MasterChef Australia – Shock Final Two?
“I am dreaming about Gary and George in my bedroom hollering at me,” said Poh as she was describing how MasterChef Australia has seriously mind her. For about 2 seconds when she started the sentence I was like “Nooo Poh not an erotic menage a tois!” Just imagining George naked and saying ’Yeah, Yeah, oh yeaaaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhh’ made my stomach flip.
Now Julie really needs to go out an buy a lottery ticket that Donna Hay was on the judging panel tonight. However you wonder how much influence she really had. I think Donna Hay is a clever women, with good cookbooks, and marketing ideas. But what really impressed me tonight was her teetering about on those really high heels. I thought at one stage she was going to stack it, but they probably would have edited it out.
I really hope MasterChef Australia has an episode of outtakes, as I reckon it could be hilarious.
Back to Julie she did not finish plating up, but still got through to the finale. Controversial? Yeah.
I have to be honest I have complained about Andre being one dimensional with his italian cooking, but Chris and his unusual meat cut mixed with boutique beer cuisine was starting to get a tad predictable. Even though he obvious is a very good technical cook.
Tonight’s challenge was to cook three dishes that would be in their first cookbook. The challenge meant they had to combine styling with flavour. They had 2 1/2 hours and they could pick 30 ingredients.
Donna Hay said she was looking for three things. Innovative recipes, thought in food styling (for camera), and she would like to see their cover recipe to blow your socks off. George also said it had to look like “food porn”.
Poh was always going to have the advantage in this challenge as she is excellent at plating up.
Tonight it was just about confirmed that the contestants know the challenges before they go in there. The pantry would not have pigs trotters, and beef cheeks just sitting there. Also Poh’s century eggs would definitely not be kitchen staples. Speaking of that egg, I am sure I have spotted something similar in a Survivor eating challenge, where they have to eat half formed duck foetuses.
Poh was first to be judged and she cooked Century duck egg and pork dumplings which Donna Hay said ”Acquired taste but I quite like it”.
Black squid ink cubic noodles with fish stock got a resounding ” Confronting but exciting,” from the judges, and her ginger custard with rice balls and sugar were an “Amazing combination of textures in your mouth”. She said her concept for a cookbook was Chinese/Malay food, and she would call it Food from Mars, because there would be some strange things in it. Donna Hay politely said there would be a niche market for it.
Poh deservedly got a place in the final two. All her dishes were outstanding. They were adventurous, looked great, and would have tasted delicious.
Chris was next to be judged with deboned quail stuffed with chicken livers . “Cloying needs a bit of acid to break it up,” said Gary.
Pig trotters which George thought there were ”Nice flavours in there, but the trotter was soft not enough”. His braised beef cheeks also did not get praised George said “Sauce not right”. However Donna Hay did give his cookbook idea the thumbs up and said it would sell. Matt Preston also gave him a great idea for the title, ‘Snout To Tail, Stout To Ale’.
Maybe Chris was trying to be too clever with his dishes cooking them in a pressure cooker which in the end cost him a place in the final. Also even though Donna Hay is married to a butcher she did not look particularly happy about supping on a pigs trotter.
Julie was judged last, and she was having a disaster. She had not plated up all her stuff even after a lingering ten seconds from Gary, so her food was going to have to be sensational. She served stuffed chicken with port and pistachio, rolled saddle of lamb with mushrooms, and flourless chocolate cake without the grand marnier sauce and truffles.
However you could tell Donna Hay loved her and loved her My Family Table cookbook idea. She probably wishes she came up with it herself.
“I felt nurtured by the chicken and mash,” said Donna, and Lamb “Taste beautiful, and succulent” said Gary. The flourless chocolate cake was criticised with a “Doesn’t have the richness I was looking for,” said Matt Preston.
I have to confess I thought it was fake editing, with the judges putting Chris down so we would think it was close when he was chosen. However I was slightly shocked when Julie was announced to go through to compete against Poh for the title. Apparently the execution of Chris’s dishes let him down.
I am not sure it is the correct decision, Chris has cooked with flair all through the competition, whilst Julie bumbled through the first half. Having said that I know which food I would have preferred to eat tonight. However if Poh does not win I will be very surprised.

69 comments
see previous post,
what a joke.
i told you all so
poh is unbackable odds to win obviously talent
I predict she will cook the last challenge in a see through artistically decorated apron with red cheeks and a very wide smile. waitaminnit isnt that half ther already
Julie, up to this very minute i was hoping to win. Now i just hope both your dishes are a disaster. This is more rigged than jiffy anal probes survivor and thats saying something.
