for those who have reality tv as their guilty pleasure
Reality Ravings | Australia's leading Reality TV blog!

Masterchef Australia – Molecular Gastronomy – You Mean The Foam And Liquid Nitro Challenge?

I thought the molecular gastronomy based theme was a really difficult challenge, and something you might see on Top Chef where they are professional chefs. Even Gordon Ramsay on his show Hell’s Kitchen would not even touch it with his diner trained contestants, hell he does not even let them sous vide on that program.

Masterchef Australia is really starting to heat up, maybe due to the lower amount of contestants (after tomorrow only ten left ) so we actually get to see what they can do. Also I thought the Matt Preston of old was on the judging panel. Passionate, articulate and evocative without having to ham it up.

Tonight they ditched the humiliating team selection and just divided the line down the middle. Brent Savage of The Bentley Bar in Sydney (which has had some amazing reviews), and Ryan Squires who is a top Brisbane chef  were the mentors/advisers.

The brief was toe] create a three course meal to a set theme being as creative  as possible, that is using molecular gastronomy. So in short hand this could be the foam and liquid nitrogen challenge.

The blue team I thought pulled the short straw and got the carnival theme so had to be inspired by the food you would get at Luna Park or at a circus. So they were looking at fairy floss, popcorn and dagwood dogs, because really what else is there?

Whereas the red team had the beach theme so they naturally went with seafood. Which made me wonder what the red team were actually thinking of making when Claire said to camera ”Ryan has made us focus on the natural aspects of the beach rather then the man made elements… it really changed how we were thinking about it.”

I am not quite sure what elements on a beach are not natural.

Callum hinted they were thinking of the coconut smell of suntan lotion. Which turned up  in dessert in a coconut ice cream. I was surprised he used  coconut essence to flavour it and not real coconut or coconut cream.  Or maybe I am being harsh, maybe the point of molecular gastronomy is not to use real ingredients at all.

There was some drama in the blue kitchen with Brent rejecting a lot of their dish selections like scallops with liquorice topping. Aaron was not happy with Brent kyboshing the blue teams menu saying “I am not feeling great, I am not feeling inspired.”

And they really seemed to struggle all challenge.

Jono told Skye she that she needed 10 gms of gellin in the popcorn ice cream however he did appear to convey he was not 100 per cent sure. That turned the ice-cream in to glug, but to give Jono his due he did fix it. It was later reveal by the judges that you only needed .05 grams per litre of ice-cream mix. Jono and Skye obviously don’t know what the molecular means in molecular gastronomy. I also don’t know why they did not ask Brent Savage how much they would need.

In the red kitchen Adam was blowtorching sword fish, and Matt was blowing out blue bottles. I query where there were a few breaches in the food standards with Matthew’s technique.

In both kitchen’s it looked like it was going pear shaped but in the last 10 seconds it all comes together and the requisite number of plates were served up.

Jonathan had a quick slash at Aaron saying “We should have had our food served up an hour ago”. How can you have scallops sitting their for an hour? I note that Aaron had toned himself down this week and was not as bossy.

The first team to be judged was the blue team on the Carnival theme. Joanne had decorated the room to look like a low rent version of Posh and Becks wedding reception. The judges were critical that there was no popcorn or fairy floss smell when they entered the room, maybe they should have hired a dwarf from an acting agency  to serve the dinner to get that carnie atmosphere going.

The blue teams entree of scallops with beetroot and chips was meant to be inspired by a ferris wheel. Gary thought a ferris wheel was round and this dish was not. Aaron squirmed and said the scallops were round and the beetroot started off as round.

Matt Preston thought the beetroot puree dominated to much, but George liked the chips.

There main was a Deconstructed Dagwood Dog, with mustard being served in a toothpaste dispenser I thought was pretty inspired. And I now know pork is the meat in a pluto pup. But Gary was not happy because there was no frankfurt element to the dish nor sweet tomato sauce. Clearly he was in need of his daily fat and salt fix.

However the judges loved Skye’s Popcorn Icecream even though the blue vodka topping did not light up. Matt thought the dessert was the one dish that captured the essence of the challenge.

