Posts from — April 2010
Masterchef Australia – Team Challenge -Another person leaves
Ok before we get into a lather over Matt Preston’s comment “If you delay it long enough they will love anything” lets talk about the selection of the teams for tonight’s challenge.
It was extremely interesting to see who was being picked first, and who was left until last.
Alvin was automatically made a captain of the red team because he won the challenge this week, and he was told to pick the blue teams captain. He picked Johnathan, and when asked for the reason for that, he was not diplomatic and said “I don’t want him on my team”. And then revealed to camera he was not Mr Popularity in the house.
I was surprised that Alvin picked Adele first, but he said because it was an italian challenge. Johnathan confirmed my theory that young Callum can cook by picking him first.
Also interesting that Jimmy was not picked early and was left until at least half had been selected. However the humiliation of being left until last had to occur to some of them. Clearly neither captains rate Dominic, Kate or Fiona as cooks. Now we know about Kate’s culinary taste, but I had thought Dominic and Fiona were ok.
Twenty-Four year old Fiona was a bit teary when she was the last person standing, and she had expected to get picked earlier as she was mates with Johnathan in the house. I doubt they are anymore.
The challenge was each team was to take over a restaurant for a night in Leichhardt (Sydney’s Little Italy) and the team that made the most money in the 2 1/2 hour of service won lunch at Luke Mangan’s restaurant Glass.
The red team decided to go for a simple pizza and pasta menu, Adele was appointed as head chef, and Jimmy was appointed front of house. The Blue team went for a much more upmarket menu which was more technically difficult, hence slower to prep. Johnathan was head chef, and Dominic was head of front of house. The rationale that Dominic was a bit of a sales person.
The challenge had some positives and negatives,here are some thoughts on the red teams performance:
- Adele who has appeared flakey and emotional in previous episodes was excellent in taking the lead in the kitchen, and produced some really good food;
- Alvin needed to be a bit more of a control freak in the kitchen and front of house;
- Jimmy was very flakey as front of house, major stuff up with a mis-print of the menu, with the sides dishes being printed in the pizza section, hence a rocket and parmasen pizza was born, this ended up being a positive thing.
- The other issue were prawns not listed as being an ingredient in the fettucini dish which was serious but the judges WERE beating it up a bit. The prawns were pretty easy to spot if you were allergic to them.
- Kate was very good front of house, maybe that is where her talents lie.
The blue team was also having their ups and downs:
- Sarah the police officer was not writing the dockets properly. After being told about it, and she cracked up and left the floor. “And I feel like I let the team down,” she said. So she walked off the floor. I am not sure she got the irony of that.
- I thought Dominic rocked at front of house he was assertive and was in control even when things were getting hairy;
- Johnathan was having trouble with the dockets, as they were pouring through all at once. Also why weren’t the zuchhini flowers already stuffed.
To be fair on both teams few restaurants are full as soon as the doors are open. And my things are so different from last year, as the teams in season one in the sushi train challenge had to go out and market to get people to come in. Here a blackboard on street and word of mouth and it was full house.
Skye appeared to perform well also.
I think the people in the blue kitchen need to watch Hell’s Kitchen to be shown how to cook more then one dish at a time. However the food coming out of both kitchens looked great, even though it appeared to take a long time.
The judges liked the pasta dish with prawns of Adele’s “the pasta is king – an ideal dish” said Matt Preston. They also liked the pizza as well.
They thought the pasta of the blue team was good, but Matt Preston thought the zucchini flower was better.
Back at the Masterchef studio where they were waiting to find out the results, Claire started bawling saying she let them down, to think we thought she was a bit cool.
Sharnee dissed Dominic’s effort of running front of house, and Sarah left to go back home to her young family.
This is the third person to have left the show of their own volition since it started. Meaning people who really wanted to be on the show are missing out. Also I think the women with families did not realise what a time commitment it is away.