I will NOT bother watching the final as i can no longer give a red rare ragged wretched round ratty rude rodents rectum about to wins or loses. cant wait for the cook book but please make it out of 3 ply soft paper. thank you 10 for wasting my time
Poh is in need of a good ….. hang on, she is getting laid by a staffer on Channel10. Maybe they should re-name the show “Cooks, Roots & Leaves and Then Cleans Up”.
They all served up dishes that looked familiar. But Julie’s looked like it was still waiting for her to plate up.
In terms of what looked tasty, Chris, Poh and then Julie’s. If she could get it out of the kitchen that is.
Poh is not involved with any staff from Channel 10 or Fremantle and never has been. I think by now you know that I’m a solid tipper. Take my word for it.
Poh made “pedestrian” food proud with her artistic talent, transforming cheap meals into stunning pieces of art through the use of colours and constrast of shapes such as squares/cubes with circles/spheres in the serving ware and food items. Take for example, the simplicity of the presentation of the dessert, a spherical, rough sesame rice ball adjacent a smooth silky custard in a square dish, conforms to elements and principles of design. As far as I could see, all the flavours were traditional and should work really well: pork congee with century eggs is a dim sum dish, so are sesame rice balls (originally served during Chinese New Year). Cubic noodles with fried fish, spheres of roe and pickled mustard greens is a contemporary interpretation of this dish http://www.mysingapore.sg/Portals/0/img/fun_stuff/a_taste_of_home/Sam%20Leong.pdf
Julie’s dishes looked very much what I want to eat. The plating suited the family theme. The chocolate cake looked stunning on my TV.
Those who remembered boiled tripe on the dinner table, would applaud Chris’s use of frugal meat cuts. The heavy meat together with masculine styling however, didn’t work.
It was clear the judges were going to appoint a loser based on marketability of cookbooks.
Julie staying in the competition with her boring unfinished naked food – what a lot of garbage.. What an injustice to the world of cooking.
Again – judges have their favourite —- Julie.
RR…new poll needed..who should win…POH JULIE or WHO CARES IT IS A LOAD OF BS ANYWAY…
I love how all the judges, especially Donna Hay, stressed how important the look of the food was in the challenge: “food porn”, they said, “you have to make them almost want to lick the cover of your book” and then when it comes to Julie and her dull, uninspired, half-finished dishes, they frantically make excuses for her. “Oh, home style cooking can be allowed to look rustic and rough! And you know, her lamb’s nice. Oh, and her gravy!” I’m surprised they didn’t resort to complimenting her on her use of her plates. “Julie, these plates are magnificent! The way you sit them on the table, and my god, they’re shiny… Julie, this is a real winner.”
I don’t see much appeal in her cookbook idea, either. Meals for the family– isn’t that the basis for basically every cookbook in the market? And a “blank chapter for your family’s own recipes”? People buy cookbooks for the recipes, not for blank pages. I think a prettily-decorated notebook filled completely with one’s family recipes is much more sentimental anyway, more than a few pages at the end of someone else’s cookbook.
Poh’s dishes were excellent, though. I think she answered the challenge very well– they looked very visually appealing– and if she doesn’t win… Ha.
Yes pretty odd outcome in most respects, as we’ve come to expect this week.
Julie shouldn’t have survived notwithstanding Donna Hay’s assurances that plain food is fine for piccies of homestyle cooking. Yet at the same time, I can sympathesize with the judges because I really wouldn’t have wanted to eat much of either Poh (century eggs, yuk) or Chris’s food (heart, Trotters) even it had been properly cooked. I’m adventurous but it was just a little too ‘confronting’ in one dollop. They both have a good concept potentially, but it needs to be structured in a way to seduce us into wanting to buy, then later try the more exotic recipes by giving us something a little familiar to build from, and those dishes didn’t.
Really this particular challenge should have been done a week (or more) ago – then Poh could have been weeded out for what is surely an extremely niche market indeed. People would not normally rush to buy a book of food with complicated cooking techniques, ingredients they have never heard of if they can’t taste it first, particularly if they are told it is an ‘acquired taste’ like from childhood! Of course in this particular case, the book will presumably be filled with photos of Poh rather than just the food, and the George’s out there in the burbs will presumably buy this book for Christmas even if they never cook anythng from it…
And why oh why weren’t they allowed enough time to cook their stuff properly rather than having to use pressure cookers, and do the silly last minute countdown rush. In a restaurant, if a dish takes a minute or two longer to plate up, the world will not normally end.
Donna Hay reminded me of a garbage bag in high heels. Last night was a disgrace. Channel 10 can stick this show up their clacka.
