This is a natural progression and expansion of MC’s demographic reach after establishing the show and the brand (and the sponsors) so successfully in season one.”

Hmm – that would fit the profile of the 3 remainig female contestants at that time, wouldn’t it. And the male ones as well. I’ve heard the term having a ‘bet each way’ many times before but thats probably taking it a bit too far !!!!!!

And just on a few other things and sorry RR but I’m compelled to defend myself here as I don’t like having statements attributed to me which I didn’t make. Normally if it was just a certain poster I wouldn’t care but it seems a few others have jumped on board as well and this is more for their benefit than hers as I know that comprehension is not her thing.

1. I quoted a media buyer who stated that ratings would fall 10%. Go back and read please. And I’m almost positive that he meant comparatively to the same stage last season as well. Not that they would fall 10% off their current base. I realise that may be a touch technical for some.

2. Its a competition. The best cook AT THE TIME will win. Australia does not always win at cricket, Brazil does not always win at soccer. Phar Lap did not win every race he contested. Its life. Thats what happens. I am perfectly comfortable with Marion going because despite her being the best cook overall (in my opinion), on the day she failed to produce. Shit happens, It has always happened and will continue to happen.

148 Pollywaffle { 07.10.10 at 2:53 pm }

Hey Paul, no need to justify that you are bored etc and thats why you are blogging. Nothing to be ashamed of, we all need our particular form of therapy/expression Im basically hogging the Open Post last night and still now with my bleatings, have no idea why except possibly that there are other things to do that feel like work

149 CG { 07.10.10 at 5:09 pm }

CG (the certain poster referred to above) said on 23 April (two-and-a-half months ago, when the top 24 were confirmed):

“[the] winner this year will have to be the “anti-Julie”. Most obvious choice would be a guy (esp given MC’s penchant for boy v. girl challenges!). But girl/guy it most certainly will be a Gen-Y-er to expand the demographic”

RR: Can I get an AVO? Someone is obsessed with me, promises to leave me alone and less than 24 hours later is back to his harassing, bullying and defamatory ways!

Disagreeing and debating different opinions is one thing and what this forum is all about. This is a reality TV show, guys. This is supposed to entertaining and fun!!

But to have a fellow poster spending so much of his time trying to “get me”, being so aggressive and hostile in his tone, constantly suggesting I and otheres have problems with “comprehension” is making this quite an unpleasant place for many.

150 CG { 07.10.10 at 5:29 pm }

AW: Was wondering where you were!! Hopefully RR can do something and you can feel comfortable coming back as we get to the pointy end of the competition and head towards the grand finale. We supposedly share a brain, afterall…and THAT is quite the accomplishment – beyond “comprehension” – given I’m in Sydney and you (I think you mentioned) are in WA! :-)

151 Airwalk { 07.10.10 at 5:35 pm }

Yeah I emailed RR to let her know how I felt, she kindly responded. Yes I am unfortunately in Perth atm :)
Yes we must share a brain as I feel exactly the same as you stated above in regards to Paul and that is the only reason I have posted(I asked RR to pass my email address on to you to say hi). I agree, the majority on this blog seem to have good natured banter and that is why I revisited it after finding it during MC last year but Pauls attacks have turned me off posting but make sure you keep posting :)
Here’s a link for all :) ciao
http://news.ninemsn.com.au/entertainment/7927399/masterchef-unleashes-macaroon-chaos
btw salsify is quite different to parsnip-more akin to the flavour of jeruselum artichoke I would say. Quite common in the US but hard to even get seeds in WA let alone the vegetable.
Also during the nuts identifying challenge…when they were informed the last 3 nuts were in their shells…I think Jon uttered the F word-noughty boy. Shame Marion went(she seems lovely)—I don’t really care who ‘wins’ this farce

152 Sourkraut { 07.10.10 at 5:49 pm }

Rusty
Semi apology accepted.
Just because I think the two of them are arrogant (as portrayed by the editing of this stupid show) does not mean i hate them. If I dislike seeing them win that is another matter.
Hate is a highly emotive word and only belongs in the realms of twitter and facebook, in fact it does NOT BELONG there either.
and while I’m preaching:-
CG and Paul chill out. you both have the right of free speech and interpretation but i think its going a little far. As I’ve said b4 if you dont like the posts dont read them. Heaps of people cant stand my opinions , so they dont read them either. fair enuff, infact i’ll give you a break for a week.
YES I can hear the Hoorays from here.

153 Paul { 07.10.10 at 6:18 pm }

This is ridiculous and AW you are an absolute disgrace printing something that I edited and did not want to appear on the blog.

I’ve seen some low things on internet forums before but thats about as low as you can go.

PS : I’m not actually ashamed of what I wrote either. Its just that I didn’t want to drag RR’s blog down with another petty argument so at the last minute edited my post.