The red team’s room received a more favourable response, as did their very clever amuse bouche, surf lifesaver tang with raspberry jelly.

I was a bit bemused that Matt was so complimentary about it saying there was a lot of tantic acid and sugar.

First up was Marion’s dish of Rockpool Squid with tomato and kombu consomme. George  loved it but Matt thought the squid was too slimey.

The main of Kingfish and crispy prawns received the praise from Matt that it was one of the best dishes in the competition so far.

“Beautifully executed” said George.

But Callum and Matthew’s dessert did not fair as well. The Suntan lotion ice cream with lemon cake did not taste or evoke the beach.

It was a no-brainer that the red team would win and they would go to lunch with David Change of Momofuku fame. For those reality TV junkies, David Chang worked for a number of years for Tom Collichio, who is a judge on Top Chef.

The blue team face elimination. The interesting thing is the whole blue team are up. First a basic skills test where they have to cook a nominated dish. Blog read NT Kate had only just commented today that these sorts of tests should be elimination challenges to test their food knowledge, rather then the taste test.

However the bottom two from that challenge will face a taste test with the loser being eliminated. I hope Channel Ten have not stuffed up their editing as it implied Jonathan and Aaron were the bottom two.  I am hoping there will be some production company manipulation and Sharnee will be eliminated.

Related Posts

53 comments

1 KC { 06.09.10 at 11:26 pm }

Oh no the blue team lost again? Oh dear…T___T…

And Aaron and Jono? They’re like my 2nd and 3rd contestants!! NO T_____________T I also majorly hope that its Sharnee…But I bet you she’ll be lucky this week again…

2 rusty { 06.09.10 at 11:28 pm }

Is it blue or Aaron that is unlucky? He’s now consistently failing to meet the designated performance criteria.

and I didn’t think he handled being team leader any better this time, either.

Sharnee won’t go – she wasn’t in the sneak preview picture. It must be JoJo or Aaron, surely?

3 sourkraut { 06.09.10 at 11:28 pm }

johnno….. Use the fooorrrrcce Johnno… let the recipe go and use the fooorrce Trust your instinct etc etc.
Alvin and the chipmunks or Alvin and wonder woman and supergirl and the 2 boy wonders
Dishes appeared to be magically plated in the last 30 seconds. Must be einsteins time dilation theory…. the faster you go approaching light speed time slows down… (or is it the opposite, either way a molecular thingummy) Or perhaps its time flies when you’re having fun.
WTF is a calcium bath? something in caves that forms stalactites… Really geting to the TRY HARD stage in this pathetic desperate desire to CREATE something post-modern BAH!
Red team decor Matt sniffs the air and says it smels like a boat shed, but I failed to see the dunny door off the prawn trawler.
Ah yes the Phallus shaped ferris wheels (left over oysters)?
Are Geo and Matty babes falling out? some contradictory judging at last. Pity none of them know what they are talking about.
Anyway less bah at the start and slightly less flashbacks helped.
A REASONABLY ENTERTAINING EP

4 sourkraut { 06.09.10 at 11:32 pm }

Raver
The unnatural elements on the beach are molecularly gastrowotsy silicon bags

5 Anon { 06.10.10 at 12:03 am }

Sourkrout – LOL

The whole concept of Molecular Gastronomy is bit of a wank.

Hopefully, Jonathan is not up for elimination tomorrow as he is seems have alot more skill than heretofore revealed.

6 pollywaffle { 06.10.10 at 12:14 am }

RR – yikes also to the bodgey bluebottles – complete with Matt Slag – that dish so disses on potato bracelets

Carnival challenge? – what are we looking for? Vomit aroma under the big dipper? good point but hard to execute in a 3 hour challenge as vomit foam wouldnt stabilise ; 3 laughing clowns with mouths wide open? say no more

The Beach Challenge? – Used condoms anywhere? Nup,any sign of a whale? Perfect!