Look, I’ve always liked Julie and wanted her to win but have to say it is a joke that she’s in the final. The fact she didn’t plate up should have been it. Much as I’m no Poh fan, her dishes mostly look amazing although I wouldn’t have eaten what she served up. Chris’ work seems same old, same old to me. Justine should have been here over either Chris or Julie.
None of the cook books attract me at all. Family cooking? Yawn. Chris’ book way too meaty for someone like me who doesn’t like squiggly bits in their meat. Poh’s original book concept of recipes tied in to some cultural/ family history sounded promising but Food from Mars? Now I know she’s off the planet.
Whatever reason we choose to watch Masterfarce for Sunday, very little of that will have anything to do with cooking.
“The chocolate cake looked stunning on my TV.”
Huh? A single piece of cake, missing the sauce she said was meant to go with it, just sitting there alone, not even a dollop of cream, looked “stunning”? You’re easily pleased.
“The heavy meat together with masculine styling however, didn’t work.”
Oh I get it, masculine = bad. That makes the decision make a bit more sense.
I agree with i_c – a ‘family’ cookbook ? Yeah, there’s a new idea. Stodge for the masses, spaggy bog and rissoles, love. Julie was very VERY lucky Donna Hay was the guest judge, although Donna – being the control freak you are, aren’t you really just encoraging competition ? Doesn’t Julie just want to be you and knock you off the shelves ?
And yes, Julie keeps bumbling and sweating and stumbling along – hasn’t she only half-plated the last 3 challenges ? And yet, she’s in contention to be a MASTERCHEF? Didn’t Gary say to her early on in the piece that it’s MasterCHEF, not MasterCOOK ?!
Ugh.
Julie’s cooking is the most marketable for a cookbook, so I would say it is a given she will win. Chris and Poh are produce much more creative and interesting food but their food is niche market. How many cook books has Kylie Kwong sold compared to Stephanie Alexander or Nigella?
…and besides, who needs cookbooks ? Just rip the recipes out of the mags while sitting in the waiting room at the doctors.
Hi Red, I am a Donna Hay fan! Here’s a link ot Donna’s chocolate recipe section http://www.donnahay.com.au/recipes-and-menus/chocolate2.php. Have a look at the food styling and photography. No fancy sauce or any other side dish etc. Freshly baked implied by cooling rack; freshly baked AND still warm implied by tea towels; delicious implied by missing piece with crumbs/dirty spoon…. etc. Look at the lighting that creates a modern feel plus coolness of day in winter. Look at the minimalistic approach, typical of the contemporary trend, and compare that to cookbooks published in 80’s or earlier with the full food spreads and clutter of serving ware etc.
Julie’s slice of chocolate cake was the last piece because it was so delicious that everything went. At least that was implied by the single slice. She should have added a few crumbs for effect, that the kids grabbed everything else, leaving a mess.
Remember the contestants were producing something to fit on cookbook covers, not plating up for a restaurant. Donna is the expert at selling cookbooks. I reckon she can sell a cookbook with Poh’s custard or Julie’s chocolate cake on the front cover.
Outside of Poh all the cooking is predictable. Seriously, Julie – how many ways are there to roast lamb?
(1) Given that they were told repeatedly that the food had to look good (I would interpret look good not necessarily as fancy, but tempting – not ugly might be a tip) and that the concept for the winner’s cookbook was very important. Poh and Chris – who are clearly better technicians and more impressive in culinary originality – blew it.
Chris has in the past made beautiful looking meals.
Poh’s book idea was desperate, like her noodle bar restaurant if she wins. But her scary food passed muster on taste and/or visual appeal.
Chris’s book idea was sketchy. He may as well have served an offal pudding for dessert the way he planned his dishes. They were all brown. He has frequently served brown stuff in unfortunate shapes and textures – those kopfta turds and sewerage onion soup eg.
I was really surprise they let Julie through – but her cookbook concept was the most original and had heart – the only heart Chris displayed last night was (I missed that) apparently in his dishes.
Not a love for Chris on leaving either, though some was stated by George. No offers to mentor him by anyone present or absent at the judges table. He didn’t win friends or influence people in his time in the comp, and maybe that’s his focus and dedication to his work, but interesting to see the contrast in Justine’s exit and the respect and liking she has garnered.
I agree Justine should have been there, but she wasn’t. The cuts are brutal at this stage.
On the last two polls people have voted for Julie’s restaurant to attend and have voted Julie to win over Chris by double the votes.
Perhaps those people don’t feel like posting in the climate of hate currently expressed.
Finally, I was grossly offended by the sniggering comment that Julia and Donna Hay “look like sisters”. Um, how? Both a little bit overweight?
