for those who have reality tv as their guilty pleasure
Reality Ravings | Australia's leading Reality TV blog!

Posts from — April 2008

American Idol – Elimination Night – Final Five Revealed.

Can Brooke White please be voted off soon. Tonight she was even more painful then usual. When it was announced she was safe and Syesha was in the bottom two, she looked quite rightfully shocked but continued to have a pained look on her face for the rest of the episode.

It appears this week the US viewers were voting for their favourites and not on last nights song performances. This was shown with Jason Castro and Brooke White both avoiding the bottom two tonight.

Bottom two were Syesha Mercardo and Carly Smithson. With Carly being eliminated. She handled it with grace and good humour, whereas Brooke still was standing on stage and moping.

Next week another baby boomer mentor Neil Diamond.

April 24, 2008   12 Comments

My Kid’s A Star – Episode 3

“Good show but not a lot of talent” was Max Markson’s assessment of the show the kids put on at the Dural Memorial Hall which was one of the challenges for the teams tonight on My Kid Is A Star.

Channel nine obviously thought the singing was so bad they put another soundtrack over most of the performances. How can we assess what talents the kids have if we never see them do anything for more then three seconds?

But apparently it is not about talent these days but branding. The mantra tonight was the “Challenge did not suit my branding” Why can’t they say it doesn’t suit my talent? Is talent so irrelevant these days? In these days of Corey Worthington and Paris Hilton who are brands I suppose it is.

Well I was not going to watch this show again, but after being flamed by one of the contestants of the show, in my previous blog here I decided to give it another shot.

I was surprised that Channel 9 haven’t pulled yet, but apparently they have reduced the episodes to half hour only from next week.

Danny Bonaduce obviously could smell the stench of failure in the air as he turned up for two days work, took the money and ran.

Tonight the kids were going to tested on their acting. They had to learn lines then they were going to be tested with a surprise special actor.

Kristina was getting a tad hysterical as it was TJ’s weak spot as she has never done any acting. What does she do but do cute. Her singing is just ok. Maybe she can get a few TV commercials in before she hits puberty.

At the studio the special guest actor was Alyssa Jane Cook – when did she last have a paid acting job? Certainly not this century.

The Restless Days it was called – it was a cheesy as the premise of the show. Prior this episode I thought maybe one of the kids may strike it lucky and get a role on Neighbours or Home and Away, now I am not so sure.

Kristina was crying because TJ stuffed the lines. I thought it was out of line and would not have made her daughter feel good.

How many of these parents are living this dream through their kids? Thereza is one. She said that for her son Sam performing was not his cup of tea. Also she said he was deep and needed to internalise things none of this light and fluffy stuff. I think Thereza sees him a mini me of her complete with matching blonde highlights. He definitely did not look like he wanted to be there. In fact does he speak?

Someone who does appear to want to be there Amber loved the challenge and said she could feel the acting. Amber well I couldn’t, but to be fair the script made Days of Lives look like a highbrow BBC historical drama.

Max and Marki both agreed Amber nailed it, and Tom got a honourable mention.

Next was this all Australian Song show the parents had to organise for 200 people waving Aussie flags at the local hall.

There were tiffs between the parents that were too tedious to mention.

We have no idea about what these kids can do as we were shown barely two minutes of the concert.

The winning team from that challenge were Dale and Shane so this meant they were safe from elimination.

Tonight Thereza and Sam were eliminated and it was the most animated I had seen him all series.

He even came out with the line of the night by saying this show “Was my first hit television show.” Unfortunately he was not being ironic.
“It was my first hit television show?” Mmm no it wasn’t.

April 23, 2008   Comments Off on My Kid’s A Star – Episode 3

American Idol Lloyd Webber Night

What was the point of having Andrew Lloyd Webber on the show? Are the songs relevant to the Idol contestants or in fact their target audience? Apparently Idol is losing viewers in the younger demographic could it be because the mentors are so old? Mariah Carey looked positively youthful compared to Lord Webber and Dolly Parton.

Randy thought it was going to be the toughest night of the season. For the viewers or the singers Randy?

Simon said the singers have to make themselves memorable and contemporary.

Syesha Mercardo sang “One Rock and Roll To Many” from Starlight Express. Lord Webber’s advice was to “Have a laugh with it”. She asked whether to do the animated or unanimated version. He said the animated version.

Seemed to turn it into the sexy version. Is there any verse to this song or was it all chorus?
Voice was good, performance I thought was a bit overacted but then I guess it is musical theatre.

Randy Jackson said “This is your element, I think you could be a Broadway star, best performance by you by far.”