Other observations defying Newton’s laws of Gastrophysics…

… since when can foam be tall? [I guess if you’re not tall yourself you can always live your life through your foam]

… fennel 3 ways will create a vortex of infinity ( in terms of number of trips to the loo)

… G’s positive review in direct opposition of MP’s negative one , particularly if microherbs are involved, as a necessary but not sufficient condition, will create a vacuum of comment from that point on. The atmosphere will collapse thus rendering no oxygen for subsequent lighting of poncy desserts

… don’t know why anyone didn’t attempt the obvious carnival dessert – 100 year old refried donuts

[Note to Aaron : please stop wearing your boy band ‘s clothes]

7 seepi { 06.10.10 at 12:21 am }

I hope I never have to eat any molecular gastronomy…. what happened to the idea of ‘use only the best and freshest ingredients and do little to them’?

8 saffronlie { 06.10.10 at 12:29 am }

I thought this ep was really interesting, and a great idea for a challenge, although perhaps the contestants should have been taught more about molecular gastronomy before starting. I also thought it odd that Callum used coconut essence to flavour the ice cream, especially as it was that ubiquitous cheap supermarket brand (which I use myself, but I’m not on Masterchef!). I was really impressed by how Jonathan stepped up to help out Skye, even if it was his mistake to begin with… and I can finally see what all those who have commented about his beard were on about. It works for him.

9 Fides { 06.10.10 at 12:29 am }

I liked the reds dessert – I thought it looked very beachy, but I realise why George was critical and thought it was nothing more than lemon cake… remember what he did to Julie’s lemon diva last year? So serving a squashed cake, crumbs, soil, sand or whatever just wouldn’t be special enough for him. Also, I don’t care that it was flavoured with coconut essence, the thought of sun screen ice cream made me feel really sick.

I think it is tricky editing which makes it look like Jono and Aaron are facing the final spice challenge. Jono did well with curry last time so hoping he can do it again.

Sour – I got a distinctly phallic impression of the ferris wheel with the positioning of the two scallop balls – embarrassed to admit it reminded me straightaway of one particular scene from one of the Austin Powers movies.

10 pollywaffle { 06.10.10 at 12:30 am }

skt – agree there is a weird vibe with Matt & G. Maybe its a Greek thing about breaking a plate on a Sunday?

11 AnonyMousse { 06.10.10 at 12:51 am }

I’m still not sure what was molecular about the fish – it looked like a fairly normally cooked dish to me.

Putting that aside though, the entire episode was worth it for the long shots of George in that gigantic chair. He looked hilarious.

12 Airwalk { 06.10.10 at 4:23 am }

Mousse-I agree Geo was like an oopla loompa in that chair especially next to the giant aka MP. OK challenge(felt a little bit Top Chef and prefer the division of teams randomly…go the knife draw ala tc) and good to see them getting back to basics tomorrow…but how is cooking a curry getting back to basics? Poach an egg without gladrap, make an omlette, trim or bone a cut of meat…oh a million things…but liking the show this week…
I think its getting better as the past 3 weeks have been droll…Aaron to go tomorrow I hope. Him drying a sieve while screaming at everyone was tiresome and don’t think Jon was happy being on his team.
I was a bit confused as one second Claire was shopping and the next frame she was waling behind Adam and guest chef (i am liking Adam…and as always Marion)
Thanks RR for your blog…

13 Airwalk { 06.10.10 at 4:35 am }

And what did Jon say to Geo when he was giving him the shits when rolling the pork?

14 Airwalk { 06.10.10 at 4:46 am }

pw:i think matt as jealous about the big chair-oh matt likes real food and geo lurves mg

15 dmc { 06.10.10 at 7:14 am }

I’ve bagged the editors on this show a lot, but not even they could be so incompetent as to let us know beforehand who the bottom two would be.

16 rusty { 06.10.10 at 8:13 am }

Airwalk,

Jono said, “hope, George, hope” when asked what he was using to make the pork set.

Is that what you were asking?

I’m liking Adam more and more this week. But maybe I’m just being manipulated by the editing … though I’ve always liked JoJo, despite the editing and everyone’s attempts to cast her as a rubbish cook, self-absorbed non-team playing, bad hair, …blah, blah, blah

17 NT Kate { 06.10.10 at 8:18 am }

Enjoyable ep – interesting challenge, and good to see Matt actually say something concrete and real about the food (and good to see a bit of disagreement between the judges).

