for those who have reality tv as their guilty pleasure
Reality Ravings | Australia's leading Reality TV blog!

Masterchef Australia – The P&O Cruise PR Challenge

Yes we get it each team has to make 4000 canapes. Yes we know it was a huge challenge of providing all those canapes for the sailing away party for a P&O Cruise, but we don’t need it repeated 50 million times.

But first the team selection. Aaron was captain of the blue team and even though they had been told it was the biggest challenge ever, he picked Skye to head up the red team. Why wouldn’t you put the contestant’s with the less life skills in charge, like Sharnee or Matthew.

I seriously think Sharnee is this year’s Sam. Will she float through to final’s week, by being lucky enough to be in winning teams, or just have people who stuff up worst then her on the day.

Aaron picked Marion first, and Skye picked Peter. Jonathan was picked late, but it was Joanne who was left until last. Tonight she looked like she have been attacked by her blusher brush. Speaking of facial issues, what is with Jonathan’s beard? Is this a new thing?

Because the Red team had one less person they were given a trainee chef, which I thought it gave them an advantage of having a person who would know the equipment and know how to prep faster.

Anyway the deal was each team had four canapes to prepare, and produce 4000 of each just in case you missed it on the episode.  Aaron got to blind pick the four the blue team would do.

The blue teams canapes were:

  • Stuffed zucchini flowers,
  • Salmon sashimi,
  • Wagyu beef, pear, and parmasan,
  • Lamb chops.

The red team were to prepare:

  • Seared tuna with wasabi mayo,
  • Chicken Wings;
  • Roast Beef Canape;
  • Pork belly canape.

At first I thought that the blue team had the easier plate, however the zucchini flowers were a killer as they are so delicate and fiddly.

Aaron’s strategy was to do two canapes first and then do the other two once they have done. Ge0rge who was looking a little lost without Gary to bounce off was concerned about this. In the end Aaron had to buy an extra chef which would cost the team 100 votes, otherwise they were in danger of not getting the food out.

A few thoughts on the challenge:

  • Was the challenge good PR for P&O cruises, that blue drink was not appealing?
  • Aaron had the crazy stressed eyes  going all challenge, and was running around supervising, but not sure I saw him do much hands on work;
  • Claire looked like she had had enough when she got yelled at for putting beef on the counter. Also  realising the beef had been cut too thickly and she was only going to be able to make 280 of the required 1000 canapes made her look even more miserable. Having said that we did not see if she was the one who actually sliced it. I blame the trainee chef myself otherwise they would have shown one of the contestants slicing it.
  • George yelled at Peter at the potential of the passengers getting salmonella, if he had not further cooked the chicken wings. He said it took six hours for the illness to come on and they would have left port. Hysterical yes.
  • No surprise the crowd loved the lamb cutlets;
  • No surprise that 98 per cent of the crowd did not know what a zucchini flower was;
  • Not sure about the integrity of the voting system, yes there was a girl in a nice pink coat watching, but would she recognise if someone was voting twice;

Also thought it was ironic (in a positive way) that there was an anglo guy Mark Jensen, working at Red Lantern, a vietnamese restaurant. This was the prize for the winning team this week to have lunch and a cooking lesson at the restaurant.

The red team comprehensively won with 1138 votes versus 762 so were off to eat prawn rolls.

The twist for this elimination challenge was the team had to put up the three who would face elimination tomorrow night.

Joanne puts her hand up and accepts responsibility for the salmon and dusty tempura, Jake is unhappy he is in the firing line as he worked his patooty off, and Marion is in because she sliced one salmon incorrectly. How did Aaron dodge the potential bullet he so deserved to be there.

However now we might find out how the immunity badge works. It appears you can see what the challenge is before you decide to bail. That is an advantage.

Tomorrow night the Laksa taste test.

Share:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati
  • TwitThis
  • email
  • MySpace

Related Posts

76 comments

1 Paul { 06.02.10 at 11:03 pm }

At least we know why Aaron always gets picked last now.

Also was that a Nazi Iron Cross I saw tattooed on the neck of the head chef. Won’t have pleased the Jewish community I’d imagine.

2 pollywaffle { 06.02.10 at 11:04 pm }

Best way to experience a P&O cruise, vicariously.

Good grief – how did that ship stay afloat? All those fatties AND Matt P. Groan, pump up the lifeboats boys. P&O must have bolstered the ballast mechanism and hired plenty of slight Asians before that show. Yes, Claire your deft use of portion control with the beef might have been a good thing in hindsight

Were all those people really going on a cruise or was it an afternoon freebie for the local ‘seagulls’? (litmus test : plenty of red/blue striped elcheapo travel bags but strangely didn’t spot one).
RR agree the Menu didnt completely fit the “all you can eat crowd – forgot the kabana plus a tugboat of KFC would have easily won the challenge. ( I do worry that it takes a P&O cruise to experience prosciutto. )

George as always wonderfully inspirational – Dis challenge is ALL about ‘the power of winning’ ( or something like that)…..[didn’t you learn at school it was you know about doing your best, trying hardest, teamwork blah blah and not worrying about the prize or has the only kid with chicken oyster and feta sandwiches got something to prove to the world.]