The show is not filmed in real time. The first episode of the top 50 took three days to shoot. They obviously still need to eliminate someone otherwise they would not have had an episode for tomorrow night.
The Blue team made $1253 and the red team over $1400.
The judges by putting Johnathan up for the elimination challenge are indicating that if it is a team challenge and you lose some responsibility must fall on the captain, and Devon is also up for elimination for letting people in early. A bit unfair but really there was no one else to take the fall, Sarah had already gone.
Anyway back to Matt’s “If you delay it long enough they will love anything” comment, it would have sound hotter coming from Gary Mehigan’s mouth.
April 29, 2010 31 Comments
Survivor Heroes V Villains – Game On
“There has been a reason why I have been doing Rupert’s strategic play thus far, as he needs to be told how to vote by someone he really trusts and let that be done,” boasts JT after Rupert was telling his fellow hero tribemates about what Sandra had told him about Russell, and how in fact it was him was leading the villains tribe and not an all girl alliance.
Personally I don’t think the two words strategy and JT really go together, he was concocting all this crap about how Russell and Parvati both played the immunity idols and then that is why Courtney went home. I also don’t get why JT so firmly believed Russell was on their side. Maybe because he was in complete denial about how dumb it was to give Russell (someone not even in your own camp) your immunity idol.
I agree with Rupert anyone that swears on their kids lives is a douche and should not be trusted.
Oh by the way if you did not watch the episode the merging of the tribes occurred tonight, so it is seriously game on.
Also how dumb is Amanda? Pavarti told Amanda she had an immunity idol, and she doesn’t twig that would mean that Parvati had not actually played the Idol at the previous tribal council as they had been told.
And I agree with Parvati, Amanda was obviously lying to her.
I would liked to have known why Russell wanted to vote JT out, was because he thought once he realised he had been taken for a fool he would become a target.
Tribal Council was a cracker. Parvati played to immunity idols, one Russell gave her and the one she found. Jerri will be forever grateful to her I am sure. Sandra probably won’t be as she is really starting to play the game and I am really starting to admire her strategy.
Next week it appears she makes a big move it will be interesting to see if it pays off.
Russell looked put out when Parvati played the idols and dolled them out to Sandra and Jerri, hopefully off camera to him she said “I am nobody’s bitch” just to let him no she was not “riding on his coattails”.
It was a gutsy move by Parvati.
Anyway JT was voted out as Jerri was now safe. So he was eliminated because of his own stupidity I had no sympathy whatsoever.
I cannot wait to see next week’s episode. Will Russell and his ego turn on Parvati? Will Amanda and Parvati have a scrag fight? Will Rupert be saying I told you so? And who will Sandra be aligning with?
Here is an exit interview with JT from UGO.
April 28, 2010 14 Comments
Masterchef Australia – Celebrity Chef Challenge – Luke Nguyen
“He’s [Alvin] is a real contender?” says Masterchef judge George Calombaris. Would the producers of the show let a gay Asian guy win? I suppose we will just have to wait and see. If I was a betting woman I would say no. But Alvin definitely has a likeability factor.
Anyway tonight was the first Celebrity Chef Challenge with Red Lantern‘s chef Luke Nguyen behind the burners. He had challenged Alvin to produce a Vietnamese banquet. It consisted of Hanoi rolls, pork and prawn pancake, and barramundi wrapped in lotus leaves.
Alvin had 90 minutes, and Luke had 75 minutes to produce it, it looked like it took Luke about 40 minutes for him to complete.
What I loved about Luke was his Jackie Chan style chopping with a knife in both hands. It must his for TV technique because it seemed to create a lot of mess and food wastage.
Tonight the prize was no longer the fast track to the final week, but an immunity pin which they can use at anytime throughout the competition. I am presuming you have to put it up prior to the judging, not once you were actually told you are eliminated. But let’s worry about those semantics once someone actually wins one.
Basically Alvin acquitted himself very well, with no disasters, and not too many dramas, apart from having to redo the pancake after pouring way too much oil into the pan.