I agree it would have been good for them to have been given a bit of instruction upfront (that we were let in on!) about molecular gastronomy though, perhaps rather than or during visits to the beach/luna park?

As in the last time external mentors were used, it wasn’t clear that they were all that helpful to the teams’ causes, and in fact may have helped along Blue’s loss (didn’t seem to give much leadership or focus while at Luna Park – when he could have been giving them the gastronomy cooking mini-course, vetoed most of their ideas unfortunate when they lost for not being innovative enough, and where was he when they needed to know how much nitro to use or to taste dishes?).

Maybe the mentors should give a mini-masterclass upfront and be available to answer technical questions along the way rather than dictating what the teams menus can and can’t include?

And yes, surely the taste off should be between Joanne and Sharnee!

Personally I think you are all being a bit hard on Aaron – I still quite like him despite some obvious weaknesses (viz clothes, headgear, and general food knowledge!). He has clearly cooked some excellent dishes along the way, and I saw his attempts to cajole Joanne along, and get her out of the ‘I can’t do it’ whinge in the oyster shucking fiasco as a positive rather than a negative!

18 librarygirl { 06.10.10 at 10:10 am }

It was interesting to see it done but this sort of Frankensteinish-Milton-the-Monster style of cooking doesn’t appeal to me at all.
I would have preferred Skye’s dessert and the dawg and beetroot chips rather than anything the red team put up – particularly the slimy squid.
I wonder how the blokey bloke judges from last Sunday night would have rated/scored the dishes?

19 pollywaffle { 06.10.10 at 10:22 am }

Did anyone else notice the Matt P’s assessment and pronoucement of the winning team was edited by Edward Scissorhands? ‘Red team, that was the mostest, bestest ( pan to Blue team ) and also the least wonderous ( pan to Blue), innovative, ( pan L, pan R, then back to Red team)
Or, the more likely explanation, the 3 wise monkeys know jack about MG.

I think the show should keep the carnival set – really suited the judging panel

20 Fides { 06.10.10 at 10:34 am }

And it was also really obvious from the blues body language that they’d lost before the announcement was made. Pretty well all of them had slumped shoulders, bowed heads and just looked like they wanted to be put out of the misery. Makes me wonder how good the reds praise/blues criticisms were that we didn’t see.

NTKate – well said about Aaron. Though I’ve never liked him and find him such an enigma I also found his encouraging of Jo a positive. Though when I mentioned it on the MC forum, I’m told he’s just making alliances (albeit with Jo) and is just playing the game!

Also, we’ve all seen Jo’s special Thursday elimination hair, but does Jono also reserve the pink shirt for the Thursday episodes? I swear he’s worn it a lot on team elim challenges.

21 TDK { 06.10.10 at 10:38 am }

My observation – the whole episode is quite tacky I thought – correction: the whole series is very tacky.
They’ve run out of ideas to entertain and so came up with this.

22 MelbaToast { 06.10.10 at 10:44 am }

Yawn – whilst this challenge showed a bit more of the contestants cooking, I struggle to call what they were acutally doing “cooking”…it was more like a grade 9 science experiment. I keep expecting someone to lose their eyebrows in a small calcium bath explosion.

It’s funny that there is a whole organic food movement about taking chemicals out of our food…and then we have molecular crapstronomy putting it all back in.

I think the challenge was a little unfair in that how many of our these amateur cooks would know anything about this hocus pocus way of cooking – it’s not really the sort of stuff people practice with at home, so they were all out of their depth really (and a lot of the plates just ended up looking like normal food to me).

The mentors seemed total hopeless – the blue team might have done better without their ‘helper’.

Pollywaffle – your comments were hilarious. Nearly chocked on my coffee at a few of your comments.