Jake, you’re getting that fishy aroma that spells the end of your MC bream, er dream. But its laksa, maybe not

‘J-Bomb’ – if you are so ‘over eliminations’ then stop choking.

Aaron – you have to learn one thing – only George is allowed to boom boom around the kitchen, marching and a hollering and looking mighty important, and thats only on Re-launch nights, with sevan minutes to goooo, whats up with you, do you want to work in dis industry?

3 Injera { 06.02.10 at 11:13 pm }

Mark Jensen is Pauline Nguyen’s partner (Pauline and Luke are brother and sister).

Missed the team picking – thank god, it’s my least favourite part of the week – and was catching up on other things as I watched… somehow, even though I missed a lot, I think I heard every time they mentioned 4000 Canopies!

My big question was why, after 1.5 seasons, did George finally master the correct pronunciation once they were back in the Masterchef kitchen?

I reckon if it hadn’t been Claire who cut the beef too thickly, they wouldn’t have featured it – would’ve brushed it under the carpet if it had been the apprentice (and I agree – that would have been a bit of an advantage).

Good to see that Joanne took responsibility, but I really can’t see how Marion – with her one fillet is there. And how Aaron dodged it.

4 Laura { 06.02.10 at 11:15 pm }

I saw footage of Claire slicing the beef herself.

I think that Aaron made a big mistake choosing Skye as his opposition. She is well-liked and I don’t think that she has ever been in an elimination. I would have picked Jo again.

I think that they should have been able to devise their own dishes, it would have been a lot fairer. Were the people voting for their favourite dishes, or how well they were cooked?

5 nonnymouse { 06.02.10 at 11:16 pm }

And now you know why Aaron is picked last. Guy is manipulative, fake and a coward as well.

6 rusty { 06.02.10 at 11:29 pm }

Yes, now we know what Aaron’s problem is. And thumbs down to him for not taking any responsibility, even for choosing who should go for elimination.

And thumbs down for fat Matt and little G. for putting on the team. I bet if the girly team had lost you wouldn’t have made ‘em do that.

And it did seem a bit rich for little G. to be narky about Aaron’s behavior, even if G. was just carrying on in age old Chef tradition of pot calling the kettle black.

Jake, you didn’t have to be quite such a loser. If you thought you shouldn’t have been the one, then you should have said so, and put in one of the failed flower boys.

Pretty dull episode. I never wanted to go sea anyway, but certainly not on those canapes.

Sharnee must be running out of lives, soon, surely?

7 pollywaffle { 06.02.10 at 11:29 pm }

The less than subtle Aaron, clearly a fan of “House”, calls a spork a spork, and thats not appreciated in MC where you got to follow the recipe.

8 KC { 06.02.10 at 11:32 pm }

NOOOOOOO All this is making me not want to watch the episode…Aaron…Why must you do this to me???

AND TO MARION!?!?!?! Oh man if Marion gets out I WILL CRY! But definitely hoping Jake or Joanne gets out…

Oh yea why didn’t he choose Sharnee…

9 akris { 06.02.10 at 11:36 pm }

Maybe I missed something.. but did the blue team have to fillet the salmon and remove the bones as well? Was the reds one already filleted and deboned?

I feel bad for Jake.. although he should have said something.. I don’t think he deserved to be there…

I personally would’ve thought the zucchini boys and aaron should’ve been at the bottom.

10 Anon { 06.02.10 at 11:42 pm }

@Pollywaffle – are far as i understand they were ‘real’ passengers. On a P&O forum talking about the challenge a few of them were complaining that their departure was delayed because of MC.

11 sourkraut { 06.02.10 at 11:44 pm }

Well we’re on the good ship venus,
my gawd ya shoulda seen us,
the figurehead was a team in red (or blue)
trying to cook some wieners

1 trainee chef = 1 best amada chef in oz?

Back to the pop deck with matt or was that the poo chute? Avast ya scurvy scum,swab that chook, can those peas, hoist the Zuchini flowers and batten down the beef. awwk pieces of eight! and other such nautical nonsense. Would have loved to see a parrot flying round the galley (o,malley).

what an INCREDIBLY loud cheer from the passengers of the jolly roger on learning MC chefs are catering? (but was that an applause sign I saw in the wings?

Alvin Matey… there’s more than one dip on board.

Skye me hearty. Ifn u really want to “pick up the pace” try NOT stopping for a “current” live commentary every 5 minutes.

Geo, is salmonella wot u get from raw unboned brilliantly filleted (yes YOU miss immunity) salmon?

So all you Joanne haters…I think she did the right thing when Jake whose fault it was NOT took the blame on himself, and of course Doris day jumped in immediately after.

So the zuke flowers were not a big hit. Wot do you expect? It’s a bit like a lexus, you can put all the bells and whistles on it but its still just a toyota. likewise Zuke flowers. Might as well have cooked an Alaskan bull moose turd stew ( but make sure fresh ingredients are used).

The whole thing was UNFAIR. they were not comparing apples with apples by each team cooking different things with different degrees of simplicity.
For eg. FAR easier to do semi raw filleted slabs of tuna than to do unfilleted salmon.