I did leave a comment last night, but it seems to has been deleted. I am very dissapointed with last nights elimination results.
Chris, although not as likeable as others, has been the most consistent in delivering at each challenge & has clearly demonstrated the most skill, talent & direction.
If this show is about finding AU’s most talented cooks, then the two best should be able to battle it our at the Grand Final – which should have been Chris & Poh based on the 3 that was left last night.
The judges have clearly not looked at the overall performance of each Grand Final contender.
Let’s see”¦.Poh had been eliminated, so Chris would have been the rightful winner had she not re-entered based on who was left.
And Julie has had countless elminiation battles because her food is not good enough, staying in only by the skin of her teeth.
VERY disspointed.
Donna Hay is to food, what Stephen Fielding is to politics.
Chris was never going to get a ‘fair shake of the sauce bottle’ from the this Queen of suburban kitchen mediocrity.
As this show is called MasterChef why have we not seen a proper restaurant challenge where the contestants have to design and deliver a full night’s service to a restaurant full of punters?
So all that counts in the Donna Hay universe is how well the food takes a photo.
Perhaps there’s a cross-over program here combining Australia’s Next Top Model with MasterChef with the prettiest plates of fat, sugar and bacon bits winning.
Sabrina I think you are right about the need to look at their overall performance, not just on the night. It has really been a problem all along, thus the reason for bringing back three.
Especially in this last week, it would have been better to have a cumulative points system or something rather than a sudden death elimination.
Personally, much as I like Julie (and I agree with the coment that her stuff looks like old Gourmet Traveller fare rather than homecooked as such) I would have liked to see a Chris vs Justine cook off in the final.
And culinary boner, you are absolutely right. I was expecting them to bring back some of the eliminated contestants to work as kitchen staff for each of the two finalists in producing a properly served meal for once, not yet another series of silly challenges as the preview for the final suggests. Mind you, such a scenario would certainly have caused Poh to lose, since she is incapable of working with others.
Oh well. Think Game Show, think Game Show not cooking.
Sooty: sensitive much! I posted that Donna Hay and Julie look like sisters and my comment was based on their facial features primarily and body type secondarily. Similarities in eyes, nose and facial expression is what I noticed first and what prompted my post. It was also an expression to convey how much alike Donna and Julie apparently are in their style and tastes. And many have posted that Julie is fortunate that Donna was on the panel and praised her dishes for their taste whilst she criticised others (Chris namely) for the look and appearance and because “brown” is hard to style. Intentional or not, conscious or not, Donna Hay was biased towards Julie and Julie’s “type” of cooking and cookbook concept ($$) and this is the key reason why Julie was selected over Chris for the final.
Kate: the problem is there has been a huge inconsistency in what eliminations are based on. Sometimes they are based on the specific dish/performance and others are based on the persons’ overall performance. I think more eliminations – or rather ’saves’ – have been based on overall performance rather than the specific dish. And it is this approach that disadvantaged Julia and resulted in her being eliminated because of one challenge and not her overall portfolio. I believe Chris, Poh, Justine and Julie have faced at least one challenge – if not more – when they should have been eliminated for the dish but were saved based on either an assessment of their overall performance and/or factoring in their vision/specificity of their future plans and (last night) vision for their respective cookbooks! It is this inconsistency in the judging criteria…as well as the second/third chances being given to certain contestants…that has really disappointed me. And while I will watch the final on Sunday, I will think twice before getting “hooked” on next year’s series.
I think a lot of people identify with Julie, and that is why she is popular. I think the fact she is overweight, a mum and seems to genuinely care for the other contestants.
I am not sure she should have gotten in ahead of Chris, but over the past few weeks I thought his cooking was becoming one dimensional. And the constant self-promotion of his beer business (as great a concept as it is) was getting a tad tiring.
I thought Poh deserved her place in the final 2, everyone of her dishes popped last night. And it was not just traditional Malay that she was dishing up.
I would not buy her concept of her cookbook, however if she did a malaysian cookbook for dummies I would be very tempted to get it. Malaysian food in cookbook terms is the poor cousin to vietnamese, Chinese and thai.
I find it interesting that the top two popular people on my poll are in the final. Have we been manipulated to want them to be there?
My head said Chris, but my heart said Julie
CG: Yes, I am sensitive. It is one of my best traits.
Wow looking forward to Julies unfinished cook book.
Featuring puddle pie.
Flourless chocolate cake but without the grand marnier sauce and truffles that weren’t avaiable by the time we went to print.
Oh well maybe next edition.