23 Culinary Boner { 06.10.10 at 10:45 am }

librarygirl, Milton-the-Monster cooking is a hilarious description of this wank-a-rama of a cuisine and very apt to this episode with Johnno totally arsing up the quantities of Gellin.
How did that show’s theme go again…
“And now for a tinture of…Gellin…but I must use only a touch…(nah, what the fuck… let’s just ‘go with the force’ as sourkraut notes and tip in, say, 200 times the recommended amount)…whoops too much, better hold Skye’s hand it’s startiing to tick, better hold Skye’s hand I’m feeling sick…*the creation emerges*…I’m Gellin icecream, you brand new son *the creation scans the room and its eye locks in on Matt* Dadda, Dadda!!!”.
Hey Johnno, don’t take up a career in pharmacy, mate.
They were always going to fail to reach the true heights of molecular gastronomy in this family friendly, non-SBS timeslot. Yes, I’m referring to you Heston B and your vibrating dildo trifle with ejaculating mousse. Now that would have brought a smirk to George’s lips and tear to Matt’s eye.
Back to somewhat more serious commentary, Skye’s unflappable manner and good skills have now made her my favourite. And hell, she’s even a doppelganger of her namesake Skye Gyngell.

24 Colls Bolls { 06.10.10 at 10:53 am }

I liked the disagreement between Gary & George over the sea dessert. I’d only commented to my husband a few minutes before that Matt & George had such different opinions of the squid entree but there was no questioning of one another’s views. I want to see them openly disagree with one another rather than have such differing opinions with no clarification.

Similarly, when Brent Savage dissed the Blue team’s entree, there was no discussion as to why, just a yes from Aaron. I hope that it was just editing and that Brent & Aaron discussed the issues so that Aaron & Sharnee could move on.

@Culinary Boner: LOL :D

25 Injera { 06.10.10 at 11:11 am }

Sourkraut, thanks for explaining the time-theory – I was very surprised to see three times three plates at the end given that at the 30 seconds to go mark we were looking at nothing on plates. Now I understand!

Aaron’s been taking lessons from Marco Pierre White: “Sharnee! Where are my scallops?” “Two minutes, chef!” [Chef?] “You’ve got ONE MINUTE!”. Of course, because magical chefs can control time (see Sourkraut’s theory above). I always found that frustrating in HK and no less so now. Of course, the scallops were perfectly cooked, so… I guess they only needed a minute.

Fides: The blue entree really was quite blue, wasn’t it?

26 Laura { 06.10.10 at 11:22 am }

I don’t care who goes as long as it’s not Skye.

27 Suzanne { 06.10.10 at 11:57 am }

Really enjoyed this episode. I like the idea of taking the flavour of a food and then playing with it to create a totally different texture. That to me is the benefit of the whole molecular gastronomy movement.
Would have liked to see a lot more of the instruction from the chefs and actual making of the dishes.
Thought Jono was hilarious when he was saying to Skye – “I don’t know how much gellin to add” – several times, and then throws out 10 grams as a random number. Why she bothered to even listen to him I have no idea. Also thought he slipped the knife in Aaron’s back when he said they should have started plating an hour ago – what was he thinking?? I think Aaron’s lucky it wasn’t “nominate yourself or a team member for elimination” week.
As for Joanne’s lucky plait? I think (hope) the luck has finally run out.

28 Muru { 06.10.10 at 1:05 pm }

I have to laugh at how the fictionalisation of Joanne is getting you all worked up. Why let her bother you that much? Her persona was created by the producers to annoy you.

Anyway, I’m guessing that Aaron will be going home tonight but I’m hoping that the producers choose to kill off Sharnee. I definitely agree with you RR that she’ll most likely cruise to final’s week, just like Sam did last year. Correct me if I’m wrong, but I don’t think any of her dishes have landed in the top 3?

Oh, and Adam’s a tart.

29 rusty { 06.10.10 at 1:09 pm }

Funny how people stick the knife into some contestants every time no matter what, and not others. No matter what they do or say, it’s always them, not their favs, that are at fault.

Take Jonno – Skye asks for help, He says he doesn’t know, she keeps on so he suggest a figure. It doesn’t work. He, not she, then takes responsibility and solves the problem. The dessert gets the thumbs up. She smiles. Her rep with desserts is enhanced but Doesn’t mention her need to ask someone else to work it out for her.

Response from the crowd:

sourkraut -
“johnno….. Use the fooorrrrcce Johnno… let the recipe go and use the fooorrce Trust your instinct” (very funny, of course- sour is the best) -but the Force obviously favours him over Skye – he must be Obi Won -cos’ he solved the problem, not her and without the little hairy bat guy. Unlike his fellow contestants this week – Skye, Aaron, Adam – who all needed to seek the guidance of a higher power of some balding god.