I think for the judges it was fairly obvious whose dishes were whom. And Luke ended up winning easily.
Alvin was given a total of 22, and Luke 24 points.
I found it interesting tonight that George seemed to be the lead judge role, something Gary Mehigan did last year. He was the one leading the judging conversation and talking to the Alvin. I wonder if the judges fight over who gets what lines and screen time.
There was comment in the Sunday Telegraph gossip column, indicating the Masterchef Australia judges ego’s were out of control. Personally I think they are allowed a bit of hubris considering they were on one of the most highly rated TV show of last year. However I think they should be careful they don’t become parodies of themselves. Yes I am talking to you Matt Preston.
BTW Regular commenter CG suggested a ‘book’ on who we think will take out the Season 2 crown. I will put up the form guide tomorrow, for you to pick who you think will win. There will be prizes for those for those who get it correct (I have no idea what yet). Great idea CG thanks.
April 27, 2010 18 Comments
Masterchef Australia – The Top 24 – Are They Really The Best Amateur Chefs In Australia?
OK hands up who has rushed to the Masterchef Australia website to see if Kate’s Chicken and Potato Pie recipe has been up loaded on there yet? I wonder if they will give both the microwave cooking time, as well as the convection oven time.
I really am not sure why they rate her as one of the top 24 amateur chefs in Australia. If someone can enlighten me please do.
Tonight the top 24 contestants moved into the Masterchef house in what looks to be the suburb of Double Bay, which looked fabulous, as did the Masterchef kitchen.
There is a restaurant and a cafe as well, I hope this year they have to use them, last year the judges were the only one that used it.
The first challenge was to cry when talking about a childhood memory or family. Callum, Claire, Adele all were choking up. Though this was not a negative thing for Claire as she has been so cool during the previous episodes that it was good to see some emotion.
Oh Masterchef Australia you got me tonight. Confession – I teared up when Callum Haan was talking about his father dying. By the way I really think Callum can cook, and won’t be surprised if he is on the show for quite some time.
But seriously they need to tone down the contestants crying it was becoming irritating and tedious.
And then they got to the cooking challenge which was to create a dish which reflected their childhood. The winner would go into a beat the chef challenge with the possibility of gaining an immunity card that they can play anytime during the show. I presume it cannot be used in final’s week.
This is one of the changes from last year. Previously the person who beat the chef was fast forwarded straight to the finals week. The immunity card makes much more sense. As even though going to the finals seemed like a great prize it really wasn’t as you were taken out of the high pressure competition, and also missed out on a lot of fun. As Julia Jenkins would know.
The first top 24 challenge and some were feeling the pressure. Adam Liew did not get the rice for his rice dish, which was a pity as it would have been sensational.
George was horrified that Kate was not going to make her own mayonnaisse for her chicken and potato pie. She seemed to imply she wanted to keep the integrity of the original dish. But she says she did change it by NOT microwaving it. Just as well because they would have had to revive George.
Did she put the mayo in the dish and then it was cooked? If so that is the first time I have seen that occur. I bet one of her favourite cookbooks is the 4 ingredient ones. Not that there is anything wrong with that.
Jake also wanted to keep the integrity of his dish by using jar oysters in his Oyster soup canapes. But his dish appeared to work out ok.
They contestant’s obviously are told of the challenges before hand, as something like oysters in a jar would not just be stocked in the pantry. Nor would all the asian ingredients required. I actually don’t have a problem with that.
Alvin cooked drunken and bruised it is chicken in chinese wine and mirin (I think), and snake beans. It looked devine. Go Alvin.
Jimmy whose mother is not going to be happy with his impersonation of her again looked like he was going to be sticking around for awhile. His prawn pathia looked divine. I will definitely be checking that out on the official website.
Adele’s crostini looked great – as I have said in previous posts she can cook. However I wonder what she will be like when she has to diversify out of the comfort zone of italian food.
