for those who have reality tv as their guilty pleasure
Reality Ravings | Australia's leading Reality TV blog!

Posts from — May 2010

Masterchef – Masterclass (open post)

I’m not going to blog the Masterclass tonight. Rather than watch people cook, I’m going to be out stuffing myself with Peking Duck. I have been enjoying the classes, though, so let me know what I’m missing out on, in the comments.

May 14, 2010   45 Comments

Australia’s Next Top Model – Has Healthy Body Image Been Discarded?

The Herald Sun reports today that one of the contestants on this year’s Australia’s Next Top Model has been told to lose weight.

The article states:

At 55kg, Melbourne’s Alison Boxer is underweight, according to the universally recognised Body Mass Index.

But that’s not good enough for a guest mentor on the latest series of the Fox8 show.

Alison, 16, said she was told to lose “centimetres from her thighs”.

“It was a shock to the system to be told I needed to lose weight,” she said.

“At home a lot of people say I’m too skinny. I was 50kg at one stage, which I thought was a bit scary.

“So I was coming from a place where people were telling me to gain weight, to now people saying I should lose weight.”

Alison, the second-youngest of 16 contestants, said she was one of four girls told to lose weight just a week into filming of the catty TV competition.

A Foxtel spokesperson confirmed Alison was told to shed a centimetre around her waist. But the Yarraville teen said she was told her hips and thighs were the real problem areas.

“It was a bit of a shock as I’m so young and new to the world and to be told, no, your walk was bad and to lose weight in the first week was pretty full-on,” she said.

“I have never tried to lose weight before, but since then I have been going to the gym twice a day and eating in proportion to try to lose the weight.”

I take it that this girl is not going to win the series after blabbing on like this. However isn’t the show’s host Sarah Murdoch the Chair of a group promoting healthy body image? I am not sure what Sarah would think of this, but the reality is the modelling world want their girls young and thin.

An article in the Daily Telegraph confirms the producers went with “more commercial” frames. It also reveals the three NSW contestants  – Ashton Flutey, Chantal Croccolo and Kelsey Martinovich.

The series will premiere on Fox 8 in July.

May 14, 2010   Comments Off on Australia’s Next Top Model – Has Healthy Body Image Been Discarded?

Masterchef Australia – Is Jonathan Daddier This Year’s Villain?

One thing Jonathan Daddier CANNOT complain about is the amount of air time he is getting on Masterchef Australia compared to the other contestants, but he is probably a bit miffed about how he is being portrayed.

He is definitely being given the negative edit, and whether this really reflects his true personality is yet to be seen.

The Daily Telegraph has an article that says Jonathan has been getting the most comments on the forums, but a lot of it is negative.

The article also goes on to say that he is using strategy as well as cooking to advance in the competition. Personally I don’t find this a negative thing.

The article said:

Many viewers say Daddia is playing MasterChef as though it is Survivor.

To them, Daddia is using strategy as well as his cooking skills to give himself the best possible chance of winning.

Others point to the contestants’ reaction to Daddia winning the elimination challenges to show that he is unpopular in the MasterChef house.

“He is clearly trying to manipulate the rest of the contestants in the house to earn their sympathy. He is a manipulator and it doesn’t take a psychologist to know it,” a viewer wrote.

Daddia has his fans, though.

They admire his determination and steely reserve.

“The guy’s obviously very intelligent and comes across as being very articulate. His cooking talents are obvious,” one fan wrote.

Other rumours circulating are that he worked as an apprentice chef as some stage. I have emailed Channel Ten for comment on this, I will update if I get a response.

He has done work experience at Gordon Ramsay’s  restaurant in London, however other contestants have also done that when they realised they were on the show.

Anyway if Jonathan is going to be the villain of the show I wish he would be a true villain and harden up and stop crying.

UPDATE: I have received a response from Fremantle – they stated Jonathan has not worked as an apprentice chef, and confirmed his work experience at Gordon Ramsay’s which was some time ago.

Interestingly enough the most recent contestant to be eliminated Courtney said to news.com.au that Jonathan is “nice”.

May 14, 2010   10 Comments

Masterchef – the red team dons the black aprons

Ah, the Masterchef kitchen, once again! Matt is praising the red team for their effort in the French challenge, but reminds them that the blues “knocked it out of the ballpark”. If you don’t count their creme brulee or champagne course. He sends the reds to wait out some nerves upstairs – for no reason that I can discern – and they perch on the couches, each declaring that he/she is not ready to go home. I agree with those who say they still have a lot to learn, but perhaps that means they are likely to be at risk.