Suzanne -
“Why she bothered to even listen to him I have no idea.” Hmm, perhaps because she knew he could be the man and fix it for her, when she didn’t know what to do

CulinaryBoner –

“Johnno totally arsing up the quantities of Gellin. better hold Skye’s hand it’s startiing to tick” and ” “Skye’s unflappable manner and good skills have now made her my favourite.’ – what skills? can’t rescue a failed dessert. Hold HER hand? other way round. She gets in a tizz (even the voice0over mentioned that) and runs around getting help. couldn’t shuck oysters the other day ( me, neither) – she got in a tizz and had to get (male) help again.

How would Skye manage without all these men getting in her way? How will she cope tonight with a non-dessert? And why don’t they give the group an organic, vegan, macrob challenge so she can shine on her own merits?

No one ever gives her the non-desserts in the team challenge – obviously they know the Force is not with her.

30 akris { 06.10.10 at 1:15 pm }

I’m thinking that Joanne will go, or will be in danger of going.. Sharnee will be safe as she wasn’t in the preview at all. Usually when Joanne (or anyone) is safe the preview will show them struggling, making it seem like they’re next out.. this time around Joanne showed optimism in the preview in her determination to make top 10.. therefore she’s out… Channel 10′s attempt at reverse psychology so far has been very transparent.. we’ll see if I’m right tonight….

I don’t dislike Joanne.. she says it how it is.. Aaron is still in my ‘dislike’ list from his cowardly leadership last week.. i was actually hoping this was also a ‘team vote’ elimination.. that way someone, Jono, would have the guts to put Aaron in his place.

31 Suzanne { 06.10.10 at 1:29 pm }

Hi Rusty
Neither Jono nor Skye are my favourites. I just thought it was an interesting situation. And, considering that it was Jono who suggested the amount, I think it was his responsibility to (help her) fix it.
But the more important questions are:
Where was their chef/mentor when the question of gellin ratio had to be asked?
I think George later inferred that you had to read the instructions on the packet – did they?

32 rusty { 06.10.10 at 2:11 pm }

Hi Suzanne,

I know. Your comment just fitted with my comment!
I’m not sure I really like any of them, but I still have some I favour over others, usually the underdogs, though I wouldn’t put Jono in that category.

but then; while writing all that, I was multi-tasking several reports and my rising dough over-inflated and fell flat on its face and I was redeeming it in a vaguely similar way to the way Jono might, rather than throwing it away, so I probably identified with him at that moment.

but yes, what use was that mentor? And why didn’t they read the instructions? After all, that’s what they’ve been doing all this time – following instructions.

- I always thought Molecular Gastronomy was supposed to be very scientific and exact.

33 Suzanne { 06.10.10 at 2:18 pm }

I can see the spin-off show now – “Jono’s Cooking Redemptions”! :-) As seen in such challenges as the spag bog redemption vs Adele (I think??) and the popcorn/ gellin ice-cream. I did have to laugh when he put it in the blender and then through the sieve – I have used that exact same method for lumpy cheese sauce or gravy!

34 Airwalk { 06.10.10 at 2:41 pm }

Rusty, thanks yeah thats at I as asking…as hoping he was saying don’t george don’t…:)

35 NT Kate { 06.10.10 at 2:45 pm }

I’m never going to try cooking this style personally, but I do think it was legitimate to present it given its currency in the food world. And there are at least some aspects of it (playing with textures, sifting of old wives tales from fact) that are useful and could have been highlighted a bit more.

Rusty – I agree with you on the negative takes on Johnno’s intervention. He was pestered into answering and I can understand why he did even if he shouldn’t have, and did a good job in salvaging the situation.

Airwalk – I think the really basic basics like cooking an egg should have been done earlier in the piece. At this point of the competition, checking that they have the classic dishes down – which for Australians surely includes stirfries and curries – seems like a reasonably good test to me. Certainly better than guess the object swimming in the pot, distinguish between an emu and ostrich egg, or guess the herb (or spice) based on appearance!