Paula Abdul said “Real good at that”, and “You brought the house down”

Simon Cowell said “That was very sexy,”, “I think this is one of your strongest performances so far.”, and “Randy right you are more comfortable in this area.”

Jason Castro song choice was “Memories” from the musical Cats.

Andrew Lloyd Webber looked dubious about the song choice. He said he had thought he would never see the song sung by a male, and as it is usually sang by old glamour puss.

Jason sat on the chair singing mixed with a bit of gasping for air. The beige suit he was wearing just about said it all about the performance – beige.

Randy said: “A little bit of a train wreck,” and “Not your thing dude”

Paula said “Everyone used to hearing song by a female balladeer,” then she had verbal diarrhoea and did not make any sense.

Simon said “Longest two minutes of your life, it came over a young guy being forced by your mum and dad to sing a song at a wedding you did not want to attend.”

Brooke White was next singing “Where do we go from here” from Evita. Andrew said this girl does not have a clue about what she is singing about. Had to explain the song to her. Oh god another opportunity to for her to cry on Idol.

Clearly she thought if Madonna who does not have the strongest voice in the world could sing it, then she could. This was her first mistake.

Then came the next one. She lost the lyric and had to get the band to restart. Her face showed she was struggling with the notes. It was just too earnest for me. At least there was no tears.

Two bright notes the dress with the butterflies on it she was wearing, and the fact she was so bummed by her performance she did not interrupt or chat back to the judges.

Randy said “This wasn‘t great, there were parts that were good.”, and “Vocally a little tough.”

Paula said “You must never start and stop,”, and “You didn‘t overact,”

Simon said “You were so tense trying to remember the song your voice was strained. It was uncomfortable” and “You are going to be disappointed when you watch this back,”

Simon backed her in about stopping and starting. He thought it was a brave thing to do.

David Archuleta was next who was probably weaned on the Webber music catalogue first was hugged by his sisters on stage. There were so many I lost count of them. No wonder is father is pushy stage dad they probably need the money to feed them all.

He sang “Think of Me” from Phantom from the Opera another girl song.

Well he fulfilled Simon’s wish sang well and contemporised it. But was it memorable? It was the usual David Archuleta performance – inoffensive.

They panned onto Andrew Lloyd in the audience at the end of the performance who was clapping but looked inscrutable.

Randy ” Dude it was the bomb this boys the one to beat.”

Paula “It was absolutely perfect, you took the risk and quite able to turn it into a pop ballad.”

Simon said “I thought it was pleasant but one of your weakest performances over the live shows. A bit forgettable for me.”

Carly Smithson was going to sing “All I Ask Of You” from Phantom of the Opera. But Andrew Lloyd Webber suggested she sing “Jesus Christ Superstar”.

It was groovy and it was probably my favourite performance from Carly since she has been on Idol. She should be safe tomorrow night.

Paula gave her a standing ovation.

Randy said “I am not sure if it was your best performance but it was definitely good.

Paula said “Loved what you did in the chorus. “

Simon said “Even though it got a bit shouty in the middle. It was actually one of my favourite performances of the night.”

David Cook “The Music of the Night” from the Phantom. Andrew Lloyd Webber said this is the most sensual and sexy song I have written in my life.

I hate Phantom but he gave good eyes to the camera and hit the high notes. He did have a bit of a glow about him. Was he thinking of Lacey?

Randy said: “Dude that was an amazing vocal performance.”

Paula said “You are so well rounded as a performer.”

Simon said “I think you made the most of the song you were given”

Bottom three will be Brooke, Jason and Syesha. With Brooke being eliminated.

April 23, 2008   4 Comments

Australia’s Next Top Model – Episode 1

The new crop of models were divided into the not so bright, and the wannbe intellectuals.

Alexandra Girdwood the 20 year old Uni student from Sydney started off the episode reading Kafka (well if having it over your face whilst sleeping is considered reading), but by the end had revealed she wasn’t as articulate as first thought. When she was talking about her inability to talk to the other girls about fashion as they shopped at Westfield rather then trendy boutiques she said she did not “breach these conversations” with the other girls. MMM I think the word she was looking for was broach.

I must admit I was shocked that quite a few girls did not know who Winston Churchill was. Now I know we have quite rightly moved away from our British centric school history curriculum but really this is ridiculous.

Anyway this isn’t a quiz show and IQ is irrelevant it is about having the looks, figure and personality to be a top model.

One thing I found about the girls tonight, and to be fair it was the first episode, were their lack of personalities, only two really stood out, Belinda Hodge an 18 year country girl from Melbourne her kookiness, and Alexandra because of her bitchiness. The other girls just seemed very young. In fact 16 year old Demelza seemed more mature then some of the older girls like Rebecca, and Alyce.