We don’t want to spend all our time with the losers, do we? Let’s see what winners do. Claire catches us up with the news that the blues won last night – no, really! – so are enjoying a meal at Pilu. Aaron demonstrates that he has a future in children’s television with his enthusiastic miming of the feast of the senses. Fiona pretends that they are thinking of the red team, but really they are thinking of suckling pig (or should be).

Back to the losers. The elimination challenge is two rounds of basic skills. The worst three performers in round one go onto round two, and the worst in round two will go home. Test one? The reds have ten minutes to make a pesto, using mortar and pestle. Contestants have a taste of the sample dish and are given the go to rush at the ingredients bench. “It’s worse than the boxing day sale” according to Alvin.

Sharnee pops in loads of pine nuts – too many? – and Jake is hoping that some cashews with his pine nuts will give it a creaminess that will beat the others. He admits to hoping the judges haven’t seen him with the cashews, as it’s a textural rather than flavour choice, but the Gs are onto him. This is a pity – and a reason that I don’t think the judges should be watching them during this – since they both wince at his decision and you can bet they’ll be doing their darndest to pick out that flavour when they taste his.

As we come back from commercials, Adam is there to helpfully remind those of us who have short-term memory problems that they have ten minutes to make pesto.

Courtney feels that her pesto is not going to meet the size requirement, so decides that garlic is the right choice for volume building. Seems like a strange decision. Sharnee thinks that hers is too thick and Daniel realises that his has too much parmesan. Courtney’s taste test has revealed that hers tastes garlicky. Wow, who’d have thought? And what are the chances that we’ve just seen our bottom three?

Tasting

George asks Jake if “there’s cashews in there”. That really shits me, since he KNOWS there are cashews in there so is clearly trying to catch Jake in a lie.

  • Courtney’s is deemed green and vibrant but the judges’ expressions show that the garlic is overwhelming.
  • Skye’s has too much lemon and Gary can’t taste the basil.
  • Matt finds Marion’s balanced.
  • As for the others? Who knows, but clearly Adam and Peter are safe, since we’ve seen nothing of their efforts.

The bottom three are Daniel, Sharnee and the fireball. I hope to god they didn’t have to use Perfect Italiano cheese in their pesto; there’d be no chance of it being edible (although that would explain how having too much cheese – Daniel – would have been worse than too much lemon and no basil – Skye). After the ads, we find out that the fireball obscured the garlicky Courtney. The safe ones must say goodbye to the bottom three, and we must watch their “dream/journey” clips. I think Sharnee’s sad because she’s told the nation that she doesn’t want to be a lawyer, but it seems she might not be a cook, either.

Now it’s time to play Name! That! Herb! The first one is basil, but Courtney thinks it might be a trick. Fortunately none of them tries to second guess it, and they all go on to the second herb. The second herb is mint, but Courtney is trying to be more specific, which worries Daniel, who an hears more scribbling than a four-letter word warrants. She’s got spearmint, whilst the other two have “mint”. Let’s see how long Gary can drag it out. Wow – there’s been at least 90 seconds of running through the options (come ON Gary, there are only TWO!) and now we go to ads. Seriously. Growing OLD here, Ten.

The herb, once the ads are over, is revealed as mint, so goodbye Courtney. She doesn’t see herself as one of the best cooks, but didn’t see herself as number nineteen. Don’t worry, Courtney, I don’t see you as the nineteenth best cook in the country, either.

Sharnee voices over that everyone will be devastated to see her go. Back in the house, we see Carrie musing over who’s gone home while she’s still in the house despite not being able to cook (she leaves the last part of that sentence unsaid). The lift door opens to reveal…. Daniel and Sharnee. Jo and Carrie look shocked (possibly because they’ve never seen this “Daniel” before), and Claire reveals that she didn’t think Courtney would be anywhere near the top of the list. I’m not sure whether she realises that even being at the bottom of a three person list is still fairly close to the “top”.

Ah, Courtney, you’re home. Pouring beers is a thing of the past, she says. She’s now in the process of launching a catering company.

Other notes

  • I’d have hoped that basic skills would have been tested before these people were touted as the country’s best amateur chefs.
  • I’m not sure who it was who drew my attention to Kate in the credits, but thatnks to whoever you are. It always gives me a giggle.
  • Also thanks to whoever pointed out Aaron’s resemblance to Kirk Pengilly!