Wrong 3 chosen. Rule 1 in the army …NEVER VOLUNTEER and the two young lads were VERY lucky not to be facing the dreaded Boning comp.

12 pollywaffle { 06.02.10 at 11:51 pm }

Skt – they were cheering because for a minute they thought they heard MC ISNT catering today. Oh well it was probably just pizza and pasta anyway

13 Anon { 06.02.10 at 11:51 pm }

Aaron, as team captain should be facing elimination tomorrow night.

The zucchini flower canape was a bit unfair, not only fiddlely but we suspect bit of an acquired taste.

Poor Jake, two elimination challenges in one week. So which J will go?

14 pollywaffle { 06.03.10 at 12:05 am }

Think P&O cleaners will be finding those Zuke Flowers in interesting places for quite a while to come

15 Lindy { 06.03.10 at 12:06 am }

Oh Sourkraut —- I soooooo want an Alaskan Bull Moose Turd Stew to be the challenge tomorrow night!!! Literally ROFLing here!

16 CG { 06.03.10 at 12:12 am }

I’ve never been on a cruise and now I’m never going to go on a cruise now – nevah! – what a gaggle of bogans!? Good Lord. Can you imagine being trapped at sea for several days with this mob?

Exactly what point is MC trying to make by having 2000 bogan hillbillies be the judges of horse-doovers involving ingredients they have never heard of?

I also want to know who sliced the beef – show me ‘da beef! I was lapsing in and out of watching but based on the editing it looked like Shanee was the guilty party but Claire wouldn’t say her/a name?

Given the bogan crowd on the boat, I’m surprised the voting was so lopsided. I woulda thunk those lamb chops scored … and Aaron was right to try and serve them last…but alas the zucchini flowers were not ready. What dishes from the red team won them so many votes…musta been the bloody chicken wings…just like Hooters!!

Very surprised Joanna effectively volunteered to go in to the elimination round given her behaviour in previous episodes where she was jumping quickly to blame someone / anyone else but her for any problems with the task. Its as if she has heard/read the feedback? Hmmm.

Is Marion throwing herself on her sword, too? It hardly seems that among the entire team she would be in the worst 3 and deserves to head to the elimination challenge? Is this yet another production call to rid Marion of the immunity pin and return to a “level playing field” and increase the tension and suspense? Aaron should have been in the bottom 3 if for no other reason than they had to bring in “help” whereas Skye’s team did not (not that the 100 votes made any difference in the end).

The taste test elimination challenge is the fairest of all challenges. Yes, the outcome can be cruel if a good cook misidentifies a variety of mint, for example. But it is a hell of a lot fairer than a “blind” taste test / confessional elimination challenge.

A few other observations: George is getting really, really fat: Georgie Porgie… he was busting out of his ill-fitting jacket tonight. And for the first time, tonight I thought Jono was looking rather attractive and sexy. Is it just the regrowth…or perhaps he just looks different because I’m on the road and watching the show from a hotel tele (or perhaps it is the red wine). Ha!

I reckon there is a lot of drama tomorrow night and either Marion will invoke her “pin” and no one will go…or Jake will put out of his misery.

17 Jenny Draut { 06.03.10 at 12:12 am }

yeah, so Aaron finally showed his true colour..don’t like him no more…no wonder he gets to be picked last…want him gone..

as for Jake, should have said something as I did think that he worked very hard to debone the poorly filleted salmon…

why Marion put her hand up? she is quite a sweet girl for doing that..dont really want her to go….

for some reason i sort of knew the red team would win…anyone had the same feeling??? maybe Aaron being arrogant

18 Fides { 06.03.10 at 12:16 am }

Sourkraut – LMAO at Doris Day. Captures the sunshine that is Marion perfectly!

I never liked Aaron, then I did, but now I don’t again…what a roller coaster! Agree he should take responsibility as team captain : his escape from being in the firing line reminds me of a particular hat wearing S1 contestant/team captain who served raw chicken in a challenge…

I hope it is Jo that goes because she did stuff up the tempura batter (though I was really feeling for her trying to whisk it) and left all the little bones inside for Jake to fix. My TV guide says it is a Thai green curry taste test, so Marion should be OK, or perhaps she’ll overthink it. But she won’t be going home, so why is she even there?

RR : even though I knew it was 4000 canapes, when I first read your recap I misread it as 40 000 and thought – hey that would have been more fun! Perhaps that’ll be for next year when they have to outdo everything that’s taken place already…

19 Jenny Draut { 06.03.10 at 12:17 am }

and O yes, Mark Jensen may be a “Gwai Lo”(white dude) he really can make great asian food particularly vietnamese. and he really is the partner of Luke Nguyen’s sister…

and what have i said all along…too many fatties around plus big fat Matt P…

he really should meet with Jenny Craig or better meet with Weight Watchers…

come on people..be healthy………

20 Asteroth { 06.03.10 at 12:21 am }

I am rather disgusted with the fact that Aaron was not put up for elimination… He was the Team Captain – as such he is responsible for keeping his team on time, & ensure the quality of the food prepared. He failed to show leadership & as such should be the one to walk the plank.