First up they were called before the panel of Jodhi Meares, Charlotte Dawson, Alex Perry, and Priscilla Leighton Clark in pairs. In America’s Next Top Model Tyra Banks dominates these situations, whereas Jodhi has a more laidback role with Charlotte spitting out the one liners.

Leiden Kronemberger a 19 year old unemployed girl from Sydney and Jamie Lee a 21 year old office assistant from Adelaide who has a tanning addiction were first.

Jamie who does have a good body wants to model Victoria Secret, and Leiden want to bring a new fashion look in.

They then had to get into Tigerlily bikinis for an all over body assessment. Charlotte Dawson like Jamie “better with her clothes off.”

Then it was off to shoot ten frames with a photographer.

Leiden as Charlotte put it “Looked like she was told to look like a dog giving birth to puppies.”

Kamilla Markowska a 17 year old law student from Adelaide, and Alamela a 17 year old student from Byron Bay were next. Kamilla was a bit bland and also looked like she had an eating disorder very bony in the bikini but the judges gushed about the body. Whilst Alamela looked very thin also, and she did appear as if she were an intelligent model, but her manner slightly irritated me.

Rebecca an 18 year old customer service from Wollongong and Alyce unemployed from Kiama who are friends were next in and they were told they had two of the best walks.

Caris Eves a 19 year old Uni student and Demelza a 16 year old student were told they needed to lose weight otherwise they would not get work if they did not fit into a size 8. Yes Caris probably did have a little bit of flab on the thighs but gee it wasn’t too bad, and I have know idea what was wrong withe Demelza’s body.

Alexandra when it was her turn to front the panel again showed her lack of intelligence or savviness when she went before the panel by saying her favourite Australian designer was Josh Groot. Real smart with Alex Perry fashion designer with ego sitting right in front of you. He duly noted the slight.

Also her answer when asked to outline five things where she was more superior then Samantha Downie a 20 year old uni student from Melbourne, the girl who was before the panel with her and she said she was whiter then her. Charlotte Dawson thought this was an offensive thing to say.

Then it was off to the Port Hacking mansion, where the girls were having to sleep in bunk beds. The over 18’s in one room, and the under ’18’s in another. On the beds were the product placement goodie bags. If I was the shoe company I would be a bit peeved as their was no camera shot of the shoes brand they were holding up.

The first challenge was to shoot the promotion advertisement for the show.

Johnathan Pease was to be style director. He is no Jay Manuel. The person directing the shoot was Travis Keneelly the Fox 8 creative director. I didn’t really see them giving the girls much direction when they were doing stuff the directors were unhappy with.

The girls all had a superhero character to play as the promo was a spy theme. The challenge winner would obtain an exemption from this weeks elimination.

Rebecca had the difficult job of have a snake draped around her as she was jungle girl.

Emma was a pilot and her modelling inexperience showed.

Belinda snowboarded and with her glasses off and make up on she really reminded me of Sophie Monk. She absolutely nailed her shoot.

Alamela played a ninja schoolgirl, but she just wimped it and couldn’t get aggressive enough. Travis was not impressed by the amount of film he had to use to get the shot.

Alyce playing a commando did her shoot in one take which made her look good to Johnathan and Travis.

I thought this pair were not giving enough direction to the girls. Johnathan and Travis were bitching between each other more then telling the girls what they needed to do.

Alyce was the winner of the challenge.

Alyce later that night had a nervous breakdown that some one did a number two in the upstairs toilet. The house rule were you could only do them downstairs. There was fear and loathing and people were woken up. I don’t know why they thought it was a model it could have been one of the camera man.

The next challenge was a shoot for the Vogue forums wearing Collette Dinnigan clothes. It was to be a group shot and as Vogue editor Kirstie Clements said ” No over posing or overacting”.

Belinda went and talked to Kirstie Clements which resulted her in saying “I thought Belinda was an interesting prospect.” She meant that in a positive way.

Emma whose height and legs were fabulous as the judges said ” she did not know how to work it.”
Kamilla was “Very pretty but boring”

Kirstie Clements favourites were “Belinda as she has a modern look,” “Caris a dark horse,” and Leiden “surprised her and not a bad look.”

It was judgement day the usual suspects of Charlotte, and Alex were there and the two guest judges were Kirstie Clements and Vogue photographer Jason Capobianco.

The girls were asked to nominate three contenders in the competition. All included themselves in the answer except Belinda “as she needed to learn more”. Good modest answer which went down very well with the judges.

Jodhi then told the girls one by one who was safe whilst reading lines from a clip board. I note Tyra appears to do this off the cuff.