Most of the book is blank pages as Julie never had the time to finish the dishes,so you can take your own photos.
Masterchef Julies too busy cooking for her family and she’s a busy mother you know.
This is meant to be about the best cook to be able to go on and run and own a food establishment, not personality!
As much as Chris did not win fans with his arrogance he has shown his capabilities in the kitchen, not only as a cook, but in directing others in the team challenges. What hope would either Julie or Poh have in the actual running of a kitchen?
Julie would never be able to find anything in her mess and Poh would be dithering over where to place the last piece of parsley to even know what the other staff members were doing. Their establishments would fail in a short time. Where as Chris’ would be well organised noval place to visit, with a expectation from him, that it stayed that way.
I think the judges should have taken a wider view in what the show is meant to be fully about.
LOL @ airwalk’s comment, the latter would win hands down.
LMAO @ i_c’s comment also.
Love this blog RR.
Julie’s cookbook will just be an empty scrapbook with her on the cover waiting for you to fill out the pages yourself. Because she won’t even finish that.
Donna Hay is the real joke.
How is it harder to style meat, which is brown, but on a full and complete plate, but a chocolate cake, which too is brown, that isn’t even half done. Well, that’s fantastic cookbook material that slice of 20% cake. So rustic!
Kyvyny – LOL, good point re the chocolate cake also being ‘brown’! there really is no excuses for the totally inconsistent logic and criteria the judges applied last night. what a bloody farce!
Suzykay – excellent point re the contestant’s ability to act as “chef” and to run and manage a kitchen and teams of people. Not a single challenge in this last, finals week of MasterCHEF has had anything to do with this key aspect of being a chef. On this measure, Chris (from prior challenges) came across the the strongest in this area by a large margin.
What a jip. Chris should feel so ripped off – he performs, works hard, plates up FULLY every challenge and continues to blow them away with flavours, originality, organization, presentation (even that OTT choc mousse cake was perfect) and he gets beaten by a half arse, poorly presented, plain, everyday meal we cook at home. I mean roast lamb? Roast potato? And they said potato & leek soup was too ‘ordinary’ for this end of the competition.
Come on… its MasterCHEF, Julie is lovely but would have NO chance of ever working in a real commercial kitchen (trust me, I’ve been there). Can you imagine the chaos?
Donna Hay totally influenced that decision and it’s so disappointing she was allowed too. What a crap ending to a great series.
one further comment – would anyone really want to eat in Julie’s restaurant given that you would probably end up waiting an hour and a half to get a meal that turns out to be nothing like the one your ordered!
Jesus – flourless chocolate cake at this stage of the comp?
And by the way, I have eaten the century egg in numerous asiann dishes and it is delicious – I personally would love to try Poh’s food.
And I looked back over the controversial wedding episode where poh was eliminated first and you have to hand it to Chris for being coolly in charge in the kitchen – sure he comes across as arrogant and his personal life may be questionable – but that’s his business – but he really has the makings of a great boss – can you imagine putting Julie in charge of that kitchen?
Seems like all the previous challenged really worth nothing.
Has anyone seen the French cookbook ‘Pork & Sons’- obviously Donna Hay hasn’t – Basic french cookery displayed farmhouse style (looks uncontrived – sure it isn’t!) – Chris food would fit this genre perfectly.
Have many cookbooks, one Donna Hay – and never even refer to it – my daughter used it once to make vanilla slices and they didn’t work……..
jp – one further comment – would anyone really want to eat in Julie’s restaurant given that you would probably end up waiting an hour and a half to get a meal that turns out to be nothing like the one your ordered!
- i wouldn’t if it takes that long
jp – Jesus – flourless chocolate cake at this stage of the comp?
- looks like something i can get at coles/safeway’s bakery section
jp – And by the way, I have eaten the century egg in numerous asiann dishes and it is delicious – I personally would love to try Poh’s food.
- yeah, don’t think it’s that disgusting; comparing it to fried insects, offals, snakes, and other considered delicacies from the East
jp – And I looked back over the controversial wedding episode where poh was eliminated first and you have to hand it to Chris for being coolly in charge in the kitchen – sure he comes across as arrogant and his personal life may be questionable – but that’s his business – but he really has the makings of a great boss – can you imagine putting Julie in charge of that kitchen?
- very true, he was way cool in the kitchen; which is good, get food on time for customers
jp – Seems like all the previous challenged really worth nothing.
- agree
CG – I’m not convinced they were saved based on overall performance. Last night for example we were told the criteria were about the book – vision for it, the piccy for the cover and taste.