As for all the blubber on show tonight…. here’s an idea for a future “greatest challenge yet….” prepare several Jenny Craig dishes. Tubby Matt might actually learn something to help him.

21 pollywaffle { 06.03.10 at 12:32 am }

CG- I had a fleeting ‘ hey you’ve become sort of really good looking ‘moment” with Jonathan an episode or 2 ago.

He also sounds very Jeremy Irons at times – that might be a compliment. But I checked and it was a full moon, phew

22 sourkraut { 06.03.10 at 12:33 am }

CG
Wrong . No MC2 chef has been eliminated in the taste test for WRONGLY identifying a VARIETY of mint!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

23 CG { 06.03.10 at 12:36 am }

Sour, ur right…not a taste test..an herbs test! But still better than a “blind” taste test.

24 sourkraut { 06.03.10 at 12:41 am }

Lindy
If they use the A.B.M.T.S for the taste test it will be a bit hard on the contestants as they will have to correctly identify eye of LOWER LITHUANIAN newt, and wing of UPPER TRANSYLVANIAN bat as ingredients, and I’m not sure if these sophisticated contestants will know what a bat is. Maybe it will be confused with a faro?

25 sourkraut { 06.03.10 at 12:45 am }

CG wrong again
That’s an URBS test!
Now there’s an idea. blindfold these jokers and make them go on taste and aroma alone. That should stop any confusion between “onions” and “shallots ” Course noone on MC would ever make (or get away with) THAT MISTAKE even by looking at them, would they?

26 pollywaffle { 06.03.10 at 12:51 am }

Skt : Rick Stein ( as seen in “Asians are kicking our British culinary arses, sorry bottoms, cooking special) couldnt even get half the ingredients from the Asian dishes he was shopping, and got all excited ( as pink as his shirt) about pandan leaf. Wot hope have the MC twits got

27 Anon { 06.03.10 at 1:00 am }

Jenny, re the feeling that the red team won, I think Peter smirking in the interview prior to the winner been announced was the big give away.

28 Jenny Draut { 06.03.10 at 1:08 am }

but i still dont understand how the votes counted??????????? double votes were not that far-fetched..
based on the pre view on tomorrow night elim, Jake might be going home

29 crabtech { 06.03.10 at 1:16 am }

Why did they have to be at the pier at sun up but they did not start cooking until 11?

30 Georgina { 06.03.10 at 1:40 am }

I feel for Jake. He’s right that everybody else abandoned him when the job was too hard — but he should’ve spoken up at the team meeting. Bitching about it to the camera afterwards might get you sympathy points but it’s not going to help you stay on the show, mate.

(I can’t be the only one who thinks his palate vs Marion will be no contest. Joanne, I don’t know. She’s so good at riding other people’s coattails that it’s hard to tell how much skill she actually has.)

I’m getting very tired of seeing 50 mins of contestants being yelled at for being too slow, too unorganised, too awful, then hearing Matt back at the Masterchef Kitchen say, “You all did an amazing job.” It happens every team challenge. Fake drama is fake.

31 Jacqui { 06.03.10 at 8:21 am }

Interesting episode. Why can’t they make the episodes longer though? One hour is not enough!

32 Paul { 06.03.10 at 9:56 am }

1.96 million last night – almost cracked the 2m mark which is basically unheard of for a reality show that is only half way through. If this upward growth continues we could be looking at breaking the 4m mark for the final show (last years got 3.7m).

I think with Marion up for elimination tonight we could see another big audience even though the Thursday night episode is generally one of the weaker ones in ratings terms.

People might criticise the show (and it does have its faults) but the fact is people flock to it in droves and whilst it keeps performing as it is I doubt the copncept is going to alter that much. So if you don’t like the tears and the challengers then you had better either get used to it or turn the channel as it ain’t going to change short term.

33 Injera { 06.03.10 at 10:17 am }

Sourkraut, I’m going to spend my day humming The Good Ship Venus now, thanks. I’ll try to remember the alternative version from The Gillies Report, though. My favourite verse:

The Ship’s Dog’s name was Big Balls
Though nobody was sure why he was called that
There was nothing remarkable about the size of his knackers
And the name was gratuitous and offensive.

Back OT – CG Imma take your lead and drink wine tonight! But I do think Jonno was looking pretty good last night, even though I was sober.

When George was talking about the prospect of salmonella on board, I wonder if the sponsors were groaning. It reminded me that there were some hideous outbreaks in cruise ships (I think it was around the Caribbean) a couple of years ago, which – even though I’d never thought of taking a shipboard holiday – made me double-underline it on the “NOT” list.

34 TDK { 06.03.10 at 10:27 am }

I think the reason the teams were given those canapes to make was due to the ship’s kitchen’s limitations / tool size?
It would have been designed to serve for large masses, and therefore some createive dishes would not be possibly be effeciently pumped out for thousands of people per service.

35 Culinary Boner { 06.03.10 at 11:10 am }

Have to admit that my inner snob was working into overdrive whilst the camera panned over the cruise guests.