If it were up to me, I’d be getting them to make a few different types of pastry, the standard sauces, cook a risotto (and break the fatal run on the series of this dish!), make a coq au vin, etc etc! Then in the last few weeks bring out the croquembouche type challenges once the sheep have been sorted from the goats….

36 Airwalk { 06.10.10 at 2:58 pm }

NT Kate-yeah I agree totally, its a bit late in the contest to go right back to basics but I suppose I am trying to say they virtually go straight into challenges against chefs and now they seem to go back to basics which now highlights how weak they really are and also they show that they are pretty clueless during other episodes…eg. gormless Callum throing a whole dirty potato in a pot of water expecting it to cook within 30 minute. Starting with basic tests early would weed out the clueless and show growth.

37 Culinary Boner { 06.10.10 at 3:35 pm }

Hey Rusty, yep, the game’s up, you pinned me in one.
Yep I am biased against he of the mad eyes, banal corporate chatter and people management skills of Dilbert’s boss – Johnno. And have to ‘fess up to being deeply in lurve with MCA’s resident Tantric Love Goddess – she of the dyed gold-brown tresses with the soft aural caress of a Dolphin Love CD soundtrack – Skye.

Maybe I was a bit too hard on Johnno. Afterall he was badgered so incessantly and mercilessly by Skye, what else could he do but make shit up about an ingredient I’m sure we will never hear of again? Must stop be unfair to Johnnyboy. Now write that 100 time, you bad Boner.

38 Reality Raver { 06.10.10 at 4:15 pm }

Just a few comments:
I actually think it is a bit unfair that Joanne is having to fight it out for elimination this week as she was really not involved in the cooking in this episode, just the decorations. If it was just three going up for it she should not be it. However it is all in.

I hope it is a furphy re: Jono and Aaron going head to head in the bottom two. Jono is fast becoming one of may favourites, direct, makes decisions and prepared to take responsibility and can cook.

Both Skye and Jono need to get reading glasses they both seemed to cursorily look at the instructions, or they need to brush up on their maths. I suspect the issue was the latter.

They must have briefed the contestants on how to use the ingredients and equipment, otherwise how could you even come up with a menu.

I think Brent Savage looked nervous, but may have been correct in kyboshing scallop with a liquorice topping. But then again to quote Bon Jovi if you are going to go out go out in a “blaze of glory”.

Ryan did appear to give a bit more direction.

I hope Aaron stays in a bit longer, but they have been giving him a lot of TV loving which may be ominous. I am hoping Sharnee for the fall.
Joanne gives good TV and ok food. Sharnee gives neither.

39 pollywaffle { 06.10.10 at 4:51 pm }

Oi, am I too late for the beach challenge….

‘Budgie smuggler’ – Soft Capsicum pouch sous vide with aged parmesan cheese, stuffed with poached peacock eggs straddling crisp,dried seaweed arrangement ;

Beach shag – olive ‘bikini’ with burnt brazillian butter mounted by caramelised pork belly skewered with stoned crabstick atop a ‘texture towel’ of striped cucumber, radish and turnip with potato fringe and mini alcopop reduction

40 Injera { 06.10.10 at 4:58 pm }

Pollywaffle, I am so glad I was neither eating nor drinking when I read that comment!

41 TDK { 06.10.10 at 5:15 pm }

pollywaffle – a picture tells a thousand words, can you sketch your nominated dishes please? RR/Injera – I’m sure you can work out some graphics post for this?

42 MelbaToast { 06.10.10 at 5:17 pm }

As long as it doesn’t look like a Ferris Wheel it sounds like it could be a winner. Would the judges eat that whilst lying on said towel of “cucumber, radish and turnip with potato fringe and mini alcopop reduction”.

43 RarelySeen { 06.10.10 at 5:27 pm }

Airwalk: Hilarious re G’s resemblance to an Oompa Loompa in the big chair.
Melba Toast: Fabulous comment re the eyebrows in the calcium bath explosion lol
Pollywaffle: love your take on the beach theme, maybe it’s time to try a different beach?
Keen to see Sharnee or Aaron go. Hope it’s not poor little Alvin.

44 Fides { 06.10.10 at 5:29 pm }

Polly, perhaps that is what the reds had in mind before their mentor directed them towards the natural aspects of the beach.