Chris seems to have failed badly on the taste – Quail lacking acidity, trotter not glutinous. Poh’s also had some problems at least according to George and based on her description of the noodles; Julie did well on this. Chris failed the piccy test badly according to the expert (and really pig’s trotter on the cover?!). And he didn’t do a great job spruiking his vision for the book.
If overall performance had been taken not account on the other hand, he would have been saved.
Kate: I agree last night’s judging was – in part – challenge specific – although very flawed. My point is the inconsistency…some days it is challenge-specfiic somedays based on overall performance, somedays based on vision/potential/future plans.
BTW: Matt Preston appeared on this morning’s Ch10 “David and Kim” show. Not usually my cup of tea but I saw the advert earlier saying he would be on and made a point of tuning in. Anyhoo, the host David asked Matt point blank if the final two on MC were the best cooks in the competition. Matt dodged the question and said he thought the “top 5″ were the best 5 cooks in the competition. LOL. (Poor Lucas, wasn’t he #6.) Matt seemed a little embarassed and continued to dodge and also subtly insutled G&G about their knowledge of Asian cooking . Wonder if he was in agreement with the producers on the final 2. He also confirmed there would be a celebrity MC series coming to air starting in October and that recruiting for next season’s MC series would start in September/October.
RR: any chance you can get a link to Matt’s interview this morning; I think many would be interested to see/hear how he answered the various questions. he’s also got a new haircut!
And the winner is…….
Australia’s best AMATEUR chef.
This show is not and never was about innovation, technical skill, organisation or commercial kitchen skills.
MC deliberately blurs the distinction between the elite world of fine dining and our own homely offerings. Each night viewers can tune in and for a moment believe that we are all part of the great culinary tradition. In MC everyone is a ‘winner’.
A good amateur chef would at least finish plating. Julie was far from that.
I love that Julie is still there. Of all of them she has improved out of sight. She has grown in confidence and proved that she can cook. Out of all three last night, hers is the food I would want to eat. Oh and the cookbook idea of hers will walk off the shelves. So you all can bleat all you like, most people think Julie should win! Roll on Sunday night!
dutchsmum – most people don’t care who wins now
TDK – everyone has their own ideas about what they consider to be good food, that includes the judges. I for one take the show for what it is………..entertainment!
Chefs can cook but not all cooks are chefs. There is a major difference between cooking a meal for a dinner party and running a kitchen that turns out consistent dishes for several dozen people night in and night out.
http://www.wisegeek.com/what-does-a-chef-do.htm
I would be happy to turn up for a home cooked meal from most of these contestants but I would shudder to think about how some of them might run a restaurant.
Great recap and fabulous comments here. I might just skip the last two episodes and focus on the discussion here, because… dead to me. (I mean that metaphorically, of course – I don’t live in a ratings household and I’ve stuck it out this far so will probably do so for two more nights.)
I wonder what Adrian Richardson, whose MEAT book is fabulous, would have to say about Donna Hay’s rejection of the brown? Chris’ beef cheeks looked gorgeous on my TV – the rich brown against the mash with the chive (or whatever green it was) across the top was really appealing to me. Donna Hay’s styling is, well, very 2004.
I’m sure at the beginning of the series they made a big deal about the restaurant, so it’s disappointing to see that it hasn’t been used. Maybe that’s why the premises is up for sale. They’ve realised they can just rent out the Women’s Weekly test kitchen a couple of days a week and save even more money.
It was even more of a slap to the viewer that we had to trudge through the blather of “the journey” so far – particularly since it merely reinforced how circular (and we are talking very small radius) Julie’s “journey” has been. Maybe Matt figured that, having hugged her at audition, he had to follow through.
i_c – so true! They had to shift the goalposts so far that they ran out of field in order to accommodate Julie.
Whoever made the comment about Julie’s blank pages in the cook book being a necessity of bad deadline management – excellent! If I want a scrap book, I buy a scrap book. And, with the way books are produces, there are often blank “notes” pages anyway. Big deal.
This is all about grrrrr for me.
Who said the winner had to open a restaurant immediately. I know a pastry chef who has worked all over the world in the best restaurants and hotels. He was once fired by woolworths as they said he didn’t have what it took to be a bakers apprentice. He has easily spent over $100k refining his skills with different training on top of his apprenticeship and is currently working in a michelin starred restaurant in France. There seem to be an awful lot of food snobs on this thread, I wonder how many of you will actually put yourself out there and turn up at next years auditions. Or are you all gunning for Matts job as a food critic.