Whilst the tragic Brimble case confirmed certain prejudices I have about cruises embarking from Australia for the South Pacific, last night’s MCA managed to cement the stereotype as ‘Mt Druit afloat’ – which I suppose is not a bad thing if you are from Mt Druit or want to to mix the experience of a night on the piss at Panthers with the added bonus of seasickness.

It was also pleasing to see further sterotyping in the form of the neo-Nazi looking sous chef. Clearly this guy would be at home as a Guy Ritchie film extra.

Points also to the head chef Lars, for his unscripted and highly amusing look of polite alarm and dismay at Matt Preston’s over-the-top, manic eye-rolling performance.

The whole scene played out like Basil Fawlty’s Gourmet Night with crumbed lamb chops easily trumping zucchini flowers. As Fawlty lamented – “lets heat up buckets of baked beans garnished with a couple of dead dogs, that’ll get ‘em in”.

George should have taken this as an opportunity to check his theory from earlier episodes that most people dine regularly on truffles.

36 I like food { 06.03.10 at 11:55 am }

Agree with Rusty…if you’re so pissed off cement dude then say so and dont sit there like a kid sulking. He wasnt afraid to say it to the camera by himself, so say it to the others. Aaron was pretty quick to take his nomination….he’s such a douche bag.

37 rusty { 06.03.10 at 12:00 pm }

In retrospect (ie. this morning) it seems odd that those 3 just volunteered for elimination, knowing it wasn’t primarily themselves to blame, or that it wouldn’t be their practical skills being tested.

After all, no-one said the salmon canape was lousy or didn’t win votes, like the flowers.

Is this just another “Matt the Crap”reality tV set-up?

38 pollywaffle { 06.03.10 at 12:11 pm }

MC Elimination Dick-tionary:

‘That plate has all the alaments’ – but frankly one more slither of saffron would have got it there

‘Its all about the taste’ – bugger they got the plating correct

‘Shall we?’ – better hurry up before Matt scoffs the lot

‘I lurrrv the way the salty/zesty/zingy melts in with the fresh, crunchy, creamy’ – when in doubt just throw together any old word salad

‘I’d be happy to see that in any restaurant’ – yep, since Channel 10 pays for anything I consume

‘The steak/fish/chicken is overcooked, under, raw’ – Great, the constant interruptions at your food station worked a treat

‘Digustation menu’ – innovative dish consumed but not shared by large colourfully attired food tosser

‘Pteh,Gerrrguphaw – thats a pip,shell,bone in my dish’- slam dunk

‘How do you feel right now? How much does this mean to you? For someone your food dream is over’. – Im serving up your elimination, 3 ways

‘You must leave the MC kitchen for the last time’ – pick up the souveenir cravat on the way out but don’t do anything drastic

39 Paul { 06.03.10 at 12:11 pm }

Not odd at all if you know anything about human behaviour.

Marion & Jake seem to be two that don’t like conflict and Joanne I imagined sensed that Jake was going to get nominated and so therefore put her own hand up as well.

Its quite simple really.

40 rusty { 06.03.10 at 12:25 pm }

It’s a cooking competition, Paul, in case you have forgotten, not Big Brother.

Supposedly they are in, to win it.

People really aren’t that simple, at all. Have you learnt nothing even from just reading this blog? After all, you are the one always puzzled about the attitude of most of us to the show, and why we keep watching and whining about it.

Do you not know anything about human behaviour?

“No man is all of a piece”, Paul. Not even you.

41 TDK { 06.03.10 at 12:34 pm }

Paul – I don’t think Joanne is smart enough to be such a schemer.
I think she’s just come to her senses that being liked is more important than being disliked.
She did say she’s like this in real life, to tell it as it is and be honest.
So good on her for sticking to her words.
I still don’t like her smugness and annoyingness.

42 Reality Raver { 06.03.10 at 12:36 pm }

Paul – Aaron came across that he was not coping well in the leadership role.

Pollywaffle – The asian workers are always on those cruises, mainly indonesian and phillipino’s hired from those countries because they are cheaper labour. Agree I think Jake’s time has come.

I also wondered if the ship was going actually going to leave as I wondered where the prep was happening for the meals that would be happening after the cruise started.

ANON – thanks for clarifying that it was an actual cruise.

Sourk – hilarious as usual – but I don’t want to sound like a inner city latte sipper, but I like Zucchini flowers. Think you should audition next year with the Alaskan Turd Moose stew.

CG – Agree we saw very little footage of why Marion got put in the bottom 3 – did she try and defend herself? Jono acquitted himself well yesterday, took over on the dreaded pinning from Joanne, and did the chops well, yes easy in one sense but they still had to be cooked to the right level. It think Matt has put on more weight than George. But both are expanding.

Jenny Draut – Aaron probably lost a few sympathy votes last night.

Fides – Interesting to see if Marion plays the pin she will kick herself if she doesn’t and goes out for saying galangal when it is not in there.

Crabtech – I think they would have had to make sure they ran the challenge to time, as the ship had to take off. It would take them a few hours to brief them, and work out a logistics plan etc etc.

Asteroth – well if it had been Celeb Apprentice Aaron would be up for elimination.

Georgina – maybe Jake did speak up they just didn’t show it.