I didn’t expect someone to publish it but then again I didn’t know how low some people would stoop. What a nasty piece of work you are.

And I’m really sorry RR but I have to defend myself against this shit. I didn’t intend for this to happen.

Sour,
These two keep attributing comments to me that I don’t make and then go post after post with general crap about it. It happens again and again and again. First, I thought it was general stupidity but as we’ve seen with this vindictive and low post of AW’s, maybe there is another agenda.

I apologise to all other readers of this blog. I am as pissed off as you are and I completely understand your frustration. Please understand I am only defending myself against comments not made by me but attributed to me. That is all.

154 Pollywaffle { 07.10.10 at 6:20 pm }

RR, you are probably busy previewing the new reality show Masterchefs – Tribal cooking in the Outback, but in case not, it would be fab at some stage if you could empty in your raw blog comments into this baby and see what words stick out ( Paul?) http://www.wordle.net/

155 Anonymous { 07.10.10 at 6:32 pm }
156 Pollywaffle { 07.10.10 at 6:41 pm }

Gee thanks Anon….Polly loves a picture

157 Anonymous { 07.10.10 at 6:45 pm }
158 CG { 07.10.10 at 6:46 pm }

Isn’t Wordle cool. Looks like it is picking up poster names and names of posters appearing in posts!

On a more serious note: PETA is now weighing in and calling for Paul’s release! :-)

http://bit.ly/bS2Xto

159 Anonymous { 07.10.10 at 6:49 pm }

At least that Paul was right

160 Anonymous { 07.10.10 at 6:58 pm }

one Paul is psychic
the other Paul is psychotic

one Paul is an oracle
the other is an a-hole

161 Sourkraut { 07.10.10 at 7:15 pm }

Airwalk
i’m not sure which post upset paul. I only looked at the one about Zumbo’s little splatterpissery.
Now I am thoroughly depressed. Are people really so insecure or stupid that they have to go like a bunch of try-hards to instantly buy some crap seen on Masterchef cos it must be grate if its on there.
No wonder advertising works
No wonder idiots buy handeeswipe
No wonder the crap show has 2 million viewers. Shit a brick that ARSEHOLE Goballs would have been proud of this effort
no wonder we have the state govt that we have had for 16 looooooooooooonnnnnnnnngggggggggggg years.

162 Anonymous { 07.10.10 at 7:20 pm }

Pauls comment @ 19 above echoes Mel Gibson trying to sue the mother of his newest child for contempt of court for releasing(allegedly) tapes of him ranting on.

163 AniMotek { 07.10.10 at 7:27 pm }

@dmc: Most of the eliminations have been at about the level of the satay sauce so I’m not sure why you thought that this one in particular should make any more sense – people have gotten whacked for not being able to whip cream quick enough, or calling mint “spearmint” so why should things be different now? I’d love to see eliminations (and the whole contest, for that matter) be more about showing how well the contestants actually cook when left to their own devices but that’s not what the show has done up to now. Therefore, complaining about Marion leaving on a single dish elimination seems a bit unrealistic.

164 Anonymous { 07.10.10 at 7:31 pm }

Exactly AniMotek, you hit it on the head although I haven’t noticed them cooking. Running, hiking, getting out of bed, talking to camera…but cooking: I missed that bit(but if Callum, Jimmy or Aaron are in the fnal 2 it will become a comedy)

165 Anonymous { 07.10.10 at 8:34 pm }

Comment 162 is referring to 153

166 Sourkraut { 07.10.10 at 8:46 pm }

Anonymous 164
It already is!
Glad i did not read the thing at 19. Its rather sad ALL ROUND

167 Anonymous { 07.10.10 at 8:49 pm }

Sourkraut How was your pizza? If you are full watch this (if not it should make you hungry especially Part 3)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eqbTRLIOsdw&feature=channel

168 Reality Raver { 07.10.10 at 10:23 pm }

Well I am about to dish out a bit of “spank and fluff” to quote Gary Mehigan -

Paul, CG and Airwalk,
I have had an absolute gutful of the shenanigans that continues to go on this blog.

1. This is about reality TV which is meant to be fun and lighthearted, and I think I am really lucky to have a blog where the majority of the comments are witty, intelligent and respectful.

2. All three of your comments ARE like that, EXCEPT when they are directed to each other.

3. It is unpleasant for me, and possibly is for other readers. (Some people have contacted me about the ongoing squabbling.)

4. Currently and for the next 2 weeks due to the Masterchef phenomenon, I will have my highest readership for the year (though I am expecting The X Factor to be big), with 1000′s of new people hitting the blog daily. This is a time where I have the opportunity to increase my readership.