Realistically we will not be watching the two best cooks in the competition (for me Julia and Justine) on Sunday night and I can’t help but yearn for the format of the last week of Masterchef UK, which was always the best week of the competition because it showed three amazing cooks facing diverse challenges across an entire week before the winner was finally selected. But most of us have accepted by now that this is not Masterchef UK and this week they do appear to be making assessments on each challenge. Julia, Justine and Chris have all left the competition when there were lesser cooks behind them but that is the essence of a sudden death final week.
Tell Donna Hay that you didn’t really think about food styling when you were presenting your dishes to her on a cookbook/food styling challenge and you should not be surprised to go home. For people who find you arrogant, this may seem like a fitting departure.
The reality is that come mother’s day, Julie’s cookbook could make a mint – I know many mothers that would be touched if their child presented them with her concept cookbook and pasted a few recipes and photos in to represent their family’s cuisine. If the recipes were accessible and tasty, sequels would probably also sell well.
Chris’s cookbook, although interesting in concept would sell well for one Christmas when everyone would grab it for difficult to buy for men but would be on the sales rack soon after, as soon as everyone realised that many of his recipes are too challenging to either the cooking skills or palette of said men.
Webster dictionary:
Definition: Chef
Pronunciation: ˈshef
Function: noun
Etymology: French, short for chef de cuisine head of the kitchen
Date: 1840
1 : a skilled cook who manages the kitchen (as of a restaurant)
Word history
“Chef” (from Latin caput) is the abbreviated form of the French phrase chef de cuisine, the “chief” or “head” of a kitchen. The title chef in the culinary profession originates from the roots of haute cuisine in the 19th century.
from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chef_de_cuisine#Chef_de_Cuisine
But heaps of books are produced for one Xmas sale – it makes enough to justify the print run = look at all the cricket/fishing books that come out for Xmas shopping time.
Poh’s book though, I think would be a very very niche market that wouldn’t even set the Xmas gift market alight.
I think Julie’s blank pages, if done well could be really nice to personalise the book as a gift to someone, you would paste in your own favourite recipe for them.
I wouldn’t mind if she won based on good honest food (roasts etc). Basic food done well with good ingredients is a style of it’s own. But not finishing the plating was a bit of a dud.
Seepi fair point that lots of books are produced for one-off runs although if the book is being published under the Masterchef brand, presumably the producers would prefer it to be something which might not result in disappointment for the purchaser (my fear for a Chris or Poh cookbook)
If the focus is really on finding a chef, maybe the solution is to remove the cookbook deal from the prize altogether.
Is it possible to be a considered a chef without doing an apprenticeship or years of training? Perhaps if the show sticks to the definition of chef pointed out by Mastertwominutenoodles, then perhaps they should change the prize to the winner recieves a restaurant to manage. There has been no mention that the winner has to use the money to buy a restaurant, however each contestant have their own idea of what that is. If Julie should open her establishment I’m sure her customers won’t be standing in the kitchen with a stop watch and preventing her from plating up a whole meal. I think the comments about running after her kids are cruel and derogatory to any mother wanting to make a success in her life but I’m sure I will be howled down by some of you for my “suburban mediocrity”, which according to such worldly souls is considered some sort of crime.
Wow great comments and debate thanks everyone.
Injera – I cackled loudly and evilly at your comment about maybe not watching the last 2 episodes. I thought it is like pulling out of a marathon in the last 500 metres.
I will try and see if I can find the Matt Preston interview.
I actually think Chris’s dishes probably were a bit of disaster last night flavour wise, but then was Julie’s plating and finishing, so that probably made them equal.
Maybe by that stage they knew he was on with Julia and were concerned about having a scandal ridden masterChef winner. By the way did anyone else notice there was no welcoming home shot with family and friends. And it has been confirmed there had been one and one of his girlfriends Homaxi was there.
Channel ten must have edited it out.
By the way word on the street is the girl he was SMSing last year as per the news.com.au article yesterday had a food related job.
Two of Australia’s most successful cooks have never done a chef apprentice – Donna Hay and Bill Grainger.
I have eaten at Bills many times breakfast, lunch and dinner and never had a dud meal. And his is really up market home cooking.
Contestant Chris Badenoch admits to two previous bankrupcies in article in the Courier Mail. This would explain why he has never ‘realised his dream’ of opening his own bar/restaurant.
-One bankrupcy is badluck, but two?
-Maybe one of his girlfriends is cashed up?
- I wonder what his new potential business partners will think of this?