Jacqui – Agree this episode could have gone longer, particularly seeing how the three contestants got up for elimination. Yes JOanne volunteered but the other two didn’t. How did this consensus come about?

Injera – thanks for the Mark Jensen link. I like the team pickings is that it gives an insight into who they think is a good cook, or who they don’t like. But it must be horrible for some of them.
Maybe the contestants have been watching too many episodes of Survivor, and want Marion in early to force out the immunity pin. Not a bad strategy after all it is a reality TV show.

Laura – thanks for confirming that Claire would have been responsible for her own nomination if the red team had been up for elimination. I think it would have been logistically impossible for them to pick their own canapes to make. They must have been on a strict deadline.

Nonnymouse – I have not seen much of Aaron but obviously he is brushing people the wrong way.

Rusty – Agree Jake needs to be more assertive and since he has stopped injuring himself he has become a tad dull.

KC – I thought it was an interesting episode, also made them realise that professional cooking is not all glamour.

Akris – good call – it would have been interesting if they had put a whole tuna in front of Adam.

43 wallah { 06.03.10 at 12:41 pm }

Oh jeez…..just watched this online. Too bad I didn’t watch this last night but I had a mate around who was telling me of the hell of being stuck on a cruise ship chock full of bogans. Likened it to a Tiger flight. As for the food, surely by now with these public challenges, the contestants should know that the simpler the better.
But, on a side note, so many fond memories came flooding back to me from the days of being a banquet waiter after watching the seagulls attack the trays all at once. Good thing they didn’t have spring rolls, ’cause the punters like to grab those by the 4 or 5 at once.

44 pollywaffle { 06.03.10 at 12:43 pm }

Wallah – did the double dipping give you the heaves as well

45 wallah { 06.03.10 at 12:48 pm }

Double dipping is always fun, but my thoughts were they must all know each other, so hey! Go nuts people. However, nothing, and I mean nothing, can compete with the behaviour at a buffet full of prawns.

46 Paul { 06.03.10 at 12:50 pm }

rusty,
Yes it is a cooking competition hence my puzzlement that you think the 3 contestants up for elimination is a ‘set up.’ I don’t really get where you’re coming from.
The explanation as to the 3 contestants up for elimination is fairly simple.

TDK,
Not suggesting that Joanne was scheming at all. More thinking along the lines that she felt guilty that Jake was going to be up and so she thought she should be up as well.

47 Reality Raver { 06.03.10 at 12:51 pm }

Paul – great ratings there is so going to be a season three.

INjera – do you think because Matt P has become a parody of himself, and Gary is injured that Jono is the go to man now for the perv?

Culinary Boner – Maybe Channel Ten did not realise what the cross was or they are pro- palestinian?

TDK – maybe Joanne didn’t like being picked last so decided to try and become more likeable.

Pollywaffle – the Masterchef dictionary is gold. Can I put it in it’s own blog post as a guest post?

48 pollywaffle { 06.03.10 at 12:54 pm }

Wallah – the ‘prawn pounce’ is worthy of a David Attenborough Voice over. Few things appeal less to me than spongy pre-cooked prawnocopia on a buffet table. At least it gives you a clearway zone to run over to the ‘packet mix’ dessert table and scoop up anything with enough rum in it to drown the taste.

49 pollywaffle { 06.03.10 at 12:55 pm }

RR – that would be bewt-ti-ful

50 seepi { 06.03.10 at 12:57 pm }

I actually liked this episode, and Aaron didn’t bother me. At least he made efforts to take charge, rather than just getting on with his own cooking, as some other ‘leaders’ have done in the past.

The major flaw was having 4 different dishes for each team. Barring a major stuff-up (the beef?), it was going to come down to the audience’s preferences for chicken wings over zucchini flowers.

Claire annoyed me majorly in this episode. She was going on and on about her beef, bugging her team leader, and wasting more and more time – counting the pieces??, when clearly there was nothing to be done about it – just get on with it.

I have always been anti-cruise, and after the Diane Brimble episode, I wouldn’t touch one with a barge pole, but several quite normal friends of mine at work love them. they say there are so many activities, people gravitate to their own areas (eg – yobbos to the nightclub, families to the pool deck).

I do think it is a bit suss that they got exactly 2 thousand votes – surely someone would have forgotten/not bothered etc. Also – does that mean each guests only got 2 ‘canopies’?

51 wallah { 06.03.10 at 1:04 pm }

Pollywaffle…..have to disagree. The opportunity to sink more free piss on the father in law is the order of the day! And to make sure the waiter (i.e.me) was in no doubt as to what would happen if someone tried serving light beer again. And this was at a 5 star hotel. Still, was a lot of fun, and nothing beats going to a nice little inner city pub at 4 am after work and watching the bogans you’ve had to put up with all night get refused entry. After being kicked out of the casino. Tools.

52 Injera { 06.03.10 at 1:06 pm }

Raver: Matt and Gary were never eye-candy for me! I think it was the stubble that CG noted that put Jono in the “hot” category last night – and the fact that he seemed to just get stuck into his tasks (not a euphemism). Of course, Moran is the real draw-card. Is he on tonight?

Thanks, Wallah, another reason to keep Tiger on my “no fly” list!