Whoever suggested the Masterchef Uplate (was it on another thread? I’m all confused) – they really ought to have a true food porn challenge and revisit the adult version of the Dagwood dog (and don’t forget Gary wants it on a stick).

45 Culinary Boner { 06.10.10 at 5:52 pm }

I’ll have one of them ‘beach shag’ thingies, thanks pollywaffle…brazillian style, ona stick, if you please. Does it come with an umbrella?

46 pollywaffle { 06.10.10 at 6:00 pm }

Fides ,Yes we all saw how disappointed Gary was with the ‘John Wayne Bobbit’ Dagwood, and little Georgie didnt quite get why he got served the little squirt

47 Fides { 06.10.10 at 6:28 pm }

Yeah George was quite put out about getting the wee tube. Did you see his dear little face scrunch up?

Polly, quite seriously, you ought to write an anti MC book. No doubt channel 10 would fight you all the way, but it would be a Christmas best seller!

48 brain dead dave { 06.10.10 at 9:54 pm }

The only reason for me to watch has been eliminated…Roll on Masterfrump!!

49 NT Kate { 06.11.10 at 2:35 pm }

Hmm, 30 mins seems far to short to me – from a food safety point of view as much as anything else, given that they probably had to spend more than a few minutes working out what the spices were (I noticed they all dashed for the spices first – if I’d been doing it I think I would have started cooking the chicken first, so there was at least a chance of it being cooked, even if that meant sacrificing the spice taste a bit.

And five spices to make a curry?! I haven’t found any korma recipe that is that barebones.

A good test of skill though – shame that some of the one’s who have been looking better panicked (or perhaps were suffering too much from flu, stress and lack of sleep!). And a shame that the judges’ prejudices dictated the selection of too bland (too much yoghurt) over spicy (too much chilli).

I do think this was too short – agree that it would have been good to see more of the curry being cooked more or less correctly (Alvin). Would also have been nice to know which spices each one selected (and thought they were selecting?).

Bring on those spoilers Raver!

50 sourkraut { 06.11.10 at 3:22 pm }

rusty
I wasnt going to bother at first, but if you read previous posts of mine you would find me criticising Alvin, who I have previously said is one of my faves, likewise i also criicised joanne heavily at the start but switched to her when everyone decided to hate her.There have also been others but its not worth the effort of writing them all down for you.
So dont make inconsistent silly statements thank you

51 NT Kate { 06.12.10 at 10:22 am }

Hmm, my post here at 49 was supposed to be on the curry challenge, oops, sorry – feel free to delete it RR!

52 Melbourne Food Depot { 06.14.10 at 8:29 pm }

Oh RR,
This was the EP that we supplied product and I went to Sydney to advise on in March 2010. Everyone had an extensive briefing regarding the products including the guest chefs & producers. It turns out that the guest chefs were not allowed to have any input, they were more like sounding boards for ideas without supplying a strong direction to the contestants.

Being in the control room watching Skye put the whole packet of Gellan Gum into the ice cream I knew what was going to happen. I expressed this to the producers and they were wrapped that it was a stuff up. Once it was on film Brent came out of the blue teams kitchen into the control room and we both figured out a way to save it. This was then passed onto Jonno to save it. GC was also happy that it had happened but I wanted him to mention that it is so important to read the label and know your percentages when using gums. This he did and really brought home the skill level required for progressive (molecular) gastronomy.

It was a really long hard day in Reality land starting at 5.30am finally leaving the location at 4pm. Being behind the reality curtain it is amazing how many people go into making an ep. They all work together and it is amazing what gets filmed, to what gets edited, to what gets on the box.

Overall a fantastic opportunity to showcase some of our products and get the heads up before anyone else knew. Pity I signed the disclosure statement otherwise you (RR) would have had some great scoops. Like you said a bottle of grange under the nose but being unable to smell it.

53 seo { 02.01.12 at 5:17 am }

Its like you read my mind! You appear to know a lot about this, like you wrote the book in it or something. I think that you could do with some pics to drive the message home a bit, but instead of that, this is great blog. A fantastic read. I will certainly be back.

Leave a Comment