Maggie Beer is also a ‘cook’ not a trained chef. And her food is home cooking taken up a few good notches.
i want to buy juilies and chrisis cook book poh shouldnt b in it
TDK
agre on your comment re century eggs.
like paul hogan said ‘You can eat it but it tastses like shit”
Cmon all you poh apologists, even her number one fan the great Zorba virtually said it tastes like crap and that his mates would probably chuck on it. I know Oz is not growing enough food but we’re not that hard up yet, Bit like the excellent program on SBS (my fave channel by miles) on Magellan where the syarving sailors ate flour soaked with rats piss. Guess people will eat anything if they are hungry enuff
Maybe we need another show called MasterCookBookWriter.
unreality ravings – best handle ever. LOL. Also love the concept of the show, you should pitch it to Fremantle Media….
UrR – but, then, people would be pissed off because – based on what has happened here – the cookbook writer would end up being illiterate, but a genius chef.
Ed – you asked how many ways there were to roast lamb. Given that Julie’s looked raw as Gary was doing his final 10 sec countdown, even one seems to be too much of a challenge.
Suzykay
Right on Still we can all have sexy spunky white liquid with a gelatinous blob (pity threr was not two of them) to dream about with poh bending down low over it rosy cheeks aglow SEXY donna Sexy. and whoever made the comment about the garbage bag please accept the sourkraut iron cross with 15 bars for the funniest comment i’ve seen about this sorry excuse for a show so far. THANK YOU!
Seepi
Maggie Beer’s cooking is more than just a few notches up. She would leave all the clods on MC for dead
Sushi lamb – yum yum
I love Maggie. When I get disillusioned with Masterchef Au I always fire up The Cook and the Chef, Food Safari, Masterchef UK…
Anonymous
I’m obviously a Maggie B fan and I love the documentary style of food safari (and even 95% of the food shown there), but where can I get to see the English version of Masterchef? That’s the thing about the poms, they ALWAYS do terriffic TV shows. Our trouble is we have followed the U S Of A too far!
sourkraut – real Masterchef is on Foxtel – Lifestyle Food. I’m not sure when the next season will air. The most recent ended before this circus started. To give you an idea of the quality (and commitment) of the UK entrants: one of the runners up has been doing work experience at a range of London restaurants and is about to start a job with David Thompson at Nahm. The winner has opened a restaurant. You’d love the show – might be able to find it online somewhere… It is utterly different to the local version.
I think Masterchef UK is back on Lifestyle Food (the 2009 series) for those interested. Highly recommended. The final will blow you away. Brilliant stuff. Cooking for a room full of Michelin chefs was one of the challenges. Hardcore. Celebrity Masterchef just finished. Also look for Professional Masterchef, with Michel Roux and Gregg which is excellent.
Dear Sir/Ma’am
It is highly controversial decision for me as when Julie clearly detected Onion instead of shallots and judges tried to correct her, for me it was clear that judges made their mind who will win. She clearly lost it their, and when Poh tried to correct her decision she was not allowed to.
Not only that, Julie’s ways of creating drama was impossible for me to watch. She was called eliminator by other contestant because she was in the habit of making Puppy face and if that didn’t worked, making her eyes wet and face as if she is in a lot of agony. C’mon I m not saying she didn’t make good dishes but the drama was too much for me, always making puppy face and teary eyes when couple of time it was clear she is trying her best to make her self look miserable in front of the judges.
Regards
Jawad Saeed(Jack)
I feel Julie deserved to win out of her and Poh. Julie was in the show from start to finish unlike Poh who was sent home not once but twice and brought back into the contest both times. Talk about favourtism. As for Chris I wasn’t impressed that he was such a sour worm about not getting into the Grand final. He couldn’t even pretend to be happy for Poh and Julie. The other contstants cheered the two girls on and were excited for them. Yes they were proberly disapointed that they didn’t win but at least they showed good sportsmanship and supported their 2 friends. Chris just thought he was the best and couldn’t accept that he wasn’t. What a sore looser.
Tracey! Chris was the best . he showed intelligence, confidence, and competants. Truly the makings of an excellent Masterchef.
Julie scraped through, hiding behind team events. She really is a messy clumpsy homecook. Gawd certainly got a lot of learning to do. Her sweating and bunbling, along with crying sickend me to the stomach. She was clearly favoured by the judges, and if they think the viewing public couldn’t see that, they need the heads read. Very poorly judged, and an insult to the contestants who did deserve to win. Cookbook for beginners, oh dear Lord.
Some ot the stuff Julie tried to cook I could do better. I wouldn’t be interested in her Cook Book. I like innovative dishes, something I wouldn’t cook at home. I didn’t learn a bloody thing from Julie’s cooking. Blah! Tracey this is a competition and Chris was not a POOR LOOSER, he was duped by a dopey Mummsy.
Here is NZ, we think it is a rigged show.
Leave a Comment