I’ll be putting up an open post for the Masterclass tomorrow, so you can feel free to drop by and post your thoughts as it’s underway.  Hopefully your commentary will be so detailed that I won’t have to watch the recording, and can catch up on American Idol, Celebrity Apprentice and Jersey Shore, instead!

May 13, 2010   29 Comments

Masterchef – French letters

We are back in the Masterchef kitchen again. How can we miss it if it won’t go away? Anyway, let’s get into it.

To kick things off, it’s the customary team selection for the Wednesday night challenge. And, as is also customary, being team captain is sold as a “reward” for the Sunday night win. How can this be? I give up on trying to figure it out. I also give up on trying to work out how choosing colours is important. Unfortunately, the system used last week is out of favour, and we are back with that annoying pick-one-who-picks-one strategy, starting with the captain. I will concede that choosing the opposing captain could be important, and Jonathan chooses Daniel. My response is “who?”, but Marion’s surprised at the choice, given that he’s a strong cook. Apparently. I mean, how would we know, we never get to see him.

Jonathan’s team: Fiona who picks Matthew, who picks Claire, then Callum, Jimmy, Phillip, Joanne, Carrie, Aaron.
Daniel’s team: Peter picks Marion, who picks Adam, then Courtney, Alvin, Skye, Sharnee, Jake.

Aaron is the “non-choice” as Daniel chooses Jake over him, and he cracks the shits.

Next morning, they pop on their coloured aprons in the house and there is commentary over how that changes the dynamic within the group. So, what happens in the Masterchef kitchen no longer stays in the Masterchef kitchen.

Boxes are delivered – one for red and one for blue. They have a letter in French and a dictionary to translate. Fortunately Claire can read French, which she does, aloud, rather unnecessarily. They really only need her to translate, not read, and she gets around to that after a bit. It is a huge advantage for the blues, since the red team is reliant on the dictionary and seems to be taking forever. The upshot is that each team has to find a book with a Masterchef symbol and choose their three course menu from that book.

Callum finds the first book, which is by Michel Roux, and the blues also get the second book, by Tony Bilson. They act like prats, holding on to both while they choose and telling the waiting reds to go away to let them choose IN PEACE. They select the Tony Bilson book, leaving Michel Roux for the reds.

The blues finalise their menu and run off to the International College of Management in Manly, while the reds continue selecting their menu. They seem to work quickly and head off.

As the blues arrive, Callum thinks the deteriorating weather is worth noting, so I’m guessing there will be an outdoor eating challenge? Otherwise that is really irrelevant information. Matt greets them with the news that they will get a 15 minute head start for being first to arrive. They’ll be cooking a three course meal which we already know. It must be ready by noon, but we don’t know what time it is now. Thanks, Matt. If they win, they’ll be going to an exciting kitchen for lunch with Matt, but if they lose, all members of the losing team will be up for elimination.

Each team gets a mentor. So I guess the Blues are getting Tony Bilson and the Reds will get Michel Roux. MICHEL ROUX! Poor Tony has to come out and stand in the rain to receive his applause. Aaron is pumped, as he reminds us that the man on the landing is the very man who wrote the book Jo is clutching. We get a close up of the name on the cover to verify this. Claire says they’re feeling chipper with their head-start and their extra person, even if that extra person is the one nobody wanted. Poor Aaron.

As the reds arrive, Adam tells us that Matt is standing there in all his glory. Tuxedo, people, he’s wearing a tuxedo! The reds welcome Michel Roux. They look way more excited than the blues did. No offence, Tony, but this man has an accent. When Matt asks him what makes a good dish, he responds with “sophistication and simplicity with the best ingredients”. Sage advice.

The mentoring gets off to a flying start when Michel steers the reds from their chosen pigeon main towards the duck. Skye seems to be on the verge of a “but” (it has Asian influences, and the instruction was for classic French) but the others all fall into place.

In the blue kitchen, Jimmy’s taking the breast from the duck, Aaron is terrified that the lobster won’t be perfect and Carrie is working on the creme brulee with poached peaches with Jo and Phil. They are all concerned that if their dish or part thereof fails, it will let the team down.

In the red kitchen Marion is filleting the duck. Adam is talking vegies and is hoping that the judges don’t punish the team for the Asian style accompaniment. Sharnee is making the pistachio creme anglaise and Skye is taking care of the peaches and balancing the subtle peachiness with the rosemary. Courtney says that she is working on the oysters, but I can see Jake with a shucker and that makes me nervous (not as nervous as the oysters, though). Alvin is discussing the relevant amounts of lemon for his coulis with Michel.