5. I will be drafting a comments policy that will be posted over the next few days. I would appreciate it if it was adhered to.

169 gandke { 07.10.10 at 10:24 pm }

I agree with CG { 07.09.10 at 6:53 am } ..and others with similar posts. We have to always keep in mind that, regardless of the stated and perceived aims of the show, at the bottom line are ratings and money.My guess is that Marion will be very successfull with her “line of food” and Aaron (although clearly an inferior chef to most of the contestents), will have his own show…on the 10 Network…that will capitalise on both his experiences in the “Rock N Roll” industry and his “sucesses” in MasterChef. But, of course, I may just be a cynic.

170 Pollywaffle { 07.10.10 at 11:45 pm }

Like Soil through the drum sieve so are the Masterchef Debates of our Blog

171 MC Masochist 1 { 07.11.10 at 12:45 am }

CG Think we could skip the ‘odds’ this week and put 8 pics in a tank with some morsels and see which one Paul picks? Sourkraut and Pollywaffle to choose the morsels to match up with each amata chef?

172 MC Masochist 1 { 07.11.10 at 12:56 am }

RR…sorry was just jealous you missed me out of the spank and fluff :)

173 Pollywaffle { 07.11.10 at 1:02 am }

RR, if you can just refocus on stuff that includes ‘spank and fluff’ with ‘Adam Melonas’, forget the MC final 2 weeks, that alone will ensure your site will burn a mighty hole into the earths core

174 Pollywaffle { 07.11.10 at 1:03 am }

MCM1 -Unfortunately I’ve heard Paul ( Octopaulie) loves a fish curry

175 MC Masochist 1 { 07.11.10 at 1:52 am }

Nah Pollywaffle to make it a real competition ya gotta match up each amata cook with some morsel…eg. Aaron=mexican pasta…Callum=dessert or Clearisil etc etc(you would come up wif some classeeks)? Or you saying Paul likes Jimmy?

176 Pollywaffle { 07.11.10 at 1:57 am }

Tis right, Paul goes for a rancid curry at any time of day/night…but if we bait him with a sea sponge ( Callum lamington)…he might crossover

177 Reality Raver { 07.11.10 at 10:05 am }

MC Masochist – I have rectified that now.

178 Pollywaffle { 07.11.10 at 11:35 am }

Now these are the challenges you’d expect to see for each possible elimination if it was the fairest possible MC -

Callum – Spotted Dick
Alvin – Mee (not) Goreng ( you are)
Claire – Scientologist Slice
Aaron – INXS XO Tex-Mex Corn Chip Amuse Bouche
Jimmy- Yum-Yak Curry with Roti
Jonno – Rheeeeeubarb Fool
Adam – SueShe (and He while you’re at it)
Courtney – Lobster Parma

179 Sourkraut { 07.11.10 at 2:08 pm }

MCM1
I think Paul The octopus is Kaput. I had seafood pizza (not masterchef calss crap) which had occy on it. Anonymous 167 It was great. Thanks for the link . Have not looked at it yet, but certainly will this pm
Raver 168
Halleleujah!

180 Sourkraut { 07.11.10 at 5:38 pm }

Injera
Hot elimination
I got dem ole lumpy sate blues
Hot chestnuts
just wanna do it in my shoes
OLE

181 Sourkraut { 07.11.10 at 5:52 pm }

Anonymous 167
That PORK looked AWsum!!!!!!!1
Pity about the waiter with the tatooed arms
Was also waiting for the Mr Creosote syndrome to kick in

182 hine { 07.12.10 at 7:57 am }

Looks like Paul might have been right-Spain just scored(any luck getting him to pisk the Masterchef winner as suggested above?)

183 Dianne { 11.10.10 at 5:08 am }

I am watching Masterchef Australia, here in NZ at the moment. Have to say it is a lot better than the first round. At least we don’t have to watch Julie, dishing up uncooked food, and crying every five minutes. The talent is so much better. I have enjoyed this series so much more. Anyone of the last 6 contestants could win.

184 reality raver { 11.10.10 at 9:38 am }

Dianne – it was an ongoing debate on this blog about which season had the strongest cooks. It was another great series.

185 claud kruger { 11.16.10 at 5:25 am }

Sorry but the first season cured me to watch any more of this bad show,good production though.Did the jugdges really think they would do what they did without the viewers realizing whats going on?and Curtis sorry dude no more credibillty in my books any more.

186 Dianne { 11.16.10 at 8:53 am }

I wasn’t going to watch the second series, but you know how one gets hooked into these shows, and it is on at 5pm in the evening here, so it is at a time that doesn’t interfere with programs I enjoy at that time. I see everyone is saying Marion should of won. Well oddly she is about the only one, that I find thinks she is better than everyone else. I am not keen on her attitude.

Leave a Comment