And I must be in a brain fog this morning – it’s taken me until now to get Sourkraut’s raw salmon/salmonella joke. Maybe I should just start drinking now – it’s afternoon, after all.

53 Fides { 06.03.10 at 1:11 pm }

Just rewatched the last part of this episode – at the end when blue team are discussing who should be bottom 3, after Joanne nominates herself, Marion then says something like “I think everyone who worked on the salmon dish should be up for elimination” and so picks herself. The others then look at Jake and Aaron asks him if he has anything to say … it doesn’t show why it’s decided that the salmon was much worse than the zucchini flowers, but Matt and Callum have pretty much made themselves invisible sinking into the sofa. Then Aaron says something like “so it’s agreed that Jo, Jake, Marion were the worst performers” and I thought – does he really lack insight into his own performance as captain? Or is he in denial that he did a terrible job re time management and delegation of tasks… Or is he just such a fake and a coward that he’ll cry to the camera about judging his teammates but happily throw Jake “the hardest working cook in the house” under the bus.

Also, and do please pardon my ramblings, I think in a challenge like this, there should be some time penalty for failing to get at least one dish ready by the start time. Don’t know exactly when the blues had their first dish ready, but if say, it was half an hour, then they’re not following the rules and should be penalised accordingly. If they’re late because they’re working on their dishes so they taste spectacular, doesn’t seem fair if the other team delivers on time but with some compromise to the dish. A loss of a certain number of points for every minute it is late would cetainly add to the pressure.

54 Paul { 06.03.10 at 1:23 pm }

Just one further thing on the ratings.
MC rated an incredible 70.1 in females 18-29. Again this figure is unheard of.

So if I hear one more ignoramus state that the MC demographic is housewives and home cooks then I will vomit………

Its always been a young person’s show. This idea that it appeals to the oldies is factually wrong in every respect. In fact, if there is one demographic that shuns MC, it is people over 55.

55 spend a penny { 06.03.10 at 1:55 pm }

Paul, put down your rating sheet at once. Are you sure you arent working for Hey Hey?

There’s a concept called young at heart too which the ratings dont capture well. Over 55s are running away with the current cook book and Matt Ps book, so there!

56 spend a penny { 06.03.10 at 2:08 pm }

Has the gloss of the cooking dream been dulled by the vertigo of cooking in unsavory, boganville surroundings? EEEEwwww, no blow torch? What do you mean there is no truffle oil within a radius of 5km? Im sorry, I need a Telstra recipe prompter contraption to cook properly…. even if I skip a line, Im more comfortable that way

Dont think we’ve got any budding Robert Irvines ( ‘Dinner Impossible’ lovable rogue who would laugh in the face of 4000 canapes) amongst this shabby MC crew

57 Sooty { 06.03.10 at 2:11 pm }

Fides – thank you for that.

Joanne said she’d stuffed up tempura batter, also, hence nominating self with surprising self-awareness and humility.

Those greasy callow youths staying mum re their floundering about with the zucchini flowers for four bloody hours really pissed me off, and Aaron! Despicable!

I blame Marion – who is 27 by the way – 27 – awesome! – and Aaron who I have lost all feeling for – for poor bloody Jake being in the elimination.

I am not surprised he didn’t speak up while in the group – he has the look of a guy who is used to being shat on by other people. I really like him and I would like to see him stay. Shucks a mean oyster, too.

As for all those so-called ‘bogans’ on the boat. Many of them made informed comments on their canapes, even isolating the specific problem with the tempura batter. People are people in my book, and it was nice to see them enjoying themselves, excited about being on tv, and about to sail off on a holiday.

Claire, old droopy drawers, whined on self-effacingly for far too long. Oh how I wished the red team had lost – — but then red had Alvin and Peter and Sharnee, another mean oyster shucker, on it. Still it would have been fun to see Claire unravelling, entire spine collapsing, as she meekly bleated out the ingredients!

I can’t believe how fast my allegiances are shifting! I can’t believe how angry I get watching this show! Yeah, they’ve fucked it up a bit, but I still love it.

58 Reality Raver { 06.03.10 at 2:16 pm }

Wallah – I reckon you could handle the spring roll swill with aplomb. I was thinking of flying Tiger or would that be madness. At least it lands at Tullermarine NOT Geelong.

Injera – I hope Matt Moran is on tonight but may just be Matt P and George, they were probably wondering how long Gary would be gone at this point. But it is going to get dull quick with just the two of them.

Fides – thanks for clarifying how they got nominated. Jake should have spoke up, yes they were slow with the de-boning but did any bones make it out to the punters.

I think I will stay out of the ratings debate on the blog.

Seepi – I agree about the voting, and would there have been exactly 2000 people there?

59 spend a penny { 06.03.10 at 2:18 pm }

Wallah – once thing in life that you can rely on ( besides death and taxes), that a tool is consistently a tool

60 Guest Blog: Masterchef Australia Elimination Dictionary | reality ravings { 06.03.10 at 2:29 pm }

[...] commenter Pollywaffle put this in the comment section of Masterchef Australia P&O Challenge, however I thought it was so good it deserved to be in a separate post.  Please add your own [...]