The way Carrie is interviewing about the importance of setting the brulee makes me think it’s not going to. Jo is dealing with the pastry and is making Jonathan angry. No, “furious”.

Gary and George come in to bellow a bit about some surprise guest judges. Marion says “what else can they throw at us?” as though Michel and Tony are liabilities, not mentors.

Daniel seems to be taking control in the kitchen quite well. Gary comes in to tell them that they have 30 minutes to go and they need to do an extra dish, using Chandon Cuvee Riche for the sponsors, I guess. Michel suggests a strawberry mousse with a poached strawberry cocktail.

George breaks the extra course news to the blue team. Jonathan? Is not happy. He seems to say that they are doing a tart with tomatoes and a sabayon, but this doesn’t make much sense. Tony is only concerned about how the plating will go – he’s particularly worried about the knife skills, and he must think that Donna Hay is on the judging panel. Jimmy gets the duck out to show Tony, who is HORRIFIED that it might be overcooked. Jimmy is thoroughly chastened and Jonathan is glowering. Guess what? Claire’s brulee hasn’t set – who’d’ve thought. Jimmy’s duck breasts, fortunately, are “cooked to perfection” (his description).

Marion’s duck also looks perfect, but she’s still worried that it’s not a French classic – can they use “we was suckered into it by our hero-worship for a classic French chef?” as their excuse?

George and Gary count down their respective teams. I’m so glad they won’t be on the judging panel today.

The judges are revealed: Guillaume Brahimi and Tetsuya Wakuda. The teams dissolve into worshipful lathers.

Judging

Red

Adam pronounces Tetsuya Wakuda convincingly, but I don’t know this Guillaume Burani.

Alvin’s Cucumber coulis and Jake’s poached oysters
G – gets a lot of bitterness, “maybe too much lemon” (duh DUH!)
T – very much enjoyed the oysters. “wonderful. A nice dish”

Smoked duck breast with stir-fried vegetables (Marion and Adam)
T – perfectly cooked, and “very, very, very tender”
M – “I love the combination”… but he questions whether it is classic French (duh DUH!!!)
G – finds it very Not French

Strawberry Chandon Mousse (Daniel)
M – “wonderfully smooth, but lacking in strawberry flavour”. On the positive side, he loves the liquor

Poached White Peach with pistachio creme anglaise (Skye and Sharnee)
G – perfectly poached
T – feels that the pistachio is too course, “it should be like silk”

Blue

Roasted Lobster (Aaron, Matthew)
G – “Magnifique” AND applause! I’m so happy for Aaron (oh, and Matthew)! Sucks to those who didn’t want him.

Duck a l’orange (Jimmy, Claire)
T – “I love it”
M – wants to have a whole pile of the fig compote
G – “This is French cuisine!”

Tomato Champagne Sabayon
G – should be a palate cleanser but it’s too sweet
M – a “sweet sledgehammer”

Creme Brulee (Carrie, Joanne “I didn’t make the brulee”, Phillip)
M – brulee not set properly, “which throws the dish out of whack”
T – is a bit upset. No, really, he said “upset”.

Results

Thanks, Claire, for recapping, but I’m sure we can all remember what happened just before the Perfect Italiano ad.

Matt finally reveals where the winners will go – Pilu at Freshwater. He talks up the red team, before getting to the negatives: the lemony coulis, the grainy pistachio, and the Asian main.

Recap, recap. Matt – you want my job, buddy?

The blues’ lobster was the dish of the day and the duck was Tetsuya’s favourite, but the dessert was a disaster. A DISASTER.

Daniel, do you think you’ve won? “Yep.” Good on him for honesty. Jonathan starts to cry when Matt asks how he’ll feel if his team goes to elimination.

Drag, drag, drag it out. Jeez, and they criticised the UK version for its ponderousness, if I recall.

Blue wins, so Jonathan’s tears and overall snippishness are in vain. Unfortunately. I have failed to warm to that man.

Blues go to Pilu, and reds face elimination.

  • Was there a 15 minute penalty or were the reds just 15 minutes later?
  • Did Michel steer the reds towards duck so it would be duck vs duck?
  • Am I the only person who didn’t know Tetsuya trained in the French classics?
  • Will Joanne find her pillowcase stuffed with runny custard tonight?
  • If there hadn’t been a surprise fourth dish, would the team captains have taken responsibility for nothing?
  • How do people feel about the fact that the whole team faces elimination?

“I’m hoping to avoid donning the black apron” is my new favourite phrase.

May 12, 2010   29 Comments