The last two standing were Emma and Kamilla no surprises there, and Kamilla the 17 year old law student from Adelaide was gone.

The first episodes are always hard to assess as you are still getting to know the ‘characters’ it would appear Alexandra is setting her self up as the Paloma of the series which should make interesting viewing.

Also the comparisons to the US version is inevitable, yes Tyra can be irritating but at least she has a presence which is something I think Jodhi Meares lacks.

April 22, 2008   Comments Off on Australia’s Next Top Model – Episode 1

Australia’s Next Top Model Media Frenzy

Australia’s Next Top Model commences tonight on Fox 8, and the media frenzy continues unabated.

The Sydney Morning Herald here has an article talking about how with the overseas success of last years winner Alice Burdeau has inspired a higher quality of entrant this year.

Executive Producer Josie Mason said “A lot of girls who were already with agents saw last year that you can be in Top Model and it can actually propel your career.”

Mason also comments on the issue of eating disorders with the contestants:

We handle it on a case-by-case basis and we’re very careful,” she says. “[Host Jodhi Meares] is very passionate about girls being healthy and fit and one of her big things is that you have to last often a 16-, 18-hour day, and if you’re not eating there’s no way you’re going to be able to do that … What surprises me is how much these girls can eat. They can put it away.”

There was no sign of that when The Guide visited an early challenge, a shoot for Perry in an Alexandria warehouse. During the lunch break, the crew’s plates groaned with food while the models floated by with a lone piece of sushi or finger sandwich. To be fair, they were in the middle of a shoot and it’s hard to imagine Perry looking kindly on a model stuffing her face.

Don’t expect to see a plus size model on the show soon if Alex Perry has anything to do with it:

When asked what he thinks about the US version’s efforts to promote plus-size models, he snorts with derision: “Get. Over. It. Get over it. They haven’t got an Alice. In how many seasons? You know what? You can wrap up that fat model story anyway you want – they’re not meant to be.”

Jodhi Meares also has an interview in this weeks Woman’s Day. Link here.

Jodhi’s comments on the format of the upcoming series:
It’s a similar format but I think it’s more exciting. The challenges are more exciting. There has been a lot more going on. I think it is a more even playing field this year. It’s not as obvious “” there were more ‘stand outs’ last year. This season has been much harder on the judges and there definitely are more split decisions each week. We’re all disagreeing, all the time “” it’s been very difficult. You’ll see more sparks flying. Mainly from me “” I get on my soapbox and start yelling at the two of them “” the gargoyles! They rev me up and tease me relentlessly too.

Charlotte Dawson one of the judges appears to be having a big week co-hosting the Astra Awards last night, ex-husband Scott Miller being arrested for being in a drug ring last week, and moving out to a new flat as she had broken up from her partner Ed Harbour. But you have to give it to her in the picture here from last night shows her looking fab.

In this weeks New Weekly (NW) hard copy only Charlotte Dawson gives her own summary of what the she thinks of the contestants below.

Leiden: “Leiden’s got that Angelina Jolie quality about her. She’s a tomboy, so we’re trying to refine her.”

Alexandra: “Alexandra’s extremely confident and thinks she knows her fashion back to front. However, she doesn’t take criticism well and tends to pass the blame.”

Emma: “She’s really, really beautiful, but she’s the most awkward of all the girls. She doesn’t believe in herself or her beauty, although the other girls think she’ll be the winner. She needs more confidence before she can go further.”

Kristy: “She’ll be a good working model”

Kamila: “She’s a pint-sized ballbreaker with an awful lot of ambition.”

Jamie: “Jamie’s one of the nicest girls. She’s got a great face and photographs really well, but she has a very athletic body and muscular legs. All the boys will love her.”

Demelza: “Pop her in Miss Universe and she’d win it. She has the potential to be the next Jennifer Hawkins. She’s a bit young at this stage, but she’s incredibly beautiful so it will be interesting to see how she blossoms.”

Alyce: ” Alyce can annoy us with her giggling, so we’ll have to knock that out of her. She’s a really sexy girl but tends to over-pose.”

Alamela: “Alamela is a purely beautiful human being. She has a unique work ethic but sometimes I wonder if she’s secretly an axe murderer.”

Bec: I think she’s incredibly beautiful and has the ability to channel Megan Gale if she puts her mind to it.”

Sam: “Sam is quite something. Her in front of the camera really is magic.”

Caris: “My secret favourite. She is actually a nice girl and I get good energy from her. Caris is exceptionally beautiful, but she has braces and a bad student diet, so she has a bit against her.”

Belinda: “She is an absolute diamond in the rough. She’s never worn high heels before and is really kooky but has an endearing personality and a lot of potential.”

April 22, 2008   1 Comment