61 Fides { 06.03.10 at 2:55 pm }

Sooty, have you heard Marion’s radio voice? I posted towards the end of one of last week’s threads the link through her wikipedia page… there’s of course not one awesome! to be heard. She has a very professional ABC voice and sounded much older than the 23 she would have been. But I mean, if she used her professional reporting voice in her commentaries on the show, we’d be criticising how rehearsed and pretentious she sounds.

I still think she is pretty spectacular but agree, she could expand her vocabulary to not sound like a teenager.

62 sourkraut { 06.03.10 at 3:12 pm }

Raver
a good ABMTS needs fresh ingredients and I dont think Coles or IGA or even Woolies would stock them. maybe a spot of Dumpster diving at the MC kitchen would turn up the goodies (INJERA thanks for that one my sides still hurt)
Injera
My delicate nature (and MrsK) forbade me from qouting the verse about the cook whose name was Freeman, and the other verse about the cook whose name was O’malley who did not dilly-dally (unlike the MC contestants)
Sooty
I tend to agree with all your comments this time
So how many bottles of Bogans Pride inner city chardonnay will I need to chill for survival through tonights episode while the tv destroyer is out of action?
Paul

Re the ratings, it was Wednesday night, the MOST PATHETIC night of viewing of the week (even SBS had nothing much) so most people were inside mid week due to rain and unfortunately our progressive education has allowed the masses to forget how to read so there was nothing else to do bar watch MC unless like many you were pushing x-box controller buttons (which may have been more interesting)

63 Set up!!! { 06.03.10 at 4:00 pm }

Jo’s time is up and so she was pushed. Marion needs to volunteer to create tension. It was time for Jake to make an appearance after being in the middle of the pack too long.

64 MelbaToast { 06.03.10 at 4:07 pm }

What a stoopid challenge! Does cooking 1000 canapes (surely Georgie Porgie was pronoucing this incorrectly – he made it sound like they were going to have to go and pitch tarps up on deck to keep the passengers dry) having anything to do with being an amateur cook?

The challenge was unfair too, in that the blue team had so much more fiddly prep work to do.

AND if there’s 2000 passengers on board surely there should be 2000 of each type of canape so everyone gets to try everything.

How cruel making the team pick who should be up for the grand fireball!

65 sourkraut { 06.03.10 at 4:18 pm }

Melba toast
Exactly

66 Angry of Mayfair { 06.03.10 at 5:07 pm }

bring back Injera

67 whirlpool.net.au { 06.03.10 at 5:17 pm }

Ah don’t diss RR-but Injera’s recaps are gold. BTW ignore ratings troll everyone.

68 Reality Raver { 06.03.10 at 5:32 pm }

Angry of Mayfair – Injera’s recaps are indeed fabulous, and a different style to mine. I hope you are checking out her blog http://www.blahblogblah.com as it has some great reviews of TV shows, and other interesting eclectic stuff.

Melbatoast – Good point some people may have only got to taste one or to canapes.

Set up – there will be fear and loathing if Marion goes.

69 pollywaffle { 06.03.10 at 5:34 pm }

Skt – Just been supermarket shopping and gawd ther’es only six eggwhites of separation in this world – that blasted Donna Hay’s pinched your MC3 entry vehicle. Yes, wack bang on the cover of latest DH Mag – “Food to stay in for” , Alaskan bull moose turd stew

70 Zibb { 06.03.10 at 5:59 pm }

The canapés added up to 1,900, not 2000 (762 and 1138)
it does seem weird that it was such an even number, but it doesn’t hve the full 2000

71 pollywaffle { 06.03.10 at 6:04 pm }

Zibb – but there was a side order for Matt P for 100 of course

72 Paul { 06.03.10 at 6:11 pm }

Zibb, deduct 100 points for the hired chef.

73 pollywaffle { 06.03.10 at 8:50 pm }

RR I was sick today and had to, had to of course, keep up my energy levels with mini-wagon wheels. But I kept floating off into a cloud imagining eating that Phillipa Sibley dessert featured on MC instead – just for medicinal purposes only.

Now that she has given BG the big tuille, do you know whether she is going to serve that dessert at Il Fornaio? Its not quite cafe material but who knows what’s in the vision.
I need a fix but Im a bit worried cos at their bread prices that little beauty’s going to be more expensive than a trip to the dentist

74 Reality Raver { 06.03.10 at 10:03 pm }

Sorry Pollywaffle I have no idea, I am not on top of the Melbourne food scene. I leave it up to Injera to deal with that when I visit, as her finger is on the foodie pulse.
However I would be tempted to try that dessert if she does have it on the menu there.

75 sourkraut { 06.04.10 at 1:59 pm }

Polyyw
I hope it was not brown

76 K.C. { 06.04.10 at 11:06 pm }

I felt bad for Jake – especially as when Joanne was having problems with the salmon – Jono said – leave it and I’ll do it. Why didn’t he speak up and say that when they were deciding sho should be up for elimination?
In my mind it should have been Aaron (crappy captain-ing), Joanne (crappy boning, crappy batter) and one of the boys from the zucchini flowers.

Leave a Comment