The lovely Alvin won the challenge, and he teared up with pride. There must be nearly some peer pressure to start crying on set, otherwise you look like an unfeeling bastard.
Alvin will be challenging Luke Nyguen who is a great vietnamese chef, so should be an interesting challenge.
April 27, 2010 27 Comments
Masterchef Australia – The Top 24 Has Been Decided
I knew something was up all week, with Sharnee, the Qld law student, getting a lot of Masterchef Australia camera time in the top 50 episodes, but I was shocked when she was put through to the top 24. She did not complete a part of the dish.
Matt Preston said to her when she presented the Neil Perry snapper curry “We will be judging you on what you have done so far and this dish.” Why bother having the pressure test if it carries little or no weight.? Her other dishes this week did not appear to be particularly outstanding.
If they wanted a young girl in I thought Bel Erarslan was a better cook, her signature dish was in the top four. Ok so she had a bone left in her fish, however so did Aaron in his quail and he was put through.
The other top 24 contestant that raised my eyebrows was Kate Nugara, a 30 year old teacher from Victoria. She saw it as an achievement that she had completed the dish, but her noodles looked like worms.
Also her chocolate mousse in the mystery box challenge, was judged to be nice, but just chocolate mousse. Did she even put a glug of Grand Marnier in her mousse for flavour? George admitted she got through because of her “grit and determination”.
Also there must be some fear and loathing from some of the contestants who even in this episode I thought who the hell are you? Henry the asian guy in the blue striped t-shirt did not get one to camera chat.
Anyway more thoughts on some of the contestants later in the post.
First it was the Mystery Box challenge, and the top four were going to the top 24, and the bottom four eliminated.
It was dessert ingredients. In it was chocolate, mint, fruit, grand marnier, cinnamon sticks, hundreds and thousands. They had 45 minutes to complete it.
Tony, the grain trader, was making a german cheesecake – where was the cheese in the mystery box? For the pedants could they reveal somewhere what ingredients they have access to in the pantry when the mystery box challenges are on. Cheese is not a staple.
Also he had a disaster and it did not set, which meant he was eliminated.
Fiona used a very good strategy of sycophantically deciding to use something George had made in Masterclass. She made a strawberry jelly, which did not set so she changed it to strawberry champagne. The flavours must have been there as she got through.
Joanne Zalm’s tactic was smart just keeping it simple with crepes orange and cream. She now has a place in the top 24. Joanne will split viewers, half are going to love her, and the other half not so much.
Poor Jason had to walk the plank as his granita did not set, the judges were sympathetic.
I was a bit dubious about Matthew Caldicott’s strawberry soup, but apparently with his layered chocolate mousse it was delicious. And he was in.
Callum who is only 20 cooked a sensational looking chocolate jaffa tart.
Jo O’Brien, Tony, Claude and Jason were the four eliminated in the challenge.
Then in a shock announcement Kate decieded to leave to be with her family back in Brisbane. She said her children needed her. It must have been heart breaking for her.
This now meant there were nine spots left.
The next challenge was a pressure test, and it was Neil “the produce is the hero” Perry. I like Neil’s cooking, but I hate his ponytail. He really needs to cut it off.
His dish was a snapper curry with semolina noodles. It looked delicious.
Jake the cement renderer was the most excited he was ever going to be on the show (not that he showed it) as he said one of he reasons he came on the show was to learn from the master himself, Neil Perry. And he meant it. I thought his dish was fantastic, and I was thrilled that he got through to the top 24. I don’t think he will win.
Alvin got through,even though his dish got mixed reviews, great noodles and sauce, and bad fish.
Not surprisingly Dominic was in, but only after saying for the millionth time that he wanted to change his life.
Carrie, Kate, Devon, Sarah and Sharnee all got into the top 24.
I have mixed views I think it is a solid top 24, but there are some surprising inclusions namely, Sharnee and Kate. I also think Phil is a bit lightweight. Let us hope they prove me wrong.
April 25, 2010 21 Comments
